| Team for Villa 00:09 - Oct 20 with 16404 views | JJJack |
Don't want to dwell on tonight but there are a few under-performers of late not just tonight and I hope Monk kicks some arses by dropping a few Saturday:
Fabianski
Rangel - deserves to stay in (just)
Taylor - see above
Fernandez - possibly Amat could be given a go but I would persevere with Fede for now
Williams - undroppable
Ki - I'm not really sure how he's ended up out of the side but he should return -sharpish!
Cork - Not the problem IMO. Bad mistake tonight for the goal but is busy.
Siggurdson - Had a breather. But get him back in as he's reliable and hardworking.
Barrow - showed enough tonight to be given another go
Montero - should get more joy Saturday than against Johnson
Eder - Has shown little but Gomis, like Ayew needs to go and think about his game.
Dropped
Gomis- showed willing but the need for so many touches and his refusal to play simple balls kills many of our attacks.
Ayew - horrendous tonight and goals aside has not offered enough of late. Looked unfit tonight.
JJS - Played ok tonight. But his general performance levels aren't where they were a few weeks ago. Would benefit by a short spell on the bench IMO. |  | | |  |
| Team for Villa on 17:11 - Oct 21 with 2169 views | WarwickHunt |
| Team for Villa on 16:57 - Oct 21 by morningstar |
If we have received a loan fee from Leicester, then it is my understanding that he cannot be recallled. I seem to remember when we had Caulker on loan, they had Ledley King and Gallas injured long term at the same time, but they were unable too recall Caulker. |
Not specifically about Dyer but does this only apply if a club pays a loan fee as well as the wages?
I'd have thought a recall option was pretty standard if they were just paying a player's wages. |  | | |
| Team for Villa on 17:29 - Oct 21 with 2154 views | morningstar |
| Team for Villa on 17:11 - Oct 21 by WarwickHunt |
Not specifically about Dyer but does this only apply if a club pays a loan fee as well as the wages?
I'd have thought a recall option was pretty standard if they were just paying a player's wages. |
Yes I believe that if a player is loaned between Premier league clubs and a loan fee is paid, then that player cannot be recalled. That is a premier league ruling. If the players wages only are paid then the clubs can agree their own recall status to a point. |  |
| |
| Team for Villa on 18:02 - Oct 21 with 2127 views | jasper_T |
It's common sense. If Leicester paid us £1m for Dyer for the season (it was at least that) we can't turn around a month later and say we're taking him back, tough shit. |  | | |
| Team for Villa on 18:13 - Oct 21 with 2116 views | morningstar |
| Team for Villa on 18:02 - Oct 21 by jasper_T |
It's common sense. If Leicester paid us £1m for Dyer for the season (it was at least that) we can't turn around a month later and say we're taking him back, tough shit. |
Even if no fee had been paid at all, then it would be pointless recalling him before January as he wouldn't be able to play as he is not named in our 25 man squad! [Post edited 21 Oct 2015 18:14]
| |
| |
| Team for Villa on 18:27 - Oct 21 with 2096 views | Darran |
| Team for Villa on 18:02 - Oct 21 by jasper_T |
It's common sense. If Leicester paid us £1m for Dyer for the season (it was at least that) we can't turn around a month later and say we're taking him back, tough shit. |
Yeah but it doesn't work like that in Warwicks head.  |  |
| |
| Team for Villa on 18:31 - Oct 21 with 2088 views | WarwickHunt |
| Team for Villa on 18:27 - Oct 21 by Darran |
Yeah but it doesn't work like that in Warwicks head. |
Dull boy.
Obviously it applies if they've paid a fee. My question was about only paying the wages... | | | |
| Team for Villa on 18:34 - Oct 21 with 2084 views | Darran |
| Team for Villa on 18:31 - Oct 21 by WarwickHunt |
Dull boy.
Obviously it applies if they've paid a fee. My question was about only paying the wages... |
Idiot. | |
| |
| Team for Villa on 19:39 - Oct 21 with 2050 views | Hip |
Time to change things up. Here's a line up that can go from 433, 4231 or 442 Diamond. It's time to give some of the squad players a chance. The play has been too slow and too predictable.
