| Dowd 21:51 - Jan 29 with 5150 views | Tizzer |
Simply terrible |  | | |  |
| Dowd on 21:53 - Jan 29 with 3270 views | adhoc_qpr |
Was he that bad?
Missed Silva's kick and harsh booking of Granero but got the big decisions right? |  | | |
| Dowd on 21:54 - Jan 29 with 3240 views | CHUBBS |
Yet again another brown nosing tw@t paying homage to one of the big clubs.
He actually realized how biased he was late in the 2nd half and gave us a couple of borderline decisions he normally wouldn't. |  | | |
| Dowd on 21:54 - Jan 29 with 3237 views | Brightonhoop |
Thought he had a fair game. |  | | |
| Dowd on 21:54 - Jan 29 with 3224 views | BklynRanger |
| Dowd on 21:53 - Jan 29 by adhoc_qpr |
Was he that bad?
Missed Silva's kick and harsh booking of Granero but got the big decisions right? |
Yeah I had problems with those two decisions.
Other than that Remy's should've probably been a free on the edge and he got Nedum's desperate lunge correct, so fair enough in my book.
Though he still has a face like an arse. |  | | |
| Dowd on 21:57 - Jan 29 with 3170 views | adhoc_qpr |
| Dowd on 21:54 - Jan 29 by BklynRanger |
Yeah I had problems with those two decisions.
Other than that Remy's should've probably been a free on the edge and he got Nedum's desperate lunge correct, so fair enough in my book.
Though he still has a face like an arse. |
He's also carrying a bit of timber - doesn't look fit enough to be a professional ref! | | | |
| Dowd on 21:58 - Jan 29 with 3141 views | oddball |
| Dowd on 21:53 - Jan 29 by adhoc_qpr |
Was he that bad?
Missed Silva's kick and harsh booking of Granero but got the big decisions right? |
when it came to the important decisions ie penalty appeals he got them spot on.still a fat cooont though. | | | |
| Dowd on 21:59 - Jan 29 with 3125 views | qprwpg |
Yep, definitely not the worst ref we've seen. Glad he got the Sinclair tumble right at least. The Derry (the) Silva (fox) incident was a weird one, but Silva should have been booked for retaliation at least. Still, not many complaints here. |  |
| |
| Dowd on 22:00 - Jan 29 with 3120 views | BklynRanger |
| Dowd on 21:57 - Jan 29 by adhoc_qpr |
He's also carrying a bit of timber - doesn't look fit enough to be a professional ref! |
Dart or snooker maybe....no, just darts | | | |
Login to get fewer ads
| Dowd on 22:00 - Jan 29 with 3111 views | AlbRanger |
TV showed he got all the big decisions right.
Can't complain |  | | |
| Dowd on 22:01 - Jan 29 with 3091 views | Cornish_oooRRRR |
Can't stand him but no shockers and so didn't have a significant effect on the game. Which is what you want from a ref. |  |
| |
| Dowd on 22:02 - Jan 29 with 3079 views | BklynRanger |
| Dowd on 21:59 - Jan 29 by qprwpg |
Yep, definitely not the worst ref we've seen. Glad he got the Sinclair tumble right at least. The Derry (the) Silva (fox) incident was a weird one, but Silva should have been booked for retaliation at least. Still, not many complaints here. |
The main thing I noted about that was if Silva had kicked a lot of other 'Prem' players like that they'd have kicked their heels up like a galloping fawn and gone straight into an agonized tumble.
Derry's expression was more like "Oops I nearly damaged a very expensive player there"
 | | | |
| Dowd on 22:06 - Jan 29 with 3040 views | derbyhoop |
It wasn't a penalty to us.
It wasn't a penalty for them.
Granero got booked for tugging Silva's shirt, although he tried to let the play continue until Granero got a good tackle into clear. Then he booked him. It could have been just for the tug but it was also cumulative, after 3 previous fouls.
The only thing he missed all night was Silva's sly little kick at Derry.
Considering how unfit he is and that he only gets to see the incidents once, at full speed, he had an excellent game. |  |
| "Travel is fatal to prejudice, bigotry and narrow-mindedness, and many of our people need it sorely on these accounts. Broad, wholesome, charitable views of men and things cannot be acquired by vegetating in one little corner of the Earth all one's lifetime." (Mark Twain)
Find me on twitter @derbyhoop and now on Bluesky |
| |
| Dowd on 22:11 - Jan 29 with 2979 views | CHUBBS |
I must have been watching a different game to you lot.
I thought he missed plenty of niggly fouls on our player and should have awarded us a penalty when their player clipped Remy on the line of the 18 yard box.
