| Biggest mistakes letting players leave. 12:52 - Oct 24 with 9244 views | Snipper |
We have an absolute gem in Sam Field. Which begs the question, how the hell did West Brom let him leave? What was it that they didn’t like?
Danny Maddix is another one we picked up from Tottenham on a free transfer.
What transfer mistakes have QPR made by letting players go for a pittance at the time?
Which other clubs have made big mistakes with players? |  | | |  |
| Biggest mistakes letting players leave. on 12:56 - Oct 24 with 5682 views | Wilkinswatercarrier |
He was let go as West Brom were in a premier league relegation fight if memory serves me correctly and he was getting little game time due to ongoing injury problems. We got him, fixed the medical issue last season, and now we have a proper player! |  | | |
| Biggest mistakes letting players leave. on 12:59 - Oct 24 with 5664 views | Noelmc |
I can't remember the exact circumstances, but always remember thinking it was a big mistake letting Clive Wilson go when we did (on a Free, I think).
Fantastic player and it certainly weakened the team when he left. |  | | |
| Biggest mistakes letting players leave. on 12:59 - Oct 24 with 5661 views | denhamhoop2 |
Chelsea had Saleh and De Bruyne as youngsters think it is safe to say they may regret letting both go too soon. Back in the day Tottenham let Des Walker leave as a youngster who went on to "You'll never beat" fame at Forest and England | | | |
| Biggest mistakes letting players leave. on 13:03 - Oct 24 with 5628 views | CamberleyR |
Jimmy Carter and Dougie Freedman off the top of my head stick out for me. Carter we let go to Millwall for £15k and Freedman we let go on a free. |  |
| |
| Biggest mistakes letting players leave. on 13:31 - Oct 24 with 5438 views | QPR_Jim |
Cole Kpekawa? |  | | |
| Biggest mistakes letting players leave. on 13:45 - Oct 24 with 5367 views | Antti_Heinola |
| Biggest mistakes letting players leave. on 13:03 - Oct 24 by CamberleyR |
Jimmy Carter and Dougie Freedman off the top of my head stick out for me. Carter we let go to Millwall for £15k and Freedman we let go on a free. |
To be fair, Freedman was, remarkably, the third best of our three young strikers at that time.
Would be lovely to get a Gallen, a Dichio and a Freedman all coming through at once again one day!
Sheff Wed binning Di Canio off for £1m after the ref push incident was understandable, but West Ham got a massive bargain. Roy Keane letting Rhodes go for nothing at Ipswich was a bit of a howler.
Spurs let Dave Mackay go to Derby on a free, thinking he was finished. Uh-oh.
Newcastle let Ivan Toney go. |  |
| |
| Biggest mistakes letting players leave. on 13:46 - Oct 24 with 5347 views | Loftgirl |
| Biggest mistakes letting players leave. on 13:31 - Oct 24 by QPR_Jim |
Cole Kpekawa? |
Marco Ramkilde. |  | | |
Login to get fewer ads
| Biggest mistakes letting players leave. on 13:59 - Oct 24 with 5261 views | WestbourneR |
| Biggest mistakes letting players leave. on 13:45 - Oct 24 by Antti_Heinola |
To be fair, Freedman was, remarkably, the third best of our three young strikers at that time.
Would be lovely to get a Gallen, a Dichio and a Freedman all coming through at once again one day!
Sheff Wed binning Di Canio off for £1m after the ref push incident was understandable, but West Ham got a massive bargain. Roy Keane letting Rhodes go for nothing at Ipswich was a bit of a howler.
Spurs let Dave Mackay go to Derby on a free, thinking he was finished. Uh-oh.
Newcastle let Ivan Toney go. |
Dichio was terrible. |  |
| |
| Biggest mistakes letting players leave. on 14:11 - Oct 24 with 5198 views | Bushman |
Eric Cantona |  |
| I know almost nothing about the Premier League even though I try to catch the big games every now and then at the end of the season. But I will say this, Queens Park Rangers is just a fukking sick ass team name. Just sounds so cool. |
| |
| Biggest mistakes letting players leave. on 14:17 - Oct 24 with 5169 views | BrianMcCarthy |
| Biggest mistakes letting players leave. on 12:59 - Oct 24 by Noelmc |
I can't remember the exact circumstances, but always remember thinking it was a big mistake letting Clive Wilson go when we did (on a Free, I think).
Fantastic player and it certainly weakened the team when he left. |
Great call.
We let his contract expire, then offered him a year. Francis offered him two years at Spurs.
Huge loss. |  |
| |
| Biggest mistakes letting players leave. on 14:23 - Oct 24 with 5136 views | Juzzie |
I reckon there are so many factors. Players sometimes mature (physically as well as emotionally) later than others, a club could have a surplus of players (wholly or in certain areas), players may not be happy or make unrealistic demands, and so on. All adds up to letting some go so they can get regular games elsewhere.
Whatever the reason I'm sure it's quite often a gamble and Clubs know players have potential but it's probably impossible to accommodate everyone or predict how players will turn out in xx years time.
Another we let go was John Barnes. [Post edited 24 Oct 2022 14:24]
|  | | |
| Biggest mistakes letting players leave. on 14:27 - Oct 24 with 5091 views | BazzaInTheLoft |
Chris Kiwomya.
