| Smithies 09:09 - Nov 26 with 6171 views | Mvpeter |
Might it be time for him. Promotions not on, relegation's not likely and Green will be gone next year so why not start using Smithies? |  |
| |  |
| Smithies on 09:12 - Nov 26 with 4887 views | runningman75 |
I think he was the 3rd choice keeper. We needed a second keeper but thought we wanted someone from Southend. Will be interesting what Warnock or new manager decides but Green seems undroppable due to past reputation. | | | |
| Smithies on 09:12 - Nov 26 with 4887 views | kingsburyR |
I agree.
The way he watched that cross come over his head last Friday was enough for me.
Blood Smithies now. |  |
| Dont know why we bother. .... but we do! |
| |
| Smithies on 09:13 - Nov 26 with 4885 views | Discodroids |
I Can sense Bluce on my shoulder , thus it is with heavy heart that i agree with my chum Peter. I feel that may well be the view of the new manager as well. |  |
| The Duke Of New York. A-Number One.
|
| |
| Smithies on 09:28 - Nov 26 with 4851 views | adhoc_qpr |
Promotion and relegation are both still possible, but i'd play Smithies.
I'd rather have Smithies, Hall, Chery, Yun, Luongo, Furlong (can't be worse than Perch) et al in the team now gaining an understanding and developing into a real team. Ditch the loanees and those whose contracts are running down.
But i also understand the next manager will probably want to pick a more experienced team to ensure they get off to a good start. | | | |
| Smithies on 09:46 - Nov 26 with 4819 views | Northernr |
I'd have been picking him all season anyway but I've never been Green's biggest fan and I've always quite rated Smithies from when he was a young lad so I'm biased.
For me it's not even about planning for the future or whether anything is at stake this season, it's a simple football decision. Smithies is every bit as good a shot stopper as Green - shot stopping is the bare minimum requirement for a goalkeeper. They both have issues coming off their line and commanding the area. Smithies, however, is so far ahead of Green in distribution of the ball you can't overlook it. In his brief appearances this season his throwing - choices, distance, accuracy, pace of the ball - has been so far ahead of Green it's embarrassing really. He can not only kick it far further, but almost more accurately too. When he came on as a sub against Forest his first goal kick sailed 30 yards beyond everybody, because they're used to Green barely reaching the halfway line.
There are other, more personal, reasons this will be a good idea too. Smithies is Huddersfield born, Huddersfield fan, Huddersfield resident, Huddersfield player since he was at school. He's never known anything other than Huddersfield. He's decided to make the first move of his career and he trusted in what we told him in the summer. He's moved to London just as his Mrs has kicked out their first child and now he finds himself stuck here on our bench. He'll be pissd off inwardly, if not outwardly, I suspect.
while of course I accept he probably got a significant pay rise to come here, we have once again this summer brought a whole load of players in and discarded them. I noticed the Peterborough chairman the other week Tweeting about Gladwin and how surprised he was to see him back at Swindon. Others clubs, other players, will have seen us bring in Luongo, Gladwin, Polter, Chery and Smithies and make all our promises about being a changed club only to then completely discard all of them. That will only denigrate our already dreadful reputation in football circles further.
Personally I'd have them all (possibly apart from Polter) in the fcking team and leave them there. |  | | |
| Smithies on 09:52 - Nov 26 with 4804 views | adhoc_qpr |
| Smithies on 09:46 - Nov 26 by Northernr |
I'd have been picking him all season anyway but I've never been Green's biggest fan and I've always quite rated Smithies from when he was a young lad so I'm biased.
For me it's not even about planning for the future or whether anything is at stake this season, it's a simple football decision. Smithies is every bit as good a shot stopper as Green - shot stopping is the bare minimum requirement for a goalkeeper. They both have issues coming off their line and commanding the area. Smithies, however, is so far ahead of Green in distribution of the ball you can't overlook it. In his brief appearances this season his throwing - choices, distance, accuracy, pace of the ball - has been so far ahead of Green it's embarrassing really. He can not only kick it far further, but almost more accurately too. When he came on as a sub against Forest his first goal kick sailed 30 yards beyond everybody, because they're used to Green barely reaching the halfway line.
