Please log in or register. Registered visitors get fewer ads.
Queens Park Rangers 1 v 1 Luton Town
Carabao Cup
Tuesday, 27th August 2024 Kick-off 19:45
Southampton At Cardiff The Carabao Cup Verdict
Thursday, 29th Aug 2024 13:20

Saints dominated the first half at the Cardiff City Stadium only to lose their way a bit in the second half, before a late rally snatched victory from the jaws of a penalty shootout, so what were the plus and minus points of this game ?

Before we start let us be clear about what this game was, it was always about the second string of both sides, but you can only play what is in front of you and so their is nothing to be gained from just dismissing this victory as something that should have been comprehensive but wasn't.

We started well taking the lead after only 10 minutes, Tyler Dibling surged forward and laid a nice ball for Matteus Fernandes who fired home a well taken goal.

That lead lasted 10 minutes before Rubin Colwill fired home a dipping swerving shot that Ronaldo would have been proud of, let alone our own Le God.

10 minutes later we were back in front, Sam Amo-Ameyaw firing home another well taken goal after a very intricate build up.

So at half time there looked like their would only be one winner, initially Saints strutted but were shaken when Joe Lumley attempted to punch out a cross, only for it to hit Ronnie Edwards and go in.

No matter 7 minutes later Cameron Archer showed why he was signed for his finishing after taking a Matteus Fernandes pass, now we would cruise home, but no, the lead lasted just 2 minutes before Cardiff equalised for the 3rd time on 57 minutes.

Saints were shaken and Cardiff seemed to gain the upper hand for a while, Adam Lallana & Armel Bella-Kotchap came on and steadied the ship, but Cardiff were the ,more lively, just as the game entered injury time, suddenly it changed, James Bree firing home a superb volley to give Saints the lead, but could the Bluebirds come back for a fourth time ?

The Answer was no, and it was sealed when Tyler Dibling got his second assist of the evening and Cameron Archer swivelled and fired home.

Perhaps the most pleasing stats of the night though, were firstly all five goals were from those who had never scored for the club, before this game and not only that but the same could be said for all of the assists, none of those providing the ball for the chance had provided an assist for the club before this fixture.

That augurs well for the future and although yes the cynics will say this was against Cardiff reserves, you still have to finish the chance off and all five goals were cracking finishes.

So what will Russell Martin have learned from this, firstly we need a new keeper, Joe Lumley was good with his feet and didn't do a lot wrong, but he is not a Premier League keeper.

At the back James Bree was strong and consistent and is a good squad player.

The two central defenders had mixed nights, Nathan Jones looked good, but then again he is experienced at this level, Ronnie Edwards seemed to struggle a bit, but he is one for the future.

Charlie Taylor had an excellent game, he had poise & composure when defending and knew hoe to make the runs and passes going forward, this is going to be a difficult decision to make for Russell Martin as he needs to consider the fact that he cannot play Jack Stephens ahead of Taylor, the ex Burnley player was Captain on the night and is a natural leader.

In midfield Les Ugochukwu seemed to be finding his feet, he looked fast and strong but he also looked rusty, understandable when you take into account that he has only played 3 games totalling 85 minutes on the pitch since the end of November.

He wasn't great, but you feel that he will be, so we can't pass judgement just yet.

Tyler Dibling was immense, he has the ability to carry the ball and use his strength to shrug off tackles, he knows how to use the ball and you feel he could be a big player this season.

Likewise Matteus Fernandes, he scored a cracking goal and set up another, he buzzed around and was a great link between midfield and attack.

From the attacking perspective, Sam Edozie had a lot of the ball, but his issue is the end product, too many times he didn't take the time to cross but cut back and at others did cross but rarely found the intended target. He can have a part to play and is still young.

Sam Amo-Ameyaw was very good first half and a great goal to his name, but he faded a little as the game went on, he will be useful as an impact player this season and he will mature into a great player given his young age.

Cameron Archer was an unknown quantity to be honest and in his first two appearances, he lacked service, but he got it last night and finished two of them with aplomb, yes some will say it was against a Cardiff reserve side, but you still have to beat your man and get a shot in and then get it on target, he showed that given the chances he can score.

Off the bench perhaps saw some surprising plus points, the 3 youngsters who came on were just getting game time and a taster, but the big highlight was the way that Adam Lallana came on and pulled the strings..

In the first two league games people bemoaned the fact that we did not get the ball to the forwards quickly enough, but Lallana showed a difference in class, but we all knew that.

I doubt whether he will be a regular starter at his age, but his experience will be vital in the final third of quite a few games this season.

Armel Bella-Kotchap looked strong and to be honest could give Russell Martin an unexpected extra weapon in the armoury, I would seriously consider playing him in the centre of the defence at Brentford on Saturday.

So yes, lets not get carried away, this after all was not against a great side, but in games like these you have to look beyond the result and pick out the plus points, there were a few to see last night and I can see a few changes in the starting line up on Saturday, as well as some strength on the bench.


Photo: imago via reuters



Please report offensive, libellous or inappropriate posts by using the links provided.



