| New Daft Penalty Goalkeeping Rule...? 23:42 - Jun 20 with 2359 views | BrynCartwright |
This new rule where goalies must have a foot on or above the goal line when a penalty ball is kicked has already effected 3 games at the Women's World Cup, obviously with major ramifications for the Scottish girls.
https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/48703852
Not sure how the Premiership can decide to not enforce the new rule if it is from the IFAB? Surely the laws of the game must be consistent internationally? How will this effect Champions League games for instance if English teams are used to no enforcement, but Spanish teams are?
Makes things so much harder for the keepers.Bit bonkers in my book. Thoughts? |  |
| |  |
| New Daft Penalty Goalkeeping Rule...? on 23:50 - Jun 20 with 2344 views | builthjack |
How about they introduce penalties taken from the halfway centre spot, with no goalie.
Not easy to score. |  |
| Swansea Indepenent Poster Of The Year 2021. Dr P / Mart66 / Roathie / Parlay / E20/ Duffle was 2nd, but he is deluded and thinks in his little twisted brain that he won. Poor sod. We let him win this year, as he has cried for a whole year. His 14 usernames, bless his cotton socks.
|
| |
| New Daft Penalty Goalkeeping Rule...? on 23:55 - Jun 20 with 2336 views | STID2017 |
| New Daft Penalty Goalkeeping Rule...? on 23:50 - Jun 20 by builthjack |
How about they introduce penalties taken from the halfway centre spot, with no goalie.
Not easy to score. |
Especially if Celina is taking it ...  |  |
| |
| New Daft Penalty Goalkeeping Rule...? on 02:42 - Jun 21 with 2282 views | swans11 |
theres been a rule in place for years Keeper must not be in front of the line yet look alot of saved penalties keeper way off line rarely would penalty be retook. it's down to the on field officials to use the rule var will not be used for that in prem so to be honest I doubt anything will change |  | | |
| New Daft Penalty Goalkeeping Rule...? on 08:09 - Jun 21 with 2169 views | Pegojack |
| New Daft Penalty Goalkeeping Rule...? on 02:42 - Jun 21 by swans11 |
theres been a rule in place for years Keeper must not be in front of the line yet look alot of saved penalties keeper way off line rarely would penalty be retook. it's down to the on field officials to use the rule var will not be used for that in prem so to be honest I doubt anything will change |
Exactly. The rule has been for years that the keeper has to be standing on the line until the moment the ball is kicked, but refs interpret that as they see fit. As we all know, the keeper usually gets away with moving forward a pace or two just before foot connects with ball. |  | | |
| New Daft Penalty Goalkeeping Rule...? on 08:40 - Jun 21 with 2138 views | sherpajacob |
Let's see how heavily this is enforced when they get to penalty shootouts in the knockout stages.
Can you imagine this if the final goes to penalties |  |
| |
| New Daft Penalty Goalkeeping Rule...? on 10:16 - Jun 21 with 2072 views | Badlands |
No 'new rule'.
I occasionally played in goal for local teams n the 1960s and you weren't allowed to move let alone move forward until the ball was kicked.
Until 1905 the goalkeeper was permitted to move no further than the 6 yard line (the reason we have it).
In 1905, the goal-keeper was required to remain on the goal-line.
In 1930, a footnote was appended to the laws, stating that "the goal-keeper must not move his feet until the penalty kick has been taken"
In 1997, At the taking of a penalty kick, or kicks from the penalty mark, goalkeepers must still remain on the goal line (between the posts), facing the kicker, until the ball is kicked, but may now move laterally along the goal line before the ball is kicked.
2003 The goalkeeper also infringes the Laws if he moves from his goal-line before the ball has been kicked. Referees must ensure that when players infringe this Law appropriate action is taken.
Currently
Rule 14-1-3 tells us: “The opposing goalkeeper shall stand on the goal line, between the goal posts until the ball is kicked. Lateral movement is allowed, but the goalkeeper is not permitted to come off the line by stepping or lunging forward until the ball is in play.” Both of the goalkeeper’s feet must be on the line at the time that you blow the whistle for the kick. The goalkeeper can move to either side, but cannot move forward from the time you blow the whistle to signal the kick until the ball is kicked. |  |
| |
| New Daft Penalty Goalkeeping Rule...? on 12:21 - Jun 21 with 2028 views | NotLoyal |
No VAR in the premier league next season for penalties.
It's fücking madness all round. |  |
| |
| New Daft Penalty Goalkeeping Rule...? on 12:27 - Jun 21 with 2023 views | CountyJim |
It's the assistants call at a penalty kick hes the one looking at the keeper and the goal line and if the ball crossed |  | | |
Login to get fewer ads
| New Daft Penalty Goalkeeping Rule...? on 13:37 - Jun 21 with 1977 views | monmouth |
It definitely shouldn’t be a retake if the player misses the goal. And why just the goalkeeper? There should be no stuttering runs, delays, or bollocks designed to fool the goalkeeper, and no players attacking or defence should be in the area. ALL the advantage is with the taker, should score every time. The sad thing for the Scots is that it was such a shit penalty she could have stood three feet behind the line and still saved it. Allowing her a second go after that is criminal. |  |
| |
| New Daft Penalty Goalkeeping Rule...? on 16:06 - Jun 21 with 1914 views | AustinIsOurHero |
Each time I see this thread title, I read it as Death penalty goalkeeping rule!! 
