| QPR speak to Holloway (WLS) on 12:03 - Nov 8 with 6779 views | Antti_Heinola |
I love Ollie, but I spent as much time on here defending him from people as I did JFH. Where are the keyboard warriors who so loudly called for him to go last time now?
He looked like a shell at Palace and Millwall. Would be a disaster for both parties imo. Obviously love him and would support him though. But he's not the one. |  |
|  |
| QPR speak to Holloway (WLS) on 12:04 - Nov 8 with 6773 views | rsonist |
I don't see how nostalgia is going to move the club forward.
The tribal elders would get to sing some songs again I guess. |  | | |
| QPR speak to Holloway (WLS) on 12:13 - Nov 8 with 6719 views | simmo |
| QPR speak to Holloway (WLS) on 12:03 - Nov 8 by Antti_Heinola |
I love Ollie, but I spent as much time on here defending him from people as I did JFH. Where are the keyboard warriors who so loudly called for him to go last time now?
He looked like a shell at Palace and Millwall. Would be a disaster for both parties imo. Obviously love him and would support him though. But he's not the one. |
He really should have had a break after Palace, looked a shell of himself at Millwall especially. He has taken that time out now though so it would be goo to see him get back in somewhere, I would rather we were not the ones to test the water with him but he would have the fans onside straight away and is still hugely succesful at this level.
I am not sure it's that realistic, just one of the 6/7 we've interviewed or whose applications have been considered. It seems TBH that they sacked JFH with Sherwood to replace him and since then have backtracked and are now setting up an interview process. I hope, if that is the case, that things aren't rushed and we take whoever thefans seem to be most happy with. |  |
| ask Beavis I get nothing Butthead |
| |
| QPR speak to Holloway (WLS) on 12:13 - Nov 8 with 6713 views | essextaxiboy |
| QPR speak to Holloway (WLS) on 12:03 - Nov 8 by Antti_Heinola |
I love Ollie, but I spent as much time on here defending him from people as I did JFH. Where are the keyboard warriors who so loudly called for him to go last time now?
He looked like a shell at Palace and Millwall. Would be a disaster for both parties imo. Obviously love him and would support him though. But he's not the one. |
Agree . I havnt enjoyed being a Fan as much as when Ollie was here .
There were 3 main critics on here ,only BostonR remains I think . Trying to think who the others were. Maybe they would like to fess up ? Smiffy (RIP) used to row with them for hours
I fear for him if he comes back , he called himself in at Palace and would get no time before the critics old and new were at him .
It wouldnt be boring though if he still has gas in the tank
Edit
Just watched a couple of interviews with him near the end , he looked exhausted . [Post edited 8 Nov 2016 12:23]
|  | | |
| QPR speak to Holloway (WLS) on 12:27 - Nov 8 with 6622 views | daveB |
| QPR speak to Holloway (WLS) on 12:03 - Nov 8 by Antti_Heinola |
I love Ollie, but I spent as much time on here defending him from people as I did JFH. Where are the keyboard warriors who so loudly called for him to go last time now?
He looked like a shell at Palace and Millwall. Would be a disaster for both parties imo. Obviously love him and would support him though. But he's not the one. |
He did struggle at Millwall and in the end at Palace but he's had a break now and I think he could be quite good.
Warnock was on Danny Baker show the other week and was asked what you do when you go into these clubs mid season, he said you add a sense of humour. He was saying they can all play and you can work all week on tactics etc but players are not robots and if you add some humour to things people enjoy their work and end up working harder. It's a basic approach and is hardly the answer to everything but our team for the last 3 years have looked like one who hate playing football and find no joy from it. Holloway coming in and making it fun for the players might be something that helps bring better more relaxed performances.
Of course it could go the other way as well but why not try it?
Realistically whoever comes in we're going to be mid table at best, possibly a relegation battle if it starts badly and i think what Holloway would do is lift the place a bit and get fans onside.
Long term I don't think it would work but long term i don't think any manager works these days, if we'd given it to Warnock plenty would be wanting him out within a year.
Managers only ever last 18 months at best so I think it's worth appointing managers with this kind of thinking. Get someone in for a short term job then see where you are in 18 months and appoint what is required at that stage. It's the way Southampton do it and has worked for them. the days of a long term manager are long gone |  | | |
| QPR speak to Holloway (WLS) on 12:33 - Nov 8 with 6579 views | Mytch_QPR |
| QPR speak to Holloway (WLS) on 12:27 - Nov 8 by daveB |
He did struggle at Millwall and in the end at Palace but he's had a break now and I think he could be quite good.
