| Rate the keepers 23:15 - Mar 29 with 1225 views | Shun |
Bored.
Who are the best and worst keepers since Hill took over in your opinions?
For me:
1. Heaton
2. Gilks
3. Fielding
4. Russell
5. Lee
6. Lillis
7. OFW
8. Kurucz
9. Lucas
10. Arthur
11. Spencer
12. Kean
Did I miss any? That's quite a hefty amount of keepers for just a few years! I'm not counting the ones who only played one or two games such as Taberner, Edwards, and Button (did he actually play for us?). |  | | |  |
| Rate the keepers on 23:58 - Mar 29 with 1198 views | Knowlesy |
For me, (was Gilks here when Hill took over??)
1. Heaton
2. Lillis
3. OFW
4. Kurucz
5. Lee
6. Russell
7. Fielding
8. Lucas
9. Arthur
10 Kean
11 Spencer
Can't put Kean below Spencer for me, I can't remember Spencer making a SINGLE save that wasn't within arms reach of his starting position!! Not too much in it though. If Gilks counts then I'd stick him second as well.
Didn't rate Fielding - thought he was dodgy as hell and now whenever I notice him on the FLS he always seems to be dropping a clanger! |  | | |
| Rate the keepers on 00:14 - Mar 30 with 1181 views | dingdangblue |
| Rate the keepers on 23:58 - Mar 29 by Knowlesy |
For me, (was Gilks here when Hill took over??)
1. Heaton
2. Lillis
3. OFW
4. Kurucz
5. Lee
6. Russell
7. Fielding
8. Lucas
9. Arthur
10 Kean
11 Spencer
Can't put Kean below Spencer for me, I can't remember Spencer making a SINGLE save that wasn't within arms reach of his starting position!! Not too much in it though. If Gilks counts then I'd stick him second as well.
Didn't rate Fielding - thought he was dodgy as hell and now whenever I notice him on the FLS he always seems to be dropping a clanger! |
Yes gilks was keeper the season Hill took over. Wouldnt sign new contract and left to sit on the Norwich bench. MyTop 5 would be Heaton, Lillis, Fielding, Gilks, Fon Williams. |  |
| |
| Rate the keepers on 03:51 - Mar 30 with 1151 views | YadHoDale |
Widening it out to pre-Hillcroft...
Top five:
Heaton
Hahnemann
Welch
Lee
Gilks
Bit dodgy:
Spencer
Arthur
Kean
Malcolm
Pilkington
"Lanterne Rouge":
Dickens (and his great-great-grandad wrote crap books!) [Post edited 1 Jan 1970 1:00]
|  | | |
| Rate the keepers on 05:04 - Mar 30 with 1145 views | Knowlesy |
It's also quite a frightening statistic that in the 6 years since Hill took over we've had 12 goalkeepers, all of whom were at one stage 'first choice' (apart from Lucas) | | | |
| Rate the keepers on 09:13 - Mar 30 with 1070 views | electricblue |
| Rate the keepers on 03:51 - Mar 30 by YadHoDale |
Widening it out to pre-Hillcroft...
Top five:
Heaton
Hahnemann
Welch
Lee
Gilks
Bit dodgy:
Spencer
Arthur
Kean
Malcolm
Pilkington
"Lanterne Rouge":
Dickens (and his great-great-grandad wrote crap books!) [Post edited 1 Jan 1970 1:00]
|
Hanhemann was not a hill signing...
By far the two best keepers hill signed on loan are..
Heaton
Lillis
In that order..
Feilding to much of a clown for me....
This postion has been much neglected over the past few seasons and a decent keeper is a must, if hes decent then the defence dont have to worry about him, but if hes a clown then oops..
