| Players we should have got rid - way before we did 14:45 - May 12 with 8353 views | numptydumpty |
On similar topic as one staring who we should have kept, who did we hang onto way too long
I suspect this list will be way longer than the ones we should have kept
Appreciate contract lengths, wages, sale prices etc mean more difficult at times to get rid !!!
First on, I would have off loaded one particular player who had a realistic chance of getting rid to receive a fee and sellable on similar or better contract elsewhere.
Stand up Mr Joey Barton !!!
Was at QPR for four seasons, one on loan but a bad egg, creating even more dysfunction at a bad time to be a QPR fan.
Unbelievably divisive character and not nearly as good as he himself believed himself to be !!! [Post edited 12 May 14:49]
|  |
| |  |
| Players we should have got rid - way before we did on 14:59 - May 12 with 6147 views | CateLeBonR |
Tony Witter. |  | | |
| Players we should have got rid - way before we did on 15:44 - May 12 with 6070 views | Tonto |
Anyone bought by Hughesless or Redcrapp |  |
| |
| Players we should have got rid - way before we did on 16:35 - May 12 with 6011 views | essextaxiboy |
Nico Hammelainen (sp)
Mido Shadipo [Post edited 12 May 16:40]
|  | | |
| Players we should have got rid - way before we did on 17:12 - May 12 with 5929 views | CiderwithRsie |
Tony Roberts
This isn't just a "Roberts was crap" judgement - for a few years the jury was out, he would have occasional decent games, pull off a classy save etc.
But by 1995 at the absolute latest (when we'd had a whole season without Stejskal), when we still had a good squad in which he was clearly a weakness, and when we were about to get the Ferdinand money, we could have replaced him for a fraction of the money spaffed on Hateley etc.
PS Barton was one we never should have signed in the first place, all the warning signs were in plain view. |  | | |
| Players we should have got rid - way before we did on 17:19 - May 12 with 5907 views | CiderwithRsie |
I suppose the real "hanging onto" players are ones that were actually decent, but where we kept them to a point where we had to sell them for peanuts because the contract had run down, when we could have got a decent price and reinvested a year or two before.
Those are tough to call.
Maybe Trevor Sinclair, who we could have flogged for big money (then) when we were relegated? We kept him as part of the bid for immediate promotion, and failed badly.
But then we'd have never have had that goal against Barnsley. | | | |
| Players we should have got rid - way before we did on 17:23 - May 12 with 5901 views | Aitch |
Zesh Rehman. Preferably about five minutes before we signed him. |  |
| |
| Players we should have got rid - way before we did on 17:26 - May 12 with 5893 views | hoops_legend |
I mean Albert adomah is unfortunately one, still popular but if he had signed off with that goal
Keeping us up last season that would have been a better way to go. Especially as he lost his legs a long time before this season |  |
| |
| Players we should have got rid - way before we did on 18:42 - May 12 with 5767 views | Rs_Holy |
Shaun Wrong Phillips |  | | |
Login to get fewer ads
| Players we should have got rid - way before we did on 18:53 - May 12 with 5743 views | BazzaInTheLoft |
We love a self flagellation don’t we!
Getting rid of players is hard. It’s very rare I’ve seen us give us a player a new contract and thought ‘why the fck we done that?’ |  | | |
| Players we should have got rid - way before we did on 20:46 - May 12 with 5567 views | Spaceman_P |
someone has to do it.... Taylor Richards. |  | | |
| Players we should have got rid - way before we did on 21:20 - May 12 with 5517 views | Logman |
Matty Rose. Not a winner. | | | |
| Players we should have got rid - way before we did on 21:23 - May 12 with 5505 views | Logman |
Actually | | | |
| Players we should have got rid - way before we did on 21:24 - May 12 with 5503 views | Logman |
Dozzell | | | |
| Players we should have got rid - way before we did on 11:02 - May 13 with 5299 views | Bluce_Ree |
At 227 appearances, I nominate KARL FKING READY. |  |
| Stefan Moore, Stefan Moore running down the wing. Stefan Moore, Stefan Moore running down the wing. He runs like a cheetah, his crosses couldn't be sweeter. Stefan Moore. Stefan Moore. Stefan Moore. |
| |
| Players we should have got rid - way before we did on 14:29 - May 13 with 5120 views | nick_hammersmith |
It's got to be Joey Barton.
Anyone else who embarrasses their employer like that would be sacked immediately.
Instead, we send ours on holiday to the south of France for a year on full pay
What a weapon.
