| Dowd 21:51 - Jan 29 with 5157 views | Tizzer |
Simply terrible |  | | |  |
| Dowd on 23:28 - Jan 29 with 1058 views | ted_hendrix |
| Dowd on 22:00 - Jan 29 by AlbRanger |
TV showed he got all the big decisions right.
Can't complain |
You've got to be joking, a Man city player deliberately handles the ball in the first half right in front of the ref, the ref gives us a free kick, if I'm not mistaken the ref should caution the Man City player thus putting the Man City player under pressure for the rest of the game.
|  |
| My Father had a profound influence on me, he was a lunatic. |
| |
| Dowd on 23:30 - Jan 29 with 1040 views | antoknee64 |
| Dowd on 23:28 - Jan 29 by ted_hendrix |
You've got to be joking, a Man city player deliberately handles the ball in the first half right in front of the ref, the ref gives us a free kick, if I'm not mistaken the ref should caution the Man City player thus putting the Man City player under pressure for the rest of the game.
|
To make it worse he kicked the ball away aswell. |  | | |
| Dowd on 23:34 - Jan 29 with 1029 views | CanadaRanger |
He was complimented by the slow motion crew on TV for getting the non-penalty in our box right. Our man got the ball first, but the commentators couldn't see that in real time. Correct call of no penalty. I couldn't have called that correctly without slow motion replay, but he did. |  | | |
| Dowd on 23:38 - Jan 29 with 1018 views | CHUBBS |
| Dowd on 23:34 - Jan 29 by CanadaRanger |
He was complimented by the slow motion crew on TV for getting the non-penalty in our box right. Our man got the ball first, but the commentators couldn't see that in real time. Correct call of no penalty. I couldn't have called that correctly without slow motion replay, but he did. |
Well in real time i saw a deviation in the balls trajectory meaning the tackler touched the ball in essence meaning a fair tackle  |  | | |
| Dowd on 23:40 - Jan 29 with 1019 views | carrotcrunch_R |
On tv the remy offence looked outside the box but it did look a free kick and a booking to me. Lescott foot was dangling out and obstructed remys run it shouldn't matter wether he got touch or not the intent was there and we all saw it . |  | | |
| Dowd on 23:41 - Jan 29 with 1017 views | ted_hendrix |
| Dowd on 23:34 - Jan 29 by CanadaRanger |
He was complimented by the slow motion crew on TV for getting the non-penalty in our box right. Our man got the ball first, but the commentators couldn't see that in real time. Correct call of no penalty. I couldn't have called that correctly without slow motion replay, but he did. |
I'm not talking about the penalty decisions, If he got them correct hip hip hooray.
Over the course of the match his and the Ellersie linesman got a lot wrong, the huge cheers and I mean huge ironic cheers from the home crowd when we got a rare free kick were enough for me. | |
| My Father had a profound influence on me, he was a lunatic. |
| |
| Dowd on 23:45 - Jan 29 with 1008 views | quickpassrotter |
| Dowd on 23:19 - Jan 29 by bosh67 |
I thought he was pretty poor tonight. |
I'm sorry - but I have never rated him. I do not like his style of refereeing and his manner on the pitch. He certainly favours the bigger teams (but just like a lot of refs). I thought that he had a poor game tonight in a match whilst being obviously intense was not over physical or malicious. I think that he felt guilty about potential pen for Remy not given, and tried to make it up with that absurd free kick quickly after - and the pathetic marching back of the non existant 10 yards - which of course Granero then blasted over as usual. |  | | |
| Dowd on 00:41 - Jan 30 with 974 views | smegma |
| Dowd on 22:00 - Jan 29 by AlbRanger |
TV showed he got all the big decisions right.
Can't complain |
What about Silvas kick on Derry when he didnt even have the ball ??? |  | | |
Login to get fewer ads
| Dowd on 00:47 - Jan 30 with 968 views | queensparker |
That Sinclair penalty shout looked nailed on from halfway up Ellerslie. For that I forgive him giving every single 50% shout to City to that point.
Looked like Remy dived to me. And OK Silva flicked his leg at Derry, but really who gives a sh*t? Pleased that some refs can just ignore that type of thing, Derry certainly did. |  | | |
| Dowd on 00:59 - Jan 30 with 952 views | eastside_r |
Total rubbish from Dowd. Niggly and got a lot of the big decisions wrong. The free-kick we got which Granero w@nked
should have been other way. A rare example of his incompetence in our favour.
