| The Poppy 12:58 - Nov 2 with 11314 views | union_jack |
FIFA are banning the home nations from displaying the poppy on international shirts.
Outrageous?
Or preventing a floodgate opening for other countries to have their political say on their shirts? |  |
| |  |
| The Poppy on 13:24 - Nov 2 with 4417 views | sherpajacob |
If England and Scotland both want to wear poppies they should be allowed.
For us, bearing in mind we are playing Serbia, we should be allowed if the Serbs agree.
Serbia suffered more than any other single country during the great war, only right we should ask their opinion. |  |
| |
| The Poppy on 13:30 - Nov 2 with 4407 views | Lohengrin |
It's utter nonsense. The poppy is NOT, nor ever has been, a political symbol. When The Haig Fund was first launched in 1921 Edward, Prince of Wales, speaking after the second Cenotaph ceremony has this to say..
"all of us who were there will recall the words of McCrae, well remember the sight of this red bloom and ponder too the lads no longer with us. Though this fund is enabling vital care for wounded British ex-servicemen let the symbol itself be one of reconciliation. Let all of us, the survivors, in every nation of Europe be of one accord and lift our voices together and say never again."
Bollocks to FIFA! |  |
| An idea isn't responsible for those who believe in it. |
| |
| The Poppy on 13:30 - Nov 2 with 4405 views | dickythorpe |
6 pager........
Do the Germans wear poppies? |  | | |
| The Poppy on 13:34 - Nov 2 with 4396 views | Gravy |
Good on our PM for delivering a broadside to the corrupt chunts as well.
Yes, it is outrageous.
Two FIFA World Cups never took place at all because of WWII. I suppose the irony of that is lost on these bureaucrats, a good half of whom would be speaking German were it not for those who laid down their lives...
Boils my p/ss... |  | | |
| The Poppy on 13:37 - Nov 2 with 4382 views | Nogginthenog |
Wear them anyway no matter what that bunch of corrupt arseholes has to say. |  | | |
| The Poppy on 13:38 - Nov 2 with 4381 views | dailew |
Good.
About time someone stood up to poppy fascism.
Remember, it's all about the wearer.
Virtue signalling for right wingers.
Soon it will be all year firking round.
. [Post edited 2 Nov 2016 13:46]
|  |
| |
| The Poppy on 13:39 - Nov 2 with 4381 views | union_jack |
| The Poppy on 13:30 - Nov 2 by Lohengrin |
It's utter nonsense. The poppy is NOT, nor ever has been, a political symbol. When The Haig Fund was first launched in 1921 Edward, Prince of Wales, speaking after the second Cenotaph ceremony has this to say..
"all of us who were there will recall the words of McCrae, well remember the sight of this red bloom and ponder too the lads no longer with us. Though this fund is enabling vital care for wounded British ex-servicemen let the symbol itself be one of reconciliation. Let all of us, the survivors, in every nation of Europe be of one accord and lift our voices together and say never again."
Bollocks to FIFA! |
But is it not how it perceived nowadays? I.e. the fund supporting current serving servicemen and the regions in which we are active.
What about Iraq wearing something on their shirts which may be inflammatory to Iran for example? | |
| |
Login to get fewer ads
| The Poppy on 14:23 - Nov 2 with 4312 views | Lohengrin |
Politically neutral, studiedly so. | |
| An idea isn't responsible for those who believe in it. |
| |
| The Poppy on 14:29 - Nov 2 with 4300 views | londonlisa2001 |
| The Poppy on 14:23 - Nov 2 by Lohengrin |
Politically neutral, studiedly so. |
Surely only neutral within a defined political space though Loh? Wouldn't be seen as neutral to a global audience?
I guess that's the issue really. All of us (or the vast majority of us) would struggle to see how anyone could possibly be offended by the wearing of a poppy. But there would be parts of the world that clearly see it as a political expression. Some not too far away. I imagine it's the same the other way round - other countries may have symbols of their national pride that are as dear to them, and yet we might find it offensive from our standpoint.
