Please log in or register. Registered visitors get fewer ads.
Smithies, Luongo and a broken central midfield - knee jerks
Thursday, 17th Sep 2015 21:04 by Antti Heinola

Antti Heinola witnessed QPR’s attempt at the world record for most consecutive home games conceding exactly two goals continue apace against Blackburn on Tuesday.

Tozser/Henry

Copy and paste from Saturday if you like. I see West London Sport has, incredibly, given them both half decent write ups and awarded them 7/10. Bizarre state of affairs.

I'll go in to formation a bit in a moment, but for now, the issue with these two is that they are simply not mobile enough, or quick enough, to cover those positions effectively. Worse, their passing last night was dreadful. Karl Henry's passing is never better than average, and usually it's predominantly going backwards, but while Daniel Tozser was at least looking for forward passes, time and again he found the shins or boot of a Blackburn player. Henry did well to get forward for the chance that should've brought a penalty, but that closing of the gap between defensive midfielders and attackers was all too rare in the first half. Flabbergasted that neither was replaced by either Faurlin or Doughty. Sadly, I suspect they'll both start again on Saturday, likely with similar results.


First Half, Second Half

Not for the first time this season, the second half performance has needed a big improvement on the first. There's been a lot of discussion on here about 4-2-3-1 and how it's not working, but the fact is it has worked very well when the players are doing what they are supposed to be doing. Ramsey wants to play this way so that he can get all four of those attackers on the pitch at once. But it's a formation and a system that absolutely relies on playing a pressing game and squeezing space between defence and defensive midfield, and defensive midfield and the attack.

First half, the gap between our defensive six and our attacking four was too often too big, and when Tjaronn Chery or Massimo Luongo did drop to look for the ball they looked up to find they were bereft of options. Again and again Blackburn exploited the space in front of Tozser and Henry, where they had the freedom of the park. It wasn't working defensively, or offensively.

After the break, however, we increased the tempo, helped by the quick goal. Those gaps narrowed, we had more of the ball, and while a lot of people not at the game have been screeching about shots on target, the fact was we looked dangerous and created a few excellent openings: a wonderful move between Austin and Phillips that should have seen Luongo score; Henry's shot that should have been a penalty for handball and so on. Whereas Blackburn, who equally looked dangerous in every attack first half, were made to work harder for openings after the break. Their goal was actually a very decent one - yes, both our centre backs could have done better, but it was a good flick and then lovely skill and strength from Rhodes.

So 4-2-3-1 is not necessarily a problem. We're scoring plenty of goals with it. But for it to work we need to play at that high tempo, to squeeze the space, to play higher up the pitch, and to have at least one mobile attack dog of a defensive midfielder.

Alex Smithies

I thought at the time the first goal looked fine, but assumed by his reaction it was a foul. Seen it since, and the ref got it right. I have some sympathy for Smithies though, as it could quite easily have been given as a free kick. I've watched it several times now and it wasn't a howler as such. Simply, he went to catch it and the player just got in front of him. He didn't drop it, you can't criticise his handling - perhaps he just needed to try and get to the ball at a higher point.

Unfortunate in the first few minutes of his full league debut. Some said he looked nervous after that, but I think with the conditions and with not getting the free kick, he just elected to punch and be safe, and he probably caught or punched away more crosses in this game than Green has in about six months.

He then made two very fine saves, one absolutely point blank, to keep us in the game. Second half I was impressed. He looked confident, he shouted a lot, his kicking was safe, his distribution decent. Should retain his place. For those saying he's a bit small, at 6'3 he's not exactly short.

Deadman

It's easy to dislike Deadman. The way he carries himself, his overly fussy refereeing, his past with us. He just looks like a dislikeable man with a scary name. But really, in the cold light of day, he wasn't that bad. He was right not to award the goal and got little wrong afterwards. A fair bit I'd disagree with, but it most was arguable. Having seen the replays, we should have had a penalty for handball from Henry's shot (although it wasn't a great finish from Henry, it must be said), but Deadman was on the other side of it and needed help from his (poor) assistant, with that one.

But then there was the Charlie Austin fiasco. Firstly, I noticed some people thought Austin was carded for not having his boot on, but the guy next to me said Austin was lucky not to be sent off for a clear elbow off the ball. We'll probably never see that incident again, so only Austin knows the answer to that.

But, in terms of waving him back on, that I do not understand. I tried to be reasonable and thought perhaps there's a law that if you voluntarily leave the pitch, with the ref's permission, in a situation other than an injury, you can only return once the ball is out of play. But I've just spent a load of time combing the FA laws and FIFA's laws and can find absolutely no evidence of this. There were at least three, maybe four, clear opportunities where Austin could have safely returned to the pitch and Deadman refused to wave him on. It was crass refereeing, spiteful, without any common sense, and unnecessary. We don't go to watch refs, but Deadman is a fan of being watched.


