| What is your opinion? 08:53 - Apr 4 with 9497 views | Lucyrochdale |
I am a primary school teacher (year 5). I have a rule that children are not allowed to go to the toilet during lesson time. |  | | |  |
| What is your opinion? on 09:07 - Apr 4 with 5939 views | D_Alien |
Please miss, unless this is a piss-take, why do you think you can implement your own personal rulebook on calls of nature? Is there not a school policy? |  |
| |
| What is your opinion? on 09:11 - Apr 4 with 5924 views | Lucyrochdale |
| What is your opinion? on 09:07 - Apr 4 by D_Alien |
Please miss, unless this is a piss-take, why do you think you can implement your own personal rulebook on calls of nature? Is there not a school policy? |
It is down to teacher discretion. Year 5 are 9 and 10, they can hold on until break. | | | |
| What is your opinion? on 09:20 - Apr 4 with 5884 views | D_Alien |
| What is your opinion? on 09:11 - Apr 4 by Lucyrochdale |
It is down to teacher discretion. Year 5 are 9 and 10, they can hold on until break. |
It's a very long time since I sat in a primary school classroom, but if for instance a child has a temporary medical problem, they may not be able to hold on till break
Do you risk having them shit their pants, and stinking the classroom out? Your call | |
| |
| What is your opinion? on 09:21 - Apr 4 with 5884 views | rochdale_ranger |
My partner is a teacher and works with kids with behavioural needs and he said it depends how much it is distracting them etc. Personally if the kid needs to go let them go. |  | | |
| What is your opinion? on 09:35 - Apr 4 with 5827 views | D_Alien |
For what it's worth, I do understand the need to retain classroom control (and not just of bowels and bladder!)
I think it's wrong for the school to allow teachers discretion - children need to know where they stand - or sit - and having one rule by one teacher and different rules by others isn't a great example to them
What's your opinion on that?
[Post edited 4 Apr 2018 9:36]
| |
| |
| What is your opinion? on 09:37 - Apr 4 with 5820 views | Lucyrochdale |
| What is your opinion? on 09:20 - Apr 4 by D_Alien |
It's a very long time since I sat in a primary school classroom, but if for instance a child has a temporary medical problem, they may not be able to hold on till break
Do you risk having them shit their pants, and stinking the classroom out? Your call |
If they have a medical problem I should be made aware.
One of the parents were annoyed last week because I made her daughter wait for the afternoon, the girl asked 5 minutes after lunch. | | | |
| What is your opinion? on 09:38 - Apr 4 with 5812 views | Lucyrochdale |
| What is your opinion? on 09:35 - Apr 4 by D_Alien |
For what it's worth, I do understand the need to retain classroom control (and not just of bowels and bladder!)
I think it's wrong for the school to allow teachers discretion - children need to know where they stand - or sit - and having one rule by one teacher and different rules by others isn't a great example to them
What's your opinion on that?
[Post edited 4 Apr 2018 9:36]
|
I totally see your point. But I don't think you could have the same toilet policy for both younger and older children. | | | |
| What is your opinion? on 09:42 - Apr 4 with 5789 views | joecooke |
| What is your opinion? on 09:37 - Apr 4 by Lucyrochdale |
If they have a medical problem I should be made aware.
One of the parents were annoyed last week because I made her daughter wait for the afternoon, the girl asked 5 minutes after lunch. |
Do you normally teach full afternoons in a mainstream high school?
Sorry didnt read it properly,but if a child in a primary school needs the toilet in a 2/2.5 hour period then its unfair to deny that in my opinion,we are not in Victorian era. [Post edited 4 Apr 2018 9:48]
|  |
| |
Login to get fewer ads
| What is your opinion? on 09:43 - Apr 4 with 5785 views | fitzochris |
| What is your opinion? on 09:38 - Apr 4 by Lucyrochdale |
I totally see your point. But I don't think you could have the same toilet policy for both younger and older children. |
Completely disagree with this. Children should be allowed to use the toilet whenever they need to. |  |
| |
| What is your opinion? on 09:48 - Apr 4 with 5758 views | PaulHeymanGuy |
I'm sorry but it's totally wrong for you to deny anybody going to the toilet when they need to.