Warnock was on Danny Baker show the other week and was asked what you do when you go into these clubs mid season, he said you add a sense of humour. He was saying they can all play and you can work all week on tactics etc but players are not robots and if you add some humour to things people enjoy their work and end up working harder. It's a basic approach and is hardly the answer to everything but our team for the last 3 years have looked like one who hate playing football and find no joy from it. Holloway coming in and making it fun for the players might be something that helps bring better more relaxed performances.
Of course it could go the other way as well but why not try it?
Realistically whoever comes in we're going to be mid table at best, possibly a relegation battle if it starts badly and i think what Holloway would do is lift the place a bit and get fans onside.
Long term I don't think it would work but long term i don't think any manager works these days, if we'd given it to Warnock plenty would be wanting him out within a year.
Managers only ever last 18 months at best so I think it's worth appointing managers with this kind of thinking. Get someone in for a short term job then see where you are in 18 months and appoint what is required at that stage. It's the way Southampton do it and has worked for them. the days of a long term manager are long gone |
I think your last point may be while the club are (hopefully) stalling on smug Tim (or why he is reported to be out of the running) - I suspect he's after a large salary and at least a 3 year deal. If the fans turn against him quickly then it's going to be a very expensive mistake. |  |
| |
| QPR speak to Holloway (WLS) on 12:34 - Nov 8 with 6574 views | Antti_Heinola |
| QPR speak to Holloway (WLS) on 12:27 - Nov 8 by daveB |
He did struggle at Millwall and in the end at Palace but he's had a break now and I think he could be quite good.
Warnock was on Danny Baker show the other week and was asked what you do when you go into these clubs mid season, he said you add a sense of humour. He was saying they can all play and you can work all week on tactics etc but players are not robots and if you add some humour to things people enjoy their work and end up working harder. It's a basic approach and is hardly the answer to everything but our team for the last 3 years have looked like one who hate playing football and find no joy from it. Holloway coming in and making it fun for the players might be something that helps bring better more relaxed performances.
Of course it could go the other way as well but why not try it?
Realistically whoever comes in we're going to be mid table at best, possibly a relegation battle if it starts badly and i think what Holloway would do is lift the place a bit and get fans onside.
Long term I don't think it would work but long term i don't think any manager works these days, if we'd given it to Warnock plenty would be wanting him out within a year.
Managers only ever last 18 months at best so I think it's worth appointing managers with this kind of thinking. Get someone in for a short term job then see where you are in 18 months and appoint what is required at that stage. It's the way Southampton do it and has worked for them. the days of a long term manager are long gone |
I don't think you can compare it to Southampton Dave! They lose managers in general because they are doing well! When was the last time we had a manager poached? I know a couple sniffed round Ollie (and he had a very good sniff back with Leicester, Wolves and Plymouth, must be said) but other than that? Gerry?
Agree we need a character though. That's why I'm extremely leery about Clement. | |
| |
| QPR speak to Holloway (WLS) on 12:39 - Nov 8 with 6531 views | FDC |
| QPR speak to Holloway (WLS) on 12:33 - Nov 8 by Mytch_QPR |
I think your last point may be while the club are (hopefully) stalling on smug Tim (or why he is reported to be out of the running) - I suspect he's after a large salary and at least a 3 year deal. If the fans turn against him quickly then it's going to be a very expensive mistake. |
Yeah I think McIntyre mentioned something about salary demands being an issue -- although that may have been last time round. |  | | |
Login to get fewer ads
| QPR speak to Holloway (WLS) on 12:42 - Nov 8 with 6509 views | Antti_Heinola |
If it was Ollie - who would be his assistant? Would Birch come back from the States? Furs? | |
| |
| QPR speak to Holloway (WLS) on 12:43 - Nov 8 with 6502 views | CamberleyR |
| QPR speak to Holloway (WLS) on 12:34 - Nov 8 by Antti_Heinola |
I don't think you can compare it to Southampton Dave! They lose managers in general because they are doing well! When was the last time we had a manager poached? I know a couple sniffed round Ollie (and he had a very good sniff back with Leicester, Wolves and Plymouth, must be said) but other than that? Gerry?