It's all very difficult. I will wear a poppy with pride by the way, so am not talking about my personal views, but trying to see it as it may be viewed elsewhere. |  | | |
| The Poppy on 14:53 - Nov 2 with 4272 views | Lohengrin |
| The Poppy on 14:29 - Nov 2 by londonlisa2001 |
Surely only neutral within a defined political space though Loh? Wouldn't be seen as neutral to a global audience?
I guess that's the issue really. All of us (or the vast majority of us) would struggle to see how anyone could possibly be offended by the wearing of a poppy. But there would be parts of the world that clearly see it as a political expression. Some not too far away. I imagine it's the same the other way round - other countries may have symbols of their national pride that are as dear to them, and yet we might find it offensive from our standpoint.
It's all very difficult. I will wear a poppy with pride by the way, so am not talking about my personal views, but trying to see it as it may be viewed elsewhere. |
The RBL is most certainly neutral in a party-political sense. Could it be viewed as political in as much as it lobbies on behalf of its members, Lisa? I don't think so, most certainly not in the way critics would have us believe. That's just my opinion though I think it the correct one and I'm giving it as an RBL member of thirty years standing.
There is a great deal of pride involved in wearing a poppy and most certainly a sense of identification with previous generations. Dai seems to think that's 'virtue signalling,' most everybody else I'd suggest regards it as an act of gratitude.
No doubt there are some people somewhere who don't share my outlook. There's not much I can do about that save to tell them I have seen first-hand the enormous amount of good The RBL, and likewise the CWGC, have done and continue to do. [Post edited 2 Nov 2016 15:19]
| |
| An idea isn't responsible for those who believe in it. |
| |
| The Poppy on 14:56 - Nov 2 with 4268 views | DafyddHuw |
| The Poppy on 14:29 - Nov 2 by londonlisa2001 |
Surely only neutral within a defined political space though Loh? Wouldn't be seen as neutral to a global audience?
I guess that's the issue really. All of us (or the vast majority of us) would struggle to see how anyone could possibly be offended by the wearing of a poppy. But there would be parts of the world that clearly see it as a political expression. Some not too far away. I imagine it's the same the other way round - other countries may have symbols of their national pride that are as dear to them, and yet we might find it offensive from our standpoint.
It's all very difficult. I will wear a poppy with pride by the way, so am not talking about my personal views, but trying to see it as it may be viewed elsewhere. |
The poppy is a symbol of our national pride?
I thought it was something you bought so that money goes to the British Legion to help injured servicemen. |  | | |
| The Poppy on 14:57 - Nov 2 with 4262 views | Lohengrin |
| The Poppy on 14:56 - Nov 2 by DafyddHuw |
The poppy is a symbol of our national pride?
I thought it was something you bought so that money goes to the British Legion to help injured servicemen. |
I'd suggest it's both. | |
| An idea isn't responsible for those who believe in it. |
| |
| The Poppy on 15:00 - Nov 2 with 4257 views | DafyddHuw |
| The Poppy on 14:57 - Nov 2 by Lohengrin |
I'd suggest it's both. |
Since when? And national pride in what?
[Post edited 2 Nov 2016 15:01]
| | | |
| The Poppy on 15:00 - Nov 2 with 4255 views | Darran |
The whole debate every year gets on my tits. The fact that you won't see anyone on Sky or the BBC until the middle of November is pathetic they're clearly not wearing them as a mark of rememberance they're wearing them so some sad c*nt doesn't get offended. [Post edited 2 Nov 2016 15:10]
|  |
| |
| The Poppy on 15:05 - Nov 2 with 4250 views | londonlisa2001 |
| The Poppy on 14:56 - Nov 2 by DafyddHuw |
The poppy is a symbol of our national pride?
I thought it was something you bought so that money goes to the British Legion to help injured servicemen. |
I would suggest that the wearing of a poppy on a football shirt is a demonstration that it is at least to some degree, a symbol of national pride rather than simply a fundraiser.
