| Given? on 22:32 - May 21 with 2981 views | WeAreQPR12 |
Good keeper but too old for me.
Not a massive fan of Green so I think we should get Foster.
He's been outstanding for west brom this season and is a good age. |  | |  |
| Given? on 22:36 - May 21 with 2939 views | RANGERS4EVER |
| Given? on 22:32 - May 21 by WeAreQPR12 |
Good keeper but too old for me.
Not a massive fan of Green so I think we should get Foster.
He's been outstanding for west brom this season and is a good age. |
I agree with Foster but would take Given over him any day.
Fantastic keeper and not that old when you see how Friedel is doing .
One of the best one on one shotstoppers I have ever seen.
|  |
| |
| Given? on 22:43 - May 21 with 2894 views | Pey |
Honestly ?
Back in the days one of the best goalkeepers.
If we as a club wanna show real intention to become a real force in the PL we don't need overpaid overaged leftovers from other clubs on big wages.
Mistakes from last season should have learned us something ?
Ben Foster, now with that goalkeeper the club would show real intention.
Right age and still would have at least 4 good years to come and taking this club further.
|  | | |
| Given? on 23:06 - May 21 with 2816 views | Lblock |
From what I saw in the run in, Given and Marc Cluelessberg single handed kept Villa up
Keepers like Given are worth 9 points a season min
I'd still prefer Stockdale or Al Habsi but I've a feeling Paddy could get over whatever injury he was carrying and be back |  |
| Cherish and enjoy life.... this ain't no dress rehearsal |
| |
| Given? on 23:27 - May 21 with 2755 views | SpiritofGregory |
Hughes doesn't rate Paddy. Must say I've been really disappointed with Paddy this season and now understand why he has never been signed by an established premier league club.
Given is quality. Can't stand Green, I always get the feeling that he'll at some point during a match drop a clanger. |  | | |
| Given? on 23:31 - May 21 with 2746 views | imustbemad |
Shay Given is probably the best keeper of the last 5+ years, Fantastic signing if it came off. At least another 2-3 years at the top level in him |  | | |
| Given? on 23:37 - May 21 with 2725 views | Watford_Ranger |
I'd be delighted. Obviously he's nearing the end but his form of this season suggests he's not as on the wane as much as most his age. | | | |
| Given? on 23:38 - May 21 with 2721 views | shrewranger |
| Given? on 23:31 - May 21 by imustbemad |
Shay Given is probably the best keeper of the last 5+ years, Fantastic signing if it came off. At least another 2-3 years at the top level in him |
agreed....rather him than green any day,but only at the right price.love paddy, but the time has come sadly. |  | | |
Login to get fewer ads
| Given? on 00:00 - May 22 with 2694 views | INFIRMARY |
| Given? on 23:38 - May 21 by shrewranger |
agreed....rather him than green any day,but only at the right price.love paddy, but the time has come sadly. |
Great Keeper, watching him when we played Villa it was everything else he offered in regards of back line leadership and commanding his area ! plus time wasting |  |
| |
| Given? on 00:08 - May 22 with 2680 views | HollowayRanger |
robinson and green both out of contract
carson and given would cost us funds they could be used elsewhere? |  |
| |
| Given? on 02:14 - May 22 with 2597 views | timcocking |
I'd have loved Given earlier, now i'd prefer a bigger, younger keeper, but he's still young enough to be quality. Similar to Paul Robinson, who's a free transfer.
After being in Rustenberg and watching Robert "spastic" Green, i can't forgive him. |  | | |
| Given? on 03:15 - May 22 with 2589 views | hoopstar67 |
| Given? on 22:32 - May 21 by WeAreQPR12 |
Good keeper but too old for me.
Not a massive fan of Green so I think we should get Foster.
He's been outstanding for west brom this season and is a good age. |
I'm sorry how can you reject Given? By far one of the best keepers in the country and you want to reject him for Foster who had a nightmare of a game against us.Foster is always prone to mistakes. |  | | |
| Given? on 05:05 - May 22 with 2561 views | exiled_dictator |
Given is 'only' 36, which is generally old for a football player, but i doubt many would turn down the Ryan Giggs option at 38. Plus a goalie generally has a couple more years than an outfield player.
Are we still linked with 37 year old Del Piero? And Scholes, like him or not, is still quite handy at a similar age.
Exceptions rather than the rule, but don't rule someone out due to age.
Given has been a quality keeper for years, and still has it.
