| Ferdinand Out 10:40 - Dec 27 with 9669 views | 1JD |
Recruitment is the chief responsibility of the DOF role, and at QPR it is simply not good enough.
8m spent back in Les Ferdinands first summer, 8m spent again this summer, when we finally had money again- both a complete shit show.
Contracts are also the key responsibility of the DOF role, and again, it is not good enough- Manning and BOS both walking out the door for absolute peanuts, costing the club millions of pounds in lost revenue.
Everyone can moan about the manager but we need a new and experienced DOF, fast. |  | | |  |
| Ferdinand Out on 13:37 - Dec 27 with 2426 views | PinnerPaul |
| Ferdinand Out on 11:34 - Dec 27 by 1JD |
https://anchor.fm/footballcfb/episodes/Les-Ferdinand--Newcastle--Spurs--Goals-an
Listen to that, it hardly inspires confidence. The fist 2 minutes of this he introduces his responsibilities. Recruitment and contracts. Which is the same for most DOFs.
Wages and finances are ultimately the CEO and CFO.
Manning and BOS - contract discussions should of taken place way before they “made it” and proved themselves. Instead, the DOF did it in reverse, a schoolboy error, and we are where we are. Meaning the players have the power, and not the club.
Academy is Ramsey.
Managers are the owners choice ultimately. |
Can't win though can they/he - contract offers to Nico and Kakay widely criticised as 'too much, too soon'! | | | |
| Ferdinand Out on 13:42 - Dec 27 with 2409 views | silverbirch |
| Ferdinand Out on 11:52 - Dec 27 by 1JD |
A player may not be a reliable source for the transfer fee?
Sorry, but that’s completely nonsensical. Of course they know transfer fee. They might not be concerned with the finer details of add on clauses and payment schedules but they sure as heck know the top line figure. Which was given as 2m by Bonne himself.
Even sky sports publicise total deal value as the transfer value. This is what each club has committed in revenue to the deal, whether it happens or not is another subject entirely. |
You write with such conviction, calling for the sacking of a club legend who is working in really difficult circumstances, and then you quote sky tv. | | | |
| Ferdinand Out on 13:47 - Dec 27 with 2384 views | silverbirch |
| Ferdinand Out on 11:34 - Dec 27 by 1JD |
https://anchor.fm/footballcfb/episodes/Les-Ferdinand--Newcastle--Spurs--Goals-an
Listen to that, it hardly inspires confidence. The fist 2 minutes of this he introduces his responsibilities. Recruitment and contracts. Which is the same for most DOFs.
Wages and finances are ultimately the CEO and CFO.
Manning and BOS - contract discussions should of taken place way before they “made it” and proved themselves. Instead, the DOF did it in reverse, a schoolboy error, and we are where we are. Meaning the players have the power, and not the club.
Academy is Ramsey.
Managers are the owners choice ultimately. |
Hmm...has either manning or BOS made it?
Manning made it all the way to Swansea’s bench. BOS thinking he has made it seems to be the problem. | | | |
| Ferdinand Out on 14:30 - Dec 27 with 2321 views | derbyhoop |
| Ferdinand Out on 13:21 - Dec 27 by bakerloo8 |
Sensible post, but signing League 1 players will eventually lead only one way. |
Those figure seem more realistic than the larger ones claimed.
We're hoping that players moving up from L1 (Dickie, Bonne, Thomas) are going to get better. Dykes is still trying to adapt to English football, rather than SPL.
Losing Manning on the cheap seems a mistake, despite his defensive deficiencies, but how many other clubs were in for him? Remember just over a year ago, he was a regular sub at Rotherham.
We had the chance to get £4.7m from BOS from Club Bruges but the payer or his agent refused to go. Is that our fault? |  |
| "Travel is fatal to prejudice, bigotry and narrow-mindedness, and many of our people need it sorely on these accounts. Broad, wholesome, charitable views of men and things cannot be acquired by vegetating in one little corner of the Earth all one's lifetime." (Mark Twain)
Find me on twitter @derbyhoop and now on Bluesky |
| |
| Ferdinand Out on 14:53 - Dec 27 with 2268 views | Hooping_Mad |
Contracts are not being handled well, in fact it's a bloody shambles on that front.
