By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions. We in turn value your personal details in accordance with our Privacy Policy.
Please log in or register. Registered visitors get fewer ads.
So the poll was done by a pro indy group, how do we know the people asked were a fair and representtative example of Welsh people? You can hardly base anything on asking 1000 people.
I do find it ironic that 2 big indy supporters don't even live in Wales.
I guess who/where we are ruled by comes down to opinions. To me the UK is ruled from Westminster by our elected MP's with some powers devolved to our own minor governments.
Should wales be an independent country ? on 17:51 - Sep 3 by CwmafanJack
Your just down the road from me, living in ballyroan just outside portlaoise atm, be good to meet up for a match or two when the seasons up and running again. Is there many jacks out this way?
Went to a wedding in portlaoise, Johnny Sexton was there. That church at the end of the village with a green and pub opposite.
Had a couple of pints of the black stuff in that old bar on the left as you go up from the church, the one where the lads where white coats and they have groceries on shelves behind the bar
I think it was Morrisey’s bar
[Post edited 3 Sep 2020 20:19]
Number 1 team in Wales
0
Should wales be an independent country ? on 20:15 - Sep 3 with 1492 views
Should wales be an independent country ? on 18:31 - Sep 3 by Catullus
So the poll was done by a pro indy group, how do we know the people asked were a fair and representtative example of Welsh people? You can hardly base anything on asking 1000 people.
I do find it ironic that 2 big indy supporters don't even live in Wales.
I guess who/where we are ruled by comes down to opinions. To me the UK is ruled from Westminster by our elected MP's with some powers devolved to our own minor governments.
I do live in wales, cwmafan to be precise just back and forth to Ireland. Indy supporters are spread far and wide and every corner of wales. Matter of time before independence.
Should wales be an independent country ? on 09:58 - Sep 7 by Best_loser
55 no 44 yes percent
Closer than I expected
Yes, closerthsn I expected too but only 38 votes cast so hardly indicative. I still say do it, I might be...well I am pro union but if we have the debate, do it properly AND allow all options onto the ballot. Have the true facts not the fake news we had from both sides during brexit and then put it into the rules that we all agree this is a once in a (insert whatever time period we can agree on) and get it done.
I'm all for democracy but all sides need to respect the result.
Should wales be an independent country ? on 17:44 - Sep 7 by felixstowe_jack
Does that mean 58% of labour voters would not vote for independence?
Those 42%, is that where the pollsters remove people who say don't know or who wouldn't vote?
Anyway that 42% (of all Labour voters at last GE) comes to 266,000 then if you add in PC voters at 154,000 that's 420,000. Compare that to the remaining Labour plus theTory vote which is 932,000.
It still depends on how genuine that 42% is though.
I said about a year ago on here that Wales would be independent within 15 years. I was laughed at. I still think I am right.
Swansea Indepenent Poster Of The Year 2021. Dr P / Mart66 / Roathie / Parlay / E20/ Duffle was 2nd, but he is deluded and thinks in his little twisted brain that he won. Poor sod. We let him win this year, as he has cried for a whole year. His 14 usernames, bless his cotton socks.
Should wales be an independent country ? on 22:24 - Sep 7 by builthjack
I said about a year ago on here that Wales would be independent within 15 years. I was laughed at. I still think I am right.
You are right.
Why would any welsh person want to be stuck on Brexidiot island with Gove, Mogg, and Johnson..? They sneer, mock and care absolutely nothing for Wales.
Beware of the Risen People
0
Should wales be an independent country ? on 23:30 - Sep 7 with 1343 views
Should wales be an independent country ? on 17:56 - Sep 7 by Catullus
Those 42%, is that where the pollsters remove people who say don't know or who wouldn't vote?
Anyway that 42% (of all Labour voters at last GE) comes to 266,000 then if you add in PC voters at 154,000 that's 420,000. Compare that to the remaining Labour plus theTory vote which is 932,000.
It still depends on how genuine that 42% is though.
Its all about momentum and age group voting.