Better than anything we have at the moment, and can still offer a couple of seasons of safety & security in the box. Well worth the effort, as it now seems likely that Kenny will be teaming up with Warnock at Leeds.
Less inspired by Green, who seems to use butter on his gloves to keep them shiny. Obviously, a quality keeper is needed and I wouldn't say no to Given even at his current pay rate. |  |
| It's not what you've got; it's where you stick it. | | Poll: | Climate Change |
| |
| Given? on 07:44 - May 22 with 2459 views | KevinPR |
I'd be happy if we snapped Given up. 36 is not old for a goalkeeper.
I've never been too convinced by Green. |  | | |
| Given? on 07:57 - May 22 with 2431 views | Gloucs_R |
Being an ex keeper....
Given, one of the best keepers in the Prem and would be Man City number 1 if it werent for Joe Hart.
Foster - still learning, good keeper but loses concentration from time to time
Green - not actually that fussed about him. Average to good.
I'd have Given with Lewis as his back up. If it came down to money then Foster. |  |
| |
| Given? on 08:21 - May 22 with 2404 views | wombat |
| Given? on 22:32 - May 21 by WeAreQPR12 |
Good keeper but too old for me.
Not a massive fan of Green so I think we should get Foster.
He's been outstanding for west brom this season and is a good age. |
would bring him in a heartbeat , great keeper not to old either , commands his box brilliantly and a superb shot stopper also dont think he would cost a huge amount either |  |
| |
| Given? on 12:40 - May 22 with 2274 views | W7Ranger |
| Given? on 02:14 - May 22 by timcocking |
I'd have loved Given earlier, now i'd prefer a bigger, younger keeper, but he's still young enough to be quality. Similar to Paul Robinson, who's a free transfer.
After being in Rustenberg and watching Robert "spastic" Green, i can't forgive him. |
"spastic"????
Have a word with yerself fella ffs!!!
|  | | |
| Given? on 13:41 - May 22 with 2216 views | TacticalR |
Isn't Paddy supposed to have some kind of hip injury? I thought it was going to be operated on.
The thing he has a problem with is getting down to low shots (possibly due to the injury). One of his best reflex saves was against Robin van Persie at Loftus Road, as that was not a low shot. |  |
| |
| Given? on 14:00 - May 22 with 2177 views | Tonto |
Kenny was great last year.
this season - meh... some good saves (van persie) but too many clangers (Zabaletta). Rumours of the hip injury could be the reason - but is there any guarantee it wil sort itself over the summer?
I think we could, indeed should upgrade. Foster, Robinson and Given are all upgrades - green about equal. But Given is getting on a bit, would rather get Foster or Robinson. |  |
| |
| Given? on 14:11 - May 22 with 2153 views | barbicanranger |
this is unbearable the season's just finished and we've already been linked with 3 keepers, one of our top players going to wolfsb. and we're hot on the heals of victor moses... |  | | |
| Given? on 16:54 - May 22 with 2095 views | Mattnme |
I guess i'm the only one that likes Hennessey at Wolves. Imo he stopped them getting less points than Derby. |  | | |
| Given? on 17:01 - May 22 with 2087 views | adhoc_qpr |
| Given? on 16:54 - May 22 by Mattnme |
I guess i'm the only one that likes Hennessey at Wolves. Imo he stopped them getting less points than Derby. |
Hennessey is decent enough, but he's out for the next 6 months at least with a damaged cruciate ligament.
Sadly for Paddy, he just couldn't replicate hisChampionship winning form whether due to the better standard or his injuries i'm not sure.
I'd take any of the keeper mentioned over him - Given, Robinson, Green, Foster. | | | |
| Given? on 17:36 - May 22 with 2054 views | pomanjou |
| Given? on 22:32 - May 21 by WeAreQPR12 |
Good keeper but too old for me.
Not a massive fan of Green so I think we should get Foster.
He's been outstanding for west brom this season and is a good age. |
Plenty of top goalies have played well into their 40s and some closer to 50. Peter Shilton still played for England at 41 and stayed a pro until he was 46 I believe.
Given would be good for 5 years easy. |  |
| |
| Given? on 18:25 - May 22 with 2011 views | brendan |
Given???? Yes Please!!
Top pro, years left in him. Can't believe one of the real big teams didn't sign him at some stage. |  | | |
| Given? on 18:30 - May 22 with 2001 views | komradkirk |
Top keeper,but i see news of qpr's interest has him going down with an injury training with Ireland. |  | | |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