DOF is a former striking so coach how do we end up signing our own strikers after a 3 year wait and then settle on these two, and then tell us they don't train together !
Playing the 3rd choice keeper (no criticism of him intended) cause we've completely failed in that department again as well.
A total and complete lack of ambition, and that goes well above Les so he not culpable for that but he hasn't convinced the fan base 'he' really sees the clubs future being at a high level. Which lacks ambition and aspiration to me.
Someone mentioned they re-watched the four year plan and it made me think, last time when Amit arrived he free' d up the manager to do his thing by getting Flavio to leave 1st team affairs alone and we saw what a decent manager with backing could, this time round he inherited Les and is now just as culpable as Flavio was in not setting the club up in a manner or formula that not only does he know works but he presided over and built his reputation upon. Les may not be directly picking the team every week but he is filling it with dud's just like Flav and a Paladini
I think it's time our owners explain what the DOF role is going to deliver going forward, and if the answer is Chris Ramsey will leave if Les goes then so be it, we will just have to replace him as difficult as that may be. That is Les's attitude to everyone else after all.
Attitude and consistency does seem to be a problem, sadly the manager being a bit of a prick doesn't look like it's helping.
More of the same and Amit sticks with them both and we will go down, otherwise they both need to be gone by the end of the week.
Hate to say it but relegation maybe the medicine/business plan they need to finally get lost. Sorry but that does now include you too Amit. Unless of course you can clean this mess up, if you remember how. | |
| |
| Ferdinand Out on 15:16 - Dec 27 with 2202 views | francisbowles |
| Ferdinand Out on 13:01 - Dec 27 by bosh67 |
Most fees include an add-on for performances and promotIon (no hope of that) and sell on clause. As far as I know money actually spent was more like...
1.2m Bonne - rising to £1.75m with add-ons
1.6m Dykes - rising to £2m with add-ons and sell on clause
1.2m Dickie - rising £2m with add-ons and sell on clause
250k Willock - rising £500K with add-ons
250k Amos - rising £1m with add-ons and sell on clause
200k Kelman - rising £500K with add-ons and sell on clause
Free Thomas
Free Wallace
Thomas came on a free.
So in the region of £4.7m rather than the £7-8m quoted. That's 8 players in for less than 1 x Ivan Tonie (£5m plus add ons)... Although we should have probably just bought him instead! We got £16m now for Eze rising to £19.5m with add-ons and sell on clause. We got a pretty sad £250K for Manning (not the £150K reported).
Remembering we have lost Leistner, Hall, Pugh, Manning, Rangel, Eze, Luongo and Smith earlier on plus Wells and Hugill.
That's 10 players that kept us in this division over the past 16 months plus BOS on his way out. Lumley may well go too to reduce wages.
It's all well to shout and scream at Ferdinand but we got the world's biggest FFP fine and have had no choice but to move players on and massively reduce wages to survive. And then there is the pandemic to cope with financially.
The problem is you are having to lose experienced players at this level to survive and take in players mainly talking a step up, with almost no time to really settle. Amos is out for the season, Thomas needs a lot of minutes, yesterday was Bonne and Dykes first actual game as 2 up front, Dickie is having to step up, Kelman is a kid, Willock again has virtually no previous experience at this level, Wallace is beset with injuries and is struggling to cope at this level.
We can't spend £5m on an Ivan Tonie and afford to pay them. With the pandemic players of the calibre of Wells and Hugill are not being loaned out. There are no fans in the stadiums. Not sure if people really think about what the likes of Ferdinand, Hoos and Warburton are really expected to do given the circumstances of the club after the FFP fine and now the pandemic.
We're kind of lucky we still have a club. Others will fall. [Post edited 27 Dec 2020 13:06]
|
Great post a very accurate picture of the situation.