Running a close second has to be SWP, who was terrible, Imagine having £50k odd per week to spend on players now? |  | | |
| Players we should have got rid - way before we did on 14:35 - May 13 with 5075 views | BazzaInTheLoft |
| Players we should have got rid - way before we did on 11:02 - May 13 by Bluce_Ree |
At 227 appearances, I nominate KARL FKING READY. |
I don’t disagree but I always have to bring this up…
He won POTY! | | | |
| Players we should have got rid - way before we did on 16:46 - May 13 with 4973 views | queensparker |
| Players we should have got rid - way before we did on 11:02 - May 13 by Bluce_Ree |
At 227 appearances, I nominate KARL FKING READY. |
100% this.
He was pony and having him in central defence for all that time coincided with our slide into Div 1 from which we’ve never really recovered.
OK it wasn’t entirely his fault but I mainly blame him |  | | |
| Players we should have got rid - way before we did on 19:18 - May 13 with 4883 views | perpignanR |
| Players we should have got rid - way before we did on 14:35 - May 13 by BazzaInTheLoft |
I don’t disagree but I always have to bring this up…
He won POTY! |
227 appearances over 10/11 seasons under how many managers?
POTY in 98. That requires some explanation doesn’t it. Maybe he wasn’t as bad as some remember. | | | |
| Players we should have got rid - way before we did on 22:30 - May 13 with 4738 views | numptydumpty |
Matthew Rose | |
| |
| Players we should have got rid - way before we did on 09:01 - May 14 with 4584 views | Bluce_Ree |
| Players we should have got rid - way before we did on 19:18 - May 13 by perpignanR |
227 appearances over 10/11 seasons under how many managers?
POTY in 98. That requires some explanation doesn’t it. Maybe he wasn’t as bad as some remember. |
Probably very dedicated on the training pitch.
He got 22 appearances in 95/96 and I just remember him being bullshit for all of them. Given that we had Maddix and Macca, I don't know why Wilkins insisted on playing him.
Also, POTY for 97/98 which wasn't exactly a vintage year for us. Finished 21st (thanks to Jamie Pollock) and legitimately our best player that season might have been Mark Kennedy on loan (for 8 games). | |
| Stefan Moore, Stefan Moore running down the wing. Stefan Moore, Stefan Moore running down the wing. He runs like a cheetah, his crosses couldn't be sweeter. Stefan Moore. Stefan Moore. Stefan Moore. |
| |
| Players we should have got rid - way before we did on 12:04 - May 14 with 4413 views | SheffieldHoop |
I'll get the popular ones out the way, Lee Cook, Gareth Ainsworth, Martin Rowlands, Dan Shittu....All had stopped playing a long time before their final contracts expired, all seemed pretty much done as Championship level players by that time as well. Ainsworth you can argue was involved behind the scenes. Cook and Shittu should probably have never come back really. Lessons learned.....Or maybe not. Adel Taarabt? Left in the end for nothing....Should we have cashed in at some stage before that?
Then there's the Peter Ramage, Hogan Ephraim, Gary Borrowdale class who were never very good and got moved aside by new signings, and saw out their contracts, club perhaps should've had get out clauses in place - Did we learn from that?
Then there's the Andrew Johnson, Bobby Zamora Injury prone types and the Nedum Onouha, Park Ji-Sung, Junior Hoilett flatter-to-deceive types, who IMO sit somewhere between the last lot and the next....
Next is the piss-taker class.....Steven Caulker, Leroy Fer, Luke Young, Jack Robinson, Sandro, Armand Traore, SWP, Kieron fcking Dyer (Who we signed for 1 year, watched get injured after 4 minutes, and gave another year to) - In a proper organization, these people would've been kicked out, dismissed.
I don't think Barton makes even the top 20 in my time, so amazed that he does with people who can remember the 90's decline with Ned Zelic and all that. I don't think he was in the piss taker class (What I gather is he was very much in with the Hills and Derrys), I don't think he was very good either, but I do think we were a better team with him in it. MOTM in the play off Semi home to Wigan, one of our better players throughout that season. Even Clive, who I think would admit has a strong dislike of Barton, gave him 6 MOTM awards in his final season (relegated) with us. Goes to Burnley, wins another promotion and their POTY while we're pissing around with Chris Ramsey as Head Coach and Onouha as the Captain, both apparently too afraid to speak up and call out the piss takers. Terminal decline ensues. |  |
| "Someone despises me. That's their problem." Marcus Aurelius |
| |
| Players we should have got rid - way before we did on 12:29 - May 14 with 4384 views | robith |
Will never forget how far my jaw dropped when Barton's name was cheered on the first day of the season in the team read out. A fan base bereft of self esteem at that point |  | | |
| Players we should have got rid - way before we did on 13:01 - May 14 with 4331 views | nick_hammersmith |
| Players we should have got rid - way before we did on 12:04 - May 14 by SheffieldHoop |
I'll get the popular ones out the way, Lee Cook, Gareth Ainsworth, Martin Rowlands, Dan Shittu....All had stopped playing a long time before their final contracts expired, all seemed pretty much done as Championship level players by that time as well. Ainsworth you can argue was involved behind the scenes. Cook and Shittu should probably have never come back really. Lessons learned.....Or maybe not. Adel Taarabt? Left in the end for nothing....Should we have cashed in at some stage before that?
