x

3-5-2 - It's Not Going To Happen

There has been many suggestions in recent weeks about changes in formations that the Swans could play with and the formation of 3-5-2 suggested in more than one place - an option pretty much quashed by our manager last night in front of 250 fans at the Liberty Stadium.

Monk was specifically asked the formation question by one of the fans in the audience and he stated reasonably clearly that it would not be something he would look to consider as an option as he felt it was too much of a change from formations and styles that his players were used to.

Interestingly he mentioned Louis Van Gaal and Manchester United which seems to be the catalyst for some of the suggestions which also to me suggested that maybe some of the things discussed on the forums do end up in the ears of the manager although 99.7% of them are probably just to amuse him in times of stress...

Monk stated that it was easier for clubs like Manchester United to change their style on the basis that they were working with "some of the best players in the world" and that adapting styles at that level was much easier. For me it put to bed rumours that we may change formation this season to fit the players that we have into a new system. It was a pretty clear message that the players we have will fit around the system we want to play rather than the other way around.

Monk spent the best part of two hours answering questions from the audience that turned up at the event which was organised by the Swansea City Supporters Trust.

He was fiercely protective of criticism of the players and at times almost dismissive of some of the questions that were asked. This may seem something that wasn't a good trait but I disagree in that it showed a belief in the fact that some of the comments bordered on just being complete rubbish.

But the biggest one for me was the formation which was a big discussion point after last weekend's game against Villarreal at the Liberty and Monk admitted that he got it wrong last week and that he could have changed mid match but he wanted to ensure the players on the pitch got the game time that they needed.

Which in itself will give you a big clue as to the starting XI for Saturday although I would add in Nathan and Routs to his thoughts and you have the 13 players from which he will choose. In my view.

Give our current playing staff - what would be your preferred playing formation?


The Result:
MembersNon-MembersTotal
4-3-3022
4-2-3-191120
4-4-2235
3-5-2145
5-3-2011
4-5-1617
Other044


To embed this in a blog, comment, forum post etc, use [poll_688]

What to read next:

Swansea City 3 - 4 Leeds United - Player Ratings and Reports
If you saw the match, please give us your player ratings and a mini match report.
Swansea City v Leeds United : Team News
The teams are in this afternoon for the big Championship game, Swansea City v Leeds United. There’s a lot on this game with Leeds looking to return to a joint top spot and the Swans moving up the table to ninth.
Swansea City v Leeds United : Latest news & Coleman speaks directly to the supporters
It’s the morning of the Swans biggest game of the season and it’s the visit of Leeds United. A fixture that in the past created huge interest in the city. Nowadays with Sky TV, financial constraints, a general feeling of apathy and it has to be said, performances on the pitch times are a lot different,
Swansea City : This is not a hedge fund, we explore the new people involved
If there has ever been a fresh feel to the club this week then Swans Chairman Andrew Coleman signifies that. His whirlwind approach to the ‘coup’ that saw Jason Levien and Steve Kaplan leave Swansea City under agreement two weeks ago is making pace.
Swansea City v Leeds United : Cabango, Darling, Roberts & injury news
The Swans are back in action at the Swansea.com this coming Sunday when they take on Leeds United (KO:3pm) And Luke Williams adding on to our report yesterday is keen to see what comes out of the current negotiations with Ben Cabango and Harry Darling. We expect these to be finalised come the first week of December.
Swansea City : Dates fixed for Cabango & Darling new and improved contract offers
It seems there is now a way ahead for both Ben Cabango and Harry Darling to at least sit down with Swans Chairman, Andrew Coleman and their agents to try and forge a way forwards to solve their contract issues.
Swansea City : Club football is back so we look backwards
There has been a great deal of progress this season. Despite the unfortunate defeat at Burnley, the Swans capped off the week with strong performances and valuable points. Looking back on the season so far, the team has matched top teams and is playing some lovely football it is much more competitive and there appears to be a strong team spirit.
Wales 4 Iceland 1 : Cullen culls Iceland and Wales win the group
Wales have won their group in the Nations League to earn promotion to League A next time around as Türkiye had the rug pulled from underneath them in Montenegro. The unlikely became the likely, and the saying ‘Let us see what happens at the end’ never more a reality. Better seedlings, games and a whole lot more is the immediate future for Wales.
Wales TEAM NEWS Cabango starts
It’s the final game of this Nations League campaign for Wales later tonight in Cardiff (KO:745pm) It’s an interesting tie for a number of reasons.
Wales : Nations League, World Cup qualifiers and dates explained
The Nations League has provided football fans with some interesting focus as opposed to meaningless friendlies which Wales especially find themselves playing during international breaks. The lack of understanding regards the Nations League (and it’s a bit of a minefield) has seen interest wavering at times.