Forum | That penalty decision by TFP

Forum index | Previous Thread | Next thread

That penalty decision 16:27 - Sep 22 with 11580 views

Im sat behind the goal in the pearl street end and I'm incredulous about that penalty and red card. Are defenders not allowed to even brush an opponent with their shoulder? Hope we don't pay for it

That penalty decision on 22:41 - Sep 22 with 1294 views

442Dale

That penalty decision on 22:26 - Sep 22 by Clivert
Just watched it again and still thinking 'Hmmmmmm?' Can see the penalty but not the red card.

If he hadn't gone to ground he would have had a goal scoring opportunity.

When McIntyre touches the ball for he first time it's about 4/5 yards to the right of the penalty spot with nobody else in a position to prevent a goal.

Poll:

Greatest Ever Dale Game

That penalty decision on 22:46 - Sep 22 with 1269 views

KenBoon

Not seen it, but didn't they change the laws in the summer regarding the three punishments rule (penalty, sending off, suspension). I think if a penalty is given they're only supposed to give them a yellow card (unless its really bad) as a penalty is viewed as punishment enough, whereas if its outside the box you can be sent off if you deny a clear goalscoring opportunity.

That penalty decision on 22:49 - Sep 22 with 1258 views

TVOS1907

That penalty decision on 22:35 - Sep 22 by chuckleberry
What's the sudden interest in Bolton? Perv.

Read earlier posts instead of fraternising on my manor.

When I was your age, I used to enjoy the odd game of tennis. Or was it golf?

That penalty decision on 22:50 - Sep 22 with 1258 views

Clivert

That penalty decision on 22:41 - Sep 22 by 442Dale
If he hadn't gone to ground he would have had a goal scoring opportunity. When McIntyre touches the ball for he first time it's about 4/5 yards to the right of the penalty spot with nobody else in a position to prevent a goal.

Ok.

Still thinking that Bennett can get round.

That penalty decision on 22:52 - Sep 22 with 1251 views

TVOS1907

That penalty decision on 22:46 - Sep 22 by KenBoon
Not seen it, but didn't they change the laws in the summer regarding the three punishments rule (penalty, sending off, suspension). I think if a penalty is given they're only supposed to give them a yellow card (unless its really bad) as a penalty is viewed as punishment enough, whereas if its outside the box you can be sent off if you deny a clear goalscoring opportunity.

It was muted but nothing more.

When I was your age, I used to enjoy the odd game of tennis. Or was it golf?

That penalty decision on 22:52 - Sep 22 with 1252 views

442Dale

That penalty decision on 22:50 - Sep 22 by Clivert
Ok. Still thinking that Bennett can get round.

Ryan Edwards is nearest, and still too far away to stop the chance.

Poll:

Greatest Ever Dale Game

That penalty decision on 22:56 - Sep 22 with 1234 views

TVOS1907

That penalty decision on 22:50 - Sep 22 by Clivert
Ok. Still thinking that Bennett can get round.

But would Bennett getting round stop it still being a goalscoring opportunity?

When I was your age, I used to enjoy the odd game of tennis. Or was it golf?

That penalty decision on 22:57 - Sep 22 with 1232 views

Clivert

That penalty decision on 22:52 - Sep 22 by 442Dale
Ryan Edwards is nearest, and still too far away to stop the chance.

Still a matter of opinion if he could have put the Daggers player off.

That penalty decision on 22:59 - Sep 22 with 1223 views

Clivert

That penalty decision on 22:56 - Sep 22 by TVOS1907
But would Bennett getting round stop it still being a goalscoring opportunity?

No, but Edwards may have

That penalty decision on 23:01 - Sep 22 with 1219 views

442Dale

That penalty decision on 22:57 - Sep 22 by Clivert
Still a matter of opinion if he could have put the Daggers player off.

From approx 6 yards away to his left? If he could, then he's using water bombs or an air-horn.

Poll:

Greatest Ever Dale Game

That penalty decision on 23:08 - Sep 22 with 1199 views

Clivert

That penalty decision on 23:01 - Sep 22 by 442Dale
From approx 6 yards away to his left? If he could, then he's using water bombs or an air-horn.