I think that this lad from WHU will be here come August.. |  |
| My all time favourite Dale player Mr Lyndon Symmonds |
| |
| Rate the keepers on 09:35 - Mar 30 with 1055 views | SuddenLad |
Wot ? No Luke Daniels ? |  |
| “It is easier to fool people, than to convince them that they have been fooled†|
| |
| Rate the keepers on 09:39 - Mar 30 with 1050 views | Doolan_Is_God |
1) Tommy Lee
Nowhere) Everyone else
:) |  | | |
| Rate the keepers on 10:12 - Mar 30 with 1027 views | mario |
1. heaton, gilks, lee, lillis
5.russel
6. owf
7. kurucz
8. the rest have been hope less
|  | | |
Login to get fewer ads
| Rate the keepers on 10:24 - Mar 30 with 1018 views | officialdale |
Heaton
Fielding
Kurucz
Lee
Russell |  | | |
| Rate the keepers on 10:48 - Mar 30 with 998 views | electricblue |
Anybody know why lee was not signed by hill!
| |
| My all time favourite Dale player Mr Lyndon Symmonds |
| |
| Rate the keepers on 11:41 - Mar 30 with 972 views | sweetcorn |
| Rate the keepers on 10:48 - Mar 30 by electricblue |
Anybody know why lee was not signed by hill!
|
Because we already had 2 keepers on the books and couldn't afford to take another permanently.
Also anyone who says fielding isn't in, is just plain stupid, commanded the box and a great shot-stopper. Had one of the best keeper records here and never made a mistake. Top class.
My order:
1.Fielding
2.Heaton
3.Lillis
4.Gilks
5.OFW
6.Lee
7.Russell
8. Kurucz
9. Lucas
10. Arthur
11. Kean
12. Spencer |  |
| Leader of the little gang of immature cretins. |
| |
| Rate the keepers on 12:06 - Mar 30 with 954 views | TomRAFC |
heaton and gilks were both a class above as shown by the levels they have reached
i was never over enamoured with fielding. good keeper but not amazing.
lee did a great job for us and is always worth applause when he comes back
OFW should never have been released after the amount of clean sheets he kept. rumour has it hill only had him released because he had a quality signing lined up before he left for barnsley | |
| |
| Rate the keepers on 13:29 - Mar 30 with 909 views | Knowlesy |
| Rate the keepers on 11:41 - Mar 30 by sweetcorn |
Because we already had 2 keepers on the books and couldn't afford to take another permanently.
Also anyone who says fielding isn't in, is just plain stupid, commanded the box and a great shot-stopper. Had one of the best keeper records here and never made a mistake. Top class.
My order:
1.Fielding
2.Heaton
3.Lillis
4.Gilks
5.OFW
6.Lee
7.Russell
8. Kurucz
9. Lucas
10. Arthur
11. Kean
12. Spencer |
Stupid? Disagree. His handling was terrible which often put us under pressure, his 'command of the area' was in fact eccentricity that also kept your heart in your mouth as he'd come charging out for a ball that wasn't rightfully his and punting it out (yes he'd get it but it's not what I wanted to see, anyway, when the defender could've easily dealt with it).
Also he was dreadful at coming for crosses. Stupid to think so though. | | | |
| Rate the keepers on 17:21 - Mar 30 with 829 views | SkiptonDale |
| Rate the keepers on 10:12 - Mar 30 by mario |
1. heaton, gilks, lee, lillis
5.russel
6. owf
7. kurucz
8. the rest have been hope less
|
I've never pointed the finger at anyone on here, everyone's entitled to their own opinion, but calling Frankie Fielding hopeless?? Have a word mate.
My top 5 would be:
-Heaton
-Fielding
-Gilks
-Lee
-Lillis |  | | |
| Rate the keepers on 15:03 - Apr 1 with 751 views | macro |
Heaton & Gilks at the top
Arthur and Lucas in the relegation spots |  | | |
| Rate the keepers on 15:09 - Apr 1 with 745 views | electricblue |
What are the chances i know its a slim one of the following..
Signing lillis next season as im sure his contract ends this summer.
Or
Making Heaton an offer as hes not wanted at Cardiff and hes been that he can go leave.. | |
| My all time favourite Dale player Mr Lyndon Symmonds |
| |
| Rate the keepers on 15:34 - Apr 1 with 730 views | macro |
| Rate the keepers on 15:09 - Apr 1 by electricblue |
What are the chances i know its a slim one of the following..
Signing lillis next season as im sure his contract ends this summer.
Or
Making Heaton an offer as hes not wanted at Cardiff and hes been that he can go leave.. |
Lillis a possibilty, Heaton a non-starter | | | |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
