| Is there something in the air? on 15:06 - Nov 8 with 2897 views | Yorkshire_Dale |
13 match ban surely? |  | |  |
| Is there something in the air? on 15:10 - Nov 8 with 2883 views | D_Alien |
Will he claim he was playing the ball not the man? |  |
| |
| Is there something in the air? on 15:23 - Nov 8 with 2832 views | rochdaleriddler |
| Is there something in the air? on 15:10 - Nov 8 by D_Alien |
Will he claim he was playing the ball not the man? |
 |  |
| |
| Is there something in the air? on 16:46 - Nov 8 with 2617 views | RoChDaLe |
How is that any different to the Andrews one? | |
| how is anthony elding still in league one? |
| |
| Is there something in the air? on 16:52 - Nov 8 with 2593 views | davidab2202 |
Smaller clubs such as Dale or Burton will be fair game.Will be interesting to see what happens when the incident involves a much higher profile club or player. Before anyone mentions Cantona or Suarez ,more someone being caught by camera evidence.As this is apparently the second charge this Burton player has faced this seson it may be interesting were the ban is pitched following the length of Calvin's ban | | | |
| Is there something in the air? on 17:04 - Nov 8 with 2551 views | davidab2202 |
| Is there something in the air? on 16:52 - Nov 8 by davidab2202 |
Smaller clubs such as Dale or Burton will be fair game.Will be interesting to see what happens when the incident involves a much higher profile club or player. Before anyone mentions Cantona or Suarez ,more someone being caught by camera evidence.As this is apparently the second charge this Burton player has faced this seson it may be interesting were the ban is pitched following the length of Calvin's ban |
Having now watched the video perhaps Calvin should have gone down like a sack a spuds and claimed a broken arm.Before anyone has a go--not defending Calvin's action in anyway.He deserves every game of his ban even though do wonder what prompted his actions.Guess we will always wonder because don't think it will ever get into the public domain.
Now water under the bridge,we move on,hopefully with Calvin still part of our plans | | | |
| Is there something in the air? on 18:11 - Nov 8 with 2440 views | nordenblue |
| Is there something in the air? on 16:46 - Nov 8 by RoChDaLe |
How is that any different to the Andrews one? |
It's not, so we'll see what our very consistent FA hand out for this one... | | | |
Login to get fewer ads
| Is there something in the air? on 18:18 - Nov 8 with 2423 views | 442Dale |
| Is there something in the air? on 18:11 - Nov 8 by nordenblue |
It's not, so we'll see what our very consistent FA hand out for this one... |
Is there a video of it? |  |
| |
| Is there something in the air? on 18:25 - Nov 8 with 2399 views | fermin |
| Is there something in the air? on 18:18 - Nov 8 by 442Dale |
Is there a video of it? |
About 35 seconds into the highlights video posted above. |  | | |
| Is there something in the air? on 18:29 - Nov 8 with 2384 views | 442Dale |
| Is there something in the air? on 18:25 - Nov 8 by fermin |
About 35 seconds into the highlights video posted above. |
Cheers. Not as bad as Calvin's but definitely worthy of a longer ban than 3 games. | |
| |
| Is there something in the air? on 18:32 - Nov 8 with 2380 views | SimpkinsLeftPeg |
| Is there something in the air? on 18:25 - Nov 8 by fermin |
About 35 seconds into the highlights video posted above. |
That was back in September, he was given three games.
How is there nine games difference between that and Calvin's? |  | | |
| Is there something in the air? on 18:47 - Nov 8 with 2317 views | dingdangblue |
| Is there something in the air? on 18:11 - Nov 8 by nordenblue |
It's not, so we'll see what our very consistent FA hand out for this one... |
As been stated, they already acted on the off the ball elbow back in Sept. 3 match ban. Also had previous before that ! Bit of a nutter this one!
http://m.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/17587708
I know Calvins was bad - but surely his unblemished career up till then meant for something. You've potentially got another player getting less of a ban for his 3rd charge in 4 years! |  |
| |
| Is there something in the air? on 19:41 - Nov 8 with 2201 views | D_Alien |
My interpretation is the arm was thrust out to stop the player from running towards the ball, i.e. interfering with play, and not completely off-the-ball, which Calvin's was
It was an elbow to the face just the same, but occurred with much less aforethought
I believe the 3-game ban was correct, but I also believe Calvin should've got 6 games plus 6 suspended - but what I believe doesn't matter in this instance | |
| |
| Is there something in the air? on 11:12 - Nov 9 with 1956 views | dingdangblue |
| Is there something in the air? on 18:47 - Nov 8 by dingdangblue |
As been stated, they already acted on the off the ball elbow back in Sept. 3 match ban. Also had previous before that ! Bit of a nutter this one!
http://m.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/17587708
I know Calvins was bad - but surely his unblemished career up till then meant for something. You've potentially got another player getting less of a ban for his 3rd charge in 4 years! |
Meant to put it on here but put it on the Calvin thread by accident. Now this is in no way excusing what Calvin did but 4 games for a serial offender (3 violent misconduct charges in 4 years) seems as lenient as Calvin's punishment harsh. As ever the F.A seem to make it up as they go along.
https://mobile.twitter.com/FA/status/796298840378904577/photo/1?ref_src=twsrc%5E | |
| |
| Is there something in the air? on 11:22 - Nov 9 with 1931 views | dingdangblue |
That F.A statement isn't even factually correct. McFadzean hasn't been sent off twice. They've both been missed by the officials - it's his 2nd violent misconduct charge. Joke. | |
| |
| Is there something in the air? on 12:40 - Nov 9 with 1839 views | nordenblue |
| Is there something in the air? on 19:41 - Nov 8 by D_Alien |
My interpretation is the arm was thrust out to stop the player from running towards the ball, i.e. interfering with play, and not completely off-the-ball, which Calvin's was
It was an elbow to the face just the same, but occurred with much less aforethought
I believe the 3-game ban was correct, but I also believe Calvin should've got 6 games plus 6 suspended - but what I believe doesn't matter in this instance |
To be fair DA they are both "off the ball" and I'd say having your centre half flattened is certainly "interfering with play"
However wrong they both are and there's no denying that, all people would expect is a level of consistency which appears to be too much to ask for,for the record I fully agree with your 6 game immediate ban for Calvin etc... | | | |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