Still not having it, you'll never make a referee442!?!

That penalty decision on 23:09 - Sep 22 with 1197 views

SalwaDale

That penalty decision on 23:08 - Sep 22 by Clivert
Still not having it, you'll never make a referee442!?!

Dunno, he's a w****r.

TBBT

That penalty decision on 23:12 - Sep 22 with 1186 views

chuckleberry

That penalty decision on 23:09 - Sep 22 by SalwaDale
Dunno, he's a w****r.

That's a harsh comment about your school pal.

That penalty decision on 23:12 - Sep 22 with 1186 views

442Dale

That penalty decision on 23:09 - Sep 22 by SalwaDale
Dunno, he's a w****r.

True.

And, like any ref, think i'm right. Watch it again Clivert, pause the action when McIntyre touches the ball.

Then eeeeeeemail Sepp Blatter if I'm wrong. I'll hand in the whistle (used in Xanadus in 92)

Poll:

Greatest Ever Dale Game

That penalty decision on 23:13 - Sep 22 with 1180 views

442Dale

That penalty decision on 23:12 - Sep 22 by chuckleberry
That's a harsh comment about your school pal.

Aye. But everyone who went there was a bit shite.

Poll:

Greatest Ever Dale Game

That penalty decision on 23:14 - Sep 22 with 1176 views

SalwaDale

That penalty decision on 23:12 - Sep 22 by chuckleberry
That's a harsh comment about your school pal.

I hated everyone at my school. I had no friends.

More importantly though, I wanna see the incident, see what I think.

TBBT

That penalty decision on 23:23 - Sep 22 with 1165 views

chuckleberry

That penalty decision on 23:14 - Sep 22 by SalwaDale
I hated everyone at my school. I had no friends. More importantly though, I wanna see the incident, see what I think.

I concur.

That penalty decision on 23:26 - Sep 22 with 1161 views

SalwaDale

That penalty decision on 23:23 - Sep 22 by chuckleberry
I concur.

Would be funny if it wasn't true.

TBBT

That penalty decision on 23:30 - Sep 22 with 1152 views

judd

That penalty decision on 23:26 - Sep 22 by SalwaDale
Would be funny if it wasn't true.

You hated everyone at school?

You clearly never had Miss Crawford for English.

Hoo Yes.

Poll:

What is it to be then?

That penalty decision on 23:30 - Sep 22 with 1152 views

Clivert

That penalty decision on 23:12 - Sep 22 by 442Dale
True. And, like any ref, think i'm right. Watch it again Clivert, pause the action when McIntyre touches the ball. Then eeeeeeemail Sepp Blatter if I'm wrong. I'll hand in the whistle (used in Xanadus in 92)

The referee is always right!

Apart from whenever the decision goes against Rochdale!

That penalty decision on 23:32 - Sep 22 with 1147 views

chuckleberry

That penalty decision on 23:30 - Sep 22 by judd
You hated everyone at school? You clearly never had Miss Crawford for English. Hoo Yes.

We were about 20yrs behind you Judd so no idea who you're on about you old bastard.

That penalty decision on 23:34 - Sep 22 with 1139 views

judd

That penalty decision on 23:32 - Sep 22 by chuckleberry
We were about 20yrs behind you Judd so no idea who you're on about you old bastard.

Those independent learning programmes really did not work, did they?

Poll:

What is it to be then?

That penalty decision on 23:35 - Sep 22 with 1137 views

442Dale

That penalty decision on 23:32 - Sep 22 by chuckleberry
We were about 20yrs behind you Judd so no idea who you're on about you old bastard.

And we weren't going to many lessons by the end anyway.

Poll:

Greatest Ever Dale Game

That penalty decision on 23:40 - Sep 22 with 1125 views

chuckleberry

That penalty decision on 23:35 - Sep 22 by 442Dale
And we weren't going to many lessons by the end anyway.

We were supposed to go to lessons? Thought we just had to drink pints in the Dog?

That penalty decision on 00:51 - Sep 23 with 1093 views

ColDale

based on what was just shown on the FLS, there's no doubts at all about the penalty.

Forum index | Previous Thread | Next thread