Andy Butler on 14:35 - May 22 with 4084 views | isitme | With the signing of McGinty I feel centre half is a position in which we are well served and I am not sure that Butler would be significantly better than what we have currently. | ![](/images/avatars/1081.gif) | | ![](/images/icons/ignore-user.png) |
Andy Butler on 14:51 - May 22 with 4035 views | richfoad32 | I would have him here like a shot if possible. Still only 30 and I've always been impressed with him whenever we've played the Saddlers. He offers far more experience at League 1 level than any of our current centre halves and a Walsall fan I work with is gutted he's leaving. If he's leaving Walsall because he's unhappy with the terms they've offered though I don't possibly see how we could offer him anything better unfortunately. | ![](/images/avatars/0.gif) | | ![](/images/icons/ignore-user.png) |
Andy Butler on 14:55 - May 22 with 4018 views | Brierls | He trained with us for a while after leaving Huddersfield and was expected to sign (from what I heard). I don't know what happened, but he ended up joining Walsall and did very well for them. I wouldn't be disappointed to see him sign, he's a good player with plenty of experience in League One. No such thing as too many leaders in the dressing room, especially after losing Cav. If he did sign I think we can defo put to bed any hope of getting O'Connell back on loan, we've already got Lancashire, Eastham & McGinty (and Bennett & O'Connor at a push) contracted for next season. I do think we will sign another centre half. | ![](/images/avatars/1199.gif) | | ![](/images/icons/ignore-user.png) |
Andy Butler on 18:25 - May 22 with 3732 views | AtThePeake | Would definitely take him at Dale. Was gutted when we didn't sign him last time round and I've been proven right by his time at Walsall. Very capable CB. | ![](/images/avatars/1813.gif) |
| ![](/images/icons/ignore-user.png) |
Andy Butler on 18:38 - May 22 with 3710 views | ValleySaddler | From what i have being told by mates who watch Walsall,Butler is after a big payday .. | ![](/images/avatars/2294.gif) | | ![](/images/icons/ignore-user.png) |
Andy Butler on 19:30 - May 22 with 3628 views | SuddenLad |
Andy Butler on 18:38 - May 22 by ValleySaddler | From what i have being told by mates who watch Walsall,Butler is after a big payday .. |
We've had enough of the mercenaries down the years. Let someone else pander to his requests. | ![](/images/avatars/5895.gif) |
| “It is easier to fool people, than to convince them that they have been fooled†|
| ![](/images/icons/ignore-user.png) |
Andy Butler on 19:31 - May 22 with 3626 views | Brierls |
Clucking bell. I didn't expect that. | ![](/images/avatars/1199.gif) | | ![](/images/icons/ignore-user.png) | Login to get fewer ads
Andy Butler on 05:46 - May 23 with 3384 views | electricblue | Possible bury target......! | ![](/images/avatars/6227.gif) |
| My all time favourite Dale player Mr Lyndon Symmonds |
| ![](/images/icons/ignore-user.png) |
| |