By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions. We in turn value your personal details in accordance with our Privacy Policy.
Please log in or register. Registered visitors get fewer ads.
F*ck... I dunno if there's much chance - there was a similarity between Bowie's "Starman" and "Somewhere over the rainbow " that they were going to look at.Depends how deep your pockets are to pay the lawyers really.
This sort of thing has been going on for a long time in the world of music and few claimants ever win. Many songwriters are known to borrow riffs or make them sound similar to others sometimes without even knowing it. Not until the song or tune is played do they realise it sounds like someone elses work. Many musicians will just cite that they were influenced by others with no intended plagiarism meant. I think the Kinks kicked up a bit of a stink towards The Doors, when the latter wrote Hello I Love You which 'borrowed' the same riff as the Kinks All Day and All of the Night. Not sure if anything came of it.
There aint half been some clever bastards.
0
Led Zepp in trouble for plagiarism on 15:01 - May 20 with 5956 views
Led Zepp in trouble for plagiarism on 13:55 - May 20 by TheBlob
F*ck... I dunno if there's much chance - there was a similarity between Bowie's "Starman" and "Somewhere over the rainbow " that they were going to look at.Depends how deep your pockets are to pay the lawyers really.
If you think about it, as there a finite number of actual musical notes available in western music, at some point, melodies will sound similar when there has been no conscious intent to replicate another artists creation, be it a whole line, a partial phrase, a hook. I suppose there is more scope for arguing plagiarism with song lyrics but even then the chances of someone coming up with the same line in popular music has to be high.
However, there ARE those "popular" artists who surely must be taking the p@ss or felt at the time it was a "tribute" to the original as opposed to Plagiarism...
and that is not his only "tribute" eh Paul.
Edit: In fairness Jeff Lynne is credited as one of the writers of the changing man according to the Wiki page on the Stanley Road Album!
Weller is one of the worst culprits - 'Start' and 'Taxman' by the Beatles (Harrison) are quite similar. Then again Harrison was a naughty boy once with 'My Sweet Lord' copying 'He's so Fine' and he did get done for it.
0
Led Zepp in trouble for plagiarism on 15:35 - May 20 with 5893 views
Led Zepp in trouble for plagiarism on 15:33 - May 20 by ElHoop
Weller is one of the worst culprits - 'Start' and 'Taxman' by the Beatles (Harrison) are quite similar. Then again Harrison was a naughty boy once with 'My Sweet Lord' copying 'He's so Fine' and he did get done for it.
Aye, I believe that's the most famous case of this type of thing
QPR - "shit but local"
0
Led Zepp in trouble for plagiarism on 17:39 - May 20 with 5819 views
Back in the 80's there were three hits in the charts with the same title. The power of love, Jennifer rush, Huey Lewis and Frankish goes to Hollywood, don't remember any legal action then.
[Post edited 20 May 2014 18:06]
favourite cheese mature Cheddar. FFS there is no such thing as the EPL
"If you think about it, as there a finite number of actual musical notes available in western music, at some point, melodies will sound similar when there has been no conscious intent to replicate another artists creation, be it a whole line, a partial phrase, a hook. I suppose there is more scope for arguing plagiarism with song lyrics but even then the chances of someone coming up with the same line in popular music has to be high."
I had this conversation with my Dad a few years ago what with him being a retired musician (had 3 albums released as the drummer for Skin Alley amongst many other notable things in the late 60's/early-mid 70's) and he agreed about there being a finite amount.
The difficult thing is to decide is if something just happens to sound the same as something done years earlier (there was a boy band single a year or so ago where the opening riff sounded like a Joe Jackson track) or it was intentionally ripped off.
Led Zepp in trouble for plagiarism on 15:01 - May 20 by A40Bosh
If you think about it, as there a finite number of actual musical notes available in western music, at some point, melodies will sound similar when there has been no conscious intent to replicate another artists creation, be it a whole line, a partial phrase, a hook. I suppose there is more scope for arguing plagiarism with song lyrics but even then the chances of someone coming up with the same line in popular music has to be high.
However, there ARE those "popular" artists who surely must be taking the p@ss or felt at the time it was a "tribute" to the original as opposed to Plagiarism...
and that is not his only "tribute" eh Paul.
Edit: In fairness Jeff Lynne is credited as one of the writers of the changing man according to the Wiki page on the Stanley Road Album!
[Post edited 20 May 2014 15:07]
You could make a case for ELO v Beeadles' "I am the Walrus"...mostly the arrangement....
Noel Gallagher's made a tidy fortune out of ripping off other people's songs.
"Shakermaker" rips off "I'd Like To Teach The World To Sing" "Stand By Me" in the chorus rips off "All The Young Dudes" "She's Electric" nicks the ending of "With A Little Help From My Friends" are just three off the top of my head I can think of, I'm sure there are more.
