| First World War definitive book 08:07 - Nov 7 with 2441 views | Pegojack |
An appeal to Loh, or anyone else who can help. With all the focus on the First World War in recent weeks, I realised that although I knew a lot about the fighting and the horrendous conditions endured, I knew nothing about the causes. The historical background. Can anyone recommend a definitive history book which covers the political build up, the war itself and maybe the aftermath? Thanks. |  | | |  |
| First World War definitive book on 08:41 - Nov 7 with 2423 views | Lohengrin |
These two cover both periods very well, mate.
 |  |
| An idea isn't responsible for those who believe in it. |
| |
| First World War definitive book on 08:46 - Nov 7 with 2418 views | Lohengrin |
For the war itself the best, most accessible short account would be this from a British perspective. I’ve turned to it hundreds of times over the years.
We’d be here for a month if I was to start listing books you ought to read but if it’s just an excellent general account you’re after then this would be it.
 | |
| An idea isn't responsible for those who believe in it. |
| |
| First World War definitive book on 10:14 - Nov 7 with 2385 views | Catullus |
| First World War definitive book on 08:46 - Nov 7 by Lohengrin |
For the war itself the best, most accessible short account would be this from a British perspective. I’ve turned to it hundreds of times over the years.
We’d be here for a month if I was to start listing books you ought to read but if it’s just an excellent general account you’re after then this would be it.
|
I shall give that a try, if they have it on Kindle.
I do prefer the WW2 books though, out of personal interest. My grandfather was a Royal Marine Commando, I always look out for anything that's about places he served. He was in a lot of well known engagements, including the disastrous amphibious assault of Tobruk. He was on HMS Sikh which wa sunk and he made it to HMS Zulu, he was at El Alamein and Normandy.
How the hell he made it through I can barely understand and like you, Lohengrin, I don't idolise fotbballers or celebrities, my Grandfather is my hero.
I was watching Britain's Great War (BBC2 14.45) and it's hard to understand, to fathom out. So much stupidity and waste of life.
I think the final scene of Blackadder captured the stupidity very well. Imagine being told to go over the top and walk in lines towards machine guns, were they very brave or mad...or both? Lions led by Donkeys indeed. |  |
| |
| First World War definitive book on 10:52 - Nov 7 with 2371 views | controversial_jack |
| First World War definitive book on 10:14 - Nov 7 by Catullus |
I shall give that a try, if they have it on Kindle.
I do prefer the WW2 books though, out of personal interest. My grandfather was a Royal Marine Commando, I always look out for anything that's about places he served. He was in a lot of well known engagements, including the disastrous amphibious assault of Tobruk. He was on HMS Sikh which wa sunk and he made it to HMS Zulu, he was at El Alamein and Normandy.
How the hell he made it through I can barely understand and like you, Lohengrin, I don't idolise fotbballers or celebrities, my Grandfather is my hero.
I was watching Britain's Great War (BBC2 14.45) and it's hard to understand, to fathom out. So much stupidity and waste of life.
I think the final scene of Blackadder captured the stupidity very well. Imagine being told to go over the top and walk in lines towards machine guns, were they very brave or mad...or both? Lions led by Donkeys indeed. |
Going over the top was the only option at the time, all armies did it, usually preceded by an artillery bombardment - often unsuccessfully | | | |
| First World War definitive book on 11:04 - Nov 7 with 2363 views | WarwickHunt |
| First World War definitive book on 10:14 - Nov 7 by Catullus |
I shall give that a try, if they have it on Kindle.
I do prefer the WW2 books though, out of personal interest. My grandfather was a Royal Marine Commando, I always look out for anything that's about places he served. He was in a lot of well known engagements, including the disastrous amphibious assault of Tobruk. He was on HMS Sikh which wa sunk and he made it to HMS Zulu, he was at El Alamein and Normandy.
How the hell he made it through I can barely understand and like you, Lohengrin, I don't idolise fotbballers or celebrities, my Grandfather is my hero.
I was watching Britain's Great War (BBC2 14.45) and it's hard to understand, to fathom out. So much stupidity and waste of life.
I think the final scene of Blackadder captured the stupidity very well. Imagine being told to go over the top and walk in lines towards machine guns, were they very brave or mad...or both? Lions led by Donkeys indeed. |
Buy a proper book, FFS. |  | | |
| First World War definitive book on 13:14 - Nov 7 with 2328 views | Pegojack |
Thanks to all for the very interesting replies, which I will follow up.
