| Bristol rovers highlights now online on 21:15 - Nov 18 with 3047 views | ColDale |
great effort by Matty Edwards in the first half.
That 2nd sending off looks worse with every viewing. |  | |  |
| Bristol rovers highlights now online on 21:18 - Nov 18 with 3024 views | sweetcorn |
Penalty looks soft on the highlights if you ask me. |  |
| Leader of the little gang of immature cretins. |
| |
| Bristol rovers highlights now online on 21:19 - Nov 18 with 3016 views | 442Dale |
| Bristol rovers highlights now online on 21:18 - Nov 18 by sweetcorn |
Penalty looks soft on the highlights if you ask me. |
Definite pen, and Edwards knows it.
A foul is a foul and it would been a free-kick on the halfway line, so it's a penalty. |  |
| |
| Bristol rovers highlights now online on 23:25 - Nov 18 with 2908 views | Daley_Lama |
| Bristol rovers highlights now online on 21:15 - Nov 18 by ColDale |
great effort by Matty Edwards in the first half.
That 2nd sending off looks worse with every viewing. |
Desperation/amateurish tackle brought about by the situation in the game, i.e. if Grimes breaks away, it's game over as it was the very last minute of the game.
The Brizzle Pen doesn't look like a pen because their player doesn't roll around the floor screaming as though he has been shot.
RE caught him alright. |  |
| |
| Bristol rovers highlights now online on 10:51 - Nov 19 with 2743 views | MoonyDale |
| Bristol rovers highlights now online on 21:19 - Nov 18 by 442Dale |
Definite pen, and Edwards knows it.
A foul is a foul and it would been a free-kick on the halfway line, so it's a penalty. |
Have to say it looked a soft penalty to me but we all see things differently I guess. The foul on Grimes looks worse on the screen that it did live, shows how hard it is for the officials who don't get the benefit of replays... |  |
| |
| Bristol rovers highlights now online on 10:55 - Nov 19 with 2738 views | dalenumber2 |
| Bristol rovers highlights now online on 21:15 - Nov 18 by ColDale |
great effort by Matty Edwards in the first half.
That 2nd sending off looks worse with every viewing. |
Matty Edwards?
edit: just watched the highlights!
[Post edited 1 Jan 1970 1:00]
|  | | |
| Bristol rovers highlights now online on 12:32 - Nov 19 with 2662 views | olympicdale |
| Bristol rovers highlights now online on 23:25 - Nov 18 by Daley_Lama |
Desperation/amateurish tackle brought about by the situation in the game, i.e. if Grimes breaks away, it's game over as it was the very last minute of the game.
The Brizzle Pen doesn't look like a pen because their player doesn't roll around the floor screaming as though he has been shot.
RE caught him alright. |
I still think it looked soft at the time, and having seen the highlights it hasnt changed my mind. It looks like to me that their guy simply tripped over his own feet, if there was true contact he would have at least shouted for a penalty, but from the view the ref had, you stick a leg out and he falls over it looks like one. |  |
| |
| Bristol rovers highlights now online on 12:55 - Nov 19 with 2625 views | lurker |
Bottom line is that fouls like that in the box do not usually get given. Obviously the rule is that if you make contact with your opponent without touching the ball and he goes down it is a foul. However, if the referee was consistent he would have to be giving 20+ penalties a game. Very harsh decision IMHO |  | | |
Login to get fewer ads
| Bristol rovers highlights now online on 13:44 - Nov 19 with 2580 views | 442Dale |
Watch the reaction of Edwards, he puts his hands up in mock horror when he realises he's tripped him.
It was a clear penalty and our lack of protests illustrate that. | |
| |
| Bristol rovers highlights now online on 13:49 - Nov 19 with 2572 views | D_Alien |
| Bristol rovers highlights now online on 12:55 - Nov 19 by lurker |
Bottom line is that fouls like that in the box do not usually get given. Obviously the rule is that if you make contact with your opponent without touching the ball and he goes down it is a foul. However, if the referee was consistent he would have to be giving 20+ penalties a game. Very harsh decision IMHO |
Those were my thoughts at the time. Their lad was obviously "inviting" contact and the actual contact should have been seen in that context - it was nothing like a blatant trip.