Holding in urine is extremely bad for your health. I'm not sure why you'd even consider this being the right thing to do. How would you feel if your child came home and said that they wet or sh*t themselves because their teacher wouldn't let them go to the toilet when they needed too? Would you be cleaning any mess up for these students If they were left with no alternative but to go in their pants? The last point also could lead to bullying in from class mates if it was to happen.
Sounds like somebody went into teaching for a power trip rather than wanting the best for these kids. | | | |
| What is your opinion? on 09:54 - Apr 4 with 5718 views | Lucyrochdale |
| What is your opinion? on 09:42 - Apr 4 by joecooke |
Do you normally teach full afternoons in a mainstream high school?
Sorry didnt read it properly,but if a child in a primary school needs the toilet in a 2/2.5 hour period then its unfair to deny that in my opinion,we are not in Victorian era. [Post edited 4 Apr 2018 9:48]
|
The longest they go without a break is a couple of hours. If the girl had gone at lunch she would have had no problem. They are 9 and 10 they should be able to hold their wee. | | | |
| What is your opinion? on 09:57 - Apr 4 with 5699 views | fitzochris |
| What is your opinion? on 09:54 - Apr 4 by Lucyrochdale |
The longest they go without a break is a couple of hours. If the girl had gone at lunch she would have had no problem. They are 9 and 10 they should be able to hold their wee. |
I reckon you’re on the wind up.
If I need a slash at work, I get up and go to the toilet. I don’t sit there doing a contortionist act in my chair, giving myself abdominal pain into the bargain.
Sometimes I need the toilet after just coming back from lunch. That’s the way it goes. My body doesn’t run to a corporate clock. | |
| |
| What is your opinion? on 09:57 - Apr 4 with 5698 views | DaleiLama |
Is it always the same child wanting to go to the loo or different ones i.e. is it an attempt to exert power? If so, you may wish to consider pre-emptive visits before class starts?
If not, and the child is in a genuine state of anguish, I would think it would be wrong to deny an "exceptional" visit. Especially if the child had a tendency towards your namesake! That might be more distracting than allowing a short bathroom break. |  |
| |
| What is your opinion? on 09:59 - Apr 4 with 5691 views | D_Alien |
| What is your opinion? on 09:37 - Apr 4 by Lucyrochdale |
If they have a medical problem I should be made aware.
One of the parents were annoyed last week because I made her daughter wait for the afternoon, the girl asked 5 minutes after lunch. |
A child might've eaten or drank something which disagreed with them that day, so their parents wouldn't have any pre-knowledge of it. Have you never been similarly indisposed? | |
| |
| What is your opinion? on 10:00 - Apr 4 with 5687 views | nordenblue |
| What is your opinion? on 09:54 - Apr 4 by Lucyrochdale |
The longest they go without a break is a couple of hours. If the girl had gone at lunch she would have had no problem. They are 9 and 10 they should be able to hold their wee. |
It's not Strangeways you're teaching at is It?
Get a grip and an element of common sense helps,if my daughter came home from school having wet herself as a result of some control freak like you I'd certainly have something to say about it to you. | | | |
| What is your opinion? on 10:07 - Apr 4 with 5644 views | Lucyrochdale |
| What is your opinion? on 10:00 - Apr 4 by nordenblue |
It's not Strangeways you're teaching at is It?
Get a grip and an element of common sense helps,if my daughter came home from school having wet herself as a result of some control freak like you I'd certainly have something to say about it to you. |
9 and 10 year olds shouldn't be wetting themselves. | | | |
| What is your opinion? on 10:07 - Apr 4 with 5644 views | Barrowdale |
It is "one of the parents was annoyed"
Hope you don't teach grammar! |  | | |
| What is your opinion? on 10:07 - Apr 4 with 5642 views | EllGazzell |
| What is your opinion? on 09:37 - Apr 4 by Lucyrochdale |
If they have a medical problem I should be made aware.
