| Swansea City already sourcing new players for the January transfer window on 11:06 - Oct 4 with 2621 views | Chief |
Is is telling that there's no mention of the guy from Brentford in there? Who was the recruitment guru? |  |
|  |
| Swansea City already sourcing new players for the January transfer window on 11:11 - Oct 4 with 2615 views | Chief |
Apologies, Scott I'm referring to. | |
| |
| Swansea City already sourcing new players for the January transfer window on 12:14 - Oct 4 with 2553 views | AustinIsOurHero |
Of the strikers we have already:
Piroe drops too deep as he gets no service
Obafemi is injured more often than not
Whittaker can't seem to get minutes
Cullen isn't good enough.
We need a 10 more than we need more strikers. Getting Obafemi fit would help too. |  |
| |
| Swansea City already sourcing new players for the January transfer window on 12:29 - Oct 4 with 2535 views | KeithHaynes |
| Swansea City already sourcing new players for the January transfer window on 11:11 - Oct 4 by Chief |
Apologies, Scott I'm referring to. |
Mark Allen seems to have taken over. He is now sporting director.
Scott is more ‘recruitment’ and by that I assume at a level outside of the first team, at least the majority of the time. |  |
| |
| Swansea City already sourcing new players for the January transfer window on 12:34 - Oct 4 with 2527 views | Catullus |
| Swansea City already sourcing new players for the January transfer window on 12:14 - Oct 4 by AustinIsOurHero |
Of the strikers we have already:
Piroe drops too deep as he gets no service
Obafemi is injured more often than not
Whittaker can't seem to get minutes
Cullen isn't good enough.
We need a 10 more than we need more strikers. Getting Obafemi fit would help too. |
Agree about Piroe, lets hope Oba can get and stay fit. Agree about the other two as well.
I thik Paterson is doing ok and Ntcham can be a 10 as well. In fact, if I cou;d swap Cullen and Whittaker for another striker, I would but I think we're alright at 10. The problem there is we play to CAM's where I think one with 2 strikers would work better.
I'm rattling the same sabre again but with 2 strikers we looked far more dangerous, with just Piroe we look a bit toothless. The way our so called wing backs are pushed up we might as well get wingers in and the middle of the park can look a bit congested. Why not go 3-4-1-2 or even 3-2-3-2? |  |
| |
| Swansea City already sourcing new players for the January transfer window on 12:53 - Oct 4 with 2505 views | Chief |
| Swansea City already sourcing new players for the January transfer window on 12:29 - Oct 4 by KeithHaynes |
Mark Allen seems to have taken over. He is now sporting director.
Scott is more ‘recruitment’ and by that I assume at a level outside of the first team, at least the majority of the time. |
So he's been demoted to signing kids for the u23s? | |
| |
| Swansea City already sourcing new players for the January transfer window on 13:19 - Oct 4 with 2474 views | A_Fans_Dad |
Sourcing and "paying for" are two completely different things. | | | |
| Swansea City already sourcing new players for the January transfer window on 13:33 - Oct 4 with 2470 views | jasper_T |
| Swansea City already sourcing new players for the January transfer window on 12:29 - Oct 4 by KeithHaynes |
Mark Allen seems to have taken over. He is now sporting director.
Scott is more ‘recruitment’ and by that I assume at a level outside of the first team, at least the majority of the time. |
The way I understand it Scott was in charge of senior recruitment and we hired help for him over the summer (Lee Maybury ex-Stoke) while others came in to assist u23s and below (Derek Langley ex-Man Utd, Neil Roberts). It's not a one-man job. As Sporting Director Mark Allen will be at the head of the table rather than the only guy in the room, just as he was for the batch of academy and u23s recruits he oversaw.
If he is the only man in the room that would be concerning. | | | |
Login to get fewer ads
| Swansea City already sourcing new players for the January transfer window on 14:22 - Oct 4 with 2395 views | onehunglow |
| Swansea City already sourcing new players for the January transfer window on 12:34 - Oct 4 by Catullus |
Agree about Piroe, lets hope Oba can get and stay fit. Agree about the other two as well.
