x

Are Mark Hughes Days Numbered

The media are full of reports that if Saints lose to Fulham then Mark Hughes will be sacked, perhaps they are just speculating but the reality is that win lose or draw on Saturday Hughes is walking a fine line.

It doesn't take a rocket scientist to look at the results of Southampton Football Club and work out that Mark Hughes is a man under pressure, defeat at Craven Cottage on Saturday could plunge Saints into the bottom three and the alarm bells will start to ring louder than ever in the Saints boardroom..

Although results have picked up in the last four Premier League games in terms of there being only one defeat and that being at Manchester City was almost expected, but there is far more evidence against Hughes than for him.

Unlike say Mauricio Pellegrino who came in at the start of a season Hughes has now been in charge for 20 League games over half a season and he has a grand total of only 3 wins and 16 points, a ratio of only 0.80 points per game overall.

This season it is even worse and he has accrued only 0.66 points per game and somewhere along the line this has to change even under Hughes or without him.

Put it another way he has now had over a half a season in charge and even if he improves to his overall ratio that is still only 30 points over a season.

In comparison in his 30 games in charge Pellegrino managed to accrue 28 points, a ratio of .93 a game, again rocket scientist's are not needed to work out that if Pellegrino was not up to standard at that ratio, then why should Hughes be.

Certainly the whisper in the press is that the Fulham game is do or die for him, that the Saints board are well aware that they left it too long in firing Pellegrino and that almost cost them dearly, the Mail claims

"There is acknowledgement behind-the-scenes at Southampton that waiting so long to make a material change was a mistake, even though Hughes eventually kept them up."

"And there is a feeling at St Mary's that they cannot afford Hughes a similar amount of time and are likely to take decisive action significantly sooner if he can not halt their alarming slide down the table."

"Furthermore, Southampton's top-brass believe their squad is far better than their current 17th place position and are therefore concerned Hughes is currently underachieving. "

But the fact that the board are even thinking like this, if indeed they are is perhaps suggesting that whatever happens Hughes days are numbered, after all this is no blip, it runs across two seasons and not a lot has changed.

The Mail also suggests that the firing of Les Reed might have bought Hughes time, I don't quite agree with this in that Reed has paid the price for sticking with Pellegrino for too long,if he had stayed he would have had to back Hughes as sacking him would be damning on Reed's own judgement.

The fact that Reed has gone means that the board can point the finger at Reed and the fact that he has gone and do not have to keep Hughes to try and protect themselves.

The only thing that is perhaps keeping him in the job is that Reed's departure has left a hole in the committee that would appoint a new manager and Krueger would rather have Reed's successor in place to get in the man that he wants.

Saints have given Hughes all the time and resources that he needs and although it cannot be denied that the last transfer window was not great ( I discount last January, we had to make a panic buy and do something, we stayed up to that justifies the expense) but the squad should still have been doing better than it is.

It is still short in key areas notably in the central defensive positions and again Reed failed to deal with that, but there is a spark missing that is present in teams like Bournemouth and Watford and wins them games that we would draw, we are no worse than them, but we don't have that motivation and that has to be down to Hughes.

Reed went safe in appointing Hughes, there was a euphoria in staying up and it was only after that died down that we realised that Hughes didn't as much keep us up as Swansea dropped like a stone.

If Saints draw at Fulham it may buy Hughes a little time, but I feel only enough to allow the board to source his successor, even a win might not be good enough for more than a few weeks grace.

But defeat would surely mean the board would have to act quickly and decisively to change things, at the moment it could be claimed that because the team lacks so much spark, direction & leadership that anyone could pick it and the truth is that if we have to sack Hughes without his successor lined up then it would be down to goalkeeping coach Dave Watson and Kelvin Davis to pick the team unless we go to the academy and bring in Radhi Jaidi, none of these three have any real experience and that is a dilemma for Saints.

By 5pm on Saturday we will either have a little bit of time bought for both Hughes and the board or we will be in crisis.

However better to have that crisis now when there is more than enough time and games to turn things around and get out of it than do as we did last season and leave it to the last 8 games.

What to read next:

Swansea City in absolute joke mode after deadline day
Thousands and thousands of Swansea City followers were expecting positve action with so many players linked to the club on deadline day morning. In the end we saw no permanent signings and a desperate scramble to save face late on in the day.
Swans turn to plan B : Million pound offer rejected
Swansea City have had some knock backs today, Jacob Wright the Man City youngster who has agreed and disagreed to joining the Swans it seems is now going elsewhere.
Swansea City on deadline day : Afternoon update
For those who are happy to follow the ever changing day on the Indy here are the latest links today.
Swansea City : Transfer Deadline Day
It’s Transfer Deadline Day on the Indy. From this morning will be reporting on all activity that directly and Indirectly affects Swansea City today right up until 11pm tonight (UK time)
Swansea City in another shocking display
Whatever hope Swansea City fans had today was quickly dashed as another low energy and clumsy performance greeted us today at the Swansea.com.
Team News : Grimes out for Coventry City
Team news coming up.
Man City : Jacob Wright link confirmed : Swansea City Transfer News
Manchester City U21 player, Jacob Wright came from nowhere last night as the transfer deadline is upon us come Monday 11pm UK time. When we were alerted to some very good open sources it’s clear the name cannot just be plucked out of the air.
Swansea City v Coventry City : A proud record to protect : Don’t make it about Grimes
The Swans, depleted but surely with fire in their bellies take on the Sky Blues this afternoon at the Swansea.com. This after a week of off the pitch news and some Swans fans learning a little bit more about loyalty.
Darling new contract isn’t over yet PLUS latest news on transfer links and Melker signs
It seems that Swansea City have now managed to move themselves into a position they ‘purported’ to be in four weeks ago. We have been told that there are numerous players that the club are negotiating for over this weekend and Monday.
Melker in Wales as the purchase and loan back is explained
There has been a general confusion and some quite vociferous concerns on the current transfer of Melker Widell from his club AaB to Swansea City. After two days of research we can possibly explain the reasoning behind the Swans accepting the transfer of Widell to Swansea and then loaning him back.