Needs to go on a diet, the fat tw@t. |  | | |
| Dowd on 01:03 - Jan 30 with 941 views | karlski |
| Dowd on 22:52 - Jan 29 by antoknee64 |
I counted two occasions the ball was hoofed out and hit the top of Ellerslie Road and ball came back into play and both the fat short officials played on.
Even Onuoha bought the ball down and put towards where the ball went out by Hart and Fat Dowd gave a throw to them. |
To be fair there was a gale force wind blowing off the top of Ellerslie and once the ball got into that it looked like it hit a brick wall and changed direction sharpish. Source of great amusement in the Upper Loft. | | | |
| Dowd on 01:10 - Jan 30 with 935 views | qprmick |
If we had clipped someone on the edge of the box it would have been a penalty and a sending off. Imagine the uproar if Barton had done what Silva did, Tevez and co. would have been right on to it. | |
| |
| Dowd on 01:19 - Jan 30 with 925 views | ozranger |
| Dowd on 00:41 - Jan 30 by smegma |
What about Silvas kick on Derry when he didnt even have the ball ??? |
If no action takes place from the FA then it will become obvious that they now condone this behaviour. They need to be held accountable for allowing this type of behaviour - and the LOTG say striking or attempting to strike is punishable by expulsion - to continue unchecked. Pity we are talking about the FA here. Here in Aussieland Silva would have been given a three-match ban by a tribunal post-match. |  | | |
| Dowd on 03:19 - Jan 30 with 908 views | QPR_Nippon |
| Dowd on 22:06 - Jan 29 by derbyhoop |
It wasn't a penalty to us.
It wasn't a penalty for them.
Granero got booked for tugging Silva's shirt, although he tried to let the play continue until Granero got a good tackle into clear. Then he booked him. It could have been just for the tug but it was also cumulative, after 3 previous fouls.
The only thing he missed all night was Silva's sly little kick at Derry.
Considering how unfit he is and that he only gets to see the incidents once, at full speed, he had an excellent game. |
Agreed, especially regarding the Granero booking.
The only other thing I thought he got wrong, other than missing the Silva kick, was a very soft free kick against Onuouha on the edge of our box in the second half.
There seems to be a clear difference on this thread between those who went to the game and those who watched on TV and had replays. Now I appreciate you get a perspective on the game at the stadium that you don't with the the narrower field of vision on the screen, but in terms of the big refereeing decisions those with the benefit of seeing replays, close-ups and slow mos are surely better placed to judge.
(Having said that, the Remy penalty shout wasn't at all clear cut. The replays don't prove either way whether or not there was contact, in which case I think the ref has to give the benefit of the doubt to the defending team.)
|  | | |
| Dowd on 08:41 - Jan 30 with 852 views | connell10 |
feck me, the bloke looked about 5 stone over weight, ive seen fitter blokes walking outta kfc! surely there must be some sort of fittness tests for refs! |  |
| AND WHEN I DREAM , I DREAM ABOUT YOU AND WHEN I SCREAM I SCREAM ABOUT YOU!!!!! | | Poll: | best number 10 ever? |
| |
| Dowd on 08:47 - Jan 30 with 812 views | westberksr |
also 2 incidents in the second half that don't appear to be mentioned....
Taraabt was checked when he'd released the ball and landed about 5 foot from where he was standing; now Adel is a bit of a chunk so that took some doing. Then about 5 minutes later in the same area (our left side attack) the same happened to Traore.
neither were awarded, and then the fat prik went and gave a soft free kick to them for an absolute nothing challenge. Apparently they can use their hands to control the ball as much as they like too! |  | | |
| Dowd on 08:50 - Jan 30 with 808 views | WokingR |
| Dowd on 08:41 - Jan 30 by connell10 |
feck me, the bloke looked about 5 stone over weight, ive seen fitter blokes walking outta kfc! surely there must be some sort of fittness tests for refs! |
There is, but once they've taken it they all go for a pie and a pint to celebrate |  | | |
| Dowd on 08:59 - Jan 30 with 797 views | smegma |
| Dowd on 00:47 - Jan 30 by queensparker |
That Sinclair penalty shout looked nailed on from halfway up Ellerslie. For that I forgive him giving every single 50% shout to City to that point.
Looked like Remy dived to me. And OK Silva flicked his leg at Derry, but really who gives a sh*t? Pleased that some refs can just ignore that type of thing, Derry certainly did. |
If Derry had done it Silva would've rolled over ten times to get Derry sent off.And if Barton had done it he would've been bannd for life. Dowd was clueless and his assistants.Three times I saw the ref look at the paddock lino, he looked at ref, there was a pregnant pause for about 5-6 seconds then Dowd made a decison. So he was guessing.And guess what, all 3 decisions went to Citeh. No coincidence.