However, we do have huge immediate problems with no time to develop players until we can get out of them, if we can.
We need some experienced recruits and a more pragmatic approach to try and get out of this hole.
I would question whether we really need a DOF, with our financial constraints. Could the role not be split so that Chris Ramsey and Mark Warburton (or successor) share responsibility for recruitment, and report directly to the CEO. He has the responsibility for finance and could take over contracts. After all he is very experienced in football now having been at Southampton, Burnley and Leicester before us. | | | |
| Ferdinand Out on 15:18 - Dec 27 with 2183 views | bakerloo8 |
| Ferdinand Out on 14:30 - Dec 27 by derbyhoop |
Those figure seem more realistic than the larger ones claimed.
We're hoping that players moving up from L1 (Dickie, Bonne, Thomas) are going to get better. Dykes is still trying to adapt to English football, rather than SPL.
Losing Manning on the cheap seems a mistake, despite his defensive deficiencies, but how many other clubs were in for him? Remember just over a year ago, he was a regular sub at Rotherham.
We had the chance to get £4.7m from BOS from Club Bruges but the payer or his agent refused to go. Is that our fault? |
Understand all that but if you suppliment L1 additions with kids from the academy and not experienced high level pros then you will more than likely get relegated, and the players with any potential will be off anyway.
If nothing changes then we are staring down the barrel. Someone is culpable for the mess we find ourselves in and the wishy washy vague responsibilities of management at the club is a full joke. |  | | |
| Ferdinand Out on 15:46 - Dec 27 with 2107 views | charmr |
Mike Rigg and his cronies with their over inflated egos and only after a paycheck with fchk all respect for the clubs history, culture and identity.
How did that go? [Post edited 27 Dec 2020 15:49]
| | | |
Login to get fewer ads
| Ferdinand Out on 15:59 - Dec 27 with 2069 views | charmr |
As soon as Gregory was gone Rangers became a mistress that people just took from. It attracted takers and it found takers.
The community department got the wheels turning at the grassroots level and under Hoos and co the boardroom level.
It had to change. What has changed is protests are not now on the pitch or outside the main entrance of the stadium but on keypads. | | | |
| Ferdinand Out on 23:17 - Dec 27 with 1885 views | daveB |
For what it's worth I think what Ferdinand has tried to do in developing players, signing low and selling high etc is the right way to do things but I don't think anyone can say we've done a good enough job at implementing that. We've got some right but a lot more wrong and for us to succeed doing this you can't make many mistakes in the transfer market and we make too many.
I also think we've become a little too obsessed with player development and less concerned with improving the team, the two can go hand in hand but haven't with us.
I'd be surprised if Ferdinand is still at the club next season however this season pans out, I'm not sure if thats a good or bad thing anymore. |  | | |
| Ferdinand Out on 23:37 - Dec 27 with 1854 views | PunteR |
| Ferdinand Out on 23:17 - Dec 27 by daveB |
For what it's worth I think what Ferdinand has tried to do in developing players, signing low and selling high etc is the right way to do things but I don't think anyone can say we've done a good enough job at implementing that. We've got some right but a lot more wrong and for us to succeed doing this you can't make many mistakes in the transfer market and we make too many.
I also think we've become a little too obsessed with player development and less concerned with improving the team, the two can go hand in hand but haven't with us.
I'd be surprised if Ferdinand is still at the club next season however this season pans out, I'm not sure if thats a good or bad thing anymore. |
FWIW i think this is a good post. |  |
| Occasional providers of half decent House music. |
| |
| Ferdinand Out on 23:45 - Dec 27 with 1837 views | distortR |
| Ferdinand Out on 23:37 - Dec 27 by PunteR |
FWIW i think this is a good post. |
fwiw, good to see you back posting! | | | |
| Ferdinand Out on 00:04 - Dec 28 with 1811 views | FredManRave |
| Ferdinand Out on 23:45 - Dec 27 by distortR |
fwiw, good to see you back posting! |
FWIW I think this is a good post. |  |
| |
| Ferdinand Out on 02:05 - Dec 28 with 1748 views | superhoopdownunder |
Below are the permanent signings made whilst Ferdinand has been our Director of Football since early in 2015.