I thik Paterson is doing ok and Ntcham can be a 10 as well. In fact, if I cou;d swap Cullen and Whittaker for another striker, I would but I think we're alright at 10. The problem there is we play to CAM's where I think one with 2 strikers would work better.
I'm rattling the same sabre again but with 2 strikers we looked far more dangerous, with just Piroe we look a bit toothless. The way our so called wing backs are pushed up we might as well get wingers in and the middle of the park can look a bit congested. Why not go 3-4-1-2 or even 3-2-3-2? |
Russ selects the team. New striker is futile especially when he is taken off.
Cullen is no striker in football terms | |
| |
| Swansea City already sourcing new players for the January transfer window on 16:09 - Oct 4 with 2362 views | ReslovenSwan1 |
| Swansea City already sourcing new players for the January transfer window on 13:33 - Oct 4 by jasper_T |
The way I understand it Scott was in charge of senior recruitment and we hired help for him over the summer (Lee Maybury ex-Stoke) while others came in to assist u23s and below (Derek Langley ex-Man Utd, Neil Roberts). It's not a one-man job. As Sporting Director Mark Allen will be at the head of the table rather than the only guy in the room, just as he was for the batch of academy and u23s recruits he oversaw.
If he is the only man in the room that would be concerning. |
The academy recruits are not performing too well to date. The U18 in particular do seem to improve as the season develops if the past is anything to go by. |  |
| Wise sage since Toshack era |
| |
| Swansea City already sourcing new players for the January transfer window on 17:22 - Oct 4 with 2320 views | ReslovenSwan1 |
| Swansea City already sourcing new players for the January transfer window on 12:53 - Oct 4 by Chief |
So he's been demoted to signing kids for the u23s? |
Why do you say that? Allen is the chief of all football operations and takes a view of both Scott and Martin. You like to think if Scott suggested hypothetically Barry McKay like Potters man did he would veto it or kick the idea into the long grass. (as most fans would having seen his characteristics).
For example Potter spent £2m on Asoro a speedster. He already had a much better player in the academy he was not aware of in Dan James. Allen would be aware of the whole picture and advised Potter of this player. £3.5m wasted then and there.
Scott carries on as normal I would imagine and simply answers to Allen not Winter. It is a team. I suspect Cooper did not like this team set up and wanted full control of recruitment. This may explain his "not liking the direction the club is moving in" comment. [Post edited 4 Oct 2021 17:24]
| |
| Wise sage since Toshack era |
| |
| Swansea City already sourcing new players for the January transfer window on 17:31 - Oct 4 with 2304 views | Chief |
| Swansea City already sourcing new players for the January transfer window on 17:22 - Oct 4 by ReslovenSwan1 |
Why do you say that? Allen is the chief of all football operations and takes a view of both Scott and Martin. You like to think if Scott suggested hypothetically Barry McKay like Potters man did he would veto it or kick the idea into the long grass. (as most fans would having seen his characteristics).
For example Potter spent £2m on Asoro a speedster. He already had a much better player in the academy he was not aware of in Dan James. Allen would be aware of the whole picture and advised Potter of this player. £3.5m wasted then and there.
Scott carries on as normal I would imagine and simply answers to Allen not Winter. It is a team. I suspect Cooper did not like this team set up and wanted full control of recruitment. This may explain his "not liking the direction the club is moving in" comment. [Post edited 4 Oct 2021 17:24]
|
Because Keith stated that Scott is responsible from recruitment outside of the first team. What am I to deduce from that? He's the chief scout for the veterans side? | |
| |
| Swansea City already sourcing new players for the January transfer window on 17:54 - Oct 4 with 2275 views | ReslovenSwan1 |
| Swansea City already sourcing new players for the January transfer window on 17:31 - Oct 4 by Chief |
Because Keith stated that Scott is responsible from recruitment outside of the first team. What am I to deduce from that? He's the chief scout for the veterans side? |
You are well known for misquoting people and making incorrect conclusions despite clarifications. Even then you stick to them for some strange reason I cannot explain.
