Andre Marriner’s gets Chelsea game — referee
Thursday, 9th Apr 2015 21:23 by Clive Whittingham

Andre Marriner is the man in the middle for Sunday’s West London derby against Chelsea at Loftus Road on Sunday.

Referee >>> Andre Marriner ( West Midlands ), refereed QPR’s 2-1 defeat at Burnley in January.

Assistants >>> Scott Ledger (South Yorkshire) and Darren Cann (Norfolk)

Fourth Official >>> Craig Pawson (Sheffield). Again.

History

Burnley 2 QPR 1, Saturday January 10, 2015, Premier League

Within five minutes of the restart QPR had once again fallen fast asleep while defending a throw in, allowing Ashley Barnes to stand totally unmarked in the penalty area and receive the ball to his feet - Green made a fine save to deny him as he turned and struck a first time volley towards goal. Later, with Caulker caught downfield protesting to referee Andre Marriner that he should have been awarded a corner, Barnes was able to find more space around the penalty area and this time fired a shot high over the bar. Within six minutes Green had allowed another shot from the former Brighton forward to bounce out for a corner via a heavy deflection when it looked like the keeper could have easily caught the ball on the full.

Zamora’s first act was to give the ball away cheaply resulting in an attack from which Burnley won a corner. This marked the start of QPR’s apparent determination to concede at least once from a header at the back post. In this instance, they left Ben Mee unmarked and his downward header was bundled over the line by Barnes only for Marriner to rule that he’d fouled Green in the process of doing so. He definitely had, but Hill had plenty of Barnes as well.

QPR, who’d earlier rightly felt aggrieved that Marriner had shown Joey Barton a yellow card for his first foul of the match while Marney was allowed to pull Vargas down deliberately and interrupt a promising counter attack without so much as a word on the run, were grateful to the official for his generosity there.

Burnley: Heaton 7; Trippier 7, Keane 7, Shackell 6, Mee 6; Boyd 8, Marney 6, Jones 6, Arfield 6; Ings 7, Barnes 6 (Vokes 73, 6)

Subs not used: Duff, Wallace, Kightly, Reid, Gilks, Jutkiewicz

Goals: Arfield 12 (unassisted), Ings 38 (assisted Barnes)

Bookings: Marney 45+1 (foul), Barnes 52 (foul)

QPR: Green 6; Isla 5, Caulker 4, Dunne 5, Hill 4 (Traore 75, 4); Fer 6, Henry 6 (Zamora 69, 4), Barton 5, Vargas 6 (Zarate 76, 5); Taarabt 7, Austin 6

Subs not used: Phillips, McCarthy, Onuoha, Mutch

Goals: Austin 32 (penalty, won Austin)

Bookings: Barton 44 (foul), Traore 75 (foul)

Referee - Andre Marriner (West Midlands) 7 Difficult week for Marriner with his old boss Keith Hackett publicly saying he should be struck off the Premier League list, but he did reasonably well here. The penalty decision was correct, as was the disallowed Burnley goal. I thought he was inconsistent with his yellow cards though. The one handed to Barton was purely because of his reputation - it was debatable whether the challenge even warranted a free kick and was his first foul of the day. Earlier Marney had hauled Vargas to the floor cynically as the Chilean ran clear on a counter attack - blatant yellow, but Marriner only awarded a free kick.

Sunderland 0 QPR 0, Tuesday November 27, 2012, Premier League

Physically dominate they certainly did. When Jamie Mackie was turned down in his search for an attacking free kick in the sixth minute by referee Andre Marriner it created a counter attacking opportunity for Sunderland that Ryan Nelsen calmly brought to an end with a shuddering, deliberate foul on Stephen Fletcher that really should have brought the evening’s first yellow card. Craig Gardner smacked the subsequent free kick wide from fully 40 yards — another sign of desperation and lack of ideas from the home team.

Probably a good job Marriner was in a forgiving mood because Diakite committed his standard six fouls for only one yellow card in return before he was substituted in the second half.

