 | News
Comment | Southampton At Brentford The Damning Verdict
at 11:10:06
Agree with much of your analysis Nick and the contributors especially Westsussex. I would just add that as well as our errors at the back and against Newcastle in goal Smallbone has been poor at this level and Adam Armstrong looks the same as he did when he was last in the PL. Neither appear to be up to the level required. We need our strikers to score because if they don't, we are immediately hoping for a flawless display at the back and that looks highly unlikely at this level in any game.
I am not one shouting or seeking RM to go (I want management stability and there is no guarantee based on previous recent history that SR would make the right selection) but if he does not deal with the issues and make the right selections and become more adaptable in his tactics and style he will be the architect of his own eventual dismissal.
The Man Utd game is now becoming very interesting for both managers. Both are facing question marks over their style and ability to get a team to perform. I fear that Man Utd (as they often do when they are criticised) will respond better and whilst we may put up a fight the outcome may well be the same. The last 3 games are ones you feel we should have picked up at least a couple of points. |
| News
Comment | Arsenal Delaying Signing Ramsdale Transfer Paperwork
at 23:05:05
............and if they don't sign someone? then what? transfer day goes and we are left with McCarthy and Bazunu and Lumley. I assumed Arsenal wanted rid of Ramsdale because he was surplus to requirements and was unlikely to get playing time with them.
|
| News
Comment | Southampton Turn Attentions To Arsenal Goalkeeper
at 16:21:35
This could all have been avoided if we had pulled our finger out as soon as the final whistle went at Wembley. It is not as if there were not keepers out there and available and for less than this.
I have not understood our recruitment strategy at all this summer. It has felt scatter gun in nature. |
| News
Comment | Sekou Mara Departs
at 12:53:42
I am not glad to see the back of him Nick. I wish him well and hope he progresses and becomes the good player I think is in there somewhere. Whether it was game time or what, but for some reason it hasn't quite happened with him at Saints and it is right for him and us that he is moving on. But, good luck to him. |
| News
Comment | Southampton At Newcastle United The Verdict
at 11:14:35
The one exception I take to the report is that in my view McCarthy should and has to take responsibility for that error. Whilst he may be expected to play the ball out I cannot believe that RM or any manager would say you do that irrespective of the threat. McCarthy is not a young green keeper, he is experienced and mature and he had time to assess the situation and the threat and how near we were to half time and the obvious and simplest thing to have done was to boot the ball up or off the pitch. He was to blame plain and simple. The thing is RM either gets a keeper that can play his way and is skilled and able to deliver that or accepts that McCarthy can't play that way and allows him to play the way he is best able to.
I agree with you on Brereton-Diaz. I don't like what he did and I am uncomfortable with it and hope it is not something he adopts. But it was the pot calling the kettle black when it comes to Newcastle and many teams. It was good to see that we could mix it though and not be bullied. We should had have at least a draw on Saturday - but McCarthy's error and our failure to offer a real goal threat (for all our approach play) let us down - but we cannot afford to be that generous or profligate. |
| News
Comment | Newcastle Winger Spotted At Southampton Airport
at 17:07:32
I have always said that Newcastle will release him to us after we have played them.
I like Fraser but I must be one of the few (or may be the only one) who doubts his ability to perform in a 90 minute game and at PL level. He was good at times, but there were moments when I forgot he was on the pitch. He was better as a sub. |
| News
Comment | Saints Confirm Arrival Of Japanese Midfielder And also His Loan To Goztepe
at 17:52:25
I am sorry Nick. I know I come from an age that probably no longer fits into modern football, though I do try not to be stuck in the past but I am a simply a one club person.
It's all about Southampton FC for me. I understand loans but I don't understand what we gain from purchasing and then immediately shipping out. I am not interested in clubs in Turkey or for that matter anywhere else and I don't want to help them particularly or be some sort of feeder club for them (I can partly understand being a feeder for more local clubs which may help local football or the community/economy).
For me, owners of my club should be focused on my club if they are not then they clearly don't completely invested in it (and I am not talking money here, I am talking about investing in it as what it means to Southampton the city, the people, the fans, the games etc).
I appreciate that you won't agree with me and many others won't but that is how I feel. |
| News
Comment | West Brom Striker On Southampton Radar
at 16:15:03
Following the West Brom away game in the playoffs and on my return to the hotel where I was parked there were many WBA fans and they stated that their biggest issue is that they did not have a real goalscorer that could change a game from a loss or a draw to a win. They did not rate this guy, though whether it was harsh I do not know. He does not sound like a step up for what we need for the PL. |
| News
Comment | Ryan Fraser Set to Train With U21 Squad As Newcastle Play Hard Ball
at 12:17:17
Though I have enjoyed Fraser since he joined us and he has made a difference, I doubt that this is as black and white (unintended pub) as we would perhaps like it to be. I doubt that Fraser is entirely blameless and we have seen it ourselves with some players. As someone has said, I would think Eddie Howe has bigger fish to fry than focus on the shenanigans around Fraser. I suspect (and here I am being a cynic) they would probably welcome nothing being sorted until after we have played Newcastle.