The clue was in the chant! |  | | |
| Biggest mistakes letting players leave. on 14:28 - Oct 24 with 5085 views | TheChef |
Clint Hill and Ale Faurlin. |  |
| |
| Biggest mistakes letting players leave. on 14:29 - Oct 24 with 5084 views | BazzaInTheLoft |
Going in the other direction, John Barnes says in his autobiography that we ignored him didn’t offer him a contract after a trial. | | | |
| Biggest mistakes letting players leave. on 14:39 - Oct 24 with 5043 views | Antti_Heinola |
| Biggest mistakes letting players leave. on 13:59 - Oct 24 by WestbourneR |
Dichio was terrible. |
He wasn't at all. His first two seasons he was really effective and even in our relegation season managed 9 goals from 28 appearances, including against top teams Spurs, Newcastle, Liverpool and Man Utd. Objectively, he was very good for us that year when still only 19 I think, and the year before had proved to be an able deputy for Ferdinand. At youth level, he and Gallen were certainly above Freedman anyway, which is what we're talking about here.
Bit reductive from you, Westbourne, but maybe you're a bit younger than me and only remember his later career which I agree did tail off from his significant early promise. | |
| |
| Biggest mistakes letting players leave. on 14:56 - Oct 24 with 4979 views | Snipper |
Tottenham letting Pat Jennings leave to join Arsenal for nothing. They said they had a much better goalkeeper in Barry Daines.
That went well. | | | |
| Biggest mistakes letting players leave. on 14:56 - Oct 24 with 4977 views | bosh67 |
Sir Les to Newcastle. I think we got £6m. Brilliant move for him but I seem to recall we were relegated the next season! |  |
| |
| Biggest mistakes letting players leave. on 14:57 - Oct 24 with 4965 views | Boston |
| Biggest mistakes letting players leave. on 13:03 - Oct 24 by CamberleyR |
Jimmy Carter and Dougie Freedman off the top of my head stick out for me. Carter we let go to Millwall for £15k and Freedman we let go on a free. |
To be fair, Jimmy did land that President of the United States gig. | |
| |
| Biggest mistakes letting players leave. on 15:07 - Oct 24 with 4910 views | BrianMcCarthy |
| Biggest mistakes letting players leave. on 14:56 - Oct 24 by bosh67 |
Sir Les to Newcastle. I think we got £6m. Brilliant move for him but I seem to recall we were relegated the next season! |
I think we did really well to keep him for as long as we did, to be fair. And he could have demended a move a year or two prior if he'd been like other players we had. | |
| |
| Biggest mistakes letting players leave. on 15:12 - Oct 24 with 4878 views | Noelmc |
| Biggest mistakes letting players leave. on 15:07 - Oct 24 by BrianMcCarthy |
I think we did really well to keep him for as long as we did, to be fair. And he could have demended a move a year or two prior if he'd been like other players we had. |
Agreed.
I think most of us expected him to go at least a year before he actually did. That's why he was always so welcomed by our fans when returning as an opposition player.
The £6m fee was good at that time too. It was just a shame it was nearly all wasted. | | | |
| Biggest mistakes letting players leave. on 15:14 - Oct 24 with 4859 views | BrianMcCarthy |
| Biggest mistakes letting players leave. on 15:12 - Oct 24 by Noelmc |
Agreed.
I think most of us expected him to go at least a year before he actually did. That's why he was always so welcomed by our fans when returning as an opposition player.
The £6m fee was good at that time too. It was just a shame it was nearly all wasted. |
"It was just a shame it was nearly all wasted."
Don't.
Just don't!
 | |
| |
| Biggest mistakes letting players leave. on 15:15 - Oct 24 with 4855 views | Rangersw12 |
| Biggest mistakes letting players leave. on 14:39 - Oct 24 by Antti_Heinola |
He wasn't at all. His first two seasons he was really effective and even in our relegation season managed 9 goals from 28 appearances, including against top teams Spurs, Newcastle, Liverpool and Man Utd. Objectively, he was very good for us that year when still only 19 I think, and the year before had proved to be an able deputy for Ferdinand. At youth level, he and Gallen were certainly above Freedman anyway, which is what we're talking about here.
Bit reductive from you, Westbourne, but maybe you're a bit younger than me and only remember his later career which I agree did tail off from his significant early promise. |
I still think the massive drop in form for Spencer in 97/98 was because Dichio left for Sampdoria that summer
As for the op, I suppose most recent one would be Josh Laurent who seems to have become a decent enough Championship player [Post edited 24 Oct 2022 16:47]
| | | |
| Biggest mistakes letting players leave. on 15:46 - Oct 24 with 4761 views | Toast_R |
How about Birmingham buying Clinton Morrison for 4.25 million and throwing in Andy Johnson as part of deal? |  | | |
| Biggest mistakes letting players leave. on 15:59 - Oct 24 with 4699 views | CamberleyR |
Quite a few of Brian Clough's Forest league champions/first European Cup winning side were deemed surplus to requirements at the clubs they were signed from and left for pittances:
Frank Clark
Larry Lloyd
John McGovern
Archie Gemmill | |
| |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
