| Anthony Taylor 11:47 - Mar 5 with 4949 views | BenJ94 |
Should any action be taken against him? We all know that it was probably the worst decision against any team in a long long time, luckily, in the end, it didn't affect the outcome, but if we'd lost or drawn I'd be a lot more pissed than I am now. So, should we take the matter to the FA? Could this be the incident that changes people's mind on Video Referee's etc? |  | | |  |
| Anthony Taylor on 11:49 - Mar 5 with 3379 views | union_jack |
Unfortunately these things happen week in, week out. Not saying it wasn't an appalling decision because it was. The future of off-field refereeing won't hinge on this alone but it will undoubtedly add fuel to the fire. |  |
| |
| Anthony Taylor on 11:51 - Mar 5 with 3354 views | Darran |
First thing that should be happening imo is that refs should be explaining some of their decisions and Taylor should explain what he saw.
I'm not usually one to go on about decisions going against us like the Chelsea penalty not given last week seeing as we had a staggering decision go for us in the home fixture but yesterday's decision was incredibly bizarre. |  |
| |
| Anthony Taylor on 11:53 - Mar 5 with 3349 views | swancity |
Quite simply an error. It wasn't costly. Get over it. |  |
| Only an idiot would eat a turkey curry on Christmas day |
| |
| Anthony Taylor on 11:56 - Mar 5 with 3328 views | exiledclaseboy |
| Anthony Taylor on 11:53 - Mar 5 by swancity |
Quite simply an error. It wasn't costly. Get over it. |
Partially agree, mistakes happen. But we'd all be feeling very differently had we not gone on to win the game. |  |
| |
| Anthony Taylor on 11:57 - Mar 5 with 3312 views | DafyddHuw |
| Anthony Taylor on 11:53 - Mar 5 by swancity |
Quite simply an error. It wasn't costly. Get over it. |
Thing is though, refs can just shrug this off as a mistake and move on to the next game.
But that decision could well have cost us the game and we could easily have got relegated because of it. For teams down ther like us fighting for survival, ref's mistakes can cost millions of pounds.
We really need to be using video tech asap. |  | | |
| Anthony Taylor on 11:58 - Mar 5 with 3309 views | union_jack |
| Anthony Taylor on 11:51 - Mar 5 by Darran |
First thing that should be happening imo is that refs should be explaining some of their decisions and Taylor should explain what he saw.
I'm not usually one to go on about decisions going against us like the Chelsea penalty not given last week seeing as we had a staggering decision go for us in the home fixture but yesterday's decision was incredibly bizarre. |
It's easier to deal with because ultimately we won the game.
But, I have sympathy with the refs at times. I have no doubt that Taylor was sure he'd seen a Swansea arm handle the ball. Now with all the denial by Swans players and the lack of appealing by Burnley players it must have made him think. However, he can't change his mind because of that otherwise it would set a dangerous precedent. Video refs should be used for things like this but such referrals will have to be very definitely categorised. On other words, nit for just any old thing. | |
| |
| Anthony Taylor on 11:58 - Mar 5 with 3297 views | Darran |
| Anthony Taylor on 11:53 - Mar 5 by swancity |
Quite simply an error. It wasn't costly. Get over it. |
It's more than an error for me. He clearly didn't see a Swansea player handle the ball so why did he give a penalty?
I'd like to hear his view on it. | |
| |
| Anthony Taylor on 12:00 - Mar 5 with 3282 views | Darran |
| Anthony Taylor on 11:58 - Mar 5 by union_jack |
It's easier to deal with because ultimately we won the game.
But, I have sympathy with the refs at times. I have no doubt that Taylor was sure he'd seen a Swansea arm handle the ball. Now with all the denial by Swans players and the lack of appealing by Burnley players it must have made him think. However, he can't change his mind because of that otherwise it would set a dangerous precedent. Video refs should be used for things like this but such referrals will have to be very definitely categorised. On other words, nit for just any old thing. |
He couldn't possibly have been sure. | |
| |
Login to get fewer ads
| Anthony Taylor on 12:01 - Mar 5 with 3283 views | perchrockjack |
Players are basically dishonest and officials need help
However, they also need to be in possession of gonads
Two refs bottled matters yesterday | |
| |
| Anthony Taylor on 12:03 - Mar 5 with 3276 views | union_jack |
| Anthony Taylor on 12:00 - Mar 5 by Darran |
He couldn't possibly have been sure. |
Well in hindsight of course. But you can see something that you are 100% certain about at the time and it transpires you are wrong. As they say, hindsight is 20/20 vision.