Its a staggering increase in support for Indy in Wales since 2016. Its also staggering that the young (post war) generations are markedly more pro Indy, than the retirement age groups. Once that ‘flows through’ naturally then the balance flips to hugely pro Indy.
This is all before any campaigning.
Scotland leaving will greatly encourage Wales in joining the other Celtic indy nations. Defo within 15 years.
Get on the Indy bus and enjoy the ride .... â¤ï¸ðŸ´ó §ó ¢ó ·ó ¬ó ³ó ¿
Beware of the Risen People
0
Should wales be an independent country ? (n/t) on 23:33 - Sep 7 with 1342 views
Should wales be an independent country ? on 23:20 - Sep 7 by Kilkennyjack
You are right.
Why would any welsh person want to be stuck on Brexidiot island with Gove, Mogg, and Johnson..? They sneer, mock and care absolutely nothing for Wales.
Why would any sensible Welshman want to be governed by a coalition of labour and plaid. They have run the Welsh Assembly for the 20 years and life in Wales actually getting worse and waiting lists in the welsh NHS getting longer despite vast subsidies from the UK government.
Should wales be an independent country ? on 23:30 - Sep 7 by Kilkennyjack
Its all about momentum and age group voting.
Its a staggering increase in support for Indy in Wales since 2016. Its also staggering that the young (post war) generations are markedly more pro Indy, than the retirement age groups. Once that ‘flows through’ naturally then the balance flips to hugely pro Indy.
This is all before any campaigning.
Scotland leaving will greatly encourage Wales in joining the other Celtic indy nations. Defo within 15 years.
Get on the Indy bus and enjoy the ride .... â¤ï¸ðŸ´ó §ó ¢ó ·ó ¬ó ³ó ¿
The bus to poverty without the UK subsidy for the fares.
Should wales be an independent country ? on 23:30 - Sep 7 by Kilkennyjack
Its all about momentum and age group voting.
Its a staggering increase in support for Indy in Wales since 2016. Its also staggering that the young (post war) generations are markedly more pro Indy, than the retirement age groups. Once that ‘flows through’ naturally then the balance flips to hugely pro Indy.
This is all before any campaigning.
Scotland leaving will greatly encourage Wales in joining the other Celtic indy nations. Defo within 15 years.
Get on the Indy bus and enjoy the ride .... â¤ï¸ðŸ´ó §ó ¢ó ·ó ¬ó ³ó ¿
IF Scotland leaves and IF scotland is a success it will encourage other Indy supporters. Time will tell.
What if Scotland leave and it's a disaster?
You keep going on about brexit being a disaster but what we're seeing now is because of the pandemic. We have no way of knowing how things would have turned out if Covid hadn't hit. Of course when we come through the pandemic, however long that takes, and the UK turns out to be doing quit well, what will you say?
Should wales be an independent country ? on 11:27 - Sep 8 by Catullus
IF Scotland leaves and IF scotland is a success it will encourage other Indy supporters. Time will tell.
What if Scotland leave and it's a disaster?
You keep going on about brexit being a disaster but what we're seeing now is because of the pandemic. We have no way of knowing how things would have turned out if Covid hadn't hit. Of course when we come through the pandemic, however long that takes, and the UK turns out to be doing quit well, what will you say?
Experts are generally a good thing.
For a brain operation would you prefer a qualified surgeon, or Keith from down the pub ?
All the experts say Brexit is shite. Keith from down the pub says Brexit is good.
Who do you believe ?
Small countries are rich counties in Europe. Small countries with lots of oil are going to be mega rich. I think Scotland will be just fine.
Its like considering staying in an abusive relationship because if you leave it could get even worse. Its the wrong reason to stay.
Beware of the Risen People
0
Should wales be an independent country ? on 15:05 - Sep 8 with 1268 views
Should wales be an independent country ? on 14:53 - Sep 8 by Kilkennyjack
Experts are generally a good thing.
For a brain operation would you prefer a qualified surgeon, or Keith from down the pub ?
All the experts say Brexit is shite. Keith from down the pub says Brexit is good.
Who do you believe ?