Sunderland were still struggling though — laboured and sluggish, with the weight of their winless run sitting heavy on their shoulders. QPR got a lot of joy attacking down the Sunderland right side with Armand Traore having his best game of the season from left back. He crossed for Granero to head at Mignolet straight after half time, and then drew the first yellow card of the evening for Carlos Cuellar after breaking at speed down the centre of the field.

Redknapp also sent on Shaun Wright-Phillips for Adel Taarabt later on in the game. Taarabt was sold to QPR by Redknapp during his time at Spurs and there has been much talk this week — exacerbated by Redknapp’s constant comments about work rate without the ball — that the fans’ favourite may be on borrowed time at Loftus Road. He was guilty, as on Saturday, of trying a little too hard to impress at times here but as usual was often the only QPR player who looked capable of unlocking the opposition. Redknapp will be well aware of that, and looked happy enough with his player’s effort as he went off the field despite an incident at the midway point of the half when he conceded possession in a bad area and Clint Hill was called upon to commit a cynical foul on Larsson as he burst into the area. Hill furiously accused the Sunderland man of diving but Larsson had done no such thing and I suspect Hill’s anger was false and designed to try and water down any punishment Marriner had in mind. All parties seemed happy enough with a yellow card.

Sunderland: Mignolet 7, Bardsley 6, Kilgallon 6, Cuellar 6, Rose 7*, Cattermole — (Colback 5, 6), Larsson 5, Gardner 5 (Saha 78, 5), Johnson 5 (McClean 70, 6), Sessegnon 5, Fletcher 6

Subs not used: Westwood, Bramble, Vaughan, Campbell

Bookings: Cuellar 50 (foul)

QPR: Cesar 7 (Green 46, 7), Bosingwa 6, Nelsen 7, Hill 7, Traore 7, Mackie 7, Diakite 6, Granero 6, Mbia 7, Taarabt 6, Cisse 6

Subs not used: Ferdinand, Fabio, Derry, Hoilett

Bookings: Diakite 54 (repetitive fouling), Hill 67 (foul), Mackie 80 (foul)

Referee — Andre Marriner 9 Controlled the game superbly and in an unfussy manner. No complaints about any of the yellow cards, no major decisions wrong, and made the whole thing look very easy.

QPR 0 Chelsea 0, Saturday September 15, 2012, Premier League

Granero was caught in possession after 12 minutes but fought back with a cynical foul to deny Chelsea a chance for a quick break. That’s an intelligent thing to do against the Blues because any free kick they get within 40 yards of the goal is almost always kicked weakly back to the goalkeeper or into the wall by Frank Lampard after a three quarter of a mile run up and that’s exactly what happened here. From the resulting corner Rangers were able to counter attack themselves and when Faurlin was chopped down by Ramires he became the first player shown a yellow card by referee Andre Marriner.

Ramires was perhaps fortunate to stay on the field two minutes later when he was caught in possession on the touchline thanks to some hard work from Fabio and he retaliated with a nasty foul. Fortunately for him Marriner waved play on as Rangers accelerated into the penalty box andBobby Zamora drew a routine save from Petr Cech with a low curling shot. Sadly, after he’d made a bright start to the game, that tackle ended Fabio’s participation in the game and he was replaced by Nedum Onuoha a short time later, with Bosingwa switching from right to left back. Ramires was lucky the referee chose not to pursue retrospective action when the ball eventually went dead.

Chelsea had two men sent off on this ground in a 1-0 league defeat last season and having narrowly escaped a red card there the visitors were then grateful for Marriner’s leniency for a second time when Ryan Bertrand crashed through the back of Shaun Wright-Phillips with the type of air born, two footed, out of control tackle we’re told is now a mandatory red card offence. He was only booked, and 11 man Chelsea drew another save from CÃ©sar when Torres moved into the penalty area, turned back inside and then went searching for the far bottom corner.

