x

Swans Paying Price For Previous Transfer Dealings

The transfer window I am sure was a disappointment to most Swans fans with seemingly very little movement inwards and some very significant departures - most notably club captain Ashley Williams and Andre Ayew.

But yesterday's statement promising "significant losses" when the accounts are released tells you more than just what has happened in the last three months and that is that we are now paying the price for some pretty poor transfer dealings over the past two years.

When you look at the players that we have bought in - particularly in the three transfer windows under Garry Monk - then you realise that we have not really had much value for money out of any of them. You could argue that Ayew was the best value of them all but even he came at a significant cost to the club and whilst a profit was turned off that particular deal it will not be as significant as we possibly could have coped.

You only have to look at the likes of Tabanou, Eder, Gomis and Paloschi to start with to realise that the value was not there and then you add in other moves that seem to have not benefited us where even the purchase of Federico Fernandez seems to have not necessarily been value for money.

Our much praised scouting system that gave us some great buys in the past few years has failed us big time and there has to be a series of people who hold their hands up and admit that it has not been good enough.

What this all tells you of course is that a club of our stature and size cannot afford to make too many mistakes in the transfer market and when you make a series of those mistakes together then the fall out can last for a period longer than just the length of the contracts that have been given out.

Without defending what we have done you wonder how much that has been spent in this summer transfer window - a total of £1.1bn - will be classed as regretted spend in four months time let alone in twelve months. Even our relatively minimal spend could be regretted and there are those already telling you that the money on Llorente is money badly spent.

We have also given out new contracts this summer to existing members of the squad which is a surprise given that money is tight and may have been better used in fees/signing on fees but it is probably testament to just how much players control the spend these days and when there is extra income they all want their share - agents and all.

What we do know though is that we need to undertake a review of our transfer dealings and policy and look at better ways of doing that. Whether that is better scouting, better negotiation or just a better sell of Swansea City I do not know but I do know that something needs to change on this front or we will continue to pay the price for poor dealings and eventually there will not be an income there to balance out the mistakes.

What to read next:

Warnock's QPR at their best - History
Back more than a decade to happier times for this week's Memorable Match as we prepare to welcome Sheffield United back to W12 on Saturday.
And breathe... – Column
QPR’s accounts for the 2023/24 season, which started with Gareth Ainsworth and ended with Marti Cifuentes, show a £13.5m loss, apparently just about squeaking the club under the FFP line for permitted losses over three years – Simon Dorset digs into the figures for LFW.
Kirk in charge of Sheff Utd visit - Referee
Manchester-based official Thomas Kirk takes his second QPR game on Saturday as the R’s host Sheff Utd at Loftus Road.
Known knowns – Report
Portsmouth, who are excellent at home, beat QPR, who are ropey away, 2-1 at Fratton Park on Saturday, and if you’d gone there looking for surprises or learnings about either team you’d have left disappointed.
Portsmouth 2 - 1 Queens Park Rangers - Player Ratings and Reports
If you saw the match, please give us your player ratings and a mini match report.
Look at us (hey, look at us) – Preview
QPR and Portsmouth were the bottom two in the Championship with a single win between them when they fought out a calamity-riddled 2-1 at Loftus Road in October – they meet again motoring off into midtable with sets of results unmatched outside the top four.
Fortress Fratton predictable key to Pompey survival bid – Oppo Profile
Portsmouth have won seven and lost only one of ten at Fratton Park to lift themselves seven clear of the relegation spots ahead of Saturday’s meeting and, as Jonny Barrett (@PompeyJonny) tells us, even Andre Dozzell is playing quite well.
Early win at Fratton Park comes at horrible cost to QPR and Gallen – History
A televised Friday night victory with a late goal should have been terrific news for Ray Wilkins’ QPR as they looked to get their Premier League bounce-back 96/97 season up and running, but the injury Kevin Gallen suffered in scoring that winner was to prove a harbinger for the campaign.
Bramall in charge of Pompey trip - Referee
New Premier League referee Thomas Bramall is in charge on Saturday as QPR head to Portsmouth in the league for the first time since 2010.
Something about a Valentine’s Day massacre – Report
QPR cut loose for their biggest win of the season on Valentine’s night, thrashing hapless Derby County 4-0 at Loftus Road.