Agree with the accountability though. Even if it's via an official statement rather than a press grilling. Would be a start. | |
| |
| Anthony Taylor on 12:05 - Mar 5 with 3257 views | tomdickharry |
With all the technology available nowadays the game should embrace what is available and use it as an aid especially for match officials when key decision are questionable.With mistakes happening practically every weekend Video technology can't come quickly enough. | | | |
| Anthony Taylor on 12:05 - Mar 5 with 3253 views | Brynmill_Jack |
| Anthony Taylor on 11:58 - Mar 5 by union_jack |
It's easier to deal with because ultimately we won the game.
But, I have sympathy with the refs at times. I have no doubt that Taylor was sure he'd seen a Swansea arm handle the ball. Now with all the denial by Swans players and the lack of appealing by Burnley players it must have made him think. However, he can't change his mind because of that otherwise it would set a dangerous precedent. Video refs should be used for things like this but such referrals will have to be very definitely categorised. On other words, nit for just any old thing. |
If you see the replay immediately after the ball hits Vokes' hand Gylfi appealed for hand ball. He was the only one to appeal. Burnley didn't AFAIK |  |
| Each time I go to Bedd - au........................ |
| |
| Anthony Taylor on 12:07 - Mar 5 with 3237 views | 34dfgdf54 |
| Anthony Taylor on 11:58 - Mar 5 by Darran |
It's more than an error for me. He clearly didn't see a Swansea player handle the ball so why did he give a penalty?
I'd like to hear his view on it. |
I'm with Darran on this.
It happens too many times with certain refs with us, someone posted the QPR away game on facebook today with Anthony Taylor. Routs red carded for being fouled and Rob Green handling miles outside his area stopping a certain goal. You could show several games of us being shafted by Mike Dean also, some refs have it in for us big time. |  | | |
| Anthony Taylor on 12:11 - Mar 5 with 3212 views | monmouth |
Clement had it right again. The only people in the ground that don't have instant access to a replay are the only ones that really need it. I don't like Taylor though, I think he is just a really poor referee. |  |
| |
| Anthony Taylor on 12:40 - Mar 5 with 3147 views | WarwickHunt |
| Anthony Taylor on 12:07 - Mar 5 by 34dfgdf54 |
I'm with Darran on this.
It happens too many times with certain refs with us, someone posted the QPR away game on facebook today with Anthony Taylor. Routs red carded for being fouled and Rob Green handling miles outside his area stopping a certain goal. You could show several games of us being shafted by Mike Dean also, some refs have it in for us big time. |
They don't - they're just shite.
Madley, Foy and Taylor are simply incompetent. Dean is a drama queen. |  | | |
| Anthony Taylor on 12:45 - Mar 5 with 3122 views | waveydavey |
Taylor has reffed us 4 times in the last 3 seasons.
1.QPR away .Routledge incorrectly sent off and Rob Green not sent off when deliberately handling outside the area.
2. Liverpool away . Only goal of game a Liverpool penalty given when Neil Taylor had his back to the ball.
3. Everton away. Nothing controversial as far as I remember (I may be wrong)
4. Yesterday
It's not a very good record is it? | | | |
| Anthony Taylor on 12:56 - Mar 5 with 3077 views | WarwickHunt |
| Anthony Taylor on 12:45 - Mar 5 by waveydavey |
Taylor has reffed us 4 times in the last 3 seasons.
1.QPR away .Routledge incorrectly sent off and Rob Green not sent off when deliberately handling outside the area.
2. Liverpool away . Only goal of game a Liverpool penalty given when Neil Taylor had his back to the ball.
3. Everton away. Nothing controversial as far as I remember (I may be wrong)
4. Yesterday
It's not a very good record is it? |
He's not a very good referee... | | | |
| Anthony Taylor on 13:01 - Mar 5 with 3050 views | Bournedore |
| Anthony Taylor on 11:49 - Mar 5 by union_jack |
Unfortunately these things happen week in, week out. Not saying it wasn't an appalling decision because it was. The future of off-field refereeing won't hinge on this alone but it will undoubtedly add fuel to the fire. |
See what you're saying but not sure something as bad as that happens week in week out. That was particularly poor. Contentious decisions yes but errors as blatant as that? No. His gaffers need to read him the riot act. He must have guessed and that's just not good enough. If he wasn't certain it's play on. |  | | |
| Anthony Taylor on 13:12 - Mar 5 with 3008 views | Jinxy |
In my view, part of the problem is the expectation/norm to make a snap decision within a second or two. Where else in life are decisions, with such considerable potential consequence, expected within such a short space of time, in such a chaotic environment?
