By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions. We in turn value your personal details in accordance with our Privacy Policy.
Please log in or register. Registered visitors get fewer ads.
I think the OSC found Philip Beard's tactic of saying he wasn't aware of any of the issues raised at the forum and would look into it quite exasperating because they'd been raising a lot of those issues with the club for a long time. I said at the time that I thought it was a tactic of Beard's to try and make the forum easier to get through, rather than because he was actually unaware of them, but can see how annoying that must have been for people who had raised points and e-mailed in and had no response.
Thankless task.
0
RIP official supporters club on 23:31 - Mar 4 with 9220 views
RIP official supporters club on 23:25 - Mar 4 by Northernr
I think the OSC found Philip Beard's tactic of saying he wasn't aware of any of the issues raised at the forum and would look into it quite exasperating because they'd been raising a lot of those issues with the club for a long time. I said at the time that I thought it was a tactic of Beard's to try and make the forum easier to get through, rather than because he was actually unaware of them, but can see how annoying that must have been for people who had raised points and e-mailed in and had no response.
Thankless task.
Agreed.
For all his business expertise, read just another corporate shill.
RIP official supporters club on 23:31 - Mar 4 by eastside_r
Agreed.
For all his business expertise, read just another corporate shill.
The OSC has done excellent work in the past particularly in terms of fund raising. I hope it will continue in some guise.
I think the difficulty is though with a supporters group that is not independent and is effectively owned by the club is that if it disagrees with the club then it has no room to manoeuvre. The only option is to disband.
At the end of the day if consultation is to have any creditability the Club needs to engage directly with the two main independent democratically run fans groups- the LSA and QPR1st. It is unfortunate that both organisations struggle to get members because the larger these organisations are the greater the fans voice.
Clive regarding your point it struck me as very odd that Phil Beard was not better prepared especially as we were told to submit questions in advance. I can only guess he underestimated the strength of feeling amongst the fans about how the club is run and was expecting more questions would be directed at 'Arry and the lads
0
RIP official supporters club on 00:33 - Mar 5 with 9106 views
Either he genuinely had little idea of the complaints, in which case he is incompetent, or he knew about them and pretended he didn't, in which case he is dishonest.
Air hostess clique
0
RIP official supporters club on 06:24 - Mar 5 with 8974 views
RIP official supporters club on 00:33 - Mar 5 by TacticalR
Either he genuinely had little idea of the complaints, in which case he is incompetent, or he knew about them and pretended he didn't, in which case he is dishonest.
mr beard should resign if he just bluffed the forum, pleading "i'm unaware" and he did know he's lost any trust!
0
RIP official supporters club on 08:08 - Mar 5 with 8794 views
RIP official supporters club on 00:18 - Mar 5 by mygeneration
The OSC has done excellent work in the past particularly in terms of fund raising. I hope it will continue in some guise.
I think the difficulty is though with a supporters group that is not independent and is effectively owned by the club is that if it disagrees with the club then it has no room to manoeuvre. The only option is to disband.
At the end of the day if consultation is to have any creditability the Club needs to engage directly with the two main independent democratically run fans groups- the LSA and QPR1st. It is unfortunate that both organisations struggle to get members because the larger these organisations are the greater the fans voice.
Clive regarding your point it struck me as very odd that Phil Beard was not better prepared especially as we were told to submit questions in advance. I can only guess he underestimated the strength of feeling amongst the fans about how the club is run and was expecting more questions would be directed at 'Arry and the lads
The LSA has over a 1,000 paid up members so is the biggest voice of the fans group I would imagine. I believe you don't have to pay to be a member of QPR 1st. The OSC is just part of being a member or season ticket holder.
0
RIP official supporters club on 08:24 - Mar 5 with 8759 views
The OSC didn't, from the outside, appear to be the place to go for supporters who had issues with the club which they couldn't resolve individually. The latest forum seemed to see issues raised which aren't on the list of issues raised by the OSC, and they have raised issues which nobody else ever seems to have raised such as cheap hospitality. So they probably represented their own view in the main and to the extent that those views corresponded with everyone else's then they were representative, but I'm not sure that there was ever a proper channel for supporters to take their views to the OSC and get them passed on to the club.
0
RIP official supporters club on 09:02 - Mar 5 with 8683 views
Hold on, how many supporter groups do we have at the club?!