There are other, more personal, reasons this will be a good idea too. Smithies is Huddersfield born, Huddersfield fan, Huddersfield resident, Huddersfield player since he was at school. He's never known anything other than Huddersfield. He's decided to make the first move of his career and he trusted in what we told him in the summer. He's moved to London just as his Mrs has kicked out their first child and now he finds himself stuck here on our bench. He'll be pissd off inwardly, if not outwardly, I suspect.
while of course I accept he probably got a significant pay rise to come here, we have once again this summer brought a whole load of players in and discarded them. I noticed the Peterborough chairman the other week Tweeting about Gladwin and how surprised he was to see him back at Swindon. Others clubs, other players, will have seen us bring in Luongo, Gladwin, Polter, Chery and Smithies and make all our promises about being a changed club only to then completely discard all of them. That will only denigrate our already dreadful reputation in football circles further.
Personally I'd have them all (possibly apart from Polter) in the fcking team and leave them there. |
Agree with all of that.
Although is poor Poulter that bad?
He looked useful enough in his first couple of 10 minute cameo - big, physical, committed and slightly mad (although clumsy with the ball).
He can't have played more than 45 mins in the league and a couple of cup games. I understand him being behind Austin and JET, but behind Phillips too? | | | |
| Smithies on 09:55 - Nov 26 with 4792 views | superhoopdownunder |
In the January transfer window given the choice I would move the remaining high paid players on:-
Traore
Fer
Phillips
Green
Sandro
Austin | | | |
| Smithies on 10:40 - Nov 26 with 4734 views | Antti_Heinola |
| Smithies on 09:55 - Nov 26 by superhoopdownunder |
In the January transfer window given the choice I would move the remaining high paid players on:-
Traore
Fer
Phillips
Green
Sandro
Austin |
Doubt Phillips and Traore are on enormous wages tbh.
Green will have taken a big pay cut too and is going next summer anyway.
Good luck getting anyone to take Sandro or Traore or possibly Fer with their injury worries.
Brilliant post by Clive above - totally agree with it. Really hope whoever comes in uses our new players a bit better. |  |
| |
Login to get fewer ads
| Smithies on 10:45 - Nov 26 with 4716 views | WilloW4 |
| Smithies on 09:46 - Nov 26 by Northernr |
I'd have been picking him all season anyway but I've never been Green's biggest fan and I've always quite rated Smithies from when he was a young lad so I'm biased.
For me it's not even about planning for the future or whether anything is at stake this season, it's a simple football decision. Smithies is every bit as good a shot stopper as Green - shot stopping is the bare minimum requirement for a goalkeeper. They both have issues coming off their line and commanding the area. Smithies, however, is so far ahead of Green in distribution of the ball you can't overlook it. In his brief appearances this season his throwing - choices, distance, accuracy, pace of the ball - has been so far ahead of Green it's embarrassing really. He can not only kick it far further, but almost more accurately too. When he came on as a sub against Forest his first goal kick sailed 30 yards beyond everybody, because they're used to Green barely reaching the halfway line.
There are other, more personal, reasons this will be a good idea too. Smithies is Huddersfield born, Huddersfield fan, Huddersfield resident, Huddersfield player since he was at school. He's never known anything other than Huddersfield. He's decided to make the first move of his career and he trusted in what we told him in the summer. He's moved to London just as his Mrs has kicked out their first child and now he finds himself stuck here on our bench. He'll be pissd off inwardly, if not outwardly, I suspect.
while of course I accept he probably got a significant pay rise to come here, we have once again this summer brought a whole load of players in and discarded them. I noticed the Peterborough chairman the other week Tweeting about Gladwin and how surprised he was to see him back at Swindon. Others clubs, other players, will have seen us bring in Luongo, Gladwin, Polter, Chery and Smithies and make all our promises about being a changed club only to then completely discard all of them. That will only denigrate our already dreadful reputation in football circles further.
Personally I'd have them all (possibly apart from Polter) in the fcking team and leave them there. |
Absolutely spot on. |  | | |
| Smithies on 12:09 - Nov 26 with 4621 views | Jigsore |
Yes. 2/3rds of a season to get used to the team, to iron out kinks in his game, to settle any jangling nerves.
Green is a consumate professional so while he won't like it i'm sure he'll accept it.
Downsides: he might make an error and we will finish 12th instead of 11th |  |
| “The thing about football - the important thing about football - is that it is not just about football.†|
| |
| Smithies on 12:11 - Nov 26 with 4615 views | simmo |
He's already better than Green. Should have been playing all season. |  |
| ask Beavis I get nothing Butthead |
| |
| Smithies on 12:15 - Nov 26 with 4607 views | RBlock |
| Smithies on 09:52 - Nov 26 by adhoc_qpr |
Agree with all of that.