Perhaps 'respect' would be a better word than pride? Don't know. But I do believe that not wearing a poppy is now seen as somehow non-patriotic. I think that's what dailew was referring to. A politician / newsreader / public figure wouldn't be seen without one these days. | | | |
| The Poppy on 15:06 - Nov 2 with 4246 views | Lohengrin |
| The Poppy on 15:00 - Nov 2 by DafyddHuw |
Since when? And national pride in what?
[Post edited 2 Nov 2016 15:01]
|
Since inception and pride in the sons of these islands who gave their lives so you and I wouldn't have to. | |
| An idea isn't responsible for those who believe in it. |
| |
| The Poppy on 15:08 - Nov 2 with 4237 views | DafyddHuw |
| The Poppy on 15:05 - Nov 2 by londonlisa2001 |
I would suggest that the wearing of a poppy on a football shirt is a demonstration that it is at least to some degree, a symbol of national pride rather than simply a fundraiser.
Perhaps 'respect' would be a better word than pride? Don't know. But I do believe that not wearing a poppy is now seen as somehow non-patriotic. I think that's what dailew was referring to. A politician / newsreader / public figure wouldn't be seen without one these days. |
See Daz's previous post.
And I've never worn a poppy on my life? Does that make me non-patriotic?
[Post edited 2 Nov 2016 15:10]
| | | |
| The Poppy on 15:10 - Nov 2 with 4231 views | londonlisa2001 |
| The Poppy on 15:08 - Nov 2 by DafyddHuw |
See Daz's previous post.
And I've never worn a poppy on my life? Does that make me non-patriotic?
[Post edited 2 Nov 2016 15:10]
|
Yes, and I agree with it.
But that also demonstrates that it's far more than a fundraiser, for if it was simply a fundraising mechanism, people would wear it, not wear it, at their pleasure. | | | |
| The Poppy on 15:11 - Nov 2 with 4223 views | Darran |
| The Poppy on 15:09 - Nov 2 by Lohengrin |
After reading that I've never been more certain that the demise of the Grammar School heralded disaster.  |
I was on my phone piss off.
It's true though. | |
| |
| The Poppy on 15:13 - Nov 2 with 4220 views | londonlisa2001 |
| The Poppy on 15:08 - Nov 2 by DafyddHuw |
See Daz's previous post.
And I've never worn a poppy on my life? Does that make me non-patriotic?
[Post edited 2 Nov 2016 15:10]
|
With regard to your edit, which was done after my answer - no, not in my eyes. I think it's completely up to you.
I think you are misunderstanding my point of view. I was simply trying to point out to Lohengrin why a symbol of an organisation that supports the British Armed Forces could easily be seen as political in the broadest sense when viewed by the rest of the world even if it is politically neutral in a British sense. | | | |
| The Poppy on 15:14 - Nov 2 with 4217 views | Lohengrin |
| The Poppy on 15:11 - Nov 2 by Darran |
I was on my phone piss off.
It's true though. |
Of course you start seeing them crop up as November approaches, they don't sell them all year round, dopey!  | |
| An idea isn't responsible for those who believe in it. |
| |
| The Poppy on 15:25 - Nov 2 with 4186 views | DafyddHuw |
| The Poppy on 15:13 - Nov 2 by londonlisa2001 |
With regard to your edit, which was done after my answer - no, not in my eyes. I think it's completely up to you.
I think you are misunderstanding my point of view. I was simply trying to point out to Lohengrin why a symbol of an organisation that supports the British Armed Forces could easily be seen as political in the broadest sense when viewed by the rest of the world even if it is politically neutral in a British sense. |
No, I completely understood your point of view. What surprised me was -
"I imagine it's the same the other way round - other countries may have symbols of their national pride that are as dear to them, and yet we might find it offensive from our standpoint. "
where you're clearly implying that the poppy is a symbol of our national pride which is dear to us. I just wondered why you made that assumption. | | | |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