I would understand having a few different ones if we were say a Liverpool or a Manchester club. But surely being the size that we are, having just one all encompassing supporters group would mean greater solidarity over the key issues at the club and would carry more influence when trying to get things changed or resolved.
Just my opinion anyway.
0
RIP official supporters club on 09:42 - Mar 5 with 8617 views
RIP official supporters club on 09:02 - Mar 5 by LimehouseR
Hold on, how many supporter groups do we have at the club?!
I would understand having a few different ones if we were say a Liverpool or a Manchester club. But surely being the size that we are, having just one all encompassing supporters group would mean greater solidarity over the key issues at the club and would carry more influence when trying to get things changed or resolved.
Just my opinion anyway.
You'd have to think that if there are mass resignations at the only supporters group that the club deigns to interact with at any level, alarm bells must be going off somewhere in the club. Otherwise, wtf, have we got some fat orange git back in charge?
RIP official supporters club on 09:02 - Mar 5 by LimehouseR
Hold on, how many supporter groups do we have at the club?!
I would understand having a few different ones if we were say a Liverpool or a Manchester club. But surely being the size that we are, having just one all encompassing supporters group would mean greater solidarity over the key issues at the club and would carry more influence when trying to get things changed or resolved.
Just my opinion anyway.
Because the fans cannot agree on anything everyone wants their voice heard and it is even worse now that websites now have meetings with the club !
We haven't been a united fanbase for years and everyone of the fan groups has their own agenda
0
RIP official supporters club on 09:45 - Mar 5 with 8606 views
RIP official supporters club on 09:44 - Mar 5 by Rangersw12
Because the fans cannot agree on anything everyone wants their voice heard and it is even worse now that websites now have meetings with the club !
We haven't been a united fanbase for years and everyone of the fan groups has their own agenda
The club should be communicating with the fan base through as many avenues as possible. The media team getting together with the websites to discuss that side of things is a very good idea.
0
RIP official supporters club on 09:50 - Mar 5 with 8591 views
RIP official supporters club on 09:45 - Mar 5 by Northernr
The club should be communicating with the fan base through as many avenues as possible. The media team getting together with the websites to discuss that side of things is a very good idea.
Maybe so but do you think we need all these different fan groups and websites at meetings ?
Wouldn't it be better if we had 1 or 2 proper fans group organisations to represent the fans , I just think it makes us look small time with all these number of groups at meetings
0
RIP official supporters club on 10:00 - Mar 5 with 8574 views
RIP official supporters club on 09:50 - Mar 5 by Rangersw12
Maybe so but do you think we need all these different fan groups and websites at meetings ?
Wouldn't it be better if we had 1 or 2 proper fans group organisations to represent the fans , I just think it makes us look small time with all these number of groups at meetings
I agree it would be better if the fan groups could actually come together so there were just one or two - maybe the Trust and the LSA - because greater membership yields greater power.
However I think the club talking to as many fans as possible is a good thing. Even now when they talk to a dozen or so at a meeting you get people on here saying "they don't represent me" so how is having less voices going to help that?
There should be regular fans forums for anybody to attend, there should be regular rep meetings between senior board members and the LSA, QPR 1st and the OSC, and then there should be smaller meetings lower down for the websites and fanzines with different department heads. It would help the club get a feel of what the fans are saying and what they do well and badly in the eyes of the supporters. I think they're working towards this and I think the club have found it useful to have these meetings so far.
The more communication the better.
0
RIP official supporters club on 10:01 - Mar 5 with 8570 views
RIP official supporters club on 00:33 - Mar 5 by TacticalR
Either he genuinely had little idea of the complaints, in which case he is incompetent, or he knew about them and pretended he didn't, in which case he is dishonest.
I think he's both incompetent AND dishonest. Amazes me he doesn't get too much stick,yet if he was called Paladini, we'd have a 74 page thread on him. He is absolutely useless and a liar, as was revealed at the Fans Forum.
0
RIP official supporters club on 10:29 - Mar 5 with 8502 views
RIP official supporters club on 09:50 - Mar 5 by Rangersw12
Maybe so but do you think we need all these different fan groups and websites at meetings ?
Wouldn't it be better if we had 1 or 2 proper fans group organisations to represent the fans , I just think it makes us look small time with all these number of groups at meetings
the judean liberation front
0
RIP official supporters club on 10:32 - Mar 5 with 8493 views
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