WestSussexSaint added 13:25 - Aug 29
Good write up so it seems a little churlish to point out it was Nathan Wood in defence and not Nathan Jones (God help us!).
0

I_would added 13:35 - Aug 29
Very good report.
3

131153 added 13:39 - Aug 29
Good game to watch and feel of the 8 goals only the OG could have easily been avoided. All in all feel the game proved the depth of the squad, not all would step in and do a great job, but none would be a big liability.
1

HythePeer added 13:48 - Aug 29
Some of the attacking players need to be in the first eleven.
8

Colburn added 13:48 - Aug 29
Assuming Fernandes is going to start in place of Aribo or Smallbone on Saturday as he came off early last night. And thus Archer and Dibling will both be on the bench again. I hope we don’t play without a central striker again on Saturday.
Taylor does look good but when will he be in instead of KWP at left back? Unless Sugawara misses out. I think we expected to lose Kyle and now we have too many to please. Will Manning go?
0

Bowlercow added 13:57 - Aug 29
Much the same thoughts as I had about this game Nick I think archer and Ramirez will start on Saturday probably in place of Small one and Aribo Big Les Tyler and Sam Amo to get 20 minutes for the next few games All of them looked leggy at the end
Some good creative work and defense splitting passes it makes you wonder if it would have been better to keep ,Dom Ballard and develop him at home
2

ItchenNorth added 14:00 - Aug 29
Didn't learn too much from last night.

If you've ever seen Archer play before, ya know he's a clinical finisher. I'm not sure where this comment about him being an unknown quantity comes from. Speak to any Villa or Boro fan and they'll tell you he's quality. He has to start in the 9 in the Premier League.

Fernandes looked quality again and should start over Smallbone in the 8 in the Premier League.

The main surprise was the quality of Lallana. His touch and eye for the pass was excellent.

Apart from that (and Dibling) the other players were and will largely be second string and it showed.
1

Monksway added 14:06 - Aug 29
I think ABK despite his obvious talents burnt his boats last year when he made it clear he wanted to leave and had no intention of playing with Saints in the championship. I think RM places great store on team spirit, character etc and I think it would send a very bad message to the squad if ABK played against Brentford. Yesterday was simply a shop window display to show he is fit having failed the medical. I wonder whether Ralph might take him at Wolfsburg as they appear to have lost their CB to Palace.
-1

IanRC added 14:12 - Aug 29
Better, but come on Sports Republic, sign the Corinthians striker to give us some cheer.
1

IanRC added 14:18 - Aug 29
Thought Lallana was good going forward but BK did well to bail him out from one dreadful back pass to nobody.
0

pintsizedsaint added 14:55 - Aug 29
Lallana looked excellent when he came on, the difference in his vision for Defence splitting passes is stark. dibbling looks good form for this too
0

halftimeorange added 15:15 - Aug 29
I'm glad James Bree got some positive words in this report. I've always thought he's a tidy player and, whilst not possessing exceptional skills, is a useful guy to provide cover when necessary. Edozie was openly wasteful again last night and we can't afford crosses to no-one. Agreed that Archer should start as a number 9 in our next game. Amo-Ameyaw was a constant nuisance, but did lose the ball a fair amount. I thought Dibling started well but, faded out of the game until late second half. Fernandes looks to be the real thing. I wonder if RM has taken Colwill's name down in his Christmas wish list.
4

ElSanto added 15:23 - Aug 29
Back on the Southampton roller-coaster we go for another season of ups and downs and round and rounds.

Who else would you rather support.

COYS!!!!!!!! <3
1

Farlow added 16:07 - Aug 29
I Thought ABK looked a class above any defender on the pitch and i,d love to see him alongside Harwood Bellis.I Was,nt too impressed with our new central defenders
but Bree and Charly Taylor did well.I Think weve bought a couple of good youngsters.
The Chelsea loanee is going to be a bit special when he,s up to speed.A good bit of
power to add to the lineup.

1

Block8 added 16:50 - Aug 29
Strange I thought Edwards looked comfortable and confident on the ball and made some good choices & with the ball at his feet only lost possession once?
We were a bit more positive in our passing decisions and agree Fernades looks good. Great to see Bree get a goal, I like him, he is a good honest defender and I don't think he would let us down should he be picked. Tyler is a youngster who will need time to build & learn to pace himself better. And totally agree with halftime orange Colwill looked impressive all game!
1

Boris1977 added 17:37 - Aug 29
Last night's game reminded me of last season i.e. we've got a decent championship side that makes hard work of what should be routine victories.

A cup run would be great and the draw has been kind to us as Everton have only 1 focus this season and it won't be the milk cup

Coyrs
2

JoeEgg added 18:16 - Aug 29
Not quite sure why so many have taken to commenting on the Cardiff match. This match bares no resemblance whatsoever to a Premier League game which is all the excuse that Russell Martin needs to roll out Stephens, Smallbone, Manning and co on Saturday. Scoring five against Cardiff Reserves will also count for nothing if the manager persists in playing all his forwards wide with no experienced centre forward.
2


You need to login in order to post your comments

Blogs 31 bloggers

Knees-up Mother Brown #22 by wessex_exile

Luton Town Polls

About Us Contact Us Terms & Conditions Privacy Cookies Advertising
© FansNetwork 2024