Anyway, unless they stand firm and make penalties be retaken 2,3 maybe 4 times, nothing will change as keepers have always encroached off their line. |  |
| |
| New Daft Penalty Goalkeeping Rule...? on 17:09 - Jun 21 with 1885 views | jacktar_ |
We're not in the Premier league next season, neither will we be in contention for a long time, maybe another generation, so I couldn't give a flying f@ck. | | | |
| New Daft Penalty Goalkeeping Rule...? on 23:31 - Jun 21 with 1791 views | BillyChong |
| New Daft Penalty Goalkeeping Rule...? on 10:16 - Jun 21 by Badlands |
No 'new rule'.
I occasionally played in goal for local teams n the 1960s and you weren't allowed to move let alone move forward until the ball was kicked.
Until 1905 the goalkeeper was permitted to move no further than the 6 yard line (the reason we have it).
In 1905, the goal-keeper was required to remain on the goal-line.
In 1930, a footnote was appended to the laws, stating that "the goal-keeper must not move his feet until the penalty kick has been taken"
In 1997, At the taking of a penalty kick, or kicks from the penalty mark, goalkeepers must still remain on the goal line (between the posts), facing the kicker, until the ball is kicked, but may now move laterally along the goal line before the ball is kicked.
2003 The goalkeeper also infringes the Laws if he moves from his goal-line before the ball has been kicked. Referees must ensure that when players infringe this Law appropriate action is taken.
Currently
Rule 14-1-3 tells us: “The opposing goalkeeper shall stand on the goal line, between the goal posts until the ball is kicked. Lateral movement is allowed, but the goalkeeper is not permitted to come off the line by stepping or lunging forward until the ball is in play.” Both of the goalkeeper’s feet must be on the line at the time that you blow the whistle for the kick. The goalkeeper can move to either side, but cannot move forward from the time you blow the whistle to signal the kick until the ball is kicked. |
Hello Huw | | | |
| New Daft Penalty Goalkeeping Rule...? on 23:32 - Jun 21 with 1788 views | BillyChong |
| New Daft Penalty Goalkeeping Rule...? on 16:06 - Jun 21 by AustinIsOurHero |
Each time I see this thread title, I read it as Death penalty goalkeeping rule!!
Anyway, unless they stand firm and make penalties be retaken 2,3 maybe 4 times, nothing will change as keepers have always encroached off their line. |
The keeper gets a yellow card for it in the WWC, not sure how much more they can enforce it. Not that I agree with VAR whatsoever. | | | |
| New Daft Penalty Goalkeeping Rule...? on 19:28 - Jun 26 with 1531 views | CountyJim |
| New Daft Penalty Goalkeeping Rule...? on 10:16 - Jun 21 by Badlands |
No 'new rule'.
I occasionally played in goal for local teams n the 1960s and you weren't allowed to move let alone move forward until the ball was kicked.
Until 1905 the goalkeeper was permitted to move no further than the 6 yard line (the reason we have it).
In 1905, the goal-keeper was required to remain on the goal-line.
In 1930, a footnote was appended to the laws, stating that "the goal-keeper must not move his feet until the penalty kick has been taken"
In 1997, At the taking of a penalty kick, or kicks from the penalty mark, goalkeepers must still remain on the goal line (between the posts), facing the kicker, until the ball is kicked, but may now move laterally along the goal line before the ball is kicked.
2003 The goalkeeper also infringes the Laws if he moves from his goal-line before the ball has been kicked. Referees must ensure that when players infringe this Law appropriate action is taken.
Currently
Rule 14-1-3 tells us: “The opposing goalkeeper shall stand on the goal line, between the goal posts until the ball is kicked. Lateral movement is allowed, but the goalkeeper is not permitted to come off the line by stepping or lunging forward until the ball is in play.” Both of the goalkeeper’s feet must be on the line at the time that you blow the whistle for the kick. The goalkeeper can move to either side, but cannot move forward from the time you blow the whistle to signal the kick until the ball is kicked. |
It's not rules its laws of the game | | | |
| New Daft Penalty Goalkeeping Rule...? on 19:32 - Jun 26 with 1521 views | NeathJack |
Get rid of penalties. It's a stupid arbitrary punishment which more often than not far outweighs the offence. |  | | |
| New Daft Penalty Goalkeeping Rule...? on 21:02 - Jun 26 with 1471 views | Dr_Winston |
Why don't they just properly enforce the rules already in existence?
Retake penalties until the keeper stays on their line. Caution players immediately for dissent. Award free kicks when a keeper holds on to the ball too long.
These rules already exist, it's just that referees never enforce them. Doing so is one of the things Rugby does a lot better. |  |
| Pain or damage don't end the world. Or despair, or f*cking beatings. The world ends when you're dead. Until then, you got more punishment in store. Stand it like a man... and give some back. |
| |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