Although is poor Poulter that bad?
He looked useful enough in his first couple of 10 minute cameo - big, physical, committed and slightly mad (although clumsy with the ball).
He can't have played more than 45 mins in the league and a couple of cup games. I understand him being behind Austin and JET, but behind Phillips too? |
I don't think Polter is that bad. From what I have seen of him he is hardworking, aggresive, elbowy, and looks horrible to defend against. Strong in the air and can hold the ball up really well. His finishing seems to be lacking but that will come with game time and confidence. |  | | |
| Smithies on 12:19 - Nov 26 with 4592 views | Northernr |
Went to Dundee Utd on a free in the summer. | | | |
| Smithies on 12:23 - Nov 26 with 4577 views | paulparker |
I for one cannot wait to see the back of Green, Sandro, Phillips , Fer, Toszer , Angella,
Green is and always will be a liability, how he was ever Englands number 1 is a mystery to me ,
we should of got rid when we signed Mcarthey but didn't and now history is repeating itself with smithies |  |
| And Bowles is onside, Swinburne has come rushing out of his goal , what can Bowles do here , onto the left foot no, on to the right foot
That’s there that’s two, and that’s Bowles
Brian Moore
|
| |
| Smithies on 12:37 - Nov 26 with 4546 views | adhoc_qpr |
| Smithies on 12:23 - Nov 26 by paulparker |
I for one cannot wait to see the back of Green, Sandro, Phillips , Fer, Toszer , Angella,
Green is and always will be a liability, how he was ever Englands number 1 is a mystery to me ,
we should of got rid when we signed Mcarthey but didn't and now history is repeating itself with smithies |
I definitely haven't written off Angella - and we do at least have the option to buy him.
Let's give him 5 games in a row in a settled defence before we send him packing. He's got good pedigree, is only 26 and decent centre backs are hard to come by.
Same for Toszer to a lesser extent - he's been largely poor, but I don't think we've been playing to his strengths either. | | | |
| Smithies on 13:03 - Nov 26 with 4475 views | Mvpeter |
| Smithies on 09:46 - Nov 26 by Northernr |
I'd have been picking him all season anyway but I've never been Green's biggest fan and I've always quite rated Smithies from when he was a young lad so I'm biased.
For me it's not even about planning for the future or whether anything is at stake this season, it's a simple football decision. Smithies is every bit as good a shot stopper as Green - shot stopping is the bare minimum requirement for a goalkeeper. They both have issues coming off their line and commanding the area. Smithies, however, is so far ahead of Green in distribution of the ball you can't overlook it. In his brief appearances this season his throwing - choices, distance, accuracy, pace of the ball - has been so far ahead of Green it's embarrassing really. He can not only kick it far further, but almost more accurately too. When he came on as a sub against Forest his first goal kick sailed 30 yards beyond everybody, because they're used to Green barely reaching the halfway line.
There are other, more personal, reasons this will be a good idea too. Smithies is Huddersfield born, Huddersfield fan, Huddersfield resident, Huddersfield player since he was at school. He's never known anything other than Huddersfield. He's decided to make the first move of his career and he trusted in what we told him in the summer. He's moved to London just as his Mrs has kicked out their first child and now he finds himself stuck here on our bench. He'll be pissd off inwardly, if not outwardly, I suspect.
while of course I accept he probably got a significant pay rise to come here, we have once again this summer brought a whole load of players in and discarded them. I noticed the Peterborough chairman the other week Tweeting about Gladwin and how surprised he was to see him back at Swindon. Others clubs, other players, will have seen us bring in Luongo, Gladwin, Polter, Chery and Smithies and make all our promises about being a changed club only to then completely discard all of them. That will only denigrate our already dreadful reputation in football circles further.
Personally I'd have them all (possibly apart from Polter) in the fcking team and leave them there. |
Completely this. By far my biggest gripe. | |
| |
| Smithies on 13:21 - Nov 26 with 4437 views | Bluce_Ree |
I agree. Play Smithies for a while. Give him 5-10 games and then put Green back in because Smithies won't be the answer.
I'm more than happy for whatever hapless manager we get to experiment. Season's f**ked anyway.
