| Clapping 12:24 - Nov 3 with 4273 views | GosportHoops |
Why can't people just be quiet and observe the 2 minutes silence instead of clapping like seals, pathetic |  | | |  |
| Clapping on 12:30 - Nov 3 with 3085 views | Watford_Ranger |
To drown out people stumbling in after eight pints oblivious to a silence. |  | | |
| Clapping on 12:31 - Nov 3 with 3077 views | Match82 |
When you have 15,000 people in the crowds you are going to get some absolute weapons among that who don't have the level of respect they should and think interrupting is funny. If everyone is clapping it doesn't give them the oxygen and attention they crave. |  | | |
| Clapping on 12:36 - Nov 3 with 3042 views | HantsR |
I commented on this on the match thread. Some folk were still clapping when the Last Post was played and I even had to politely ask some supporters behind me to stop chatting.
I think it was because the names of players from both sides who died in the wars were read out before the 'silence' and it has become increasingly common to honour the deceased with applause. Nothing wrong with that, but it was not appropriate for a Remembrance Day ceremony. |  | | |
| Clapping on 12:53 - Nov 3 with 2980 views | GosportHoops |
I appreciate and understand the points made about attention seekers people on the drinks etc but we live in a world of noise just 2 minutes once a year, it's not alot to ask/expect! I just don't like the clapping instead of silence for any occasion but especially remembrance! An | | | |
| Clapping on 12:58 - Nov 3 with 2934 views | slmrstid |
I'd probably say a lot of people don't listen, when it was explained that they'd read the names out, have the silence, then the Last Post, people just started clapping after the names because they hadn't listened, then once a group have started lots of extras just then all join in.
Controversial point but I actually find the whole performative stuff this has become really uncomfortable, particularly when, as we're frequently not, not actually playing at home on Remembrance Weekend. |  | | |
| Clapping on 12:59 - Nov 3 with 2933 views | Hastings_Hoops |
IMHO - Society has changed now and everyone is doped by social media, phones, constant visual stimulation… people struggle to focus and embrace silence.
…sadly one day people will ask why the phrase ‘silence is golden’ was ever a thing. |  | | |
| Clapping on 13:05 - Nov 3 with 2894 views | Watford_Ranger |
They could just stop people coming up the stairs at 2:57 probably. Some safety nonsense perhaps stops that. Have some signs up reminding people what’s happening before the game. | | | |
| Clapping on 13:10 - Nov 3 with 2861 views | Hayesender |
I blame the death of Princess Diana for all this clapping nonsense. Is it really that difficult for some people to keep their mouths shut for a minute? |  |
| |
Login to get fewer ads
| Clapping on 13:15 - Nov 3 with 2839 views | connell10 |
| Clapping on 13:10 - Nov 3 by Hayesender |
I blame the death of Princess Diana for all this clapping nonsense. Is it really that difficult for some people to keep their mouths shut for a minute? |
I blame X factor |  |
| AND WHEN I DREAM , I DREAM ABOUT YOU AND WHEN I SCREAM I SCREAM ABOUT YOU!!!!! | | Poll: | best number 10 ever? |
| |
| Clapping on 13:33 - Nov 3 with 2782 views | Wilkinswatercarrier |
| Clapping on 13:10 - Nov 3 by Hayesender |
I blame the death of Princess Diana for all this clapping nonsense. Is it really that difficult for some people to keep their mouths shut for a minute? |
Was just about to write this. Ever since Diana funeral it seems people can't just keep a lid on it. All this gushing and wailing.
What happened to the good old British Stiff Upper Lip? | | | |
| Clapping on 14:10 - Nov 3 with 2641 views | stevec |
If they ever get the sound system to work in SAR we will have a much better idea of what’s going on.
Joined in the clapping yesterday as it spread through the stadium, protocol went out the window sadly. |  | | |
| Clapping on 14:11 - Nov 3 with 2639 views | slmrstid |
| Clapping on 13:33 - Nov 3 by Wilkinswatercarrier |
Was just about to write this. Ever since Diana funeral it seems people can't just keep a lid on it. All this gushing and wailing.
What happened to the good old British Stiff Upper Lip? |
Maybe foggy memory for me, but wasn't it George Best's death that heralded the arrival of the minute's applause? People felt uncomfortable with the silence due to his issues so decided to applaud for his career instead? Something like that anyway. | | | |
| Clapping on 14:34 - Nov 3 with 2566 views | Westy75 |
Totally agree with OP. Drives me mad. It used to be a meaningful thing to have an entire football crowd fall silent for a full minute. The announcement was clear again “one minute’s silence” but you knew what was coming… |  | | |
| Clapping on 15:34 - Nov 3 with 2401 views | Match82 |
| Clapping on 12:53 - Nov 3 by GosportHoops |
I appreciate and understand the points made about attention seekers people on the drinks etc but we live in a world of noise just 2 minutes once a year, it's not alot to ask/expect! I just don't like the clapping instead of silence for any occasion but especially remembrance! An |
To be clear I completely agree with this, I don't understand why people are incapable of showing respect for a couple of minutes, not difficult and the very least we can/should do IMO.