Sigurðsson, Eder, Ayew
Britton, Cork, Ki
Tabanou, Williams, Fernández, Naughton
Fabiański
Bench
Bafé, Emnes, Jeff, Jonjo, Taylor, Amat, Nordfeldt
It's insane that Monk keeps throwing out the same side and expects different results. [Post edited 21 Oct 2015 19:46]
| | | |
Login to get fewer ads
| Team for Villa on 12:01 - Oct 23 with 1929 views | tomdickharry |
A possible solution to the Siggerson conundrum would be to play Ayew on the left hand side of midfield which would allow Siggy to play in his normal role and Ayew with Talylor and Montero forming a formidable left side.Ki/Shelvey giving right hand side support to Rangel/Naughton as and when required.
Fabianski:
Rangel/Naughton:Williams:Fernandez:Taylor:
Ki:Shelvey:Ayew:
Siggerson:
Gomis: Montero: | | | |
| Team for Villa on 12:24 - Oct 23 with 1905 views | builthjack |
Routledge may be fit |  |
| Swansea Indepenent Poster Of The Year 2021. Dr P / Mart66 / Roathie / Parlay / E20/ Duffle was 2nd, but he is deluded and thinks in his little twisted brain that he won. Poor sod. We let him win this year, as he has cried for a whole year. His 14 usernames, bless his cotton socks.
|
| |
| Team for Villa on 18:22 - Oct 23 with 1794 views | Kilkennyjack |
| Team for Villa on 10:45 - Oct 20 by Uxbridge |
Fab
Naughton Fed Ash Taylor (maybe Tabanou if he shows up in training and doesn't think his flounce worked)
Leon Ki
Ayew Gylfi Jeff
Gomis
Move the ball quicker in the middle, rest takes care of itself. |
Perfect |  |
| Beware of the Risen People
|
| |
| Team for Villa on 19:48 - Oct 23 with 1753 views | Davillin |
| Team for Villa on 00:23 - Oct 20 by Uxbridge |
I'd play Leon. Need to speed our midfield up. Probably play Ki and Gylfi with him. May be harsh on Jonjo but he can come on.
Our failure to win the midfield battle is the main thing that is causing us to look so shoddy in other areas IMO. |
Problem identified, solution identified. Thanks.
Monk needs to play his best available in every game and stop tinkering with giving everybody playing time. |  |
| |
| Team for Villa on 21:31 - Oct 23 with 1706 views | curleigh |
| Team for Villa on 09:53 - Oct 20 by johnlangy |
Correct.
And quite how anyone reckons Barrow did enough last night to deserve to retain his place I don't know. Did people not see how any times other players were having to tell him what he should be doing. He's young and inexperienced I know but even allowing for that he was awful. |
agree with this | | | |
| Team for Villa on 21:55 - Oct 23 with 1691 views | builthjack |
| Team for Villa on 10:45 - Oct 20 by Uxbridge |
Fab
Naughton Fed Ash Taylor (maybe Tabanou if he shows up in training and doesn't think his flounce worked)
Leon Ki
Ayew Gylfi Jeff
Gomis
Move the ball quicker in the middle, rest takes care of itself. |
Worth a try this | |
| Swansea Indepenent Poster Of The Year 2021. Dr P / Mart66 / Roathie / Parlay / E20/ Duffle was 2nd, but he is deluded and thinks in his little twisted brain that he won. Poor sod. We let him win this year, as he has cried for a whole year. His 14 usernames, bless his cotton socks.
|
| |
| Team for Villa on 22:47 - Oct 23 with 1659 views | Griffting |
Fab
Naughton Fede ash tayls
Ki shelvey
Ayew siggy montero
Gomis
Arguably our strongest 11
Let's go boss them! |  | | |
| Team for Villa on 22:53 - Oct 23 with 1654 views | morningstar |
| Team for Villa on 22:47 - Oct 23 by Griffting |
Fab
Naughton Fede ash tayls
Ki shelvey
Ayew siggy montero
Gomis
Arguably our strongest 11
Let's go boss them! |
Please don't post a sensible line up mate ffs. There are people on here calling for McBurnie to lead the line in a Prem league game because he's 'bangin em in for the U21's!  | |
| |
| Team for Villa on 02:15 - Oct 24 with 1599 views | ChrisSCFC |
------------------Fabianski------------
Naughton -- Amat --- Williams - -Taylor
---------------Britton--------Ki---------------
Routledge-------Sigurdsson-------Montero
--------------------Gomiss-------------------- |  | | |
| Team for Villa on 11:07 - Oct 24 with 1518 views | A_Fans_Dad |
| Team for Villa on 19:48 - Oct 23 by Davillin |
Problem identified, solution identified. Thanks.
Monk needs to play his best available in every game and stop tinkering with giving everybody playing time. |
He DOES NOT give everyone playing time. | | | |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