As for Smithies' distribution. Great. Green's clearly under orders to punt that ball up field as soon as he gets it anyway. Smithies can be the distribution master while he's failing to save the sort of shots Green eats for breakfast. |  |
| Stefan Moore, Stefan Moore running down the wing. Stefan Moore, Stefan Moore running down the wing. He runs like a cheetah, his crosses couldn't be sweeter. Stefan Moore. Stefan Moore. Stefan Moore. |
| |
| Smithies on 13:52 - Nov 26 with 4387 views | Antti_Heinola |
| Smithies on 13:21 - Nov 26 by Bluce_Ree |
I agree. Play Smithies for a while. Give him 5-10 games and then put Green back in because Smithies won't be the answer.
I'm more than happy for whatever hapless manager we get to experiment. Season's f**ked anyway.
As for Smithies' distribution. Great. Green's clearly under orders to punt that ball up field as soon as he gets it anyway. Smithies can be the distribution master while he's failing to save the sort of shots Green eats for breakfast. |
Green eats for breakfast...
just after he's wiped the lint off them having already dropped them on the floor. | |
| |
| Smithies on 13:58 - Nov 26 with 4366 views | simmo |
| Smithies on 13:52 - Nov 26 by Antti_Heinola |
Green eats for breakfast...
just after he's wiped the lint off them having already dropped them on the floor. |
Whilst lifting his finger up to let his wife know he's had his 'one'. | |
| ask Beavis I get nothing Butthead |
| |
| Smithies on 14:44 - Nov 26 with 4294 views | WilloW4 |
| Smithies on 13:21 - Nov 26 by Bluce_Ree |
I agree. Play Smithies for a while. Give him 5-10 games and then put Green back in because Smithies won't be the answer.
I'm more than happy for whatever hapless manager we get to experiment. Season's f**ked anyway.
As for Smithies' distribution. Great. Green's clearly under orders to punt that ball up field as soon as he gets it anyway. Smithies can be the distribution master while he's failing to save the sort of shots Green eats for breakfast. |
Your fixation with rob green is incredible...when I was a young teen I had a poster on my wall of farrah fawcet and Bridget Bardot .. Do you have a poster of rob green above your bed ?. | | | |
| Smithies on 14:53 - Nov 26 with 4283 views | exiled_dictator |
| Smithies on 10:40 - Nov 26 by Antti_Heinola |
Doubt Phillips and Traore are on enormous wages tbh.
Green will have taken a big pay cut too and is going next summer anyway.
Good luck getting anyone to take Sandro or Traore or possibly Fer with their injury worries.
Brilliant post by Clive above - totally agree with it. Really hope whoever comes in uses our new players a bit better. |
both phillips and trader were on 40k a week in the premiership, with relegation clauses.
i don't have the new figures, but it will be less.
green earns less than the 50k we were paying him when he joined from why. i believe it's now 35k.
we matched sandro's 45k spurs salary when he joined, with a relegation clause added
sandro cost us a small fortune, and with his medical record and visa issues, we will be lucky if we can pay for him to leave. i mean, who will have him? |  |
| It's not what you've got; it's where you stick it. | | Poll: | Climate Change |
| |
| Smithies on 14:59 - Nov 26 with 4271 views | JonDoeman |
Smithies had the chance to take it. And he looked as nervous as a kitten . Not an admirable trait in a keeper. I fear when this does happen, we'll just be replacing one dodgepot with another! [Post edited 26 Nov 2015 14:59]
|  |
| |
| Smithies on 15:21 - Nov 26 with 4229 views | Bluce_Ree |
| Smithies on 14:44 - Nov 26 by WilloW4 |
Your fixation with rob green is incredible...when I was a young teen I had a poster on my wall of farrah fawcet and Bridget Bardot .. Do you have a poster of rob green above your bed ?. |
No.
It's more of a full scale life-like replica. | |
| Stefan Moore, Stefan Moore running down the wing. Stefan Moore, Stefan Moore running down the wing. He runs like a cheetah, his crosses couldn't be sweeter. Stefan Moore. Stefan Moore. Stefan Moore. |
| |
| Smithies on 15:28 - Nov 26 with 2053 views | WilloW4 |
| Smithies on 15:21 - Nov 26 by Bluce_Ree |
No.
It's more of a full scale life-like replica. |
Ooh, er, good luck, hope you treat each other nicely. | | | |
| Smithies on 20:04 - Nov 26 with 1976 views | PunteR |
Yeah,why not..?
Green isn't having his best season,so yeah,drop him,play the kid
...
.his throwing is amazing. |  |
| Occasional providers of half decent House music. |
| |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