But if you're in a situation where that's the case, I understand why clapping (another way of showing appreciation albeit one less fitting for the tone of the occasion) is the solution | | | |
| Clapping on 15:36 - Nov 3 with 2391 views | Match82 |
| Clapping on 13:05 - Nov 3 by Watford_Ranger |
They could just stop people coming up the stairs at 2:57 probably. Some safety nonsense perhaps stops that. Have some signs up reminding people what’s happening before the game. |
Not sure if this happens everywhere but I've had that happen to me during the national anthem in the US. They stopped people going up and down the concourses. | | | |
| Clapping on 16:24 - Nov 3 with 2277 views | Logman |
| Clapping on 12:58 - Nov 3 by slmrstid |
I'd probably say a lot of people don't listen, when it was explained that they'd read the names out, have the silence, then the Last Post, people just started clapping after the names because they hadn't listened, then once a group have started lots of extras just then all join in.
Controversial point but I actually find the whole performative stuff this has become really uncomfortable, particularly when, as we're frequently not, not actually playing at home on Remembrance Weekend. |
Agree with para 1
Para 2 - yes, it can be a bit contrived when its 9 days before Remembrance Day but for me its important, the club organise it very well and it serves a good purpose [Post edited 3 Nov 16:26]
| | | |
| Clapping on 17:09 - Nov 3 with 2171 views | HantsR |
| Clapping on 14:11 - Nov 3 by slmrstid |
Maybe foggy memory for me, but wasn't it George Best's death that heralded the arrival of the minute's applause? People felt uncomfortable with the silence due to his issues so decided to applaud for his career instead? Something like that anyway. |
Yes, George Best that's what I thought. It's interesting how times change events like Remembrance Day. In my youth, with many families including my own, having lost loved ones relatively recently in WW2, it was a very solemn occasion and I can remember being in Trafalgar Square when everything and everyone stopped still and silent at 11 am on the day. It was just the one day then, the Sunday, now it seems to last two or three weeks. | | | |
| Clapping on 18:48 - Nov 3 with 1982 views | kensalriser |
The obvious factor is that as we get further away from living memory of war there's less visceral connection to the meaning of Remembrance Day. But I think event expansion creep isn't helping. Remembrance Day wasn't yesterday, it's next week. Better to do it on the day, only on the day, and universally.
Clapping is entirely inappropriate and crass. It's a time for reflection and private thought. [Post edited 3 Nov 18:54]
|  |
| |
| Clapping on 19:00 - Nov 3 with 1930 views | daveB |
In the lower loft the speakers don't work on the concourse so no one had any idea what was going on if it was a minutes silence or applause, it was quite hard to hear if the last post was bering played as well |  | | |
| Clapping on 19:22 - Nov 3 with 1877 views | Northernr |
Agree with the OP.
It's fcking grim. |  | | |
| Clapping on 19:35 - Nov 3 with 1820 views | daveB |
| Clapping on 18:48 - Nov 3 by kensalriser |
The obvious factor is that as we get further away from living memory of war there's less visceral connection to the meaning of Remembrance Day. But I think event expansion creep isn't helping. Remembrance Day wasn't yesterday, it's next week. Better to do it on the day, only on the day, and universally.
Clapping is entirely inappropriate and crass. It's a time for reflection and private thought. [Post edited 3 Nov 18:54]
|
has it always been done like this at football? Seems to have become a thing in the last 10 year that you lay flowers, last post etc at the nearest home game, before that you just did a minutes silence on the weekend of remberance sunday | | | |
| Clapping on 19:41 - Nov 3 with 1799 views | Northernr |
| Clapping on 19:35 - Nov 3 by daveB |
has it always been done like this at football? Seems to have become a thing in the last 10 year that you lay flowers, last post etc at the nearest home game, before that you just did a minutes silence on the weekend of remberance sunday |
My memory is if your home game happened to land on the weekend of Remembrance Sunday you had a silence, and the last post. And that was it. | | | |
| Clapping on 19:56 - Nov 3 with 1705 views | FrankRightguard |
| Clapping on 19:00 - Nov 3 by daveB |
In the lower loft the speakers don't work on the concourse so no one had any idea what was going on if it was a minutes silence or applause, it was quite hard to hear if the last post was bering played as well |
It’s always a minutes silence. |  | | |
| Clapping on 06:50 - Nov 4 with 1367 views | BushRanger82 |
I've never understood this modern penchant for breaking out in applause, as a means of honouring someone who has died. To me, it's innapropriate. A minute, or two's silence, is much more dignified, solemn, and way more apropriate for such an occassion. |  | | |
| Clapping on 06:53 - Nov 4 with 1357 views | Loftgirl |
Virtue signalling. Like flowers on the side of the road where someone has died. |  | | |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