But the visitors soon had cause to be upset with the match officials themselves as QPR survived two quick fire penalty appeals. First John Terry appeared to be pulled to the ground in the area by Ryan Nelsen after getting in front of the New Zealand international under a wide set piece. Nelsen clearly had hold of Terry’s shoulders, but the Chelsea captain only hit the deck when he collided with Fernando Torres which perhaps persuaded Marriner to ignore the claims. It looked a penalty at first glance though. As did Shaun Wright-Phillips’ risky contact on Hazard just before the half hour as the Belgian international accelerated beyond him to the byline in the penalty area. The £35m man certainly hadn’t been shy of theatrically falling to ground in the opening half hour and Marriner had already waved away free kick appeals from him, Torres and Branislav Ivanovic so maybe it was the style of his fall that saw a goal kick awarded for what really should have been a spot kick.

As the debate raged — Terry and Frank Lampard are apparently allowed to discuss anything and everything with the referee at length whenever they feel the need — Mark Hughes had to redesign his side for a second time as Andy Johnson pulled up injured and was replaced by Jamie Mackie.

The rest of the Chelsea team realised very early on that Marriner was in no mood to blow his whistle every two or three minutes and adapted their games but Torres stuck with his tactic of collapsing under meagre contact, and then whingeing like an old fish wife when he didn’t get a decision. The only surprise was Di Matteo waited until the eightieth to withdraw him and given the immediate impact Sturridge made it’s a good job from QPR’s point of view that he did. Torres stormed off down the tunnel rather than watch the remainder of the game. Must be his time of the month.

QPR: CÃ©sar 8, Bosingwa 7, Ferdinand 8, Nelsen 8, Fabio 7 (Onuoha 21, 6), Wright-Phillips 6 (CissÃ© 70, 6), Granero 8, Faurlin 8, Park 7, Johnson 7 (Mackie 33, 6), Zamora 7

Subs: Green, Taarabt, Dyer, Hoilett

Chelsea: Cech 7, Ivanovic 7, Luiz 6, Terry 7, Cole 7, Lampard 6, Mikel 6, Ramires 7, Hazard 6, Bertrand 6 (Moses 58, 7), Torres 5 (Sturridge 81, 7)

Subs: Turnbull, Romeu, Oscar, Cahill, Azpilicueta

Bookings: Ramires 14 (foul), Bertrand 27 (foul)

Referee: Andre Marriner (West Midlands) 7 This is a referee I like a lot, who has progressed seriously well in recent years and is now rightly seen as the top man in the Premier League along with Howard Webb for the big occasions. Here he marshelled a potentially fiery encounter superbly, laying down a marker early by telling Ivanovic to get to his feet after a dive. He refereed calmly throughout, controlling the game and keeping his cards in his pockets. His game control and management was 10/10. However, Bertrand should have been sent off and Chelsea should have been awarded at least one penalty, so marks have to come off, which is a shame because this is exactly how I want to see football games refereed — sensibly, without fuss, and with common sense and man management used instead of card flurries.

QPR 1 Stoke City 0, Sunday May 6, 2012, Premier League

When things go wrong on an aircraft the pilots will reach under their seats and draw out a very large file of checklists that aim to troubleshoot the problem they’re experiencing. It has seemed in recent weeks that referees do something similar, abandoning the actual rules of the game in favour of a revised list of regulations if, say, Manchester United are playing at home in a must-win game.

On Sunday at Loftus Road our match official Andre Marriner, coming to the end of a fine season personally that culminated in him being awarded the Manchester derby last Monday evening, had leafed through the file for the Stoke City checklist. On there he would have found a number of useful tips, including the idea that if you penalise Robert Huth every time he fouls somebody you’d send him off every week so you just let him get on with it unchecked. Personally I would send Robert Huth off every week but referees seem to give him more leeway to do whatever the hell he likes because otherwise his career stats would be almost as farcical as the numbers Djibril Cissehas posted during his short time with QPR. Huth was excellent, Stoke’s best player for me, but had the referee refereed him as he referees every other player in the league he wouldn’t have been half as effective.

It was a similar tale with Stoke’s notorious throw ins. Ordinarily a team taking up to a minute to take every single throw in they get in the opposition half would be swiftly punished with yellow cards for time wasting, but because Stoke have a long throw, and like to trundle everybody forward for them, they’re allowed to do as they please. Marriner stood non-plussed and unmoved as Stoke set each one up meticulously over ever increasing lengths of time - towelling the ball off despite it being a dry day, organising the penalty area before finally hurling the ball towards it. It’s mind numbing stuff. The Stoke fans call it Pulis-ball and what remains of their away support carries a flag to games saying “we’ll play how we want.”

