x

Pompey 1 Carlisle 1: Cause for concern? Yes and no

So a 1-1 draw against Carlisle is the reward for an afternoon when Pompey had more possession and pressure, and as many chances, than in almost any game I can recall. A cause for concern? Yes and no.

On one hand the fact is the failure to beat a limited team who had 10 men for an hour will bring back painful memories of last season, when too many home draws - most of them 0-0 rather than 1-1, admittedly - cost Pompey dear, and in fact cost Pompey promotion.

But on the other hand, Pompey played well - very well - and if they can dominate teams like that on a regular basis they will beat more of them than they don't. Not all will be capable of frustrating them as Carlisle did.

The worry for Pompey fans after game one of 46 will be - do they have a goalscorer who can take advantage of enough of the numerous chances they look set to create?

You can't judge too much after one game but plenty seem to think Michael Smith is not the answer in a team playing 4-2-3-1. And in fairness to those who think that, and I'm one of them, they are not just basing that on this single game - they saw last season how he might give his all in every game, and chase everything, but he is not a poacher who scores a goal every other game.

Presumably Paul Cook will give Curtis Main, Noel Hunt and Conor Chaplin plenty of chances in that system or similar ones too, and it could be that one of that trio ends up being the perfect man for the role.

The promising signs against Carlisle came in the mix of midfield and attacking talent Cook has assembled. In Michael Doyle and Danny Rose as the holding pair and Gary Roberts, Milan Lalkovic and Carl Baker as the three in front of them, Pompey have five players each capable of doing serious damage to League Two defences. When you think they also have Kyle Bennett and - when fully fit - Gareth Evans to add into his options for that little quintet, it's a mouthwatering prospect.

There may be times when one of the five misses out and Cook goes with two men up front. Smith plus Hunt or Chaplin would be worth seeing from the start one week, in my view, and Main has not come here to warm the bench and will be champing at the bit for his chance to stake a claim.

Defensively, there was not much to judge against a Carlisle team who didn't do much attacking with 11 men and did virtually none with 10.

The goal that silenced Fratton for a while on this sunny first day of the season was a soft one, Carlisle cutting through the centre too easily. But with Christian Burgess marshalling things as he did last season, Pompey are unlikely to have too much to worry about at the back.

We know what we will get from Burgess and Enda Stevens - we wait to see who will be Burgess' regular central partner, though my money would be on Matt Clarke being the preferred choice once he is fit. Jack Whatmough may have other ideas but looks short of being back to his best just yet.

New right-back Drew Talbot had some good moments, though looks like he may not offer quite the same lung-bursting streaks down the right win that we became used to from his predeccesor Ben Davies. And in goal, David Forde, for the little he had to do, looks a keeper capable of commanding his defenders and his area.

Much, then, to be optimistic about at the start of a season which really ought to bring promotion - if only to finally escape a league where, still, there are too many teams who think blatant time-wasting is what we pay our money to see. If refs are cracking down on dissent (for which I detect no pressure from fans), why can't they also get stricter on time-wasting keepers like Carlisle's? A few earlier yellow cards or the odd red for using up too much time would stamp it out.

For now the jury is out on the striker issue. Smith has work to do to convince us he is the answer - Cook had plenty to think about, with games coming thick and fast now we are under way.

One thing is for sure, though - we are in for an entertaining ride.

Pompey (4-2-3-1): Forde; Talbot, Whatmough, Burgess, Stevens; Rose (Hunt 83), Doyle (c); Baker, Roberts, Lalkovic (Bennett 68); Smith (Chaplin 68). Subs not used: Bass, Davies, Barton, Main

Referee: Graham Salisbury

Attendance: 17,570 (481 away fans)

Advertisement

Click here to sign up for an account and reserve your username! You can then post on the Forum and add your comments to articles

What to read next:

Cullen on Pompey's transfer strategy: 'It will bring success long-term'
Andy Cullen is comfortable that Pompey's recruitment strategy is working - and says it's important to look at the long-term not just the short-term.
Grateful and happy - how Bishop is feeling after triumphant Pompey return
Grateful to be back in the fold - and for all the support he has been shown by staff and team-mates at Fratton Park.
Blues belief among frustration - Mousinho positive ahead of Pompey-Preston
Pompey are bottom of the Championship and there's a fair bit of doom and gloom among the fan base - but you won't find John Mousinho feeling sorry for himself as he plots to try to secure a home win over Preston North End this weekend.
Pompey head to Hull with boss insisting: We're still in positive mood
John Mousinho is confident Pompey will be in the right frame of mind as they bid to recover from their latest Championship setbacks by gaining some reward from their trip to Hull.
Pompey have so much room for improvement - but doomed already? No way!
Twelve games into Pompey's season, and it would appear we've landed slap bang in the middle of relegation fight. Not what we wanted, not what many expected, I don't think, and not a very nice prospect for the long winter months ahead.
Queens Park Rangers 1 - 2 Portsmouth - Player Ratings and Reports
If you saw the match, please give us your player ratings and a mini match report.
'At the start of the journey' - Pompey chief outlines spending strategy
Pompey chief executive Andy Cullen has promised Pompey are not shirking away from spending money on players - but stressed they're at the start of the sort of journey that's brought major success to the likes of Brighton and Brentford.
Pompey in 84-85: the Santa game, 4-4 with Fulham, Biley, Webb, Dillon and Vince - and last-day heartbreak
When I decided to devote this season's View From the North Stand columns in the PFC programme to our past 21 seasons in the second tier, there was only one it was legal to feature in the Oxford programme... 1984-85.
Pompey v Oxford - a must-win game for Blues, or is such talk too early?
October does seem early to talk about must-win games. There are, after all, 38 Championship games to go before we see the final league table.
The power of partnerships - and why Michael Eisner is happy to put faith in this pairing
Michael Eisner calls it the power of partnerships - and he is convinced the pairing he has put faith in to carry Pompey upwards is the right one.