| I hope the WAG is not strong armed to take this waste of time 15:21 - Sep 17 with 1304 views | ReslovenSwan1 |
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/ce8ddeeklxko.amp
No one really wants these games. They are a jolly for the ruling elite and funded by the ratepayers.
Unless it comes to Swansea and a tram line to Mumbles and redevelopment of St Helens part of the deal. Levelling up and all that |  |
| Wise sage since Toshack era |
| |  |
| I hope the WAG is not strong armed to take this waste of time on 15:53 - Sep 17 with 1267 views | ReslovenSwan1 |
UK govt and Birmingham council stumped up a cool £1 billion for Birmingham. Time for ratepayers to take charge and put the reigns on the athletics 'luvies' like Seb Coe and his well funded chums.
UK can do sports events. Everything else is beyond us it seems . | |
| Wise sage since Toshack era |
| |
| I hope the WAG is not strong armed to take this waste of time on 16:36 - Sep 17 with 1224 views | Whiterockin |
Wales has nowhere near the required sports facilities, infrastructure or hotels to host a commonwealth games. I have been to several Commonwealths and Olympics and believe me you don't understand the scale unless you are there. |  | | |
| I hope the WAG is not strong armed to take this waste of time on 17:07 - Sep 17 with 1186 views | Wingstandwood |
| I hope the WAG is not strong armed to take this waste of time on 16:36 - Sep 17 by Whiterockin |
Wales has nowhere near the required sports facilities, infrastructure or hotels to host a commonwealth games. I have been to several Commonwealths and Olympics and believe me you don't understand the scale unless you are there. |
I posted on here a while back saying that I would not be surprised in the slightest if those despicable clowns in Cardiff Bay, have intention(s) set upon having a future Commonwealth Games in Cardiff.
The very fact that they were desperate to have an Olympic sized swimming pool raised suspicion that they were paving the way.
A major concern for myself was the prospect of economically partitioned Wales being dragged even deeper into the gutter, because of insane vanity-project expenditure that would starve the rest of (outside of Cardiff) Wales with appalling consequences !
You have given me some comfort knowing that Wales has a lesser chance of winning a bid at this present moment of time!!!! |  |
| |
| I hope the WAG is not strong armed to take this waste of time on 17:29 - Sep 17 with 1146 views | Whiterockin |
| I hope the WAG is not strong armed to take this waste of time on 17:07 - Sep 17 by Wingstandwood |
I posted on here a while back saying that I would not be surprised in the slightest if those despicable clowns in Cardiff Bay, have intention(s) set upon having a future Commonwealth Games in Cardiff.
The very fact that they were desperate to have an Olympic sized swimming pool raised suspicion that they were paving the way.
A major concern for myself was the prospect of economically partitioned Wales being dragged even deeper into the gutter, because of insane vanity-project expenditure that would starve the rest of (outside of Cardiff) Wales with appalling consequences !
You have given me some comfort knowing that Wales has a lesser chance of winning a bid at this present moment of time!!!! |
Top quality swimmers need to train in a 50M pool, there is a massive difference between training there and a 25M pool. What we have is fine for small events but a Commonwealths never, we just wouldn't get enough spectators in never mind the broadcasting requirements. | | | |
| I hope the WAG is not strong armed to take this waste of time on 23:38 - Sep 17 with 1031 views | majorraglan |
| I hope the WAG is not strong armed to take this waste of time on 17:07 - Sep 17 by Wingstandwood |
I posted on here a while back saying that I would not be surprised in the slightest if those despicable clowns in Cardiff Bay, have intention(s) set upon having a future Commonwealth Games in Cardiff.
The very fact that they were desperate to have an Olympic sized swimming pool raised suspicion that they were paving the way.
A major concern for myself was the prospect of economically partitioned Wales being dragged even deeper into the gutter, because of insane vanity-project expenditure that would starve the rest of (outside of Cardiff) Wales with appalling consequences !
You have given me some comfort knowing that Wales has a lesser chance of winning a bid at this present moment of time!!!! |
You clearly don’t know a great deal about aquatic sport. As has been said a 50m pool is essential for aspiring swimmers to train in.
The Cardiff pool is the only Olympic size pool in Wales, we also have the 50m pool in Swansea (not Olympic size) but both are miles away from being international or Commonwealth Games standard. If WG were thinking of bringing the CG’s here, we’d have to have a brand new purpose built facility with capacity of around 2,000 spectators which could be increased up to 5,000 for the games. Cardiff has capacity for 1,000 spectators and Swansea for 1,200, but there’s no scope to increase the numbers without bulldozing the existing facilities.