On the hour Fuller was perhaps lucky to escape a yellow card from Marriner when he appeared to elbow Nedum Onuoha in an aerial challenge, and Bobby Zamora was also fortunate to get away with a loose touch on the edge of the penalty area that teed up Glenn Whelen for a high shot into the sparsely populated away end. Three minutes later Joey Barton earned his keep for the week with a fine, brave, last ditch block on the edge of the penalty area but it was clear that QPR were struggling and at this point the game looked nailed on for a 0-0 draw or Stoke victory.

QPR: Kenny 6, Onuoha 6, Ferdinand 7, Hill 7, Taiwo 6, Barton 7, Derry 6 (Wright-Phillips 81, -), Buzsaky 5 (Cisse 50, 7), Mackie 5, Taarabt 7, Zamora 5 (Bothroyd 81, -)

Subs Not Used: Cerny, Hall, Gabbidon, Traore

Goals: Cisse 89 (assisted Taarabt/Ferdinand)

Stoke: Sorensen 7, Huth 7, Shawcross 7, Upson 6, Wilson 5 (Shotton 46, 6), Walters 6, Whelan 5, Delap 5, Jerome 6 (Jones 78, 6), Crouch 6, Fuller 6 (Whitehead 78, 6)

Subs Not Used: Begovic, Etherington, Woodgate, Palacios

Referee: Andre Marriner (W Midlands) 6 A harsh, low mark for a referee who actually got nothing wrong on the day decision wise and kept his cards in his pocket. Marks deducted though for just plodding around happily in the middle of the field allowing Stoke to play to their own rule book. Fuller fouled multiple times without being booked, Huth likewise, and the flagrant time wasting over every throw in and goal kick that started in the first minute and continued right the way through until the QPR goal should have been clamped down on after a quarter of an hour at the latest.

QPR 2 Sunderland 3, Wednesday December 21, 2011, Premier League

It’s said that just before the final crucial load of Indians turned up at Little Bighorn in 1876 General Custer was heard to remark that things could only get better. He was wrong then, and everybody that’s ever uttered that line has been wrong since. Things can always, always, always get worse. While Sunderland cooled their celebrations and returned to their own half it became apparent that referee Andre Marriner, absolutely excellent to this point, was no longer able to continue and would be replaced by the fourth official. The fourth official was Stuart Attwell.

QPR: Kenny 7, Young 6, Gabbidon 4, Connolly 5 (Bothroyd 90, -), Traore 7 (Hall 80, -), Barton 5, Faurlin 6, Derry 6, Wright-Phillips 6 (Taarabt 46, 7), Mackie 6, Helguson 7

Subs Not Used: Cerny, Hill, Campbell, Smith

Booked: Faurlin (foul), Young (foul)

Goals: Helguson 63 (assisted Faurlin), Mackie 67 (assisted Helguson)

Sunderland: Westwood 6, O'Shea 6, Bramble 6, Brown 7, Bardsley 6, Larsson 7 (Gardner 75, 7), Cattermole 6, Vaughan 5 (Colback 71, 6), Richardson 7, Sessegnon 8, Bendtner 8

Subs Not Used: Carson, Kilgallon, Ji, McClean, Elmohamady

Booked: Sessegnon (foul), Cattermole (repetitive fouling)

Goals: Bendtner 19 (assisted Richardson), Sessegnon 53 (unassisted), Brown 89 (assisted Richardson)

Referee: Andre Marriner (W Midlands) 8 (Stuart Attwell 53, (Warwick) 3) If ever you needed evidence of just what a truly awful referee Stuart Attwell is, here you have it. For 53 minutes this game was calmly controlled and managed by Andre Marriner who hardly put a foot wrong. Play flowed, the crowd was absorbed totally in the game, I can hardly recall hearing the whistle. Within minutes of coming on Attwell had awarded a blatant corner as a goal kick and then changed his mind when people moaned at him — things got teadily more farcical from there. Suddenly everything was a free kick. Every little bit of contact was a foul. Suddenly decisions were wrong - clearly and repeatedly wrong. Suddenly the crowd was up and on the referee’s back. I joke about his random draw mechanism of making decisions, which you can tell from his positioning and body language are often complete guesses, but to be honest I would actually prefer a random tombola machine on the halfway line with one of the cast of The Only Way is Essex drawing decisions out every 45 seconds to this silly little prick. You couldn’t get any more decisions wrong doing it that way. The difference between a good referee and a bad one laid bare in the same match.