Keith for some reason "assumed " Scott would be focused on underage groups. This a is almost certainly a false assumption. If true Scott would be off quicker than Tate if that was the case. Allen his head of all football such as recruitment , analysis, medical, academy etc. I explained to you how useful that would have been when Potter arrived.
There is no evidence whatsoever that Scott's job has changed. He simply answers to Allen not Winter. Allen takes his recommendations and works them through with Martin. He clearly does have input (Nticham) as does Scott (Piroe and Walsh) and Martin (Downes).
Its a team effort. Martin and Allen will have to "give and take". If Martin wanted Barry McKay hypothetically for example Allen would say to Martin "Trust me on this one I've heard bad reports on his lack of physicality".
One likes to think the incident with Peterson will no longer cause friction. | |
| Wise sage since Toshack era |
| |
| Swansea City already sourcing new players for the January transfer window on 19:57 - Oct 4 with 2163 views | Chief |
| Swansea City already sourcing new players for the January transfer window on 17:54 - Oct 4 by ReslovenSwan1 |
You are well known for misquoting people and making incorrect conclusions despite clarifications. Even then you stick to them for some strange reason I cannot explain.
Keith for some reason "assumed " Scott would be focused on underage groups. This a is almost certainly a false assumption. If true Scott would be off quicker than Tate if that was the case. Allen his head of all football such as recruitment , analysis, medical, academy etc. I explained to you how useful that would have been when Potter arrived.
There is no evidence whatsoever that Scott's job has changed. He simply answers to Allen not Winter. Allen takes his recommendations and works them through with Martin. He clearly does have input (Nticham) as does Scott (Piroe and Walsh) and Martin (Downes).
Its a team effort. Martin and Allen will have to "give and take". If Martin wanted Barry McKay hypothetically for example Allen would say to Martin "Trust me on this one I've heard bad reports on his lack of physicality".
One likes to think the incident with Peterson will no longer cause friction. |
Please point to what I've misquoted then? You are notorious for making things up and this is another example.
You also have penchant for contradictions and this post is no different. You start off saying I misquoted Keith, then you go onto say the exactly same thing as I did - that Keith stated that Scott is now looking after youth recruitment.
Bizarre post.
Yes I'd like to think that Winter wouldn't inform the manager on a matchday by text that one his substitutes had been sold. Hopefully he's learnt his lesson. | |
| |
| Swansea City already sourcing new players for the January transfer window on 23:22 - Oct 4 with 2051 views | ReslovenSwan1 |
| Swansea City already sourcing new players for the January transfer window on 19:57 - Oct 4 by Chief |
Please point to what I've misquoted then? You are notorious for making things up and this is another example.
You also have penchant for contradictions and this post is no different. You start off saying I misquoted Keith, then you go onto say the exactly same thing as I did - that Keith stated that Scott is now looking after youth recruitment.
Bizarre post.
Yes I'd like to think that Winter wouldn't inform the manager on a matchday by text that one his substitutes had been sold. Hopefully he's learnt his lesson. |
Keith 'assumed' Scott would be looking after underage age players. He is a journalist or at least a publisher of information. If he said it with certainty like you suggest, it would be based on a source and corroborated. "Assumed" is a big word you need to take note of.
Scott almost certainly is not looking exclusively at youth development. I watched the Allen interview and he is not the recruitment chief, these are two different roles. This does not mean Allen is forbidden from using his contacts. It is a team effort.
You misquoted Keith like you misquote me on a regular basis. It seems to be you modus operand-um that had one poster pulling his hair out.
