Please log in or register. Registered visitors get fewer ads.
Forum index | Previous Thread | Next thread
Rednapp v Warnock 14:45 - Sep 19 with 4699 viewsRoyboy48

With Harry suggesting Kranscar would play in behind Austin, we have the intriguing possibility of mapping Harry's team with the same 4-2-3-1 formation that Colin employed so successfully just 3 years ago. (Harry wouldn't play a clunky 4-4-1-1 would he?)

Assuming we are comparing like formations, we are far enough into the season to start making opinionated judgements!

Let's start with where we are after 7 games

P W D L F A Pts
Warnock 7 6 1 0 19 2 19
Rednapp 7 5 2 0 7 2 17

Player for Player mostly (compare Warnock's with how they were then) - based on Kranscar in place

G
Kenny v Green; Green shades it
4
Orr/Walker v Simpson; Simpson over Orr, Walker over Simpson
Connelly v Onuoha; Ned, I would have to say
Gorkks v Dunne; again, Dunne I would have to say
Hill10 v Hill13/BAE; Hill13 as good as Hill10 - but BAE probably better than Hill10 (Q. If he's also better than Hill13, what happens when Ned returns from injury?)
2
Faurlin10 v Barton; Hard to split them on a Then and Now basis; Faurlin13 sadly inferior to Faurlin10 at this time.
Derry v Henry; Derry - attitude, visibility, commitment, authenticity, leadership
3
Routledge v Hoilett; Still Routledge for me but close. Hoilett could readily change my mind
Tarrabt v Kranscar; Great reputation-and-achievement signing by Harry I'm sure - but it's hard to see him transcending the Championship player of the 2010/2011 season. Warnock built the entire team around Adel - as Stock did around Rodney - and it paid off big time.
Smith/Buszaky v perm 1 from Carroll, Jenas, Faurlin13, Phillips, SWP and several others. This all needs to settle down before we can compare. I just wonder id Franscar might be the new Buszaky rather than the new Tarrabt...
1
Helguson v Austin; call me unfair but the Iceman is on a far planet in a distant galaxy..
I wish he was still here.

Overall. Warnock's team gelled from Day 1, Harry is still Work In Progress so right now we are comparing a team with an XI if you get the distinction.

There's a famous TV series called 7 up which compares a bunch of kids, now pensioners every 7 years of their life. Might do the same here after 14, 21 games etc.

Now have your say..
0
Rednapp v Warnock on 15:00 - Sep 19 with 4663 viewsisawqpratwcity

Interesting post, Laz...I mean, RobRoy.

Best argument against, I don't think Harry has got it together yet. This still could be awesome. (I'm prepared for embarrassement.)

Poll: Deaths of Thatcher and Mandela this year: Sad or Glad?

0
Rednapp v Warnock on 15:01 - Sep 19 with 4660 viewsJuzzie

When they showed the line up on the screens at the ground, it said we were playing 4-2-3-1 any way.


......................Austin
....SWP..........Phillips.........O'Neil
...............Barton...Henry............
Hill.....Dunne...Onuoha...Simpson
......................Green
[Post edited 19 Sep 2013 15:03]
0
Rednapp v Warnock on 15:17 - Sep 19 with 4600 viewsisawqpratwcity

Rednapp v Warnock on 15:01 - Sep 19 by Juzzie

When they showed the line up on the screens at the ground, it said we were playing 4-2-3-1 any way.


......................Austin
....SWP..........Phillips.........O'Neil
...............Barton...Henry............
Hill.....Dunne...Onuoha...Simpson
......................Green
[Post edited 19 Sep 2013 15:03]


Why would you put Austin in goal and Green up front?

Poll: Deaths of Thatcher and Mandela this year: Sad or Glad?

0
Rednapp v Warnock on 15:20 - Sep 19 with 4589 viewsJuzzie

'cos it might have had more of a result!
0
Rednapp v Warnock on 15:27 - Sep 19 with 4561 viewsShotKneesHoop

Because Warnock knew what he was doing.

Whereas... where's my tax form, Rosie?

Why does it feel like R'SWiPe is still on the books? Yer Couldn't Make It Up.Well Done Me!

0
Rednapp v Warnock on 15:28 - Sep 19 with 4559 viewssimmo

If we were making a first 11 choosing from both teams, mine would be this

.....................Helguson
.Hoilett........Taarabt.......Mackie ('10)
........Faurlin ('10)..Barton...........
BAE...Gorkks..Onuoha...Simpson
.....................Kenny........................


Although I have gone for mostly current players I think the 2010 team would beat our current lot. Less on paper, more on the pitch.

ask Beavis I get nothing Butthead

0
Rednapp v Warnock on 21:03 - Sep 19 with 4435 viewsRoyboy48

Mackie

I'd forgotten about Mackie

How soon we forget...

Mackie v Hoilett heart says Mackie, head says Hoilett
0
Rednapp v Warnock on 22:19 - Sep 19 with 4327 viewsjo_qpr63

My team if all players at their best on form playing in the championship, would be.
Kenny
Walker Onouha Dunne Hill
Derry Faulin
Barton Taraabt Hoillet
Helgerson.
0
Login to get fewer ads

Rednapp v Warnock on 00:15 - Sep 20 with 4236 viewsbaz_qpr

-------------Kenny

Walker Onhuoha Dunne BAE

---------Derry Faurlin

Routledge Taarabt Hoilett

------------Austin
0
Rednapp v Warnock on 21:43 - Sep 20 with 4125 viewsjo_qpr63

Rednapp v Warnock on 00:15 - Sep 20 by baz_qpr

-------------Kenny

Walker Onhuoha Dunne BAE

---------Derry Faurlin

Routledge Taarabt Hoilett

------------Austin


Forgot Routledge!!... Get barton off... Routledge your on son!..
0
Logo for 'BeGambleAware' Logo for 'BeGambleAware' Logo for 'GamStop' Gambling 18+
About Us Contact Us Terms & Conditions Privacy Cookies Advertising
© FansNetwork 2024