Fulham 6 QPR 0, Sunday October 2, 2011

The stragglers in the noisy away end were still finding their seats when Fulham went 1-0 up. Wright-Phillips had already got a shot away for QPR but Schwarzer distributed the ball quickly, the knife sliced through the butter for the first time as Fulham broke away. Dembele shot, Kenny saved but Johnson followed up to score - 78 seconds on the clock and we were 1-0 down with Johnson behaving like a complete tool by goading the away support. I’ve no idea why he did this given that it was far too early in the game for any of the Fulham players to have received the wisdom of the QPR faithful on their shortcomings, but he felt the need to stand in front of the away end gesturing for some time in the aftermath of the goal. Much has been said about referees in recent weeks and I always think it’s a complete nonsense when a player gets booked for over-celebrating a goal with his own fans but this is just the sort of behaviour that could have incited a nasty reaction and if I had been the ref I would have booked the bugger for it.

Anyway, a bad start but no need to fret as yet as we had barely got going and there was plenty of time. QPR tried knocking the ball about and their only early reward was to see Sidwell scythe Taarabt down as he turned. He was, quite rightly, booked. As the minutes ticked by the pattern of the game became established — QPR huffing and puffing trying to create an opening, Fulham sitting tight, harrying the QPR players and seeking to break with pace. The latter they did on more than one occasion and the hot knife was in evidence several times. Dempsey should have scored in the ninth minute, but was blocked by Orr, and Johnson was close in the seventeenth minute. During this time QPR had forced a corner or two but little had come of them.

Then in the nineteenth minute another Fulham attack had appeared to break down as Kenny and Hall converged on the ball in the area, but as they seemed to dither Johnson nipped in, Kenny bundled him over and the ref pointed to the spot. The juxtaposition of foul and goal was such that the ref did not even bother to yellow card anybody such was the lameness of the foul and the lack of risk to the goal at the point of contact. Murphy despatched the penalty with ease and then indulged in his own bit of fan goading, albeit limited to a minor ‘ear-cupping’.

Hall’s reputation with the QPR support is about as damaged as his hamstrings and he did it further damage here today, largely just by being out there on the field. He certainly seemed culpable with Kenny regarding the penalty. To be fair, though, I would have to watch the highlights to determine precisely who was responsible for the constant gaps in the defence, and sadly I haven’t the time to do that and get this finished before another week’s grafting starts again.

With a good fifteen minutes to go there were fears in the away end of an even more serious rout but Fulham had clearly decided enough was enough and that allowed QPR a little purple patch where, urged on by the enthusiastic Mackie, they had shots from Barton, Wright-Phillips, Mackie and DJ Campbell, with the latter also heading over. This gave a rather surprising degree of balance to the ‘attempts’ count in the match stats. Despite taking their collective foot of the gas, Fulham still managed shots by Ruiz and Dempsey. It’s also worth reporting that in the latter part of the game Faurlin (foul) and Wright-Philips (dissent — suggesting the linesman needed spectacles) received yellow cards to add to one awarded to Hall in the second half — I honestly can’t remember why Hall got one but maybe the ref responded to the collective telepathic ire of the QPR fans.

The midfield looked all at sea for most of the game, whether playing the conventional 4-4-2 or the 4-2-3-1 that we seem to play, with the three in that formation ‘floating’. After an earlier match report I was castigated by someone who was at pains to point out that I could not possibly know what I was talking about, so I’ll try to avoid a repeat of that by saying that whatever I think about team shape, in general teams play well in spite of their formations rather than because of them. In terms of decision-making and execution QPR were poor today and the various changes of personnel and shape did little to change that. We also fell over far too easily and seldom looked like getting the fouls for which the players appealed whilst sprawled on the floor. Oh, and while I am about it, please practice keeping the ball and moving it about, rather than simply hoofing it forward. Three touches and hoof was not really good enough in the Championship — it’s hopeless in the Prem.

