| POTY. 15:32 - Apr 17 with 6570 views | ted_hendrix |
Four games to go I know but what are peoples thoughts so far?
I'm still going for Rob Dickie. |  |
| My Father had a profound influence on me, he was a lunatic. |
| |  |
| POTY. on 07:51 - Apr 18 with 1559 views | distortR |
| POTY. on 00:06 - Apr 18 by karl |
Well on this thread it may be fair to say Lumley saved us 2 points today, thought he was excellent considering he came on as sub.
It's not a thread about him or keepers but the save he made down in among the feet of attackers and defenders was big in terms of the match but for him personally must be huge given the chat about his head knock against Villa being the reason for his loss of form. Perhaps a big turning point for him?
Hope so |
oh stop it, he's having fun clouding over the silver linings! |  | | |
| POTY. on 10:16 - Apr 18 with 1460 views | GloryHunter |
Big shout-out for Lummers who, having lost his place, still sits in the paddock shouting "Come on you Rs". Heroic. |  | | |
| POTY. on 10:38 - Apr 18 with 1422 views | paulparker |
| POTY. on 00:06 - Apr 18 by karl |
Well on this thread it may be fair to say Lumley saved us 2 points today, thought he was excellent considering he came on as sub.
It's not a thread about him or keepers but the save he made down in among the feet of attackers and defenders was big in terms of the match but for him personally must be huge given the chat about his head knock against Villa being the reason for his loss of form. Perhaps a big turning point for him?
Hope so |
Yeah he pulled off two great saves in the second half tbf to him
I think we are in a dilemma regarding dieng , he is the one who could fetch decent money but would be crucial to keep hold of if we are serious about a play off push next year
It’s interesting because that sale could be the difference between having maybe Austin & SJ in the squad |  |
| And Bowles is onside, Swinburne has come rushing out of his goal , what can Bowles do here , onto the left foot no, on to the right foot
That’s there that’s two, and that’s Bowles
Brian Moore
|
| |
| POTY. on 10:43 - Apr 18 with 1414 views | distortR |
| POTY. on 10:38 - Apr 18 by paulparker |
Yeah he pulled off two great saves in the second half tbf to him
I think we are in a dilemma regarding dieng , he is the one who could fetch decent money but would be crucial to keep hold of if we are serious about a play off push next year
It’s interesting because that sale could be the difference between having maybe Austin & SJ in the squad |
i'll be interested to see how and if the return of crowds will affect his level of performance. | | | |
| POTY. on 11:50 - Apr 18 with 1377 views | karl |
| POTY. on 10:38 - Apr 18 by paulparker |
Yeah he pulled off two great saves in the second half tbf to him
I think we are in a dilemma regarding dieng , he is the one who could fetch decent money but would be crucial to keep hold of if we are serious about a play off push next year
It’s interesting because that sale could be the difference between having maybe Austin & SJ in the squad |
I've said for a little while now that I thought there was a progression plan in place with the keepers.
Lumley was to develop and be sold at a profit with Dieng or Kelly to then step up and be next to put in a season or two and be sold keeping the young keepers coming up behind.
Unfortunately Joe getting injured and what looks like losing his confidence/mojo spoilt that and we looked as though we were chopping and changing with no set plan.
Fortunately for our on the park success Dieng came good at exactly the right time but now we're faced with Joe out of contract and Seny quite possibly at the top of a few clubs shopping list with Kelly, for me, not quite good enough for a team aiming for top 8.
Its a difficult decision if we get a big offer for Dieng, who could be club POTY, going by most on here, and that's not a great look selling that player if its on field ambition we're talking about. |  | | |
| POTY. on 11:58 - Apr 18 with 1365 views | dannyblue |
I appreciated Dieng even more after Lumley's cameo yesterday.
The first fingertip one from Joe was a wonderful save. But I think Dieng would have claimed the ball either from the first cross, or when it was headed up in the air, meaning a save wouldn't have been necessary. We just don't see that kind of ball bouncing around in our box / panic stations when Dieng's playing. |  | | |
| POTY. on 12:20 - Apr 18 with 1333 views | danehoop |
I was just chatting with someone yesterday about Dieng that he hasn't quite been at his admittedly exceptionally high standard for the last few games. Suspect that has been more to do with the constantly changing defensive formation in front of him over the past few weeks, but to be fair to Lumley he has done a great job when called on in Dieng's absence. I'd like to think we would keep the both of them next year and lose Kelly, but suspect we wont be able to and nor would Lumley be necessarily willing to act as second fiddle to Dieng (even though its evident that the latter is likely to move in next 12 months. |  |
| Never knowingly understood |
| |
| POTY. on 13:40 - Apr 18 with 1264 views | denhamhoop2 |
Dieng 1st Dickie 2nd Chair 3rd with reasonable mentions for at least 3 or 4 others by and large the team has been the thing. Johansson and Charlie would've been in the running with a full season Barbet just makes too many rickets to make the top 3 | | | |
Login to get fewer ads
| POTY. on 14:58 - Apr 18 with 1239 views | Sott |
| POTY. on 18:50 - Apr 17 by paulparker |
Should be joint between Austin & SJ our season changed the day they both came in on loan
Massive influence on & off the pitch |
Totally agree that their influence has been massive but surely POTY has to be one of our own ,not a loan. |  | | |
| POTY. on 15:00 - Apr 18 with 1236 views | Myke |
| POTY. on 14:58 - Apr 18 by Sott |
Totally agree that their influence has been massive but surely POTY has to be one of our own ,not a loan. |
Less concerned about whether it is a permanent or a loan, but the 'year' bit is pretty important. | | | |
| POTY. on 15:33 - Apr 18 with 1213 views | loftboy |
Dickie for me. |  |
| |
| POTY. on 15:43 - Apr 18 with 1210 views | BazzaInTheLoft |
| POTY. on 15:33 - Apr 18 by loftboy |
Dickie for me. |
Depends if you play your cards right treacle x |  | | |
| POTY. on 15:48 - Apr 18 with 1202 views | loftboy |
| POTY. on 15:43 - Apr 18 by BazzaInTheLoft |
Depends if you play your cards right treacle x |
 | |
| |
| POTY. on 16:24 - Apr 18 with 1182 views | Watford_Ranger |
Team Seny for me. Surely the most consistent performer. Dickie has been better than expected for sure but was a bit iffy to begin with, understandably.
