| The offside goal 22:31 - Mar 4 with 5627 views | Dr_Parnassus |
Why are people saying it’s onside?
Unless there is some obscure offside rule adaptation that I’m not aware of.
He was in front of the defensive line when the ball came to him after being touched by our player.
That’s offside. |  |
| |  |
| The offside goal on 22:48 - Mar 4 with 4659 views | Dr_Parnassus |
Although I may have been sent the wrong screengrab here.
I’ll be back.
Edit, now have the right clip.
Angle too poor, inconclusive as it stands. I’ll re-visit. [Post edited 4 Mar 2023 23:01]
| |
| |
| The offside goal on 01:06 - Mar 5 with 4563 views | KeithHaynes |
| The offside goal on 22:48 - Mar 4 by Dr_Parnassus |
Although I may have been sent the wrong screengrab here.
I’ll be back.
Edit, now have the right clip.
Angle too poor, inconclusive as it stands. I’ll re-visit. [Post edited 4 Mar 2023 23:01]
|
The Swans analysts have provided Martin with proof the goal was good. |  |
| |
| The offside goal on 02:02 - Mar 5 with 4535 views | KeithHaynes |
Best we can do.
 | |
| |
| The offside goal on 04:36 - Mar 5 with 4486 views | Dr_Parnassus |
| The offside goal on 02:02 - Mar 5 by KeithHaynes |
Best we can do.
|
Yeah that’s about the best I found too.
It’s a 12 degree camera angle so the optical illusion will always be that the players closer to the camera will be further back in the field than they are in comparison to those further away.
But it looks about level to me. They go either way. | |
| |
| The offside goal on 09:08 - Mar 5 with 4330 views | KeithHaynes |
| The offside goal on 04:36 - Mar 5 by Dr_Parnassus |
Yeah that’s about the best I found too.
It’s a 12 degree camera angle so the optical illusion will always be that the players closer to the camera will be further back in the field than they are in comparison to those further away.
But it looks about level to me. They go either way. |
I took that from the game highlights and freeze framed it, as you say there’s little in it. | |
| |
| The offside goal on 13:36 - Mar 5 with 4136 views | jackdee |
| The offside goal on 09:08 - Mar 5 by KeithHaynes |
I took that from the game highlights and freeze framed it, as you say there’s little in it. |
You just need to follow the lines cut across the pitch to see he looks just offside...... quite simple. The ruler is completely out of line with the cut lines |  |
| |
Login to get fewer ads
| The offside goal on 14:02 - Mar 5 with 4115 views | ReslovenSwan1 |
| The offside goal on 13:36 - Mar 5 by jackdee |
You just need to follow the lines cut across the pitch to see he looks just offside...... quite simple. The ruler is completely out of line with the cut lines |
I always recall advantage to attacker before VAR. in line was onside in the old days . |  |
| Wise sage since Toshack era |
| |
| The offside goal on 15:45 - Mar 5 with 4076 views | swan65split |
| The offside goal on 13:36 - Mar 5 by jackdee |
You just need to follow the lines cut across the pitch to see he looks just offside...... quite simple. The ruler is completely out of line with the cut lines |
Depends if the groundsman was on the lash the night before.  his angles may be wrong!
I just blame the officials...... |  | | |
| The offside goal on 17:01 - Mar 5 with 4026 views | Joesus_Of_Narbereth |
| The offside goal on 14:02 - Mar 5 by ReslovenSwan1 |
I always recall advantage to attacker before VAR. in line was onside in the old days . |
That’s the way it should be. The pedantry that’s entered the modern game with VAR where a goal is disallowed because after watching it frame by frame with lines drawn everywhere they deduce someone’s toe or nose is offside is crazy. |  |
| |
| The offside goal on 19:17 - Mar 5 with 3920 views | howenjack |
| The offside goal on 17:01 - Mar 5 by Joesus_Of_Narbereth |
That’s the way it should be. The pedantry that’s entered the modern game with VAR where a goal is disallowed because after watching it frame by frame with lines drawn everywhere they deduce someone’s toe or nose is offside is crazy. |
I remember a certain Liverpool player who was caught out many times when his teeth were off side . In the end he resorted to biting people in his frustrations ...very sad |  | | |
| The offside goal on 19:41 - Mar 5 with 3892 views | STID2017 |
| The offside goal on 19:24 - Mar 5 by shingle |
You may be absolutely barking but we can`t argue with that.  |
Seemed a lot of work to disprove his opening post, don't you think ? |  |
| |
| The offside goal on 20:43 - Mar 5 with 3841 views | Dr_Parnassus |
| The offside goal on 17:21 - Mar 5 by STID2017 |
"Why are people saying it’s onside?