Football nicely flows so quickly compared to rugby and we need to preserve that and find a balance. Referees would perhaps default to video too frequently, as they do in rugby (perhaps an easy sell there because rugby has many stoppages anyhow).
For me, a good start would be encouraging the possibility of confering with the assistant ref (even if they just buy time to think and compute what they just saw, or didn't see) without being hassled and badgered by players. |  | | |
| Anthony Taylor on 13:17 - Mar 5 with 2984 views | union_jack |
| Anthony Taylor on 13:01 - Mar 5 by Bournedore |
See what you're saying but not sure something as bad as that happens week in week out. That was particularly poor. Contentious decisions yes but errors as blatant as that? No. His gaffers need to read him the riot act. He must have guessed and that's just not good enough. If he wasn't certain it's play on. |
I worded it badly. I agree, yesterday's was a stand out error. | |
| |
| Anthony Taylor on 13:19 - Mar 5 with 2971 views | WarwickHunt |
| Anthony Taylor on 13:12 - Mar 5 by Jinxy |
In my view, part of the problem is the expectation/norm to make a snap decision within a second or two. Where else in life are decisions, with such considerable potential consequence, expected within such a short space of time, in such a chaotic environment?
Football nicely flows so quickly compared to rugby and we need to preserve that and find a balance. Referees would perhaps default to video too frequently, as they do in rugby (perhaps an easy sell there because rugby has many stoppages anyhow).
For me, a good start would be encouraging the possibility of confering with the assistant ref (even if they just buy time to think and compute what they just saw, or didn't see) without being hassled and badgered by players. |
Limit the number of unsuccessful referrals like they do in cricket.
I doubt if anyone gives a flying fûck about the odd delay though. | | | |
| Anthony Taylor on 13:23 - Mar 5 with 2948 views | Dr_Winston |
| Anthony Taylor on 13:19 - Mar 5 by WarwickHunt |
Limit the number of unsuccessful referrals like they do in cricket.
I doubt if anyone gives a flying fûck about the odd delay though. |
A two minute delay is infinitely preferable to all parties rather than a clusterf*ck like that penalty award.
Always liked the idea of a referral system like cricket, but I'd like to see the ref have the ability to check himself without a review request if he feels the need. |  |
| Pain or damage don't end the world. Or despair, or f*cking beatings. The world ends when you're dead. Until then, you got more punishment in store. Stand it like a man... and give some back. |
| |
| Anthony Taylor on 13:27 - Mar 5 with 2926 views | union_jack |
| Anthony Taylor on 13:23 - Mar 5 by Dr_Winston |
A two minute delay is infinitely preferable to all parties rather than a clusterf*ck like that penalty award.
Always liked the idea of a referral system like cricket, but I'd like to see the ref have the ability to check himself without a review request if he feels the need. |
If something is brought in I'd like to see the clock stopped a la rugby but not sure how that would work for time wasting infringements.
It's difficult in football. Far easier in rugby. | |
| |
| Anthony Taylor on 13:55 - Mar 5 with 2843 views | swan65split |
Probably worse than the refs decision Yesterday that I am still peeved at giving his record with us, is the linesmans !!!!! from his side, he should have been in line and should have had a better idea of what happened......they are both chunts !! |  | | |
| Anthony Taylor on 13:59 - Mar 5 with 2815 views | skippyjack |
If a Dr makes a mistake it costs people their lives.. Anthony Taylor earns more than Dr's..
Yesterday's decision was like telling a blind man he can see.. and he doesn't need a guide dog.
But you're not allowed to question experts and millionaires these days.. in case it hurts their feelings. |  |
| The awkward moment when a Welsh Club become the Champions of England.. shh
The Swansea Way.. To upset the odds. | | Poll: | Best Swans Player |
| |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