Barbet is/was the only outfield player in the division to play every minute and hasn’t had many mares this season. | | | |
| POTY. on 16:27 - Apr 18 with 1171 views | BrianMcCarthy |
Too close yet to call Dickie or Dieng. Last few games will settle it.
Chair and Barbet flighting for third. |  |
| |
| POTY. on 16:50 - Apr 18 with 1138 views | QPROslo |
Yeh, Dieng for me too. He probably has saved us a whole load of points this season.
Barbet, played every minute and he's been good or better every game, second. Dickie third, been very good mostly but not quite as consistent all season, understandably as it's a new Club and level for him.
There have been a few who have improved considerably since the season started, Willock and Wallace definetely, but Dykes turnaround has been the most spectacular for me. | | | |
| POTY. on 17:39 - Apr 18 with 1088 views | T_Block |
Dickie has played well but Barbet is the better defender/footballer.Not many coaches in the game would rate Dickie ahead of Barbet.Fans are funny though I remember the voting would always go to Parkes in the mid-seventies team.That team has Bowles and Francis.
Dieng is a reasonable call though
Chair does a lot but not enough for player of the year Ditto Dykes both do not shoot enough.
Wallace cannot get it as he has only been good for half a season- but he is so so good recently
Charlie is a good player but does not look fit
Cameron is underrated by fans.
Willock is getting better and better, his performances put him above chair now
Kakay has improved
Todd kane again under-appreciated
Field,Ball just warming up really all done well though
For me Barbet,just ahead of Dieng.
But true heroes are the coaching team | | | |
| POTY. on 17:53 - Apr 18 with 1062 views | Northernr |
It's going to be Dickie I think for me, narrowly ahead of Dieng. |  | | |
| POTY. on 18:36 - Apr 18 with 1016 views | BazzaInTheLoft |
| POTY. on 17:53 - Apr 18 by Northernr |
It's going to be Dickie I think for me, narrowly ahead of Dieng. |
Will be a more enjoyable End Of Season Report for you that’s for sure. | | | |
| POTY. on 18:37 - Apr 18 with 1016 views | Northernr |
| POTY. on 18:36 - Apr 18 by BazzaInTheLoft |
Will be a more enjoyable End Of Season Report for you that’s for sure. |
More enjoyable than I thought it was going to be in January. | | | |
| POTY. on 18:54 - Apr 18 with 989 views | ParkRoyalR |
| POTY. on 17:39 - Apr 18 by T_Block |
Dickie has played well but Barbet is the better defender/footballer.Not many coaches in the game would rate Dickie ahead of Barbet.Fans are funny though I remember the voting would always go to Parkes in the mid-seventies team.That team has Bowles and Francis.
Dieng is a reasonable call though
Chair does a lot but not enough for player of the year Ditto Dykes both do not shoot enough.
Wallace cannot get it as he has only been good for half a season- but he is so so good recently
Charlie is a good player but does not look fit
Cameron is underrated by fans.
Willock is getting better and better, his performances put him above chair now
Kakay has improved
Todd kane again under-appreciated
Field,Ball just warming up really all done well though
For me Barbet,just ahead of Dieng.
But true heroes are the coaching team |
I know it's all about opinions but Dickie is a proper defender and a very decent footballer. I think Barbet has improved this year as a back 3 suits him and is my no 3 after Dieng and / or Dickie for POTY.
Agree with all your other points but Barbet of late has played the opposition onside and was knocked off the ball too easily in the penalty box other week when conceding.
Dickie is a proper Centre Half and bar for lacking pace is a Premier League Centre Half. | | | |
| POTY. on 23:09 - Apr 18 with 938 views | Burnleyhoop |
Dickie, all day long. Will be the rock in our defence for years to come. Good at bringing the ball out from defence and has an eye for goal.
Dykes the most improved. Has been superb over the last 4/5 games. Save the money earmarked for Charlie (in our dreams) and use it to secure Johanson.
Willock will have a huge influence next year, oozes quality. | | | |
| POTY. on 09:57 - Apr 19 with 873 views | Nushnool |
POTY for me will be Dieng - it's made such a difference this season watching the matches having confidence when the ball goes anywhere near our goal. Dickie a close runner-up.
On the theme of youth team awards, there should be a Clubman of the Year award going to Joe Lumley this year. |  | | |
| POTY. on 10:02 - Apr 19 with 868 views | daveB |
Deing, Dickie or Barbet for me.
Probably go for Deing |  | | |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