On the subject of consistency, a "no penalty" decision was made in one of the premiership games (MOTD highlights, but can't remember which game now) following the exact same type of shoulder contact for which a penalty was awarded against us in the D&R game. |  |
| |
| Bristol rovers highlights now online on 13:54 - Nov 19 with 2561 views | dingdangblue |
| Bristol rovers highlights now online on 12:55 - Nov 19 by lurker |
Bottom line is that fouls like that in the box do not usually get given. Obviously the rule is that if you make contact with your opponent without touching the ball and he goes down it is a foul. However, if the referee was consistent he would have to be giving 20+ penalties a game. Very harsh decision IMHO |
I think that the fact their player didnt have much momentum made it look soft. Usual penalties involve players being fouled on the run. He just seemed to get a kick on his ankle/shin and fell to the floor. The ref hesitating a few seconds before pointing to the spot didnt help matters. |  |
| |
| Bristol rovers highlights now online on 14:11 - Nov 19 with 2539 views | DaleAwaydayBot |
| Bristol rovers highlights now online on 13:54 - Nov 19 by dingdangblue |
I think that the fact their player didnt have much momentum made it look soft. Usual penalties involve players being fouled on the run. He just seemed to get a kick on his ankle/shin and fell to the floor. The ref hesitating a few seconds before pointing to the spot didnt help matters. |
the way it looked on that Replay compared to the Pearl Street view i still think it were a Penalty but I'd of booked for 2 foul's not the one |  |
| After 3457 forum posts, 11 news comments & 1 match report....The Rochdale Information Robot were Born!!! |
| |
| Bristol rovers highlights now online on 16:37 - Nov 19 with 2445 views | Yorkshire_Dale |
| Bristol rovers highlights now online on 13:54 - Nov 19 by dingdangblue |
I think that the fact their player didnt have much momentum made it look soft. Usual penalties involve players being fouled on the run. He just seemed to get a kick on his ankle/shin and fell to the floor. The ref hesitating a few seconds before pointing to the spot didnt help matters. |
Talking of hesitating for a few seconds.......the Ref should have played advantage at the first red card....we were in on goal......then gone back and send the Gas man off. |  | | |
| Bristol rovers highlights now online on 16:38 - Nov 19 with 2440 views | Daley_Lama |
| Bristol rovers highlights now online on 16:37 - Nov 19 by Yorkshire_Dale |
Talking of hesitating for a few seconds.......the Ref should have played advantage at the first red card....we were in on goal......then gone back and send the Gas man off. |
That was about the only thing the ref got wrong all day for me.
9/10 | |
| |
| Bristol rovers highlights now online on 17:04 - Nov 19 with 2416 views | sweetcorn |
| Bristol rovers highlights now online on 16:37 - Nov 19 by Yorkshire_Dale |
Talking of hesitating for a few seconds.......the Ref should have played advantage at the first red card....we were in on goal......then gone back and send the Gas man off. |
The problem with that is that he could get back and prevent the play, when he should no longer be on the pitch. don't think i've ever seen the ref call back a red card.
regardless of what is said, i still think it looks soft, doesnt look like much if any contact and as if he's fell over his feet. but that may be my blue tint. | |
| Leader of the little gang of immature cretins. |
| |
| Bristol rovers highlights now online on 21:26 - Nov 19 with 2268 views | BeefCurtain |
Love it. 'Unfortunate to lose the game..' If we'd have finished that game with any less than three points then it'd have been a crime against football. |  |
| Everyone's had beef with beef curtain. |
| |
| Bristol rovers highlights now online on 22:25 - Nov 19 with 2217 views | sweetcorn |
| Bristol rovers highlights now online on 21:26 - Nov 19 by BeefCurtain |
Love it. 'Unfortunate to lose the game..' If we'd have finished that game with any less than three points then it'd have been a crime against football. |
A crime against football is in the daily star, the 7 that donnelly got for his sub appearance and only a 6 for gornell. Lawl. what game did they watch, donnelly was mostly ineffective when he came on. | |
| Leader of the little gang of immature cretins. |
| |
| Bristol rovers highlights now online on 22:53 - Nov 19 with 2191 views | phomem |
| Bristol rovers highlights now online on 22:25 - Nov 19 by sweetcorn |
A crime against football is in the daily star, the 7 that donnelly got for his sub appearance and only a 6 for gornell. Lawl. what game did they watch, donnelly was mostly ineffective when he came on. |
They will just have guessed or rolled dice or made it up |  | | |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