Unless there is some obscure offside rule adaptation that I’m not aware of.
He was in front of the defensive line when the ball came to him after being touched by our player.
That’s offside"
Your opening post
Beep beep ... |
No beep beep about it.
I was sent the wrong photo to look at, as explained 10 mins later in my follow up post.
As you were. | |
| |
| The offside goal on 20:47 - Mar 5 with 3837 views | Dr_Parnassus |
| The offside goal on 19:41 - Mar 5 by STID2017 |
Seemed a lot of work to disprove his opening post, don't you think ? |
My opening post was based on this. Someone sent asking if it was still offside despite it being a clearance that was inadvertently deflected back into the attackers path.
The answer is yes.
 | |
| |
| The offside goal on 20:59 - Mar 5 with 3828 views | STID2017 |
| The offside goal on 20:43 - Mar 5 by Dr_Parnassus |
No beep beep about it.
I was sent the wrong photo to look at, as explained 10 mins later in my follow up post.
As you were. |
So you didn't analyse the game from multiple angles, with a better view than the fans who were at the game, like you normally claim you do ?
And you did question "Why are people saying it's onside? In your opening post.
So beep beep is totally appropriate | |
| |
| The offside goal on 22:03 - Mar 5 with 3782 views | Dr_Parnassus |
| The offside goal on 20:59 - Mar 5 by STID2017 |
So you didn't analyse the game from multiple angles, with a better view than the fans who were at the game, like you normally claim you do ?
And you did question "Why are people saying it's onside? In your opening post.
So beep beep is totally appropriate |
Not multiple angles no, but most certainly a better view than the fans that were there.
I did ask that yes, about the picture above as explained.
Although the question stands if you wish to put it to the other picture too, it’s nowhere near clear cut. Multimeters in it.
So beep was complete nonsense and an attempt to troll, which failed. Again. | |
| |
| The offside goal on 22:04 - Mar 5 with 3777 views | Dr_Parnassus |
Are you wanting Russ out yet by the way, or still lack the courage to confirm?
Beep. | |
| |
| The offside goal on 22:28 - Mar 5 with 3738 views | Dr_Parnassus |
| The offside goal on 13:36 - Mar 5 by jackdee |
You just need to follow the lines cut across the pitch to see he looks just offside...... quite simple. The ruler is completely out of line with the cut lines |
But they are in between lines, plus due to the fixed position of the camera, the lines won’t be the correct angle.
You have to take the closest measurable point to them and use that same angle, that will get you the closest you can to the result.
If this was who wants to be a millionaire on the final question, I’d be taking the money rather than guessing the 50:50, it’s that close. This is the information the analysts will have too, it’s just a delayed stream they watch from. | |
| |
| The offside goal on 23:06 - Mar 5 with 3684 views | STID2017 |
| The offside goal on 22:03 - Mar 5 by Dr_Parnassus |
Not multiple angles no, but most certainly a better view than the fans that were there.
I did ask that yes, about the picture above as explained.
Although the question stands if you wish to put it to the other picture too, it’s nowhere near clear cut. Multimeters in it.
So beep was complete nonsense and an attempt to troll, which failed. Again. |
"Although the question stands if you wish to put it to the other picture too, it’s nowhere near clear cut. Multimeters in it."
Multimeters ?
What has measuring current, voltage and resistance got to do with offside
I know you have a massive tendency to overthink things, but even for you that is going too far ? ðŸ˜ðŸ˜
I understand you maybe meant millimetres.
Maybe the pressure is getting to you too ... | |
| |
| The offside goal on 10:30 - Mar 6 with 3544 views | swan65split |
NO VAR its down two one person, has been for decades
 | | | |
| The offside goal on 10:38 - Mar 6 with 3537 views | A_Fans_Dad |
| The offside goal on 13:36 - Mar 5 by jackdee |
You just need to follow the lines cut across the pitch to see he looks just offside...... quite simple. The ruler is completely out of line with the cut lines |
Wrong, the ruler is lined up with the front Penalty area borderline to get the correct line. | | | |
| The offside goal (n/t) on 11:28 - Mar 6 with 3504 views | Dr_Parnassus |
| The offside goal on 23:06 - Mar 5 by STID2017 |
"Although the question stands if you wish to put it to the other picture too, it’s nowhere near clear cut. Multimeters in it."
Multimeters ?
What has measuring current, voltage and resistance got to do with offside
I know you have a massive tendency to overthink things, but even for you that is going too far ? ðŸ˜ðŸ˜
I understand you maybe meant millimetres.
Maybe the pressure is getting to you too ... |
This post has been edited by an administrator | |
| |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