Agree we need a character though. That's why I'm extremely leery about Clement. |
Gerry was a free agent after resigning after the Rodney Marsh incident. If memory serves, Jim Smith would be the last. |  |
| |
| QPR speak to Holloway (WLS) on 12:45 - Nov 8 with 6470 views | nadera78 |
The last six months of Holloway's time at QPR was very poor - hoofing the ball up the pitch, stacks of loan players coming in, a constant chopping and changing of players. He'd really run his race with us at that point. When he later had that success at Blackpool he himself admitted that he'd been forced to re-assess his approach to the game. I absolutely thought it was time for him to go.
And I'd agree with others that he looked completely shot in his last couple of jobs.
The question I'd ask about appointing him now is this: what's the end game? Is it a serious attempt to push the club forward or is it simply a short term appointment that the owners hope might appease some of our fans? |  | | |
| QPR speak to Holloway (WLS) on 12:46 - Nov 8 with 6458 views | daveB |
| QPR speak to Holloway (WLS) on 12:34 - Nov 8 by Antti_Heinola |
I don't think you can compare it to Southampton Dave! They lose managers in general because they are doing well! When was the last time we had a manager poached? I know a couple sniffed round Ollie (and he had a very good sniff back with Leicester, Wolves and Plymouth, must be said) but other than that? Gerry?
Agree we need a character though. That's why I'm extremely leery about Clement. |
not really comparing us just saying they hire managers for what is needed at the time rather than a grand long plan. They did it with Pardew, Adkins then Poccatinio and were ruthless about it. I don't think it's a mad idea to do similar and at the moment a rabble rouser is required imo | | | |
| QPR speak to Holloway (WLS) on 12:48 - Nov 8 with 6442 views | daveB |
| QPR speak to Holloway (WLS) on 12:42 - Nov 8 by Antti_Heinola |
If it was Ollie - who would be his assistant? Would Birch come back from the States? Furs? |
A coaching staff including the Gallens, Bircham and Des Bulpin, Putting the band back together again. Come on you know you want this | | | |
| QPR speak to Holloway (WLS) on 12:50 - Nov 8 with 6426 views | ingeminate |
| QPR speak to Holloway (WLS) on 12:42 - Nov 8 by Antti_Heinola |
If it was Ollie - who would be his assistant? Would Birch come back from the States? Furs? |
Holloway, birch furs doesn't sound too bad to be fair. It's just that he has seen so broken by football management it's tough to know if he could maintain his enthusiasm if/when we went through a rough patch. |  |
| |
| QPR speak to Holloway (WLS) on 12:58 - Nov 8 with 6359 views | WrightUp5hit___ |
Would be very much in two minds about Olly, love him and would hate to see him being shredded if a return was unsuccessful.
On the other hand IF he could get of to a good start, he just might be able to generate that "feel good" thing and he could thrive on that himself.
He would need the support around him but just due to his previous relationship at Loftus Road surely that would be other ex R's. Birch? and why has Steve Gallen just resigned his role at Hong Kong Pegasus? |  | | |
| QPR speak to Holloway (WLS) on 12:59 - Nov 8 with 6353 views | simmo |
To be fair, we're a mid-table, functional team that has mostly basic players with a smattering of quality. We want hard work but with an emphasis on attacking (even if it's mostly rudimentary) and whilst we're fine to not have to win all the time, we do want to be competitive and bloody the noses of the big boys from time to time.
That sounds like an Olly team, right? | |
| ask Beavis I get nothing Butthead |
| |
| QPR speak to Holloway (WLS) on 13:03 - Nov 8 with 6302 views | Nov77 |
Id love to witness training and seeing 'today is a woof day' translated for our polish players! |  |
| |
| QPR speak to Holloway (WLS) on 13:04 - Nov 8 with 6298 views | Antti_Heinola |
| QPR speak to Holloway (WLS) on 12:48 - Nov 8 by daveB |
A coaching staff including the Gallens, Bircham and Des Bulpin, Putting the band back together again. Come on you know you want this |
I love Kev. But, er, no. Can't bring myself to say it. I'm a coward. And I still love him.
Would love Steve and Joe back though! | |
| |
| QPR speak to Holloway (WLS) on 13:07 - Nov 8 with 6273 views | Nov77 |
| QPR speak to Holloway (WLS) on 12:59 - Nov 8 by simmo |
To be fair, we're a mid-table, functional team that has mostly basic players with a smattering of quality. We want hard work but with an emphasis on attacking (even if it's mostly rudimentary) and whilst we're fine to not have to win all the time, we do want to be competitive and bloody the noses of the big boys from time to time.
That sounds like an Olly team, right? |
No , an Ollie team was made up of English characters like bircham, ainsworth etc who bought into his madness.