Then there's the Peter Ramage, Hogan Ephraim, Gary Borrowdale class who were never very good and got moved aside by new signings, and saw out their contracts, club perhaps should've had get out clauses in place - Did we learn from that?
Then there's the Andrew Johnson, Bobby Zamora Injury prone types and the Nedum Onouha, Park Ji-Sung, Junior Hoilett flatter-to-deceive types, who IMO sit somewhere between the last lot and the next....
Next is the piss-taker class.....Steven Caulker, Leroy Fer, Luke Young, Jack Robinson, Sandro, Armand Traore, SWP, Kieron fcking Dyer (Who we signed for 1 year, watched get injured after 4 minutes, and gave another year to) - In a proper organization, these people would've been kicked out, dismissed.
I don't think Barton makes even the top 20 in my time, so amazed that he does with people who can remember the 90's decline with Ned Zelic and all that. I don't think he was in the piss taker class (What I gather is he was very much in with the Hills and Derrys), I don't think he was very good either, but I do think we were a better team with him in it. MOTM in the play off Semi home to Wigan, one of our better players throughout that season. Even Clive, who I think would admit has a strong dislike of Barton, gave him 6 MOTM awards in his final season (relegated) with us. Goes to Burnley, wins another promotion and their POTY while we're pissing around with Chris Ramsey as Head Coach and Onouha as the Captain, both apparently too afraid to speak up and call out the piss takers. Terminal decline ensues. |
I'm still impressed by how much Nedum's bollocks have grown since he retired!
He was an absolute pussycat on the pitch, but all of a sudden he's speaking up about all the terrible things that happened while he was playing.
Also, I think you need to look at Barton in the context of one of the biggest earners in the club history. Then work out if it was worth the very average footballer we got in return. Then balance that against the disruptive force that he was.
The only thing that Barton has ever got right is calling out Jeremy Vine, but even then he messed up asking people to crowd fund his libel case... | | | |
| Players we should have got rid - way before we did on 13:25 - May 14 with 4248 views | SheffieldHoop |
| Players we should have got rid - way before we did on 13:01 - May 14 by nick_hammersmith |
I'm still impressed by how much Nedum's bollocks have grown since he retired!
He was an absolute pussycat on the pitch, but all of a sudden he's speaking up about all the terrible things that happened while he was playing.
Also, I think you need to look at Barton in the context of one of the biggest earners in the club history. Then work out if it was worth the very average footballer we got in return. Then balance that against the disruptive force that he was.
The only thing that Barton has ever got right is calling out Jeremy Vine, but even then he messed up asking people to crowd fund his libel case... |
Context context context. The club was paying all kinds of money to all kinds of losers around that time. I don't think Barton was any more badly overpaid than SWP, The Ferdinands (Take your pick) Luke Young, Loic Remy, Chris Samba, Granero, Vargas etc. Every single one of them had Uncle Tone's pants down. Simple as that.
As for the disruptive force. You could argue Marti Cifuentes has been our disruptive force this season. Sometimes you need that. Maybe we could have done with that at the start of this season, rather than Ainsworth making excuses for them. We saw Chris Martin do a bit at the end of last. Someone has to do it at some stage. Jimmy Dunne bollocking Lucas Andersen just before he went off vs Leeds. About time people spoke up for themselves.
All the stuff he does now has nothing to do with QPR, so I don't think it's relevant....Like saying we should have kept Vinnie Jones on a bit longer cos he turned out to be good in Mean Machine [Post edited 14 May 13:44]
| |
| "Someone despises me. That's their problem." Marcus Aurelius |
| |
| Players we should have got rid - way before we did on 13:35 - May 14 with 4215 views | SheffieldHoop |
| Players we should have got rid - way before we did on 12:29 - May 14 by robith |
Will never forget how far my jaw dropped when Barton's name was cheered on the first day of the season in the team read out. A fan base bereft of self esteem at that point |
Yeah because Samba Diakite and Jermaine Jenas would have got us up that season, wouldn't they?
I was highly cynical of Barton at the time - Of course I was, I read this website - But with hindsight I really don't think was anywhere near as bad as people make out | |
| "Someone despises me. That's their problem." Marcus Aurelius |
| |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
