| Rednapp v Warnock 14:45 - Sep 19 with 4681 views | Royboy48 |
With Harry suggesting Kranscar would play in behind Austin, we have the intriguing possibility of mapping Harry's team with the same 4-2-3-1 formation that Colin employed so successfully just 3 years ago. (Harry wouldn't play a clunky 4-4-1-1 would he?)
Assuming we are comparing like formations, we are far enough into the season to start making opinionated judgements!
Let's start with where we are after 7 games
P W D L F A Pts
Warnock 7 6 1 0 19 2 19
Rednapp 7 5 2 0 7 2 17
Player for Player mostly (compare Warnock's with how they were then) - based on Kranscar in place
G
Kenny v Green; Green shades it
4
Orr/Walker v Simpson; Simpson over Orr, Walker over Simpson
Connelly v Onuoha; Ned, I would have to say
Gorkks v Dunne; again, Dunne I would have to say
Hill10 v Hill13/BAE; Hill13 as good as Hill10 - but BAE probably better than Hill10 (Q. If he's also better than Hill13, what happens when Ned returns from injury?)
2
Faurlin10 v Barton; Hard to split them on a Then and Now basis; Faurlin13 sadly inferior to Faurlin10 at this time.
Derry v Henry; Derry - attitude, visibility, commitment, authenticity, leadership
3
Routledge v Hoilett; Still Routledge for me but close. Hoilett could readily change my mind
Tarrabt v Kranscar; Great reputation-and-achievement signing by Harry I'm sure - but it's hard to see him transcending the Championship player of the 2010/2011 season. Warnock built the entire team around Adel - as Stock did around Rodney - and it paid off big time.
Smith/Buszaky v perm 1 from Carroll, Jenas, Faurlin13, Phillips, SWP and several others. This all needs to settle down before we can compare. I just wonder id Franscar might be the new Buszaky rather than the new Tarrabt...
1
Helguson v Austin; call me unfair but the Iceman is on a far planet in a distant galaxy..
I wish he was still here.
Overall. Warnock's team gelled from Day 1, Harry is still Work In Progress so right now we are comparing a team with an XI if you get the distinction.
There's a famous TV series called 7 up which compares a bunch of kids, now pensioners every 7 years of their life. Might do the same here after 14, 21 games etc.
Now have your say..
|  | | |  |
| Rednapp v Warnock on 15:00 - Sep 19 with 4645 views | isawqpratwcity |
Interesting post, Laz...I mean, RobRoy.
Best argument against, I don't think Harry has got it together yet. This still could be awesome. (I'm prepared for embarrassement.) |  |
| |
| Rednapp v Warnock on 15:01 - Sep 19 with 4642 views | Juzzie |
When they showed the line up on the screens at the ground, it said we were playing 4-2-3-1 any way.
......................Austin
....SWP..........Phillips.........O'Neil
...............Barton...Henry............
Hill.....Dunne...Onuoha...Simpson
......................Green [Post edited 19 Sep 2013 15:03]
|  | | |
| Rednapp v Warnock on 15:17 - Sep 19 with 4582 views | isawqpratwcity |
| Rednapp v Warnock on 15:01 - Sep 19 by Juzzie |
When they showed the line up on the screens at the ground, it said we were playing 4-2-3-1 any way.
......................Austin
....SWP..........Phillips.........O'Neil
...............Barton...Henry............
Hill.....Dunne...Onuoha...Simpson
......................Green [Post edited 19 Sep 2013 15:03]
|
Why would you put Austin in goal and Green up front? | |
| |
| Rednapp v Warnock on 15:20 - Sep 19 with 4571 views | Juzzie |
'cos it might have had more of a result! | | | |
| Rednapp v Warnock on 15:27 - Sep 19 with 4543 views | ShotKneesHoop |
Because Warnock knew what he was doing.
Whereas... where's my tax form, Rosie? |  |
| Why does it feel like R'SWiPe is still on the books? Yer Couldn't Make It Up.Well Done Me! |
| |
| Rednapp v Warnock on 15:28 - Sep 19 with 4541 views | simmo |
If we were making a first 11 choosing from both teams, mine would be this
.....................Helguson
.Hoilett........Taarabt.......Mackie ('10)
........Faurlin ('10)..Barton...........
BAE...Gorkks..Onuoha...Simpson
.....................Kenny........................
Although I have gone for mostly current players I think the 2010 team would beat our current lot. Less on paper, more on the pitch. |  |
| ask Beavis I get nothing Butthead |
| |
| Rednapp v Warnock on 21:03 - Sep 19 with 4417 views | Royboy48 |
Mackie
I'd forgotten about Mackie
How soon we forget...
Mackie v Hoilett heart says Mackie, head says Hoilett | | | |
| Rednapp v Warnock on 22:19 - Sep 19 with 4309 views | jo_qpr63 |
My team if all players at their best on form playing in the championship, would be.
Kenny
Walker Onouha Dunne Hill
Derry Faulin
Barton Taraabt Hoillet
Helgerson. |  | | |
Login to get fewer ads
| Rednapp v Warnock on 00:15 - Sep 20 with 4218 views | baz_qpr |
-------------Kenny
Walker Onhuoha Dunne BAE
---------Derry Faurlin
Routledge Taarabt Hoilett
------------Austin |  | | |
| Rednapp v Warnock on 21:43 - Sep 20 with 4107 views | jo_qpr63 |
| Rednapp v Warnock on 00:15 - Sep 20 by baz_qpr |
-------------Kenny
Walker Onhuoha Dunne BAE
---------Derry Faurlin
Routledge Taarabt Hoilett
------------Austin |
Forgot Routledge!!... Get barton off... Routledge your on son!.. | | | |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.