QPR: Kenny 5, Ferdinand 5, Hall 4, Young 5, Orr 5, Faurlin 5, Derry 4 (Smith 45, 5), Wright-Phillips 5, Taarabt 4 (Campbell 45, 6), Barton 5, Bothroyd 4 (Mackie 72, 7)

Subs Not Used: Murphy, Perone, Buzsaky, Helguson

Booked: Hall (foul), Faurlin (foul), Wright-Phillips (dissent)

Fulham: Schwarzer 7, JA Riise 6, Hangeland 6, Baird 6, Grygera 7, Sidwell 8, Murphy 7 (Etuhu 83 6), Dempsey 6, Johnson 8 (Ruiz 75 6), Zamora 7, Dembele 7 (Sa 87, -)

Subs Not Used: Etheridge, Kelly, Senderos, Duff

Booked: Sidwell (foul), Hangeland (foul)

Referee: Andre Marriner ( West Midlands ) 7 Largely unfussy and just got on with things really. Can’t really recall him getting anything wrong but needs to make sure a wall starts and finishes ten yards from a free kick otherwise there seems little point to him being there to say where it should go.

QPR 0 Plymouth 2, Tuesday September 18, 2007

The first action of the game came in the fourth minute when Damion Stewart was adjudged to have fouled Hayles and Plymouth were awarded a free kick 25 yards out from goal. Peter Halmosi stepped up to take it and beat the wall and Camp all ends up but the ball flew wide of the post. From where I was sitting it looked in all the way so that was a lucky escape.

In between these two chances Cullip stayed deep and played everybody onside allowing a cross from Ebanks Blake to flash right across the six yard box in front of the QPR goal with nobody able to get a killer touch. Buzsaky was off target with two more tempting free kicks before half time as Barry Hayles continued to hit the deck with embarrassing ease for such a strong man. The first was narrowly wide of Lee Camp's goal, the second flew high into the Upper Loft.

Martin Rowlands was unlucky not to draw the R's level ten minutes into the second half. Rangers' most impressive player on the night Danny Nardiello was cynically hauled back by Seip after tricking his way through and from the free kick Rowlands bent a lovely shot over the wall, past the beaten McCormick and off the angle of post and cross bar.

QPR: Camp 6, Rehman 5 (Bignot 59, 4), Cullip 6, Stewart 5, Barker 4, Rowlands 5, Nardiello 7 (Sahar 81, 6), Bolder 4, Leigertwood 4, Moore 4 (Ephraim 59, 6), Blackstock 5.

Subs Not Used: Cole, Curtis.

Plymouth: McCormick 7, Connolly 7, Seip 6, Timar 7, Sawyer 7, Norris 8, Buzsaky 8, Nalis 7, Halmosi 8, Hayles 8 (Hodges 90, -), Ebanks-Blake 7

Subs Not Used: Larrieu, Chadwick, Doumbe, Fallon

Booked: Seip (foul), Timar (foul)

Goals: Halmosi 50, Norris 62.

Referee: Andre Marriner (W Midlands) 5 - Seemed to give every fifty fifty decision Plymouth's way and bought every dive Barry Hayles offered to sell him but overall fairly standard Championship refereeing and in no way can we blame or offer him as an excuse for another woeful home performance and defeat.

Blackburn 3 QPR 0, Saturday January 7, 2006

On the hour mark a crude foul by Matteo on Baidoo gave Rangers a free kick twenty five yards from goal. Baidoo had been baring down on the penalty area with support to his left from Cook and just two Rovers defenders in front of him. Matteo's cynical hack at the youngster was a blatant yellow card, but Mr Marriner, wary of his lack of Premiership matches so far this season no doubt, patted his mate Dom on the bum and let him off with it. Shittu fired the resulting set piece off target.