After "Come Together" was released, a few years later John Lennon was sued by the publishers of Chuck Berry's "You Can't Catch Me" and as compensation for losing the lawsuit had to record three of the publishers (Morris Levy) songs including You Can't Catch Me for his "Rock 'n' Roll" album.
Led Zepp in trouble for plagiarism on 15:00 - May 20 by Monahoop
This sort of thing has been going on for a long time in the world of music and few claimants ever win. Many songwriters are known to borrow riffs or make them sound similar to others sometimes without even knowing it. Not until the song or tune is played do they realise it sounds like someone elses work. Many musicians will just cite that they were influenced by others with no intended plagiarism meant. I think the Kinks kicked up a bit of a stink towards The Doors, when the latter wrote Hello I Love You which 'borrowed' the same riff as the Kinks All Day and All of the Night. Not sure if anything came of it.
I always wondered about Hello I Love You/All Day And All of the Night - I mean, they're not just a bit similar, they are pretty much the same bloody riff, and that's about all there is to either song, melodically at least.
The Led Zep thing is a bit ironic - they quite openly used old blues tracks and re-worked them into something new [e.g. When the Levee breaks"] - the drumming of which has in turn been sampled countless times.
I've always been convinced that the bass line of Stevie Wonder's "The Higher Ground' is ripped off from, of all people, Lemmy, on Hawkwind's "Orgone Accumulator." Higher Ground was written in May 1973 - Orgone Accumulator is on Space Ritual, performed and recorded in 1972 and released in 1973. I swear that I came across a press clipping of Hawkwind's 1973 tour of the US with Stevie Wonder amongst the audience, and said to myself "Aha..."
0
Led Zepp in trouble for plagiarism on 23:06 - May 20 with 5511 views
Led Zepp in trouble for plagiarism on 20:41 - May 20 by CamberleyR
Noel Gallagher's made a tidy fortune out of ripping off other people's songs.
"Shakermaker" rips off "I'd Like To Teach The World To Sing" "Stand By Me" in the chorus rips off "All The Young Dudes" "She's Electric" nicks the ending of "With A Little Help From My Friends" are just three off the top of my head I can think of, I'm sure there are more.
After "Come Together" was released, a few years later John Lennon was sued by the publishers of Chuck Berry's "You Can't Catch Me" and as compensation for losing the lawsuit had to record three of the publishers (Morris Levy) songs including You Can't Catch Me for his "Rock 'n' Roll" album.
I think that Gallagher got done for Shakermaker.
He himself admitted that 'Don't Look Back in Anger' was derived from All The Young Dudes but the beginning sounds like 'Imagine'. The title came from a Bowie song Look back in Anger, so he mixed it up a bit. He also borrowed a whole load of Beatle themes without actually nicking a song. Wonderwall was an obscure Harrison film score. Be Here Now was also a Harrison song. Oasis was the venue of the Beatles' first ever Manchester gig. There's loads of other Beatle references in their songs.
0
Led Zepp in trouble for plagiarism on 23:37 - May 20 with 5492 views
CiderwithRosie is right about Page. He undoubtedly 'lifted' many blues chords for Zep.
As for Randy California, Jeezus he's been dead for over 15 years, and I'm sure his path crossed Page's in the late '60's/ early '70's. This is tenuous at most.
Noel Gallagher, plagiarist Champ supreme (which he doesn't deny), must have had to pay Zep for 'Fukkin in the bushes', completely and utterly stolen from 'The Immigrant Song'.
Coldplay also legally lifted Kraftwerk's 'Computer Love' for one of their poxy songs, because Ralf Hutter gave permission, (and probably gets a nice bank transfer every six months.)
Has anyone heard the B-side to a Rolf Harris single, (am I allowed to say this?) 'War Canoe' which was basically used as 'Prince Charming' by Adam and the Ants? Probably paying for his court costs as I write. I had no sympathy for the Aussie kindergarten teacher until hearing today about the victim's lying about selling the story.
0
Led Zepp in trouble for plagiarism on 07:36 - May 21 with 5398 views
Led Zepp in trouble for plagiarism on 18:05 - May 20 by loftboy
Back in the 80's there were three hits in the charts with the same title. The power of love, Jennifer rush, Huey Lewis and Frankish goes to Hollywood, don't remember any legal action then.
[Post edited 20 May 2014 18:06]
There's no copyright on title, Loftboy. 💃
0
Led Zepp in trouble for plagiarism on 07:37 - May 21 with 5396 views
On the subject of Rolf, Gallagher has also been done by Gary Glitter for 'Hello' and Glitter has probably earned more from Oasis than anything else for quite a few years now.
