| Paul Smyth - A shout out for Smythie !!! 01:27 - Sep 23 with 4046 views | numptydumpty |
Thought would give the chap, his own thread.
Not bad enough to be highlighted out.
Not amazing enough likewise.
But apart from two seasons away, been here since he was 19, knocking on 27 now.
And always at least a squad player.
A very handy option off the bench due to his pace.
If only, he had the ability to look and think when hitting the final ball into the box, he would be more highly thought of.
Whether that's to do with ability or composure though, am not sure.
But reason for the thread being the guy has been here a long long time and every manager, no matter what their approach or whoever are their other options all have felt the guy is at the very least worth a place on the bench.
For me whatever his limitations, you know he performs and gives it his all.
He often goes under the radar here and is rarely highlighted negatively or positively on here.
Definitely for me a decent servant for our club. There have certainly been far far worse.
Been here many years and for me deserves a shout and praise for his efforts..
Good lad !!! |  |
| |  |
| Paul Smyth - A shout out for Smythie !!! on 03:51 - Sep 23 with 3931 views | jtuck |
Scored vital goal against Rotherham at home last season.
One man shithousing factory.
Quick. |  |
| |
| Paul Smyth - A shout out for Smythie !!! on 06:16 - Sep 23 with 3813 views | Lblock |
Agreed
I’ve always thought he was a good little player
Absolutely love his attitude
He’d be well ahead of both Jesus and Madsen in my book |  |
| Cherish and enjoy life.... this ain't no dress rehearsal |
| |
| Paul Smyth - A shout out for Smythie !!! on 07:16 - Sep 23 with 3708 views | hoops_legend |
Decent player and heart in right place
But not enough goals or assists realistically to be pushing on.
Happy for him to be our super sub though |  |
| |
| Paul Smyth - A shout out for Smythie !!! on 07:17 - Sep 23 with 3701 views | stevec |
He’s one of those round pegs that fits in a round hole so subsequently finds himself about 25 years out of fashion in the modern game.
Gone are the days where you had a Clement who gave you the ball early so you could run at the defender, cross it and if Givens didn’t head it, Bowles didn’t slide it in then Leach would probably bundle it in at the far post.
That said, he’s no Dave Thomas and his propensity to put crosses in that even Givens, Bowles and Leach might have said let’s call it a day, does leave him wide open to the criticism he receives.
He’s very handy to have off the bench. Or at least he would be if we ever sort out this midfield. For now though, his destiny might rest in Chair returning, Dembele centre and then he might, just might, be the better right sided option we have. |  | | |
| Paul Smyth - A shout out for Smythie !!! on 16:24 - Sep 23 with 3334 views | Spaceman_P |
I like Smyth and his attitude, love even how he plays.
All I wish for godsakes - learn to cross and learn to stay on your feet.
bloke makes Patrick from Spongebob Squarepants look like someone with great posture. [Post edited 23 Sep 16:24]
|  | | |
| Paul Smyth - A shout out for Smythie !!! on 17:17 - Sep 23 with 3197 views | nick_hammersmith |
Yep, if he could just stay onside, control the ball, stop diving, pass the ball quicker and shoot on target he might be useful.
Otherwise, I think we are looking at a L1 player at best, sorry |  | | |
| Paul Smyth - A shout out for Smythie !!! on 17:30 - Sep 23 with 3136 views | aston_hoop |
Not remotely good enough from a technical perspective. He can't cross, can't shoot and can't pass. He's quick and tenacious which shouldn't be anywhere near enough but people get easily wowed by such stuff when you've been starved of pace for years. |  |
| |
| Paul Smyth - A shout out for Smythie !!! on 17:40 - Sep 23 with 3088 views | bosh67 |
I really like him. We continually miss a big trick with him in that at Orient he was an inverted left winger and he really shone in that position, albeit a league down. We never put him down the left here so perhaps we never really get the best out of him? |  |
| |
Login to get fewer ads
| Paul Smyth - A shout out for Smythie !!! on 17:43 - Sep 23 with 3064 views | simmo |
Think he's definitely best deployed as a super sub - in either game script - and he's had really great contributions over the last year or so. The small issue is that he's our only natural right winger other than Dembele, who is so much better in the 10 based on the current setup, but not quite consistently good enough to start...
We really need someone like Andersen or Santos to cement that wide right position and allow us to switch Chair/Dembele/Saito/Madsen among the 10 and LW parts, otherwise I'm not far off having Smyth start just to accomodate Dem10... |  |
| ask Beavis I get nothing Butthead |
| |
| Paul Smyth - A shout out for Smythie !!! on 18:32 - Sep 23 with 2923 views | dutch |
The most frustrating player. Can do one half of his job really well, the other half terrible. Don't understand why you can't coach a player to look up and put in a cross. He is no longer a kid, played lots of games, yet still commits the same sins time and again. | | | |
| Paul Smyth - A shout out for Smythie !!! on 19:26 - Sep 23 with 2802 views | Dorse |
Plays like a glue-sniffing wasp with a grudge.