I have no issues with the yellows or the Silve incident which was nothing but he seemed to give them the borderline decisions whilst refusing us. | | | |
| Dowd on 22:16 - Jan 29 with 2938 views | nedflanders |
| Dowd on 22:11 - Jan 29 by CHUBBS |
I must have been watching a different game to you lot.
I thought he missed plenty of niggly fouls on our player and should have awarded us a penalty when their player clipped Remy on the line of the 18 yard box.
I have no issues with the yellows or the Silve incident which was nothing but he seemed to give them the borderline decisions whilst refusing us. |
You've got hoop tinted glasses on. Remy dived and Dowds overall performance was v good. With 22 players trying to cheat them all the time and add the fact the pace of the game is so intense- if you are going to criticise refs for those kind of performances, you'll never be happy. | | | |
| Dowd on 22:19 - Jan 29 with 2916 views | CHUBBS |
| Dowd on 22:16 - Jan 29 by nedflanders |
You've got hoop tinted glasses on. Remy dived and Dowds overall performance was v good. With 22 players trying to cheat them all the time and add the fact the pace of the game is so intense- if you are going to criticise refs for those kind of performances, you'll never be happy. |
If he's sure Remy dived why did he not book him?
I've watched it a few times now and the way he goes down means he must have been clipped. | | | |
| Dowd on 22:38 - Jan 29 with 2831 views | antoknee64 |
| Dowd on 22:19 - Jan 29 by CHUBBS |
If he's sure Remy dived why did he not book him?
I've watched it a few times now and the way he goes down means he must have been clipped. |
I sit in R-block dead in line with 18 yard box and,when Remy cut inside the two defenders one of them clipped hes right foot right on the edge of the box.
The lino was 8 yards away and must of seen it but the little fat prick did nothing. [Post edited 1 Jan 1970 1:00]
|  | | |
| Dowd on 22:40 - Jan 29 with 2815 views | ThaiHoop |
| Dowd on 21:57 - Jan 29 by adhoc_qpr |
He's also carrying a bit of timber - doesn't look fit enough to be a professional ref! |
I think I'm right in saying he actually failed his fitness test at the start of the season and had to to retake it in order to be allowed to referee! |  | | |
| Dowd on 22:51 - Jan 29 with 2764 views | loftboy |
I thought he was the most one sided "big team gets the decision" ref I've seen since Keith Hackett away at old Trafford circa 1988 |  |
| |
| Dowd on 22:52 - Jan 29 with 2753 views | antoknee64 |
I counted two occasions the ball was hoofed out and hit the top of Ellerslie Road and ball came back into play and both the fat short officials played on.
Even Onuoha bought the ball down and put towards where the ball went out by Hart and Fat Dowd gave a throw to them. | | | |
| Dowd on 22:53 - Jan 29 with 2736 views | HollowayRanger |
| Dowd on 22:16 - Jan 29 by nedflanders |
You've got hoop tinted glasses on. Remy dived and Dowds overall performance was v good. With 22 players trying to cheat them all the time and add the fact the pace of the game is so intense- if you are going to criticise refs for those kind of performances, you'll never be happy. |
2118:
Martin Keown, BBC Radio 5 live at Loftus Road
QPR 0-0 Man City
"For me, on instinct, I think that was a penalty for QPR. It was right on the edge of the box, Phil Dowd took a look and decided not to give it. Lescott just catches him. But the referee can only give it if certain, and there must have been an element of doubt. But Man City have been let off there."
|  |
| |
| Dowd on 23:05 - Jan 29 with 2664 views | JonDoeman |
they're all shit except Webb. |  |
| |
| Dowd on 23:10 - Jan 29 with 2624 views | Lblock |
The Remy one was a def pen from the loft upper but Dowd passed on that responsability to the Lino as I saw them looking at one another. From the linos angled that had to be a pen
The Sinclair one looked a pen to me as we'll but quite far away
However. Dowds complete ineptitude was summed up by Clint Hill striding 40 yards to point out the City wall was only 7 yards back. The fact he paid attention to that AFTER telling us to take the kick counts massively against him as he clearly was not managing the game
His yellow cards were atrocious and he was chuffing badly
Always over dramatic and has a face like a murdered pig |  |
| Cherish and enjoy life.... this ain't no dress rehearsal |
| |
| Dowd on 23:14 - Jan 29 with 2607 views | Pablo_Hoopsta |
He must have come across better on tv coz I thought he was the worst we've had in some time and we've had some utter shite refs. |  | | |
| Dowd on 23:16 - Jan 29 with 2594 views | CanadaRanger |
| Dowd on 22:00 - Jan 29 by AlbRanger |
TV showed he got all the big decisions right.
Can't complain |
+1 |  | | |
| Dowd on 23:19 - Jan 29 with 2577 views | bosh67 |
I thought he was pretty poor tonight. |  |
| |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