Winter is the boss and do what he thinks is right. Peterson was going and there was no point having a chat about it. Cooper created the problem and Winter solved it. | |
| Wise sage since Toshack era |
| |
| Swansea City already sourcing new players for the January transfer window on 01:25 - Oct 5 with 2026 views | KeithHaynes |
| Swansea City already sourcing new players for the January transfer window on 13:33 - Oct 4 by jasper_T |
The way I understand it Scott was in charge of senior recruitment and we hired help for him over the summer (Lee Maybury ex-Stoke) while others came in to assist u23s and below (Derek Langley ex-Man Utd, Neil Roberts). It's not a one-man job. As Sporting Director Mark Allen will be at the head of the table rather than the only guy in the room, just as he was for the batch of academy and u23s recruits he oversaw.
If he is the only man in the room that would be concerning. |
I think the club needs to clarify exactly what is the situation, it feels slightly top heavy now with Maybury ( is he now part time ? ) I believe Langley and Roberts may well be.
The main issue club have made it quite clear Allen is the main recruiter, however it goes without saying with Scott and four or so others in certain capacities there should be regular input.
Let’s not forget Julian Winter who hold the purse strings. | |
| |
| Swansea City already sourcing new players for the January transfer window on 01:28 - Oct 5 with 2019 views | KeithHaynes |
| Swansea City already sourcing new players for the January transfer window on 12:53 - Oct 4 by Chief |
So he's been demoted to signing kids for the u23s? |
I didn’t say that.
Recruitment isn’t just players though. | |
| |
| Swansea City already sourcing new players for the January transfer window on 03:55 - Oct 5 with 2000 views | jasper_T |
| Swansea City already sourcing new players for the January transfer window on 01:25 - Oct 5 by KeithHaynes |
I think the club needs to clarify exactly what is the situation, it feels slightly top heavy now with Maybury ( is he now part time ? ) I believe Langley and Roberts may well be.
The main issue club have made it quite clear Allen is the main recruiter, however it goes without saying with Scott and four or so others in certain capacities there should be regular input.
Let’s not forget Julian Winter who hold the purse strings. |
Probably hard to be definitive when the situation has been so fluid. Some staff in that area have seen their job title/responsibilities change 3 or 4 times in the last 2 years, since the old head of academy recruitment (whose name I forget) left. Nigel Rees moved on less than a year ago, Mark Allen only did 6 months with the academy. The manager's been here 9 busy weeks. If there are any teething troubles they could still take time to work out.
We won't know how good any of these people are at their jobs for a much longer period. Still room for debate over Gerhard Tremmel's eye with Benda. | | | |
| Swansea City already sourcing new players for the January transfer window on 07:17 - Oct 5 with 1967 views | Chief |
| Swansea City already sourcing new players for the January transfer window on 23:22 - Oct 4 by ReslovenSwan1 |
Keith 'assumed' Scott would be looking after underage age players. He is a journalist or at least a publisher of information. If he said it with certainty like you suggest, it would be based on a source and corroborated. "Assumed" is a big word you need to take note of.
Scott almost certainly is not looking exclusively at youth development. I watched the Allen interview and he is not the recruitment chief, these are two different roles. This does not mean Allen is forbidden from using his contacts. It is a team effort.
You misquoted Keith like you misquote me on a regular basis. It seems to be you modus operand-um that had one poster pulling his hair out.
Winter is the boss and do what he thinks is right. Peterson was going and there was no point having a chat about it. Cooper created the problem and Winter solved it. |
Yes so that's why I asked him the question if he's now looking at players for the u23s. I e underage players. Again please tell me who or what I've misquoted. Because you came to exactly the same conclusion as me - that what Keith said implied that he's now looking at youth recruitment. Whether that's true or not is irrelevant, so don't try and twist it that way. I merely asked a question. A question which you evidently agree with. But for some reason you decided to make something up.
In what way did I misquote Keith? I asked him a question. What poster?
