x

3-5-2 - It's Not Going To Happen

There has been many suggestions in recent weeks about changes in formations that the Swans could play with and the formation of 3-5-2 suggested in more than one place - an option pretty much quashed by our manager last night in front of 250 fans at the Liberty Stadium.

Monk was specifically asked the formation question by one of the fans in the audience and he stated reasonably clearly that it would not be something he would look to consider as an option as he felt it was too much of a change from formations and styles that his players were used to.

Interestingly he mentioned Louis Van Gaal and Manchester United which seems to be the catalyst for some of the suggestions which also to me suggested that maybe some of the things discussed on the forums do end up in the ears of the manager although 99.7% of them are probably just to amuse him in times of stress...

Monk stated that it was easier for clubs like Manchester United to change their style on the basis that they were working with "some of the best players in the world" and that adapting styles at that level was much easier. For me it put to bed rumours that we may change formation this season to fit the players that we have into a new system. It was a pretty clear message that the players we have will fit around the system we want to play rather than the other way around.

Monk spent the best part of two hours answering questions from the audience that turned up at the event which was organised by the Swansea City Supporters Trust.

He was fiercely protective of criticism of the players and at times almost dismissive of some of the questions that were asked. This may seem something that wasn't a good trait but I disagree in that it showed a belief in the fact that some of the comments bordered on just being complete rubbish.

But the biggest one for me was the formation which was a big discussion point after last weekend's game against Villarreal at the Liberty and Monk admitted that he got it wrong last week and that he could have changed mid match but he wanted to ensure the players on the pitch got the game time that they needed.

Which in itself will give you a big clue as to the starting XI for Saturday although I would add in Nathan and Routs to his thoughts and you have the 13 players from which he will choose. In my view.

Give our current playing staff - what would be your preferred playing formation?


The Result:
MembersNon-MembersTotal
4-3-3022
4-2-3-191120
4-4-2235
3-5-2145
5-3-2011
4-5-1617
Other044


To embed this in a blog, comment, forum post etc, use [poll_688]

What to read next:

Southampton Selected To Take Part In Pilot For Drinking In The Stands At Football
Up to the mid 1980's you could drink whilst watching the game in football grounds in England however with increased violence at matches, the then Government brought in draconian measures to combat it, including a drinking ban.
Charlie Taylor Admits He Would Have Left If Russell Martin Had Stayed
Charlie Taylor arrived at St Mary's in the summer with just the pedigree that the Southampton squad lacked, Premier League experience ! But he soon found himself an outcast with Saints manager Russell Martin.
Saints Get Pricing Badly Wrong As Set For Lowest FA Cup Attendance in 15 Years
Southampton are set to register their lowest attendance in the FA Cup for 15 years when they take on Swansea City in the FA Cup and this has to be mainly down to the price structure set by the club for this tie.
Dom Ballard Recalled To Southampton From Loan Spell But Not Striking Answer
A couple of years ago Dom Ballard looked to be on the verge of breaking into Saints first team, but since then his career has been hit by injuries and now he has been recalled to St Mary's from Blackpool, but not for good reasons.
Southampton V Brentford The Verdict
I said in the preview that Ivan Juric and his coaching staff do not have enough Premier League experience between them or for that matter any real knowledge of the Saints squad, that was exposed for all to see on Saturday's debacle.
Southampton 0 - 5 Brentford - Player Ratings and Reports
If you saw the match, please give us your player ratings and a mini match report.
Saints Confirm Signing Of Brazilian Left Back
Southampton announced that Brazilian defender Welington had signed a pre contract contract agreement with the club earlier in the season, now with the January transfer window open he has signed the real contract.
Southampton Confirm Changes On First Team Coaching Staff
Saints have now officially confirmed the ins & outs on the coaching staff after the sacking of Russell Martin and the appointment of Ivan Juric as first team manager, the question is though is the balance right.
Southampton Set To Keep Chelsea Loan Signing
A couple of weeks ago it was odds on that Maxwell Cornet & Lesley Ugochukwu would be recalled by their club's, but now the situation seems to have changed for one of them.
Southampton V Brentford The Preview
Make no bones about this game, should Saints lose to the Bees, then with only 3 days gone of the New Year, we will just about be done and dusted in any effort to try and avoid relegation back to the championship.