One of the parents were annoyed last week because I made her daughter wait for the afternoon, the girl asked 5 minutes after lunch. |
I hope you're not teaching them English. |  |
| |
| What is your opinion? on 10:11 - Apr 4 with 5622 views | joecooke |
| What is your opinion? on 09:54 - Apr 4 by Lucyrochdale |
The longest they go without a break is a couple of hours. If the girl had gone at lunch she would have had no problem. They are 9 and 10 they should be able to hold their wee. |
Definate wind up!
My daughter had started her periods by this age and if she hadnt been allowed a trip to the bathroom when needed then i can assure you that words would have been had with the school.
I also work in education, severe special needs as it goes and your policy certainly would work in our environment! | |
| |
| What is your opinion? on 10:24 - Apr 4 with 5561 views | rochdale_ranger |
| What is your opinion? on 10:11 - Apr 4 by joecooke |
Definate wind up!
My daughter had started her periods by this age and if she hadnt been allowed a trip to the bathroom when needed then i can assure you that words would have been had with the school.
I also work in education, severe special needs as it goes and your policy certainly would work in our environment! |
How does one get so wound up over a thread about children’s toilet habits? Calm down ffs. Some kids use going to the toilet as an excuse to skive of and wander around the school. I know I did at that age. And in the exceptional circumstances a primary aged child was on the rag In sure exceptions would be made. When I worked in the construction industry I used to have 16 and 18 year old apprentices who used to go for phantom shits and pisses to avoid work. Expecting your little darlings to hold their piss for an hour is not torture. | | | |
| What is your opinion? on 10:30 - Apr 4 with 5539 views | joecooke |
| What is your opinion? on 10:24 - Apr 4 by rochdale_ranger |
How does one get so wound up over a thread about children’s toilet habits? Calm down ffs. Some kids use going to the toilet as an excuse to skive of and wander around the school. I know I did at that age. And in the exceptional circumstances a primary aged child was on the rag In sure exceptions would be made. When I worked in the construction industry I used to have 16 and 18 year old apprentices who used to go for phantom shits and pisses to avoid work. Expecting your little darlings to hold their piss for an hour is not torture. |
I am not wound up fella,the question was What is your opinion? So i gave one,not that its got fook all to do with you. | |
| |
| What is your opinion? on 10:42 - Apr 4 with 5487 views | DaleiLama |
"Teacher" coming on football forum where most of posters will be male asking about a falling out with a mum over toileting and exhibiting grammar not befitting a teacher? Wouldn't you go on mumsnet? Hmmmmmmmm. Benefit of the doubt that Lucy was a Dale fan at first, but think she might have logged on to her dad's computer now. Good to know Milly is alive and kicking at least. [Post edited 4 Apr 2018 10:47]
| |
| |
| What is your opinion? on 10:45 - Apr 4 with 5467 views | SaxonDale |
It's one which requires common sense and perhaps isn't as easy as introducing a blanket rule either way. If you let children go whenever they want then you will always get some take the pee (pun intended) and go several times a day, however there has got to be common sense and usually it's quite obvious if a child needs the toilet. There are also naturally parts of a lesson which are more important to be in the classroom than others- usually an 'are you desperate?' or 'can you please just wait 2 minutes?' suffice- the kids will let you know if they can't!
Ultimately teaching is about knowing your class and judging what's best to help them and their learning. Trust yourself to make the right judgements, you know them better than any of us. |  | | |
| What is your opinion? on 11:11 - Apr 4 with 5378 views | mingthemerciless |
About a month ago I was browsing another local football club site when this exact question was posed by a complete newcomer to the site. Just like this thread. Is that a coincidence ? | | | |
| What is your opinion? on 11:14 - Apr 4 with 5354 views | rochdale_ranger |
| What is your opinion? on 11:11 - Apr 4 by mingthemerciless |
About a month ago I was browsing another local football club site when this exact question was posed by a complete newcomer to the site. Just like this thread. Is that a coincidence ? |
Do you think she’s taking the piss. | | | |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