Only a very few successes out of 88 permanent signings
Season Player Cost
2015-16 George Butler Trainee
2015-16 Nathan Corkery Trainee
2015-16 Jay Emmanuel-Thomas Free transfer
2015-16 Ben Gladwin Undisclosed
2015-16 Osman Kakay Trainee
2015-16 Massimo Luongo Undisclosed
2015-16 Jamie Mackie Free transfer
2015-16 Joseph N'Guessan Free transfer
2015-16 Axel Prohouly Free transfer
2015-16 Olamide Shodipo Trainee
2015-16 Sebastian Polter £1,000,000
2015-16 Tjaronn Chery £2,250,000
2015-16 James Perch Undisclosed
2015-16 Tyler Blackwood Free transfer
2015-16 Oscar Gobern Free transfer
2015-16 Grant Hall Undisclosed
2015-16 Alex Smithies Undisclosed
2015-16 Tom Rosenthal Undisclosed
2015-16 Dániel TÅ‘zsér Free transfer
2015-16 Joshua Wallen Free transfer
2015-16 Conor Washington $3,000,000
2015-16 Matt Ingram Undisclosed
2015-16 Abdenasser El Khayati £350,000
2016-17 Jake Bidwell Undisclosed
2016-17 Ariel Borysiuk £1,500,000
2016-17 Conor Hudnott Trainee
2016-17 Joel Lynch £1,200,000
2016-17 Chris Paul Free transfer
2016-17 Jordan Cousins £1,250,000
2016-17 Eberechi Eze Free transfer
2016-17 Yeni Ngbakoto Undisclosed
2016-17 Seny Dieng Free transfer
2016-17 Idrissa Sylla Undisclosed
2016-17 Alex Finney Free transfer
2016-17 Danny Rowe Free transfer
2016-17 Brandon Adams Trainee
2016-17 Sean Goss £500,000
2016-17 Luke Freeman £350,000
2016-17 Matt Smith £1,000,000
2016-17 Paweł Wszołek Undisclosed
2016-17 Ilias Chair Unknown
2016-17 Josh Bowler Trainee
2016-17 Marcin Brzozowski Trainee
2016-17 Dan Darbyshire Trainee
2016-17 Odysseus Alfa Trainee
2016-17 Aramide Oteh Free transfer
2017-18 Charlie Owens Free
2017-18 Giles Phillips Free
2017-18 Josh Scowen Free
2017-18 Chay Tilt Free
2017-18 Alex Baptiste Free
2017-18 Paul Smyth Undisclosed
2017-18 David Wheeler £500,000
2017-18 Bright Osayi-Samuel Undisclosed
2017-18 Zenon Stylianides Free
2017-18 Deshane Dalling Free
2018-19 Joe Felix Free transfer
2018-19 Charlie Fox Trainee
2018-19 Toni Leistner Free transfer
2018-19 Ben Wells Free transfer
2018-19 Ali Omar Free transfer
2018-19 Àngel Rangel Free transfer
2018-19 Charlie Rowan Free transfer
2018-19 Lewis Walker Free transfer
2018-19 Franklin Domi Free transfer
2019-20 Yoann Barbet Free
2019-20 Dylan Duncan Free
2019-20 Liam Kelly £50,000
2019-20 Lee Wallace Free
2019-20 Dominic Ball Free
2019-20 Conor Masterson Free
2019-20 Dillon Barnes Free
2019-20 Geoff Cameron Free
2019-20 Todd Kane Free
2019-20 Marc Pugh Free
2019-20 Stephen Duke-McKenna Free
2019-20 Marco Harboe Ramkilde Free
2020-21 George Thomas Free transfer
2020-21 Luke Amos £700,000
2020-21 Lyndon Dykes £2,000,000
2020-21 Rob Dickie £1,500,000
2020-21 Tom Carroll Free transfer
2020-21 Macauley Bonne £2,000,000
2020-21 Albert Adomah Free transfer
2020-21 Chris Willock £750,000
2020-21 Charlie Kelman £300,000
2020-21 Manasse Mampala Free transfer
2020-21 Sinclair Armstrong Undisclosed
Our League positions since he became DoF (he took over when we were 17th in EPL)
2014-15 20th in EPL
2015-16 12th in Championship
2016-17 18th
2017-18 16th
2018-19 19th
2019-20 13th
2020-21 Currently 19th in Championship
We are only going one way and that is not up.