0
Led Zepp in trouble for plagiarism on 09:45 - May 21 with 5327 views
Led Zepp in trouble for plagiarism on 23:03 - May 20 by CiderwithRsie
I always wondered about Hello I Love You/All Day And All of the Night - I mean, they're not just a bit similar, they are pretty much the same bloody riff, and that's about all there is to either song, melodically at least.
The Led Zep thing is a bit ironic - they quite openly used old blues tracks and re-worked them into something new [e.g. When the Levee breaks"] - the drumming of which has in turn been sampled countless times.
I've always been convinced that the bass line of Stevie Wonder's "The Higher Ground' is ripped off from, of all people, Lemmy, on Hawkwind's "Orgone Accumulator." Higher Ground was written in May 1973 - Orgone Accumulator is on Space Ritual, performed and recorded in 1972 and released in 1973. I swear that I came across a press clipping of Hawkwind's 1973 tour of the US with Stevie Wonder amongst the audience, and said to myself "Aha..."
Organ Accumlator - now there's a track. Need to dust that one off and have listen again for the first time in about 20 years.
Led Zepp in trouble for plagiarism on 02:37 - May 21 by SonofNorfolt
CiderwithRosie is right about Page. He undoubtedly 'lifted' many blues chords for Zep.
As for Randy California, Jeezus he's been dead for over 15 years, and I'm sure his path crossed Page's in the late '60's/ early '70's. This is tenuous at most.
Noel Gallagher, plagiarist Champ supreme (which he doesn't deny), must have had to pay Zep for 'Fukkin in the bushes', completely and utterly stolen from 'The Immigrant Song'.
Coldplay also legally lifted Kraftwerk's 'Computer Love' for one of their poxy songs, because Ralf Hutter gave permission, (and probably gets a nice bank transfer every six months.)
Has anyone heard the B-side to a Rolf Harris single, (am I allowed to say this?) 'War Canoe' which was basically used as 'Prince Charming' by Adam and the Ants? Probably paying for his court costs as I write. I had no sympathy for the Aussie kindergarten teacher until hearing today about the victim's lying about selling the story.
The thing about Led Zep is that they took those old blues riffs - that they knew and loved and the general public didn't listen to anyway - and made something new. Maybe a royalty cheque or two should have been paid but it's genuinely a creative act and based on love for the originals.
Another weird example - Glenn Matlock admits the opening riff of Pretty Vacant comes from "Knowing Me Knowing You." Does that make the Pistols an Abba rip-off band? B*llocks it does.
Neol Gallagher oversteps the mark IMO. I accept that he genuinely loves the source material, but what he does with it is just too close to being a cover version, there's not enough reworking of the material to take into a different direction that the original artist would never have gone to.
0
Led Zepp in trouble for plagiarism on 10:54 - May 21 with 5292 views
so called superstar DJ'S have been plagiarizing dance music since fischer price bought out decks for toddlers.
makes me sick to see any tool with the tools ripping of soul, funk dance music under the guise of sweedish house maffia of calvin harris or whatever they fk there called.
the old school boys paid there dues and picked up the pint pots at the end of the night and tried to break new genres of music before some bright spark decided it would be a good idea to throw £5000 per set at some one who took 5 years to learn how to beat mix,.
" I guess in four or five years, the new generation's music will be .. electronics, tapes. I can kind of envision .. maybe one person .. with a lot of machines, tapes, and electronics setups, singin or speaking .. and using machines " James Douglas Morrison | 1969
0
Led Zepp in trouble for plagiarism on 11:22 - May 21 with 5263 views
Led Zepp in trouble for plagiarism on 18:05 - May 20 by loftboy
Back in the 80's there were three hits in the charts with the same title. The power of love, Jennifer rush, Huey Lewis and Frankish goes to Hollywood, don't remember any legal action then.
[Post edited 20 May 2014 18:06]
However Huey Lewis did make (and continues to make) a huge packet out of the Ghostbusters' theme, which sounds exactly like his song 'I Need a New Drug'.
I think he initially sued for c $40million.
0
Led Zepp in trouble for plagiarism on 12:51 - May 21 with 5237 views
Led Zepp in trouble for plagiarism on 11:19 - May 21 by Discodroid
so called superstar DJ'S have been plagiarizing dance music since fischer price bought out decks for toddlers.
makes me sick to see any tool with the tools ripping of soul, funk dance music under the guise of sweedish house maffia of calvin harris or whatever they fk there called.
the old school boys paid there dues and picked up the pint pots at the end of the night and tried to break new genres of music before some bright spark decided it would be a good idea to throw £5000 per set at some one who took 5 years to learn how to beat mix,.
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