Mauro Milanese picked up the first card of the game a short time later for a foul on Thompson. With Matteo and Peter repeatedly committing fouls that ranged from niggly to dangerous through the second half it was irritating to find a QPR player entering the book first but nothing more than you'd expect of Mr Marriner.

Ainsworth's next action of the game finally, finally brought a yellow card for Matteo. After numerous offences and two crude assaults on QPR players a mistimed sliding tackle on Ainsworth finally had Mr Marriner reaching for a card.

Blackburn: Friedel 7, Neill 8, Khivanishvili 7, Todd 8, Matteo 6, Thompson 7, Tugay 8, Savage 7 (Pedersen 77, 7), Peter 9, Bellamy 9*, Dickov 7 (Kuqi 77, 6).

Subs not used: Enckelman, Nelson, Emerton.

Scorers: Todd 17, Bellamy 36, Bellamy 86

Bookings: Matteo 70, Neill 87

QPR: Royce 6, Bignot 5, Shittu 6, Rose 7, Milanese 6, Rowlands 7, Langley 6, Santos 5 (Ainsworth 55, 8), Cook 5 (Donnelly 75, 7), Baidoo 6, Furlong 6 (Moore 75).

Subs: Cole, Evatt.

Bookings: Milanese 67

Referee - Andre Marriner - 4 - A referee on the "elite" list with only 1 Premier division match to his name doesn't want any controversy against high profile Premiership personalities like Bellamy and Mark Hughes damaging his future prospects - so most of the 50/50 calls went Rovers way he only booked Matteo when he absolutely had to after numerous fouls. You only have to look at similar performances this weekend from Peter Walton at Fulham and Howard Webb at Burton Albion to realise that more often than not, these weak individuals realise what side their bread is buttered on and let the off dodgy decision slip through when it suits.

Stoke 1 QPR 2, Saturday December 3, 2005

It's often been said that the 2005/06 season at Loftus Road will make a great film one day, some of the scenes at the Britannia Stadium on Saturday wouldn't have looked out of place in Black Hawk Down. Some questionable refereeing decisions and spoiling tactics from QPR riled the fifteen thousand home fans so much the atmosphere became more poisonous than anywhere I've travelled with QPR since the last time we played in Stoke.

Nevertheless the players threw off the shackles of another difficult week at Loftus Road to take the lead inside two minutes. Carl Hoefkens was harshly adjudged to have felled Paul Furlong twenty five yards out from goal by everybody's favourite perma tanned referee Andre (with an acute accent) Marriner.

With the ball slightly right of centre it seemed ideally placed for one of Paul Furlong's trademark left foot master blasters. Richard Langley rolled the ball to Shittu instead and he hit an embarrassing low drive straight at Gareth Ainsworth on the edge of the box. Ainsworth got the ball caught under his feet but still managed to scramble it into the penalty area where Paul Furlong was waiting to pounce and force home the opening goal.

Right on half time QPR forced a rare corner, but only succeeded in picking up a booking from the resulting set piece. Gareth Ainsworth tussled with Halls at the back post and seemed to raise an arm to the Stoke man, luckily after consulting his linesman referee Marriner produced only a yellow card for the QPR player.

The turning point in the game came just seven minutes into the second half. Against the run of play Rangers launched a counter attack. Martin Rowlands hit a low shot from the edge of the box that Simonsen parried down into the ground rather than away from his goal. This allowed Paul Furlong to nip in for what would have been a simple tap in, had Halls not wrapped both arms round the striker and dragged him to the ground.

You're never likely to see a more blatant penalty but Halls complained long and hard about the decision, and had to be dragged away from the referee by Luke Chadwick once the red card had been produced. Halls had to endure a humiliating walk to the tunnel right in front of those QPR fans he had mocked after the equaliser.

After a lengthy delay and a heated argument with Gareth Ainsworth Richard Langley stepped up to take the penalty. His dead straight six step run up was exactly the same one he used the last time he took a penalty for QPR. That was against Luton in an FA Cup replay at Loftus Road and he missed, this time though he calmly waited for Simonsen to guess the wrong way, and then tucked the ball in to the keeper's left.