The only deserved yellow was Mbias mental chalenge. I thought Barrys yellow was a bit harsh but IF it was deserved he then committed a worse offence on the edge of the box and Dowd didn't even talk to him having blown for the freekick.
I've only seen the Citeh pen claim and Onuoha wins the ball cleanly. | | | |
| Dowd on 09:30 - Jan 30 with 775 views | willis1980 |
extremely poor reffing last night, he seemed to look for opportunities to give man city the upper hand then eventually relented and gave us a free kick that wasnt.
I thought he ruined the game and his over accentuated gestures prove he thinks its all about him.
hand ball shouldve been booking for sure, but surprisingly wasnt!!
What was the whole incident about when regained the ball and mbia dribbled the ball and dowd got in his way ...cue dowd blows whistle and gives citeh the ball.
i saw hart kick the ball it hit the stand and dowd just played on??? | | | |
| Dowd on 09:32 - Jan 30 with 773 views | Neil_SI |
It's not often I talk about the officials, but they were really poor on the night.
Dowd was barely 10 metres away from the centre circle for the entire match, got in the way of a couple of passages of play for either side, was giving every small issue to Manchester City but not for us to begin with. Then under the barracking of the crowd, only served to give us dubious free kicks in token areas, almost like a gesture and the free kick he gave to us just outside their box was scandalous and never a foul on Mbia in a million years (more the other way). It was almost like an admission of guilt that he might have got the Remy decision wrong.
There was also an inconsistency on yellow cards, where he let some fouls go that should have been, based on the yellows he gave in the game.
And how they missed the ball hitting the roof and coming back into play I'll never know. Astonishing. I was distinctly unimpressed, they were rubbish for both sides. |  | | |
| Dowd on 09:36 - Jan 30 with 767 views | pomanjou |
| Dowd on 22:06 - Jan 29 by derbyhoop |
It wasn't a penalty to us.
It wasn't a penalty for them.
Granero got booked for tugging Silva's shirt, although he tried to let the play continue until Granero got a good tackle into clear. Then he booked him. It could have been just for the tug but it was also cumulative, after 3 previous fouls.
The only thing he missed all night was Silva's sly little kick at Derry.
Considering how unfit he is and that he only gets to see the incidents once, at full speed, he had an excellent game. |
I agree all of that but would add the Remy tumble which looked at nailed on pen (from about 120yards away). Confirmed on match choice that he was clipped. Cost us two points. |  |
| |
| Dowd on 10:24 - Jan 30 with 740 views | HollowayRanger |
i was there and thought both were pens
hope they show both on motd |  |
| |
| Dowd on 10:37 - Jan 30 with 726 views | stowmarketrange |
| Dowd on 09:30 - Jan 30 by willis1980 |
extremely poor reffing last night, he seemed to look for opportunities to give man city the upper hand then eventually relented and gave us a free kick that wasnt.
I thought he ruined the game and his over accentuated gestures prove he thinks its all about him.
hand ball shouldve been booking for sure, but surprisingly wasnt!!
What was the whole incident about when regained the ball and mbia dribbled the ball and dowd got in his way ...cue dowd blows whistle and gives citeh the ball.
i saw hart kick the ball it hit the stand and dowd just played on??? |
It didn't hit the roof.The wind was so strong that it blew it back into play.That happened twice. |  | | |
| Dowd on 10:47 - Jan 30 with 721 views | Juzzie |
| Dowd on 22:52 - Jan 29 by antoknee64 |
I counted two occasions the ball was hoofed out and hit the top of Ellerslie Road and ball came back into play and both the fat short officials played on.
Even Onuoha bought the ball down and put towards where the ball went out by Hart and Fat Dowd gave a throw to them. |
That one where Hart hoofed it out and it hit the Ellerslie Road stand was unbeliveable. I don't think I've ever seen such a poor decision. If they'd scored from the thrown in there would have been a riot!
He got the two pen decisions right I think but he let Man City get away with all the niggly ones.
|  | | |
| Dowd on 11:42 - Jan 30 with 836 views | PinnerPaul |
I thought he had a good game.
Penalty shouts were judgement calls that even those above that have seen replays can't agree on! so can hardly said to be obvious!
Non Fitness talk is a joke, they take fitness tests and have training sessions throughout the season. | | | |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
