| Jordan Pickford on 16:22 - Jun 13 with 4299 views | Watford_Ranger |
He's worth it. Could be the Everton goalkeeper for 10 years+.
What would someone of similar experience in another position be worth like Rashford? Much more and arguably less proven. |  | |  |
| Jordan Pickford on 16:36 - Jun 13 with 4268 views | Cammington |
| Jordan Pickford on 16:22 - Jun 13 by Watford_Ranger |
He's worth it. Could be the Everton goalkeeper for 10 years+.
What would someone of similar experience in another position be worth like Rashford? Much more and arguably less proven. |
I'm inherently wary about keepers that go down but look good with terrible defences in front of them. He may well turn out to be worth it, it just seems a little ludicrous to me that he's played barely one season where he's had to save 6,7 or 8 shots a game and is suddenly worth 30 million notes. |  | | |
| Jordan Pickford on 16:39 - Jun 13 with 4256 views | MedwayR |
I'm not sure Rashford would be worth much more at the moment, although he has the potential to be worth far more.
It's a big risk by Everton, I'm glad they're looking to invest in young English talent but it's a lot of money for someone who hasn't played much and also has no experience in Champions League or international football. I know it's only one game but I wasn't impressed when he played against us for PNE, he was decent but he didn't strike me as being top class. |  |
| |
| Jordan Pickford on 16:39 - Jun 13 with 4256 views | CroydonCaptJack |
| Jordan Pickford on 16:36 - Jun 13 by Cammington |
I'm inherently wary about keepers that go down but look good with terrible defences in front of them. He may well turn out to be worth it, it just seems a little ludicrous to me that he's played barely one season where he's had to save 6,7 or 8 shots a game and is suddenly worth 30 million notes. |
It's mad isn't it.
Crazy money. |  | | |
| Jordan Pickford on 17:23 - Jun 13 with 4166 views | runningman75 |
Probably still on lower wages than Júlio César at Loftus Road! | | | |
| Jordan Pickford on 17:42 - Jun 13 with 4122 views | Northernr |
- A post straight from the Richard Keys book of football started in 1992 and consists of one division. Pickford has in excess of 100 Football League appearances under his belt and looked excellent at Preston.
- Sunderland spent £10m on Craig Gordon a decade ago and he's sht. This fee is £18m up front so isn't that much of a stretch in the general context of ludicrous transfer fees.
- Sissoko cost £30m, I'll take Pickford cheers.
- 23 yo, already a very good first team keeper in the Prem approximately 7 years away from his prime.
- good news for us when it comes to valuing Smithies.
- good point about keepers looking good keeping the score down behind dreadful defences. Sadly this may also apply to Smithies to some extent.
- good move for him. Pleased he didn't just go and sit on the bench at Chelsea or somewhere.
This post has been edited by an administrator |  | | |
| Jordan Pickford on 17:55 - Jun 13 with 4086 views | WadR |
Another thing to add to Clive's list is that one of the big differences between Pickford and a relegated keeper like David Marshall who everyone fleetingly rated just because he was facing 10+ shots on target per game, is that Pickford is an excellent footballer too.
His distribution is probably better any other British keeper and is a massive asset considering ability with the ball at your feet is an increasingly vital facet to a top level keeper's game.
£30m sounds about right tbh | | | |
| Jordan Pickford on 18:08 - Jun 13 with 4056 views | Northernr |
| Jordan Pickford on 17:55 - Jun 13 by WadR |
Another thing to add to Clive's list is that one of the big differences between Pickford and a relegated keeper like David Marshall who everyone fleetingly rated just because he was facing 10+ shots on target per game, is that Pickford is an excellent footballer too.
His distribution is probably better any other British keeper and is a massive asset considering ability with the ball at your feet is an increasingly vital facet to a top level keeper's game.
£30m sounds about right tbh |
Remember him at Preston pinging the ball about. This is another big part of Smithies' game and why Green was so overrated. | | | |
Login to get fewer ads
| Jordan Pickford on 18:08 - Jun 13 with 4055 views | simmo |
It's a position Everton desperately need to strengthen and he is already better than anything they already have. He will be an instant 1st teamer and could hold that position for 10+ years. At the very least he will be sold on for more as he will only improve.
