Forum | derry appeal thrown out by wombat |

Forum index | Previous Thread | Next thread

derry appeal thrown out 15:59 - Apr 10 with 6005 views

wombat

no supprise there .

Poll:

which is your favouite foot

derry appeal thrown out on 22:45 - Apr 10 with 652 views

WanderR

derry appeal thrown out on 17:01 - Apr 10 by Trom
There's something very wrong when even the opponents think the decision is wrong http://www.redcafe.net/f7/fa-reject-shaun-derrys-appeal-red-card-351592/

100 messages on that thread and virtually to a man they are all supportive of Derry.

Current location: OX10

derry appeal thrown out on 22:52 - Apr 10 with 645 views

Watford_Ranger

derry appeal thrown out on 22:45 - Apr 10 by WanderR
100 messages on that thread and virtually to a man they are all supportive of Derry.

Quite easy after the event with three points in the bag.

derry appeal thrown out on 23:54 - Apr 10 with 604 views

W7Ranger

derry appeal thrown out on 21:24 - Apr 10 by Jamie

Gallagher did his usual round up yesterday and to quote him:

'I don't think it's a foul but Lee's seen it and given it'

SSN bloke: 'shouldn't he discuss with his assistant and give himself some thinking time before producing a red?'

'No, if he gives himself thinking time people will assume he's being influenced by being at Old Trafford. Lee's seen a foul and done brilliantly to make the decision and give the red card so quickly'

Word for word.

Well done Lee!!

derry appeal thrown out on 01:16 - Apr 11 with 571 views

Pacy23

So the question is whether the FA now encouraging diving by stating that the minimal contact on Ashley Young actually does deserve a red card, after he had knocked the ball away from goal and outside his area of control?

The thought that two of their employees could have got two decisions incorrect in a matter of seconds (also a clear off-side decision) appears to have been lost on the FA. Then they round the wagons to protect their own with an incorrect appeal decision.

I was always thought two wrongs do not make a right, but perhaps the FA feel that three wrongs do!

derry appeal thrown out on 01:47 - Apr 11 with 561 views

CanadaRanger

derry appeal thrown out on 22:34 - Apr 10 by daveB
both teams should have 2 video reviews on top of goal line technology being standard. Either manager or captain decides what to review and the time it takes to review it is about the same time it takes for players to chase the ref and moan about it. If you've already used your two reviews before a Derry style incident then hard luck

Yes. Sense.
More sense than the whole FA combined.

derry appeal thrown out on 08:10 - Apr 11 with 538 views

CanadaRanger

derry appeal thrown out on 19:30 - Apr 10 by JonDoeman

What the FA don't watch on TV...
Left: Going for a Song
Right: The Young One's

Forum index | Previous Thread | Next thread