Voting was locked for this match at midnight on Sunday 24th November but you may still add your mini match reports. Note that members and non-members alike were able to vote.

Your Queens Park Rangers v Stoke City Match Reports

MelakaRanger added 18:07 - Nov 23 Having awarded my votes I see that Celar has an average of 1.6. How can anyone have given him more than 1. He deserves zero
2

HarryLondon added 18:41 - Nov 23 Celar is useless and Marti keeps playing him! Alfie Lloyd has to start in Cardiff and Celar needs to be sold in January- he is not up to the Championship. Neither is Madsen, Anderson or Ashby.
1

MickB added 20:10 - Nov 23 I would keep them all and flog Jackanourry. Literally. His data-driven masterplan has inflicted these expensive inadequates on us. (I don't include Anderson or young Ashby in this).
1

Geoff78 added 16:40 - Nov 24 It seems something's wrong between Cifuentes and Nourry and the crowd's support for Marti shows where the fans loyalty lies. A word of sympathy for Nourry. He shouldn't have been put in this position, without adequate support. However clever he is he can't have the experience to do a job like this without advice/mentoring from an 'old hand'. As things stand you'd probably say the summer signings consist of 2 successes (Nardi + Saito), 3 probably ok (Varane, Morgan, Morrison) + 3 maybe ok given time (Dembele, Bennie, Ashby). So far Celar, Madsen (although he was better yesterday) and Santos have not impressed. Data is great but a DoF needs more. He's clever so I'd hope he'll learn. He should start by stating his support for Marti and building a good relationship with him. But he may be feeling heat from the owners, which will make things difficult for him.

0

tsbains64 added 07:10 - Nov 25 High rating for the ref, just to annoy the wingeing Stoke fans Thought he did a reasonable job
0