We have changed managers quite a few times and still are performing the same so it can't be the manager.
The only other common denominators since 2015 are Les Ferdinand, Lee Hoos and the Owners.
I believe Lee Hoos has done a terrific job improving our financial position each season.
Whatever we think of the Owners they are still paying the bills and contributing each month to keep us in existence.
Unfortunately they don't seem too interested in the club anymore.
Ideally Amit would be more hands on and then we would not need a DoF.
The DoF role in my opinion is not required (could be covered by Amit and Lee Hoos) and not supported through the transfers above and our ongoing decline through a poor squad and results.
In my opinion Ferdinand has had 6 years to improve matters and he has not. He has bought poor players, many costing us a lot of money.
We still don't have good full backs, a quality central midfielder or a goalscorer.
He has recruited managers that have not met the mark or followed a clear direction. Each manager changes strategy - which should be set by the DoF.
Les Ferdinand is a far bigger problem than Warburton and needs to be sacked now. [Post edited 28 Dec 2020 2:10]
| | | |
| Ferdinand Out on 02:19 - Dec 28 with 1734 views | Nov77 |
We need Bernie and Flavio back!  |  |
| |
| Ferdinand Out (n/t) on 02:37 - Dec 28 with 1712 views | Sharpy36 |
[Post edited 28 Dec 2020 2:38]
|  |
| 'You didn't know that was wrong, but now you do. If you do it again, I'll know you are doing it on purpose.' |
| |
| Ferdinand Out on 02:43 - Dec 28 with 1704 views | Sharpy36 |
| Ferdinand Out on 02:05 - Dec 28 by superhoopdownunder |
Below are the permanent signings made whilst Ferdinand has been our Director of Football since early in 2015.
Only a very few successes out of 88 permanent signings
Season Player Cost
2015-16 George Butler Trainee
2015-16 Nathan Corkery Trainee
2015-16 Jay Emmanuel-Thomas Free transfer
2015-16 Ben Gladwin Undisclosed
2015-16 Osman Kakay Trainee
2015-16 Massimo Luongo Undisclosed
2015-16 Jamie Mackie Free transfer
2015-16 Joseph N'Guessan Free transfer
2015-16 Axel Prohouly Free transfer
2015-16 Olamide Shodipo Trainee
2015-16 Sebastian Polter £1,000,000
2015-16 Tjaronn Chery £2,250,000
2015-16 James Perch Undisclosed
2015-16 Tyler Blackwood Free transfer
2015-16 Oscar Gobern Free transfer
2015-16 Grant Hall Undisclosed
2015-16 Alex Smithies Undisclosed
2015-16 Tom Rosenthal Undisclosed
2015-16 Dániel TÅ‘zsér Free transfer
2015-16 Joshua Wallen Free transfer
2015-16 Conor Washington $3,000,000
2015-16 Matt Ingram Undisclosed
2015-16 Abdenasser El Khayati £350,000
2016-17 Jake Bidwell Undisclosed
2016-17 Ariel Borysiuk £1,500,000
2016-17 Conor Hudnott Trainee
2016-17 Joel Lynch £1,200,000
2016-17 Chris Paul Free transfer
2016-17 Jordan Cousins £1,250,000
2016-17 Eberechi Eze Free transfer
2016-17 Yeni Ngbakoto Undisclosed
2016-17 Seny Dieng Free transfer
2016-17 Idrissa Sylla Undisclosed
2016-17 Alex Finney Free transfer
2016-17 Danny Rowe Free transfer
2016-17 Brandon Adams Trainee
2016-17 Sean Goss £500,000
2016-17 Luke Freeman £350,000
2016-17 Matt Smith £1,000,000