It's also in line with the Everton ethos of buying young, mostly english players. Lookman, Calvert Lewis, Bowler, etc... They are not afraid to buy young or from lower divisions. The price is strong but I do think it's worth it in todays market, especially when 12m of the 30 is add-ons and performance related bonuses. |  |
| ask Beavis I get nothing Butthead |
| |
| Jordan Pickford on 18:32 - Jun 13 with 4011 views | ElHoop |
Everton probably want to spend now before everyone knows how much they have to spend from their sales. I can see them doing plenty of decent business - they've got Steve Walsh remember. |  | | |
| Jordan Pickford on 19:24 - Jun 13 with 3962 views | FredManRave |
| Jordan Pickford on 16:39 - Jun 13 by CroydonCaptJack |
It's mad isn't it.
Crazy money. |
Looks like Teresa May is correct. Austerity is over. |  |
| |
| Jordan Pickford on 19:34 - Jun 13 with 3956 views | EastR |
| Jordan Pickford on 18:08 - Jun 13 by Northernr |
Remember him at Preston pinging the ball about. This is another big part of Smithies' game and why Green was so overrated. |
Smithies to Man City for £35m on that basis.let's start that rumour and see who picks it up. | |
| |
| Jordan Pickford on 19:42 - Jun 13 with 3916 views | Cammington |
| Jordan Pickford on 17:42 - Jun 13 by Northernr |
- A post straight from the Richard Keys book of football started in 1992 and consists of one division. Pickford has in excess of 100 Football League appearances under his belt and looked excellent at Preston.
- Sunderland spent £10m on Craig Gordon a decade ago and he's sht. This fee is £18m up front so isn't that much of a stretch in the general context of ludicrous transfer fees.
- Sissoko cost £30m, I'll take Pickford cheers.
- 23 yo, already a very good first team keeper in the Prem approximately 7 years away from his prime.
- good news for us when it comes to valuing Smithies.
- good point about keepers looking good keeping the score down behind dreadful defences. Sadly this may also apply to Smithies to some extent.
- good move for him. Pleased he didn't just go and sit on the bench at Chelsea or somewhere.
This post has been edited by an administrator |
Bit harsh Clive, I'm well aware he has experience in the Football League. That sort of money doesn't fly around though for a guy whose previous experience counts Darlington, Alfreton Town, Burton, Carlisle, Bradford and PNE and is obviously because he played 30 decent games for Sunderland.
Fair point about the breakdown of the transfer fee, a fair chunk is add ons which I hadn't seen at the time.
Genuinely hope he does well and is a smart move for him as opposed to sitting on Chelsea's or Man U's bench as you say. Can only be good for the national team. | | | |
| Jordan Pickford on 19:48 - Jun 13 with 3900 views | MrSheen |
Lovely mover.
Never drops anything. |  | | |
| Jordan Pickford on 21:51 - Jun 13 with 3805 views | derbyhoop |
Really good keeper, but £30m still seems very steep. Even if a lot of it os performance related. |  |
| "Travel is fatal to prejudice, bigotry and narrow-mindedness, and many of our people need it sorely on these accounts. Broad, wholesome, charitable views of men and things cannot be acquired by vegetating in one little corner of the Earth all one's lifetime." (Mark Twain)
Find me on twitter @derbyhoop and now on Bluesky |
| |
| Jordan Pickford on 01:06 - Jun 14 with 3670 views | Match82 |
| Jordan Pickford on 17:42 - Jun 13 by Northernr |
- A post straight from the Richard Keys book of football started in 1992 and consists of one division. Pickford has in excess of 100 Football League appearances under his belt and looked excellent at Preston.
- Sunderland spent £10m on Craig Gordon a decade ago and he's sht. This fee is £18m up front so isn't that much of a stretch in the general context of ludicrous transfer fees.
- Sissoko cost £30m, I'll take Pickford cheers.
- 23 yo, already a very good first team keeper in the Prem approximately 7 years away from his prime.
- good news for us when it comes to valuing Smithies.
- good point about keepers looking good keeping the score down behind dreadful defences. Sadly this may also apply to Smithies to some extent.
- good move for him. Pleased he didn't just go and sit on the bench at Chelsea or somewhere.