The frustration was too much for Brammer who executed crude tackles on Marcus Bignot and then Richard Langley without punishment from Marriner. Brammer had been booked in the first half and, probably fearing for his safety at full time, Andre with an acute accent clearly didn't have the gumption to dismiss a second home player.

As the final whistle sounded two Stoke fans ran onto the pitch at the Boothen end of the ground. One wrestled Simon Royce into the back of the net and the pair grappled with each other until Luke Chadwick arrived to assist the Rangers keeper. Shabazz Baidoo and Ian Evatt both made it to the scene of the incident before a steward even entered the picture. When a couple of fat sods in yellow coats did arrive it was no surprise to see the Gold Range logo on their backs - as QPR know from personal experience they're a real standard bearer for crass incompetence in the stewarding of football matches.

Stoke: Simonsen 6, Broomes 7, Duberry 5, Hoefkens 6, Halls 5, Sweeney 8(Sigurdsson 76, 7), Brammer 7, Henry 6, Chadwick 8, Bangoura 8, Sidibe 7.

Subs Not Used: de Goey, Kolar, Buxton, Junior.

Sent Off: Halls (51), professional foul.

Booked: Brammer, Sigurdsson.

Goals: Bangoura 26.

QPR: Royce 8, Bignot 7, Shittu 7, Milanese 8, Dyer 5 (Evatt 59, 6), Bean 6, Langley 6, Rowlands 7, Ainsworth 7 (Cook 88, -), Moore 5 (Baidoo 90, -), Furlong 7.

Subs Not Used: Cole, Donnelly.

Booked: Milanese, Ainsworth, Bean, Rowlands.

Goals: Furlong 2, Langley 52 pen.

Ref: A Marriner (W Midlands) - 5 - Had very little choice with the penalty and subsequent sending off but apart from this he made inconsistent decisions and got caught up in the atmosphere a little. Once he'd sent Halls off, correctly, he really turned against Rangers and tried to even things up. The free kick for Rangers first goal was a poor decision, as was the award in favour of Chadwick for the second. Marcus Bean was rightly booked for a late tackle, but Brammer was allowed to get away with two, because he'd already been booked - coward. At the end of the day the guy is a poor referee.

Prior to all of that he refereed a 1-0 defeat at Cardiff at the very end of the 2004/05 season, and earlier in that campaign a 3-2 home win against Plymouth that saved Ian Holloway’s job amidst the Ramon Diaz farce. He also refereed a 4-1 home win against Hartlepool in our 2003/04 promotion season.

Stats

The red card shown to David Meyler of Hull at Swansea last weekend was only Marriner’s second in 29 appointments this season. He has, however, shown a hefty 105 yellow cards. The six yellows and a red in that game match his biggest haul of the season of seven cards in a single game which he has done on four occasions.

Last season he showed 110 yellow cards and a hefty 13 reds in 36 appointments. That included three red cards in the South Yorkshire derby between Sheff Wed and Barnsley.

Just five yellow cards in the crunch Manchester derby at the end of 2012/13 was in keeping with Marriner’s overall leniency across the season. He showed 92 yellows and five reds in 28 games — 3.25 bookings a game. He was given the top appointments at the end of last season, and has started this by doing Everton v man Utd and Liverpool v Arsenal (four yellows, no reds so far) so it seems he's the top dog which shows that you don't need to flash cards around as per the absolute letter of the law to get anywhere in refereeing these days — advice Darren Deadman might like to take on board after his shambolic handling of Crawley v Portsmouth on Sunday.

Marriner's biggest haul in a single game last year was five yellows and a red on three separate occasions. The first, at Wigan v Blackburn , was also the game where he missed a phantom corner kick that led to Yakubu scoring in a 3-3 draw. He was also the referee for Bolton ’s 5-0 home defeat by Man Utd where Kevin Davies’ challenge on Tom Cleverly, and the lack of a card for it, sparked controversy. Overall though he performed very well.

The season before he showed 131 yellows and five reds in 38 matches — 3.45 yellows a game. His biggest haul in a single game was six yellows and one red in Wigan ’s 1-1 draw with Sunderland.