Looking at the other facilities, we also need a new athletics stadium or a major redevelopment at Leckwith which would then become a white elephant. Can’t see it ever happening without Westminster pumping in a couple of billion. |  | | |
| I hope the WAG is not strong armed to take this waste of time on 00:32 - Sep 18 with 1013 views | Wingstandwood |
| I hope the WAG is not strong armed to take this waste of time on 23:38 - Sep 17 by majorraglan |
You clearly don’t know a great deal about aquatic sport. As has been said a 50m pool is essential for aspiring swimmers to train in.
The Cardiff pool is the only Olympic size pool in Wales, we also have the 50m pool in Swansea (not Olympic size) but both are miles away from being international or Commonwealth Games standard. If WG were thinking of bringing the CG’s here, we’d have to have a brand new purpose built facility with capacity of around 2,000 spectators which could be increased up to 5,000 for the games. Cardiff has capacity for 1,000 spectators and Swansea for 1,200, but there’s no scope to increase the numbers without bulldozing the existing facilities.
Looking at the other facilities, we also need a new athletics stadium or a major redevelopment at Leckwith which would then become a white elephant. Can’t see it ever happening without Westminster pumping in a couple of billion. |
No scope?
QUOTE: "Chris Jenkins, executive director of the Commonwealth Games Council for Wales, said keeping the costs down is important.
"We've got a lot of venues in Cardiff and around South Wales we can modify and use in any bid," he said.
Tell me does Cardiff have a large swimming pool that is enclosed within a building that has been built with structural steel?
 | |
| |
| I hope the WAG is not strong armed to take this waste of time on 07:18 - Sep 18 with 960 views | majorraglan |
| I hope the WAG is not strong armed to take this waste of time on 00:32 - Sep 18 by Wingstandwood |
No scope?
QUOTE: "Chris Jenkins, executive director of the Commonwealth Games Council for Wales, said keeping the costs down is important.
"We've got a lot of venues in Cardiff and around South Wales we can modify and use in any bid," he said.
Tell me does Cardiff have a large swimming pool that is enclosed within a building that has been built with structural steel?
|
He can say what he likes, but I’ve been involved in aquatic sports for 17 years and can tell you that the Cardiff pool isn’t up to hosting a major event like that without a complete rebuild. | | | |
| I hope the WAG is not strong armed to take this waste of time on 07:33 - Sep 18 with 955 views | majorraglan |
| I hope the WAG is not strong armed to take this waste of time on 00:32 - Sep 18 by Wingstandwood |
No scope?
QUOTE: "Chris Jenkins, executive director of the Commonwealth Games Council for Wales, said keeping the costs down is important.
"We've got a lot of venues in Cardiff and around South Wales we can modify and use in any bid," he said.
Tell me does Cardiff have a large swimming pool that is enclosed within a building that has been built with structural steel?
|
He can say what he likes, but I’ve been involved in aquatic sports for 17 years and can tell you that the Cardiff pool isn’t up to hosting a major event like that without a complete rebuild. | | | |
Login to get fewer ads
| I hope the WAG is not strong armed to take this waste of time on 07:53 - Sep 18 with 949 views | Scotia |
WG have previously undertaken a feasibility study for a bid for the games which ruled out a bid in the short term.
I believe the games are funded by at least an 80% contribution from Westminster, more for Glasgow 26. The amount of money that WG wastes on things like a Cardiff tram may well be better spent improving sporting facilities across a wider area.
I know that WG wanted the Swansea arena to be far larger (and contribute towards the cost) to host large sporting events but Swansea Council refused.
That's not to say the game are economically viable at all in the long term though. | | | |
| I hope the WAG is not strong armed to take this waste of time on 08:14 - Sep 18 with 936 views | Dr_Winston |
| I hope the WAG is not strong armed to take this waste of time on 07:53 - Sep 18 by Scotia |
WG have previously undertaken a feasibility study for a bid for the games which ruled out a bid in the short term.
I believe the games are funded by at least an 80% contribution from Westminster, more for Glasgow 26. The amount of money that WG wastes on things like a Cardiff tram may well be better spent improving sporting facilities across a wider area.
I know that WG wanted the Swansea arena to be far larger (and contribute towards the cost) to host large sporting events but Swansea Council refused.
That's not to say the game are economically viable at all in the long term though. |
Swansea Arena could possibly have been bigger (and y'know, an actual arena instead of just a big theatre) but they wouldn't have been able to put it where it is.