Incidentally, if anyone would like to read a fantastic novel which I think describes very well what it was like to be fighting in it, I recommend Birdsong by Sebastian Faulks, which I've just finished. | | | |
| First World War definitive book on 13:21 - Nov 7 with 2311 views | Highjack |
This one mainly focuses on the Christmas truce as the title suggests but it is very good.
 |  |
| |
Login to get fewer ads
| First World War definitive book on 20:48 - Nov 7 with 2250 views | Catullus |
| First World War definitive book on 11:04 - Nov 7 by WarwickHunt |
Buy a proper book, FFS. |
Why? So they can gather dust and take up loads of room? Until I got a reader on my tablet I used to buy "proper books" but my house was clogged up with them, we had books everywhere and ended up doing a boot sale.
With my reader I get to keep the books and read them again, when I want to, with no issues. | |
| |
| First World War definitive book on 20:55 - Nov 7 with 2242 views | sherpajacob |
The guns of August by Barbara tuchman is considered a classic regarding the build up and outbreak of war. |  |
| |
| First World War definitive book on 10:41 - Nov 8 with 2153 views | jackal |
| First World War definitive book on 10:14 - Nov 7 by Catullus |
I shall give that a try, if they have it on Kindle.
I do prefer the WW2 books though, out of personal interest. My grandfather was a Royal Marine Commando, I always look out for anything that's about places he served. He was in a lot of well known engagements, including the disastrous amphibious assault of Tobruk. He was on HMS Sikh which wa sunk and he made it to HMS Zulu, he was at El Alamein and Normandy.
How the hell he made it through I can barely understand and like you, Lohengrin, I don't idolise fotbballers or celebrities, my Grandfather is my hero.
I was watching Britain's Great War (BBC2 14.45) and it's hard to understand, to fathom out. So much stupidity and waste of life.
I think the final scene of Blackadder captured the stupidity very well. Imagine being told to go over the top and walk in lines towards machine guns, were they very brave or mad...or both? Lions led by Donkeys indeed. |
Slightly off topic, but I'm reading " The Second World War " by Antony Beevor.
Simply written, informative and interesting. We all know about the war through films and tv but this explains it from start to finish.
I have a vague memory that my old French teacher in School was on H.M.S. Zulu and he watched the Bismarck go down.
Quite right. How these overpaid prats can be considered heroes by some is incredible.
Those who served are the real ones. |  | | |
| First World War definitive book on 11:40 - Nov 8 with 2138 views | lifelong |
| First World War definitive book on 10:14 - Nov 7 by Catullus |
I shall give that a try, if they have it on Kindle.
I do prefer the WW2 books though, out of personal interest. My grandfather was a Royal Marine Commando, I always look out for anything that's about places he served. He was in a lot of well known engagements, including the disastrous amphibious assault of Tobruk. He was on HMS Sikh which wa sunk and he made it to HMS Zulu, he was at El Alamein and Normandy.
How the hell he made it through I can barely understand and like you, Lohengrin, I don't idolise fotbballers or celebrities, my Grandfather is my hero.
I was watching Britain's Great War (BBC2 14.45) and it's hard to understand, to fathom out. So much stupidity and waste of life.
I think the final scene of Blackadder captured the stupidity very well. Imagine being told to go over the top and walk in lines towards machine guns, were they very brave or mad...or both? Lions led by Donkeys indeed. |
£3.49 on Kindle, just downloaded it. 👠|  | | |
| First World War definitive book on 15:14 - Nov 8 with 2103 views | WarwickHunt |
| First World War definitive book on 20:48 - Nov 7 by Catullus |
Why? So they can gather dust and take up loads of room? Until I got a reader on my tablet I used to buy "proper books" but my house was clogged up with them, we had books everywhere and ended up doing a boot sale.
With my reader I get to keep the books and read them again, when I want to, with no issues. |
Philistine.
Catallus would turn in his grave.  | | | |
| First World War definitive book on 20:42 - Nov 8 with 2030 views | leighton1318 |
| First World War definitive book on 08:41 - Nov 7 by Lohengrin |
These two cover both periods very well, mate.
|
The Sleepwalkers (above) is excellent IMO. | | | |
| First World War definitive book on 21:05 - Nov 8 with 2018 views | Catullus |
| First World War definitive book on 15:14 - Nov 8 by WarwickHunt |
Philistine.
Catallus would turn in his grave. |
I diverge from him in many areas, for example there is a Lesbia in my life but no Juventius.
Being married though it's definitely a case of Odi et amo!!! | |
| |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