Nice. |  |
| 'What do we want? We don't know! When do we want it? Now!' |
| |
| Paul Smyth - A shout out for Smythie !!! on 11:13 - Sep 24 with 2243 views | QPunkR |
| Paul Smyth - A shout out for Smythie !!! on 17:40 - Sep 23 by bosh67 |
I really like him. We continually miss a big trick with him in that at Orient he was an inverted left winger and he really shone in that position, albeit a league down. We never put him down the left here so perhaps we never really get the best out of him? |
Hmmm, let me think - Chair or Smyth? [Post edited 24 Sep 11:13]
|  |
| |
| Paul Smyth - A shout out for Smythie !!! on 11:54 - Sep 24 with 2160 views | nick_hammersmith |
| Paul Smyth - A shout out for Smythie !!! on 11:13 - Sep 24 by QPunkR |
Hmmm, let me think - Chair or Smyth? [Post edited 24 Sep 11:13]
|
Really?
Chair was easily or best player last season, there isn't much to compare them.
If Chair was able to release the ball earlier and hit first time crosses he would probably be in the Premier League and not in the Championship.
However, I think Leyton Orient or Wycombe was probably the nadir for Smyth... | | | |
| Paul Smyth - A shout out for Smythie !!! on 14:43 - Sep 24 with 2042 views | QPunkR |
| Paul Smyth - A shout out for Smythie !!! on 11:54 - Sep 24 by nick_hammersmith |
Really?
Chair was easily or best player last season, there isn't much to compare them.
If Chair was able to release the ball earlier and hit first time crosses he would probably be in the Premier League and not in the Championship.
However, I think Leyton Orient or Wycombe was probably the nadir for Smyth... |
Err yeah that's my point. They're not even in the same galaxy. I was pointing out that LW is Chair's position so that's why Smyth has never (and will never) get to play there for us | |
| |
| Paul Smyth - A shout out for Smythie !!! on 14:44 - Sep 24 with 2035 views | Loyalitat |
| Paul Smyth - A shout out for Smythie !!! on 17:40 - Sep 23 by bosh67 |
I really like him. We continually miss a big trick with him in that at Orient he was an inverted left winger and he really shone in that position, albeit a league down. We never put him down the left here so perhaps we never really get the best out of him? |
He achieved that with Leyton Orient when they were in division 2. Just cutting in at this level, for the most part, onto his right foot will not work as the defenders are way too savvy. He doesn't manipulate the ball in the way Chair does to wrongfoot defenders.
I like him as a squad player but his best position is wide on the right. | | | |
| Paul Smyth - A shout out for Smythie !!! on 15:13 - Sep 24 with 1948 views | TheChef |
I enjoy watching him play, but as usual if he had consistent end product he wouldn't be at QPR. |  |
| |
| Paul Smyth - A shout out for Smythie !!! on 15:23 - Sep 24 with 1916 views | nick_hammersmith |
| Paul Smyth - A shout out for Smythie !!! on 14:43 - Sep 24 by QPunkR |
Err yeah that's my point. They're not even in the same galaxy. I was pointing out that LW is Chair's position so that's why Smyth has never (and will never) get to play there for us |
Sorry, I missed that.
Yes I agree, there is no way that Smyth replaces a fit Chair in the starting 11 | | | |
| Paul Smyth - A shout out for Smythie !!! on 16:09 - Sep 24 with 1788 views | Esox_Lucius |
Are we starting to run out of scapegoats? |  |
| The grass is always greener. |
| |
| Paul Smyth - A shout out for Smythie !!! on 16:10 - Sep 24 with 1783 views | BrianMcCarthy |
| Paul Smyth - A shout out for Smythie !!! on 16:09 - Sep 24 by Esox_Lucius |
Are we starting to run out of scapegoats? |
It's all Michael Meaker's fault! |  |
| |
| Paul Smyth - A shout out for Smythie !!! on 16:37 - Sep 24 with 1681 views | aston_hoop |
| Paul Smyth - A shout out for Smythie !!! on 16:09 - Sep 24 by Esox_Lucius |
Are we starting to run out of scapegoats? |
He's not a scapegoat, we could just do a lot better than him starting games. | |
| |
| Paul Smyth - A shout out for Smythie !!! on 16:41 - Sep 24 with 1666 views | Paddyhoops |
I like Smyth but Agree with Aston on this one . | | | |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