Our current Carlos kickaballs would probably think he's an idiot. | |
| |
| QPR speak to Holloway (WLS) on 13:08 - Nov 8 with 6268 views | BostonR |
| QPR speak to Holloway (WLS) on 12:13 - Nov 8 by essextaxiboy |
Agree . I havnt enjoyed being a Fan as much as when Ollie was here .
There were 3 main critics on here ,only BostonR remains I think . Trying to think who the others were. Maybe they would like to fess up ? Smiffy (RIP) used to row with them for hours
I fear for him if he comes back , he called himself in at Palace and would get no time before the critics old and new were at him .
It wouldnt be boring though if he still has gas in the tank
Edit
Just watched a couple of interviews with him near the end , he looked exhausted . [Post edited 8 Nov 2016 12:23]
|
Mea culpa on Holloway.
As Clive reminds me, I actually wanted us to lose at Luton so the club could move him on - which eventually they did. I acknowledge the positives that he brought to the club during his time as manager, but his last 9 months were truly awful in football terms. He just decided to hoof it every week! |  | | |
| QPR speak to Holloway (WLS) on 13:10 - Nov 8 with 6245 views | daveB |
| QPR speak to Holloway (WLS) on 13:04 - Nov 8 by Antti_Heinola |
I love Kev. But, er, no. Can't bring myself to say it. I'm a coward. And I still love him.
Would love Steve and Joe back though! |
Whoever gets the job will eventually fail, Holloway and Warnock did last time if you judge them on the last 6 months.
I'd honestly love it if he came back and I know it won't happen | | | |
| QPR speak to Holloway (WLS) on 13:15 - Nov 8 with 6209 views | CFW |
I hope there is no truth in this - like most people on here love the man - really funny, nice guy etc but
he like Warnock etc are yesterdays men. I was disappointed that it did not work out for JFH as he was a young new manager who was on the up (not many around that is the problem) and we were looking
forward as a club.
This appointment is really interesting and will have huge implications on our football club. No matter who it is there will be baggage. Sherwood the Spurs connection, being sacked twice already and apart from standing on the touchline gobbing off or celebrating a goal like it is the final of the world cup I really do not see what he offers or can offer in the future.
Clement is another who has huge question marks over him and wished I had not read some of the threads posted on here as it has given me huge doubts over his ability as a manager - not as a coach but that is different. You should not be hired because of sentiment - look at Bryan Robson & Roy Keane great players awful managers.
Now not sure who I want perhaps Big Sam - he has the experience but why would he come to QPR? ok MONEY!!!! | | | |
| QPR speak to Holloway (WLS) on 13:20 - Nov 8 with 6159 views | QPR_John |
| QPR speak to Holloway (WLS) on 13:10 - Nov 8 by daveB |
Whoever gets the job will eventually fail, Holloway and Warnock did last time if you judge them on the last 6 months.
I'd honestly love it if he came back and I know it won't happen |
Surely that is the fate of all managers, with notable exceptions, to fail eventually | | | |
| QPR speak to Holloway (WLS) on 13:21 - Nov 8 with 6155 views | YorkRanger |
Like Holloway and good memories of his time at Rangers, but I really do not see him as the answer now. |  | | |
| QPR speak to Holloway (WLS) on 13:25 - Nov 8 with 6124 views | 18StoneOfHoop |
| QPR speak to Holloway (WLS) on 13:08 - Nov 8 by BostonR |
Mea culpa on Holloway.
As Clive reminds me, I actually wanted us to lose at Luton so the club could move him on - which eventually they did. I acknowledge the positives that he brought to the club during his time as manager, but his last 9 months were truly awful in football terms. He just decided to hoof it every week! |
Set a club record of 7 straight wins and got Rosie leaping off the sick-bed and playing the best football of his life at left-back is what I remember more than the hoofs,Boston.
Mugged off on gardening leave by Gianni for speaking to Leicester
"A man who is happy with his wife,don't go looking.."
Having said that Gerry the second time was not exactly a barrel of laughs. #NeverGoBack
The home and away 'Wall fans I met at Madness on Clapham Common in
the summer I couldn't believe the level of hatred and vituperation they felt for Ollie.
Think he's jumped the shark football management wise and should stick to
the money-for-old-rope Bristolian cheeky chappy Sky punditry role. |  |
| 'I'm 18 with a bullet.Got my finger on the trigger,I'm gonna pull it.."
Love,Peace and Fook Chelski!
More like 20StoneOfHoop now.
Let's face it I'm not getting any thinner.
Pass the cake and pies please. |
| |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