Angella

I've seen a fair amount of criticism of our two centre backs from last night, some merited, some maybe not so.

It's worth bearing in mind that Rhodes scores goals for fun at this level, and I thought his strike partner Koita was an awkward opponent too. Simply blaming the defence is a little simplistic - we need to defend better as a team. However, although Angella lost out to Koita for the flick on for the second goal, he won a lot of the ball in the air (which was nice after he inexplicably ducked out of one early on). More importantly, we saw glimpses of the ball-playing centre back Ferdinand and Ramsey were keen to recruit. His passing and confidence to move with the ball out of defence, again, particularly in the second half, was encouraging. He passed the ball better than the two midfielders in front of him, that's for sure.

Luongo

And a quick word on Mass, who's looking like the pick of our summer signings. Another good game from him.

He has a great knack of nicking the ball from the opposition and then springing away with it. He has a bit of pace. He rarely wastes the ball. And he is the kind of player you're always happy to see receive a pass, because you know there's a decent chance he won't lose possession. A really intelligent player and it'll be interesting to see if his future lies slightly deeper once Fer comes into the side, or if Mackie forces his way into the starting XI.

Just one bad moment, after Charlie's ball of the match that opened up the Blackburn defence and Matty Phillips' perfect pass, Mass had the goal at his mercy, but shanked a poor ball to a marked Mackie. He beat the ground in frustration. He cares. Looking forward to his first goal - he does just need to have more of a killer instinct when it comes to finishing moves.

Pictures — Action Images

Photo: Action Images



Please report offensive, libellous or inappropriate posts by using the links provided.



Philothesuperhoop added 22:59 - Sep 17
I agree with almost everything here - good report Antti.
My slight worry is not what Ramsey is trying to do....but the fact he doesn't seem to see the problems they sometimes present during games.
Our massive problem last night was Tozier and Henry. Neither can run a game from midfield and because of that everything fails. Henry plays the old Shaun Derry role....just not as well. Tozier doesn't appear to be what this system needs. He has a cracking long range pass, but tries it every time. What he should be doing is winning the ball, getting it down, playing it short, moving and asking for it back. That is where the tempo and system would start from. People may have hated him but Barton (in the games when he didn't think he was Beckham) was great at this. It seems that the only current player who can do this is Ali....so why was he on the bench? Why can't Ramsey see this?
Tozier constantly gave one pass and then stood still and never ever asked for it back. He went missing for ages. You simply can't play if your central midfield don't show for the ball.
I actually thought that the Chief and the new centre half where great...but it shouldn't be them trying to link with the front four!
It was painful to watch, and it seems I was watching a different game to Ramsey.
All that said the team spirit and some of the signings are great.....so I guess we need to stick with it.
0

QPR4Me added 00:32 - Sep 18
Smithies is 25 and has played over 270 games of football as a professional. Asd an ex-parks' keeper myself, I fet that his attempt at catching the ball was weak. As a keeper, if you come for the ball, you get it and bugger anyone between you and the ball. If your own defenders get hurt, tough, they shouldn't have been in the way. Opposition players get close to a keeper at their own risk!!
The 2nd goal has to be laid at the feet of Ned and no-one else. Ned is a centre half, a position where players are meant to be strong and not one where impressions of scared little girls are allowed!
Am not going to bother too much with Deadman, other than to say, the sooner he lives up to his name, the better. My real target for the blatant basketball being played by the Huddersfield defender was the Ellerslie Road side Asst Ref. What level of blindness/ineptitude did he have. Further to that, why, oh why, do the wrost asst refs in the World have to be permanently positioned on the ellerslie Road side. For once the footballing authorities could send a good one to work that side of the ground.
Also, I have seen some nasty Ramsey out comments. Most seem to be based on a reason that I won't mention here and that all decent fans should be offended by. Very few are concerned with his two clear weaknesses, a) the inability to switch formations when things aren't going right and b) his dreadful use of substitutes. Surely, the club can bring in a tactician to give Ramsey the help that he seriously needs in these areas.
Finally, can I ask fans to consider who they give stick about our results thus far, especially the Ramsey out brigade. QPR have let in 12 goals in 7 league games. Of these, the vast majority (take note Ned, Perch and others) have been down to childish errors and lapses in concentration that no coach will ever be able to deal with.
QPR have, on paper, probably the best squad in the division, yet the goals given away have been comical. It really is time that our well paid professionals took time out and looked in a mirror and then accepted the blame for comical errorrs and childish lapses in concentration that have cost the team so many points! Once they step up, take reponsibility for their actions and man up, this squad can run away with this division!
1


You need to login in order to post your comments

Blogs 31 bloggers

Knees-up Mother Brown #22 by wessex_exile

Newcastle United Polls

About Us Contact Us Terms & Conditions Privacy Cookies Advertising
© FansNetwork 2024