I am happy if Fraser joins us but if he is made permanent I hope he does not become difficult if he is not on the teamsheet as often as he thinks he should be. I am not saying Howe has been perfect as I have no idea but you cannot blame for Newcastle playing it hard.
|
| News
Comment | Ryan Fraser Agrees Terms And Waiting For Newcastle To Sanction The Move
at 13:00:14
I'll be delighted if the move is made permanent though it will be interesting to see if his attitude and enthusiasm will remain the same once made permanent.
I don't know what he did at Newcastle Utd to warrant such an extreme reaction but looking at the comments on the Chronicle Live they absolutely hate Fraser and don't have a single good word to say about him. |
| News
Comment | Southampton Keen On Signing Brighton keeper
at 12:10:21
Agree with your assessment. I do think we need another good decent keeper but there are better than this out there. I guess it depends on what we are willing or have available finance wise to pay. |
| News
Comment | Should Russell Martin Put Out Another Reserve Side For Leeds United Trip
at 12:16:29
Assuming RM knows which players he wants to play in the playoffs you would hope that they are aware and they are training together as a unit so that they are fired up and fully understanding as a group what is expected of them (irrespective of who we may face in the playoffs). If that is happening, then I would not risk them for the Leeds game.
As others have said, Leeds have the better goal difference to Ipswich so should there be a fluke Huddersfield win, Leeds could be promoted if they win. |
| News
Comment | Southampton V Stoke City The Preview
at 10:26:15
I think RM needs to play the players that he is going to use in the playoffs because he needs to get them playing as a group again and they the players need to know that they are the ones that he has faith in to give us the best chance. The selection of McCarthy over Lumley was a really poor decision and sent the wrong message - I wonder how much that affected the feeling in the changing room. The message that RM gave out after the Cardiff game told everyone that he thrown in the towel from an automatic promotion perspective and that showed at Leicester in the players performance - loads of possession but no intent.
I am going tomorrow, travelling down from Yorkshire. I appreciate Nick you giving a supportive message of the fans because tomorrow is sold out (whether everyone turns up is another matter - I have been in 2 minds despite buying the ticket but I will go in hope that we see a different attitude on the pitch). The Saints fans support has been great this season home and away (accepting our vocal support has not always been as good as it could be). We have been there and we have been there in numbers and how let down those that went to Leicester on Tuesday must have felt.
As usual the players trotted out the same old stuff after a bad defeat about letting us down and must do better. Heard it all before after a bad defeat and you usually get a brief response and then they lapse back. I just hope the players get it as well as I am not convinced they all do or have the same desire - after all, to some it won't matter whether we challenge for promotion or not because they will just play out their loans or move on anyway.
Overall I have enjoyed this season and it has been good to watch and be a part of. It has gone a bit sour since the Easter period and there is a sense that the manager and the team have lost their way and motivation. It will be interesting to see not just how we react tomorrow but in the playoffs - will we be lions or mice?
|
| News
Comment | Southampton At Cardiff City The Verdict
at 09:17:08
If we had converted just 50% of our chances in the game we would not have lost - plain and simple and that has been the case in other marginal games where failure to convert a reasonable percentage of our chances has meant drawing or losing when we shouldn't have. I am not sure that you can blame a manager, system, etc when so called professional strikers can't seem to find the net. |
| News
Comment | Southampton V Preston North End The Verdict
at 11:01:46
A good, professional and clinical performance.
There is not much if anything you can argue or be displeased with.
If I wanted to be picky, it would have been nice to have added to the three goals in the 2nd half and Preston were very poor (and the games coming up will give more of a test I am sure to McCarthy or Lumley) but as far as last night went, it was a job well done by all concerned - the players and the manager. If only we had been like that over Easter etc!!!!! |
| News
Comment | Brighton Alleged To Be Talking To Russell Martin To Replace Roberto De Zerbi
at 10:35:05
I agree with Nick that Brighton have a good recent record of taking on managers that are not necessarily riding that high with a stock value and making it work. It perhaps says more about their management structure higher up and the support they give to their managers and coaches. I am not sure we have had good leadership at Southampton since the sad demise of Marcus Liebherr and that has eroded our position in the league and our standing as a forward thinking club in football with some quite dreadful and very costly decisions over the seasons since Marcus passed away.
I don't think that the potential move of RM to Brighton is as fanciful as it may sound. With the right players and quality his vision could work. I appreciate it is not a popular thing to say at the moment, but I have not entirely given up with RM though equally I am not convinced by him. He has made some bad errors of judgement of late and his stubbornness and unwillingness to see it or apply tactics that work in games is worrying and costly but then I was not complaining when we went on that unbeaten run and my expectations for this season at the start of it were quite low because last season the team and the squad were completely demoralised and that was going to take time to turn it around.
|
| News
Comment | Sit Back, Wait, Watch And Hope Is All Southampton Can Do This Weekend
at 11:48:16
Like you, I don't worry about it Nick. It will be what it will be. We can't control what we are not in control of. Whatever the outcome, by and large (there is the odd exception) I have enjoyed this season and the championship.
I would slightly argue that the suggested harsh programme may end our automatic promotion hopes. I think you can add in the start of the season and the recent wobble and I think most Saints fans expect that the play off's is our most realistic outcome. |
| | A1079
|
Site Scores| Forum Votes: | 322 | | Comment Votes: | 1440 | | Prediction League: | 0 | | TOTAL: | 1762 |
|
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.