Always made more sense to me in the long run to have redeveloped the Civic Centre site for it. Loads more room. |  |
| Pain or damage don't end the world. Or despair, or f*cking beatings. The world ends when you're dead. Until then, you got more punishment in store. Stand it like a man... and give some back. |
| |
| I hope the WAG is not strong armed to take this waste of time on 08:33 - Sep 18 with 929 views | Whiterockin |
On of the biggest problems would be we don't have enough hotel rooms in SE Wales to accommodate visitors and officials, the athletes could use student villages. Before anyone says Bristol is only 40 miles away, have they ever travelled when there is a big event in Cardiff. The infrastructure in SE Wales is just not good enough to support a games. | | | |
| I hope the WAG is not strong armed to take this waste of time on 09:02 - Sep 18 with 903 views | Scotia |
| I hope the WAG is not strong armed to take this waste of time on 08:14 - Sep 18 by Dr_Winston |
Swansea Arena could possibly have been bigger (and y'know, an actual arena instead of just a big theatre) but they wouldn't have been able to put it where it is.
Always made more sense to me in the long run to have redeveloped the Civic Centre site for it. Loads more room. |
The suggestion was to turn it 90 degrees and it take the place of the car park - WG were happy to provide funding and increase the size of the car park on the opposite side of the road that hasn't been finished.
Swansea turned it down, I'm in two minds if that was a goood or bad idea.
Swansea Council think the Civic Centre site is prime real estate for a very expensive hotel, unfirtunately there's been no interest in it. | | | |
| I hope the WAG is not strong armed to take this waste of time on 11:13 - Sep 19 with 748 views | ReslovenSwan1 |
There is a logic that one off events need fans. New thinking is required to keep cost down. An out door pool with temporary stands or big screen viewing areas.
A 5000 hall for one event is bonkers. Built a temporary fans zone.
All future games should not be allowed in the capital and centre of government. | |
| Wise sage since Toshack era |
| |
| I hope the WAG is not strong armed to take this waste of time on 13:50 - Sep 20 with 585 views | ReslovenSwan1 |
| I hope the WAG is not strong armed to take this waste of time on 08:33 - Sep 18 by Whiterockin |
On of the biggest problems would be we don't have enough hotel rooms in SE Wales to accommodate visitors and officials, the athletes could use student villages. Before anyone says Bristol is only 40 miles away, have they ever travelled when there is a big event in Cardiff. The infrastructure in SE Wales is just not good enough to support a games. |
Champion's League went to Cardiff. The Commonwealth games needs to be a smaller niche event with good TV coverage.
It has been a colonial event because Africa and Caribbean nations cannot afford it. It should be linked to UK aid budget.
The 50m pool should be outdoors in Namibia with new facilities.
The lavish spending is to satisfy the ruling elite paid for by the tax payer. Avoidance of corruption should be a major feature.
Swansea can hold a niche games. Spectators are optional. Small halls with few fans and a central communication hub in a pavilion with bigg screen.
Swimming is not a huge spectator sport. Huge halls of one show a year makes no sense. | |
| Wise sage since Toshack era |
| |
| I hope the WAG is not strong armed to take this waste of time on 18:05 - Sep 20 with 535 views | SullutaCreturned |
| I hope the WAG is not strong armed to take this waste of time on 13:50 - Sep 20 by ReslovenSwan1 |
Champion's League went to Cardiff. The Commonwealth games needs to be a smaller niche event with good TV coverage.
It has been a colonial event because Africa and Caribbean nations cannot afford it. It should be linked to UK aid budget.
The 50m pool should be outdoors in Namibia with new facilities.
The lavish spending is to satisfy the ruling elite paid for by the tax payer. Avoidance of corruption should be a major feature.
Swansea can hold a niche games. Spectators are optional. Small halls with few fans and a central communication hub in a pavilion with bigg screen.
Swimming is not a huge spectator sport. Huge halls of one show a year makes no sense. |
Champions league only requires one venue for the final and Cardiff can more than cope with the crowd at the Principality.
Why should the aid budget be spent on a frippery? We waste enough money on fripperies, we are short of money so we shouldn't be wasting it on vanity projects.
The lavish spending is exacty the problem. Peple are dying, people are in pverty so spend millions nay billions on a showy sports event that leaves the hosts with debt, no..NO.
The Commnwealth games by definition cannot be niche. There are 56 members states with thousands of athletes/sports people wanting to take art. | | | |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