This post has been edited by an administrator |
My first thought on seeing the news was "good, that just raised the asking price for Smithies by 50%.
Is it worth it for a keeper? Sure, if he's that good (doubt Juve have any regrets about Buffon). Given the ludicrous amounts of money in the Prem right now it probably isnt breaking the bank either |  | | |
| Jordan Pickford on 01:29 - Jun 14 with 3659 views | Boston |
| Jordan Pickford on 21:51 - Jun 13 by derbyhoop |
Really good keeper, but £30m still seems very steep. Even if a lot of it os performance related. |
Keeps it up, he'll soon be on plumbers money. | |
| |
| Jordan Pickford on 09:35 - Jun 14 with 3544 views | terryb |
I would have thought that Pickford was worth twice the valuation of Hart, so that would make the initial £18 million about right.
A fee for Smithies should be based on Hart's fee. If that is above £8 to £10 million is would be excessive.
I don't think that we could ask for the same amount of add on's as Sunderland could as Smithies won't become the first choice for England. Pickford copuld be by nect Summer. | | | |
| Jordan Pickford on 20:07 - Jun 14 with 3385 views | Watford_Ranger |
I'd happily lay across Windsor high street and let Smithies walk on me to avoid getting his shoes dirty but it's pointless comparing what we'd get for him with this. Pickford is already a far better player and should one day be in a different stratosphere. | | | |
| Jordan Pickford on 20:21 - Jun 14 with 3369 views | FredManRave |
| Jordan Pickford on 20:07 - Jun 14 by Watford_Ranger |
I'd happily lay across Windsor high street and let Smithies walk on me to avoid getting his shoes dirty but it's pointless comparing what we'd get for him with this. Pickford is already a far better player and should one day be in a different stratosphere. |
Are you saying that Smithies will only ever be in the troposphere?!
It's understandanble that comparative questions are being asked though. Smithies is our best player and will undoubtedly play Premier League football in the near future.
Present value in todays market is 8million according to GWL;
http://www.getwestlondon.co.uk/sport/football/football-news/how-much-could-qpr-s | |
| |
| Jordan Pickford on 00:02 - Jun 15 with 3288 views | Northernr |
| Jordan Pickford on 20:07 - Jun 14 by Watford_Ranger |
I'd happily lay across Windsor high street and let Smithies walk on me to avoid getting his shoes dirty but it's pointless comparing what we'd get for him with this. Pickford is already a far better player and should one day be in a different stratosphere. |
I'm not saying Smithies is as good as Pickford or ever will be but I don't agree that the comparison is pointless.
I've been saying on here for months that you'll all be disappointed with what we get for Smithies, partly because he's got no Prem experience but also because goalkeepers are notoriously under valued. This is a big wedge being paid for a goalkeeper which may well lift the value of all other goalkeepers slightly.
And if you don't believe me, look at the effect Newcastle and Villa spending £10m each on Gayle and Kodija last summer had on the market for Championship standard strikers. Suddenly you've got Hogan going for £12m, Vydra for £8m etc. | | | |
| Jordan Pickford on 08:20 - Jun 15 with 3220 views | paulparker |
Don't mind Pickford seems a good keeper the only thing I would say is he lacks presence in the way a Schmeichel or a seamen does , perhaps that comes with age and experience but pickford seems a confident lad so good luck to him , but if I was Everton I would have gone in for Butland who I think is England's best keeper by a country mile such a shame he has had the injury problems he has had because he should have replaced Hart after the Euros (btw who has Forster upset that he cannot get a game for England ? )
as for smithies he has to be at least 7-8 million especially when you hear Sunderland are buying or after the useless sam johnstone from man yoo for 5 million |  |
| And Bowles is onside, Swinburne has come rushing out of his goal , what can Bowles do here , onto the left foot no, on to the right foot
That’s there that’s two, and that’s Bowles
Brian Moore
|
| |
| Jordan Pickford on 09:42 - Jun 15 with 3174 views | daveB |
The money being paid is ridiculous but this move and Bournemouth buying a keeper means it's really only Huddersfield or Brighton who will come in for Smithies from the Prem so a stronger change he'll stay now |  | | |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