Yes and hopefully next time he'll do things differently because it was a terrible was to conduct business no matter how much you tart it up. | |
| |
| Swansea City already sourcing new players for the January transfer window on 07:19 - Oct 5 with 1964 views | Chief |
| Swansea City already sourcing new players for the January transfer window on 01:28 - Oct 5 by KeithHaynes |
I didn’t say that.
Recruitment isn’t just players though. |
That's why I asked a question - to clarify. To me that's what you were implying.
Does he hire coaches too then? | |
| |
| Swansea City already sourcing new players for the January transfer window on 09:55 - Oct 5 with 1915 views | Catullus |
Hmmm, we are arguing about who is doing what when it seems to me the only thing that matters is, whoever is doing whatever they are doing, are they doing a good job?
I don't care if we give Obi Wan Kenobi a coaching job if he can turn Cullen into Vardy or Cabango into Ramos!
Besides that the only thing that matters is are we treating them ok? | |
| |
| Swansea City already sourcing new players for the January transfer window on 10:02 - Oct 5 with 1898 views | onehunglow |
There is a tendency for fans to align with an individual and back him not the club. That is bizarre.
I am not bothered who runs what so long as they do it well. | |
| |
| Swansea City already sourcing new players for the January transfer window on 11:36 - Oct 5 with 1865 views | KeithHaynes |
| Swansea City already sourcing new players for the January transfer window on 07:19 - Oct 5 by Chief |
That's why I asked a question - to clarify. To me that's what you were implying.
Does he hire coaches too then? |
As I said the two roles seem to have overlapped for me, speculatively I would imagine he continues doing what he always did but with more emphasis on younger players. I haven’t asked the question directly as I didn’t think it would be that much of an issue. | |
| |
| Swansea City already sourcing new players for the January transfer window on 13:58 - Oct 5 with 1807 views | ReslovenSwan1 |
| Swansea City already sourcing new players for the January transfer window on 11:36 - Oct 5 by KeithHaynes |
As I said the two roles seem to have overlapped for me, speculatively I would imagine he continues doing what he always did but with more emphasis on younger players. I haven’t asked the question directly as I didn’t think it would be that much of an issue. |
Do not fall into Chief's spiders web of never ending questions and clarifications Keith. It never ends satisfactorily. I spent hours answering his questions and giving clarifications. At the end of all the research justifying my comment he called me a propagandist and general cad. Shingle has never been the same since his spat with 'The Chief'.
Here is a poem ( As this site's self appointed resident poet)
"Will you walk into my parlor?" said the Spider to the Fly.
"'Tis the prettiest little parlor that ever you did spy;
The way into my parlor is up a winding stair,
And I have many curious things to show when you are there."
"Oh no, no," said the little Fly, "to ask me is in vain;
For who goes up your winding stair can ne'er come down again."
By Mary Howell. | |
| Wise sage since Toshack era |
| |
| Swansea City already sourcing new players for the January transfer window on 16:11 - Oct 5 with 1760 views | Catullus |
| Swansea City already sourcing new players for the January transfer window on 13:58 - Oct 5 by ReslovenSwan1 |
Do not fall into Chief's spiders web of never ending questions and clarifications Keith. It never ends satisfactorily. I spent hours answering his questions and giving clarifications. At the end of all the research justifying my comment he called me a propagandist and general cad. Shingle has never been the same since his spat with 'The Chief'.
Here is a poem ( As this site's self appointed resident poet)
"Will you walk into my parlor?" said the Spider to the Fly.
"'Tis the prettiest little parlor that ever you did spy;
The way into my parlor is up a winding stair,
And I have many curious things to show when you are there."
"Oh no, no," said the little Fly, "to ask me is in vain;
For who goes up your winding stair can ne'er come down again."
By Mary Howell. |
If a resident poet there can be
We should put it a vote most free
Potential Bards should be nominated
The job should not be self designated
The nominees can post their prose
and we'll find out who we chose
The winner then can compse verse
For better or for worse
but whoever the winner may be
please god nobody nominate me! | |
| |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