Small countries are rich counties in Europe. Small countries with lots of oil are going to be mega rich. I think Scotland will be just fine.
Its like considering staying in an abusive relationship because if you leave it could get even worse. Its the wrong reason to stay.
Scotland runs a huge fiscal deficit and are subsidised by the uk government by the amount of £3500 per person per year.
What currency will they use when independence is gain. They will have to use the euro if the reapply to join the EU. The EU is unlikely to accept a country that does not meet it's fiscal rules. They made that mistake with Greece.
The UK will always be stronger together even though England would be far better off without the other 3 countries which all need subsidies from UK taxpayers.
Should wales be an independent country ? on 13:28 - Sep 3 by NotLoyal
A hundred years later the country has learned that taking up arms is not the way, may well have been relevant then to an extent, but not now. Too much to lose.
I was absolutely aghast by the very profound analysis/opinion of journalist Brian Rowan over ten years ago, and he ain't no mug, knows exactly what he is talking about with unique access to dissident Republican sources ! Privy to a lot of information.
He said that mainstream 'troops-out' Republicanism had finally got its wish to finally have troops off the streets, no roadblocks, watchtowers taken down, no intrusive helicopter flights, freedom to go about daily business unhindered etc. Great stuff peace!
The bit that really took me aback was the fact the 'dissidents' are desperate for a return of all the aforementioned, despite the fact many in the the Republican movement had previously fought, been imprisoned and killed to get the troops out anyhow.
Absolute tOssers not too dissimilar to all these extreme elements that we're all been discussing of late. People who do not want others to get on with their peaceful lives, having a gratuitous urge to divide society, desperately making up excuses just to create unnecessary conflict.
[Post edited 8 Sep 2020 19:47]
Argus!
0
Should wales be an independent country ? on 19:58 - Sep 8 with 1187 views
Should wales be an independent country ? on 14:53 - Sep 8 by Kilkennyjack
Experts are generally a good thing.
For a brain operation would you prefer a qualified surgeon, or Keith from down the pub ?
All the experts say Brexit is shite. Keith from down the pub says Brexit is good.
Who do you believe ?
Small countries are rich counties in Europe. Small countries with lots of oil are going to be mega rich. I think Scotland will be just fine.
Its like considering staying in an abusive relationship because if you leave it could get even worse. Its the wrong reason to stay.
Maybe you hadn't noticed but in the modern world that's just around the corner, fossil fuels are yesr=terdays news.
Experts are great, they know lots of important stuff but I haven't met, seen on tv or read about an expert who can accurately predict what the world will look like in 20 years.
There are experts out there who say indy will be a disaster for Scotland, you don't believe them, do you? You believe Adam Price when he says indy will be great but he borrowed tons of money, well took a grant from the Senedd for a business that went bust, he didn't see that coming and he was running that show. You are quite willing to believe these non experts about indy, people who never held high office nor managed a succesful business.
Should wales be an independent country ? on 19:58 - Sep 8 by Catullus
Maybe you hadn't noticed but in the modern world that's just around the corner, fossil fuels are yesr=terdays news.
Experts are great, they know lots of important stuff but I haven't met, seen on tv or read about an expert who can accurately predict what the world will look like in 20 years.
There are experts out there who say indy will be a disaster for Scotland, you don't believe them, do you? You believe Adam Price when he says indy will be great but he borrowed tons of money, well took a grant from the Senedd for a business that went bust, he didn't see that coming and he was running that show. You are quite willing to believe these non experts about indy, people who never held high office nor managed a succesful business.
The fact that the current lot in the Welsh Government seem more than happy for Wales to have a backward (HTV Wales reporting) 1960's transport system says a lot. Apparently even refused Westminster money to help sort some of the problem out.
The fact the opposition are still rather silent about the stagnation (e.g relief road scrapped and no alternative forthcoming) is frightening! Transport infrastructure is vital. That lot would be the same lot in charge in an independent Wales, what hope hey? Talk about alarm bells ringing?
Argus!
0
Should wales be an independent country ? on 20:20 - Sep 8 with 1175 views
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
