Skrtel or Ash 18:07 - Jul 10 with 2738 views | Sweyns_Eye | I see Martin Skrtel has just signed a new contract with Liverpool. Who do you rate as the better central defender between the two and why? | ![](/images/avatars/9100.gif) |
| | ![](/images/icons/ignore-user.png) |
Skrtel or Ash on 18:14 - Jul 10 with 2719 views | DafyddHuw | How do you expect anyone to make an informed opinion? If you only go to home matches, you'll see Ash playing 19 times and Skrtel once. If you go to all matches, you'll see Ash playing 38 times and Skrtel twice. You'll also see MOTD which tells you nothing. How can you validly rate one against the other? | ![](/images/avatars/9181.gif) | | ![](/images/icons/ignore-user.png) |
Skrtel or Ash on 18:29 - Jul 10 with 2700 views | dgt73 |
Skrtel or Ash on 18:14 - Jul 10 by DafyddHuw | How do you expect anyone to make an informed opinion? If you only go to home matches, you'll see Ash playing 19 times and Skrtel once. If you go to all matches, you'll see Ash playing 38 times and Skrtel twice. You'll also see MOTD which tells you nothing. How can you validly rate one against the other? |
Using your logic - I don't know if Messi is a good player or not....because I've never seen him play. oh and its Ash for me. | ![](/images/avatars/8936.gif) |
| ![](/images/icons/ignore-user.png) |
Skrtel or Ash on 18:39 - Jul 10 with 2669 views | Neath_Jack | Ash, all day, every day. Skrtel isn't fit to lace his boots. | ![](/images/avatars/9278.gif) |
| ![](/images/icons/ignore-user.png) |
Skrtel or Ash on 18:49 - Jul 10 with 2647 views | Sweyns_Eye | Skrtel edges it on goal stats | ![](/images/avatars/9100.gif) |
| ![](/images/icons/ignore-user.png) |
Skrtel or Ash on 18:51 - Jul 10 with 2638 views | Sweyns_Eye | And before anyone wonders i'm playing devils advocate here. | ![](/images/avatars/9100.gif) |
| ![](/images/icons/ignore-user.png) |
Skrtel or Ash on 18:52 - Jul 10 with 2629 views | Jackfath | Skrtel is 9 cm taller than Ash. | ![](/images/avatars/8659.gif) |
| ![](/images/icons/ignore-user.png) |
Skrtel or Ash on 20:10 - Jul 10 with 2529 views | JethroJack | Skrtel's got more arm tatts, so he must be better....FFS | ![](/images/avatars/12965.gif) | | ![](/images/icons/ignore-user.png) |
Skrtel or Ash on 21:14 - Jul 10 with 2455 views | GixerJack | If I got to chose my own name I wouldn't chose either Martin as a first name or Skrtel as a last name.... Just saying like, that's all | ![](/images/avatars/13593.gif) | | ![](/images/icons/ignore-user.png) | Login to get fewer ads
Skrtel or Ash on 21:27 - Jul 10 with 2434 views | sherpajacob |
Skrtel or Ash on 21:14 - Jul 10 by GixerJack | If I got to chose my own name I wouldn't chose either Martin as a first name or Skrtel as a last name.... Just saying like, that's all |
If Liverpool wanted to do a straight swap. It would be a case of you're having a laugh Brendan. | ![](/images/avatars/9550.gif) |
| ![](/images/icons/ignore-user.png) |
Skrtel or Ash on 21:45 - Jul 10 with 2418 views | Starsky |
Skrtel or Ash on 18:14 - Jul 10 by DafyddHuw | How do you expect anyone to make an informed opinion? If you only go to home matches, you'll see Ash playing 19 times and Skrtel once. If you go to all matches, you'll see Ash playing 38 times and Skrtel twice. You'll also see MOTD which tells you nothing. How can you validly rate one against the other? |
How do all the sky pundits manage then? Feck me, every time someone asks a question you've got to get obtuse about it. Skirtel for goals... Ash by far for defending and less own goals than the pretty one. | ![](/images/avatars/11964.gif) |
| It's just the internet, init. |
| ![](/images/icons/ignore-user.png) |
Skrtel or Ash on 20:21 - Jul 11 with 2288 views | JBT95 | Skrtel was very good against us last season at the Liberty. If he hadn't been back from injury for that game I think we would have won, he just seemed to get to everything that night. Dunno who is better. Who cares, we got Ash. | ![](/images/avatars/11229.gif) | | ![](/images/icons/ignore-user.png) |
Skrtel or Ash on 20:44 - Jul 11 with 2266 views | airedale |
Skrtel or Ash on 21:14 - Jul 10 by GixerJack | If I got to chose my own name I wouldn't chose either Martin as a first name or Skrtel as a last name.... Just saying like, that's all |
That's nothing, his misses is called Myrtle. | ![](/images/avatars/9940.gif) | | ![](/images/icons/ignore-user.png) |
| |