x

Saints V Manchester United The Verdict

Saints threw away a match they dominated through lack of concentration and slack defending against a poor Manchester United side.

This is a game that Saints threw away, for long periods of the game they out passed and out thought the visitors only to give away a sloppy goal when on top.

The first goal saw Jose Fonte underhit a back pass to leave Robin Van Persie straight through one on one with Forster, the second goal saw a Wayne Rooney free kick catch everyone dreaming, Fraser Forster stayed on his line and no one tracked Van Persie who slotted in unmarked at the far post.

These were two of the three shots United had on target in the whole match and that perhaps emphasised which side was in control, this defeat was not because of our injury list or because of our small squad, it was merely because of individual error at key times and sadly that has happened in each of the last four games and in three of them has cost us points.

But there are plenty of plus's to take from the game and Saints can now regroup and go into a run of games that will help define the season starting at Burnley and continuing at Sheffield United. Not least the fact that we can compete with any side in this division even with an injury ravaged side.

Ronald Koeman now needs to get the side back to basics and cut out these individual errors that have blighted the last few games, it is in times of hardship that you find out the character of the players in a squad, in the main last night ours came through with flying colours in terms of attitude and our supporters need to see that and realise that although United are a pale shadow of their former selves they are still a decent side in the Premier league and that we lost this game through errors in areas that can be addressed rather than this being the start of a meltdown.

As the injured return to the squad Ronald Koeman will now know more about who should hold their place and who shouldn't, perhaps with our previous good run that hasn't been there and that a few cracks have been papered over.

Last night Koeman will have seen that Toby Alderweireld is the major cog in the defence, without him it does not look half as good both defensively and going forward, we lacked a confidence not just in general but in each other and no one seemed to be taking charge, without Alderweireld, Jose Fonte has made a costly error in the last two games he has relapsed back into his old ways, hopefully this is temporary but without Toby and with a faltering Jose, our full backs did not look half as effective and seemed to lack a little bit of confidence.

In midfield the worry is Tadic and Mane and not Shane Long, there were those who criticised Long but in the last few games Long has shown why we bought him with a battling attitude that has shown just what his value to the side is.

Dusan Tadic is just off form, at least I hope so.

Sadio Mane is fast becoming the scapegoat of some fans, a month ago people where questioning why we had paid £12 million for Long, now the roles have reversed and Mane's quality is under the microscope, last night he wasn't great but he does offer pace and a threat and he didn't stop running and battling, I think he has more to offer us than he has shown so far or indeed last night.

It was a sickening defeat last night, sickening because we didn't deserve it and we had thrown the game away rather than being beaten by a better side, United are a shadow of their former self and without Rooney and Van Persie they would have been well beaten, the way they celebrated last night beating a side like us reminded me of another side 23 or so years ago who had previously dominated the English Leagues and were suddenly finding they weren't the dominant force any more.

What to read next:

Chansiri’s self-sabotage undermines Rohl’s Owls turnaround – Oppo Profile
Sheff Wed’s dramatic improvement under the brilliant management of Danny Rohl has had two torpedoes put in its side by the latest explosion of insanity from the club’s mental chairman Derek Chansiri – Jon Hore (@j_ho9) despairs.
Smith's class of 88 off the mark with Wednesday win - History
We're back to 1988 for the memorable match this week as Jim Smith's QPR halt the rot of a dire start to the season with a 2-0 victory over Sheff Wed on the new grass pitch at Loftus Road.
Allison makes Loftus Road debut for Sheff Wed game - Referee
Fast tracked Premier League referee Sam Allison will take charge of QPR at Loftus Road for the first time this Saturday as Sheff Wed visit West London.
Saito San for the little engine that suddenly can – Report
QPR continued their remarkable upward trajectory with a fourth straight victory to move them within four points and places of the play-offs, Hull City the victims this time.
Hull City 1 - 2 Queens Park Rangers - Player Ratings and Reports
If you saw the match, please give us your player ratings and a mini match report.
Going through changes – Preview
Upwardly mobile QPR face another long distance away trip tonight as they attempt to back up the weekend win at Plymouth by slaying another of the division’s strugglers Hull City.
Selles summoned to rescue endangered Tigers - Oppo Profile
Hull could reasonably have expected a challenging season given the talent drain they suffered over the summer, but few would have had them down for a relegation battle on their considerable budget - @NathanielWhitto tries to make sense of an unfolding horror show.
The road to Wembley - History
We’re back up to East Yorkshire tomorrow to face Hull City, and in preparation we're looking back to a classic cup tie from the 1980s, and the various horror shows Mark Hateley inflicted on both clubs for the history.
Speedie makes Championship debut at Hull midweeker – Referee
Merseyside’s Ben Speedie gets his first QPR game, and first ever Championship appointment, on Tuesday night as the R’s head north to Hull.
Kolli crowns big week with perfect Plymouth winner – Report
Rayan Kolli has a new contract in the bag, and a winning goal on the road at Plymouth to celebrate, in the most significant week of his young career so far.