Please log in or register. Registered visitors get fewer ads.
Forum index | Previous Thread | Next thread
Penalty Shout at the end? 22:08 - Oct 4 with 3114 viewsLblock

Heart in mouth job that one..... reverse the roles I'd be somewhat piffed if not awarded to us.

Bit of a shirt grapple off but personally I think Dozzell quite lucky there.

Senny would've saved it anyway but looked a pen for me

Cherish and enjoy life.... this ain't no dress rehearsal

2
Penalty Shout at the end? on 22:09 - Oct 4 with 3083 viewsdannyblue

I thought so live, but on the replay they were clearly both holding each other's shirts. Would have preferred it if Andre hadn't been!
0
Penalty Shout at the end? on 22:09 - Oct 4 with 3082 viewsMick_S

Both tugging, oh err, so well done ref and lino.

Did I ever mention that I was in Minder?

0
Penalty Shout at the end? on 22:10 - Oct 4 with 3042 viewsMalintabuk

Thought the same at the time.... there was talk on the thread that they were both pulling at each other..... that if given it would have been soft...... but Dozzell by doing it was giving the ref a decision to make........ the lad was heading nowhere so for me it was a risky thing to do
[Post edited 4 Oct 2022 22:11]
0
Penalty Shout at the end? on 22:12 - Oct 4 with 2964 viewsBenny_the_Ball

No chance. Both players were tugging each other's shirt and Dozzell lets go a nano-second before their player hits the deck. When he realised that he was running out of real estate he fell in the opposite direction to which his shirt was being pulled so clearly a dive.
[Post edited 4 Oct 2022 22:13]
4
Penalty Shout at the end? on 22:13 - Oct 4 with 2962 viewsDWQPR

Penalty Shout at the end? on 22:10 - Oct 4 by Malintabuk

Thought the same at the time.... there was talk on the thread that they were both pulling at each other..... that if given it would have been soft...... but Dozzell by doing it was giving the ref a decision to make........ the lad was heading nowhere so for me it was a risky thing to do
[Post edited 4 Oct 2022 22:11]


Tell tale sign was that Berge didn’t even bother to get up and remonstrance. Never a pen.

Poll: Where will Clive put QPR in his new season preview

1
Penalty Shout at the end? on 22:21 - Oct 4 with 2847 viewsdaveB

never a pen imo, both pulling each other shirts and no way should a man the size of him get pulled down by Dozzell
0
Penalty Shout at the end? on 22:22 - Oct 4 with 2818 viewsBenny_the_Ball

Penalty Shout at the end? on 22:21 - Oct 4 by daveB

never a pen imo, both pulling each other shirts and no way should a man the size of him get pulled down by Dozzell


Especially considering that he fell in the OPPOSITE direction to which he was being pulled.
0
Penalty Shout at the end? on 22:33 - Oct 4 with 2773 viewsLadbrokeR

Penalty Shout at the end? on 22:09 - Oct 4 by Mick_S

Both tugging, oh err, so well done ref and lino.


From what I saw that was a penalty shout. We were on thin ice there.
0
Login to get fewer ads

Penalty Shout at the end? on 22:35 - Oct 4 with 2754 viewstraininvain

Penalty Shout at the end? on 22:33 - Oct 4 by LadbrokeR

From what I saw that was a penalty shout. We were on thin ice there.


It would’ve been incredibly soft and their players barely appealed which tells us all we need to know.
0
Penalty Shout at the end? on 22:37 - Oct 4 with 2731 viewsJimmyR

I’d of wanted it if it was the other way round
0
Penalty Shout at the end? on 22:39 - Oct 4 with 2695 viewsBenny_the_Ball

Penalty Shout at the end? on 22:35 - Oct 4 by traininvain

It would’ve been incredibly soft and their players barely appealed which tells us all we need to know.


So soft that it doesn't even deserve its own thread. A desperate dive by a desperate player given the short shrift by the ref that it deserved.
1
Penalty Shout at the end? on 22:40 - Oct 4 with 2681 viewsBenny_the_Ball

Penalty Shout at the end? on 22:37 - Oct 4 by JimmyR

I’d of wanted it if it was the other way round


But you wouldn't have got it.
0
Penalty Shout at the end? on 01:56 - Oct 5 with 2471 viewsCLAREMAN1995

Penalty Shout at the end? on 22:13 - Oct 4 by DWQPR

Tell tale sign was that Berge didn’t even bother to get up and remonstrance. Never a pen.


They said on SW TV he hurt himself falling or throwing himself to the ground .I can never understand why players throw themselves down on a shirt pull it never works and luckily the ref did not give it.
Funny enough the SW commentary team mentioned QPR should have been given a penalty in the first half for a trip on Chair maybe plus there was a handball shout in the second half too
0
Penalty Shout at the end? on 03:13 - Oct 5 with 2423 viewsSydneyRs

Seen them given for sure. Stonewall at Anfield, Ibrox and certain other places.
[Post edited 5 Oct 2022 5:28]
0
Penalty Shout at the end? on 05:03 - Oct 5 with 2358 viewsHAYESBOY

Just seen the extended highlights on the offy. Both have a handful of shirt. No pen.

Smells like a trout farm in here

0
Penalty Shout at the end? on 07:55 - Oct 5 with 2167 viewsmcqpr10

Heart in mouth when it happened. Think Clarke Salter had a word with Dozell about not giving the ref a decision to make
0
Penalty Shout at the end? on 08:14 - Oct 5 with 2084 viewsTonto

The Utd player made a meal of it and "dived" in the wrong direction. Was being pulled left and fell right. So was simulation IMO and the right decision.

Why stop now, just when I'm hating it
Poll: How was the transfer window for you?

0
Penalty Shout at the end? on 08:15 - Oct 5 with 2081 viewskingsburyR

Watched it on Sky red button so no replays.

My first reaction was PENALTY. And at their end also.

Swerved one there a bit.

Dont know why we bother. .... but we do!

0
Penalty Shout at the end? on 08:51 - Oct 5 with 2002 viewsnix

Penalty Shout at the end? on 08:15 - Oct 5 by kingsburyR

Watched it on Sky red button so no replays.

My first reaction was PENALTY. And at their end also.

Swerved one there a bit.


They also swerved one earlier on, from the extended highlights. One of our players bundled over (Willock?) just as he was about to shoot. Looked more of a clear one to me and even then commentators said they got away with one.
0
About Us Contact Us Terms & Conditions Privacy Cookies Advertising
© FansNetwork 2024