2016-17 Paweł Wszołek Undisclosed
2016-17 Ilias Chair Unknown
2016-17 Josh Bowler Trainee
2016-17 Marcin Brzozowski Trainee
2016-17 Dan Darbyshire Trainee
2016-17 Odysseus Alfa Trainee
2016-17 Aramide Oteh Free transfer
2017-18 Charlie Owens Free
2017-18 Giles Phillips Free
2017-18 Josh Scowen Free
2017-18 Chay Tilt Free
2017-18 Alex Baptiste Free
2017-18 Paul Smyth Undisclosed
2017-18 David Wheeler £500,000
2017-18 Bright Osayi-Samuel Undisclosed
2017-18 Zenon Stylianides Free
2017-18 Deshane Dalling Free
2018-19 Joe Felix Free transfer
2018-19 Charlie Fox Trainee
2018-19 Toni Leistner Free transfer
2018-19 Ben Wells Free transfer
2018-19 Ali Omar Free transfer
2018-19 Àngel Rangel Free transfer
2018-19 Charlie Rowan Free transfer
2018-19 Lewis Walker Free transfer
2018-19 Franklin Domi Free transfer
2019-20 Yoann Barbet Free
2019-20 Dylan Duncan Free
2019-20 Liam Kelly £50,000
2019-20 Lee Wallace Free
2019-20 Dominic Ball Free
2019-20 Conor Masterson Free
2019-20 Dillon Barnes Free
2019-20 Geoff Cameron Free
2019-20 Todd Kane Free
2019-20 Marc Pugh Free
2019-20 Stephen Duke-McKenna Free
2019-20 Marco Harboe Ramkilde Free
2020-21 George Thomas Free transfer
2020-21 Luke Amos £700,000
2020-21 Lyndon Dykes £2,000,000
2020-21 Rob Dickie £1,500,000
2020-21 Tom Carroll Free transfer
2020-21 Macauley Bonne £2,000,000
2020-21 Albert Adomah Free transfer
2020-21 Chris Willock £750,000
2020-21 Charlie Kelman £300,000
2020-21 Manasse Mampala Free transfer
2020-21 Sinclair Armstrong Undisclosed
Our League positions since he became DoF (he took over when we were 17th in EPL)
2014-15 20th in EPL
2015-16 12th in Championship
2016-17 18th
2017-18 16th
2018-19 19th
2019-20 13th
2020-21 Currently 19th in Championship
We are only going one way and that is not up.
We have changed managers quite a few times and still are performing the same so it can't be the manager.
The only other common denominators since 2015 are Les Ferdinand, Lee Hoos and the Owners.
I believe Lee Hoos has done a terrific job improving our financial position each season.
Whatever we think of the Owners they are still paying the bills and contributing each month to keep us in existence.
Unfortunately they don't seem too interested in the club anymore.
Ideally Amit would be more hands on and then we would not need a DoF.
The DoF role in my opinion is not required (could be covered by Amit and Lee Hoos) and not supported through the transfers above and our ongoing decline through a poor squad and results.
In my opinion Ferdinand has had 6 years to improve matters and he has not. He has bought poor players, many costing us a lot of money.
We still don't have good full backs, a quality central midfielder or a goalscorer.
He has recruited managers that have not met the mark or followed a clear direction. Each manager changes strategy - which should be set by the DoF.
Les Ferdinand is a far bigger problem than Warburton and needs to be sacked now. [Post edited 28 Dec 2020 2:10]
|
That my friend is the post of the year, and sums up our club. | |
| 'You didn't know that was wrong, but now you do. If you do it again, I'll know you are doing it on purpose.' |
| |
| Ferdinand Out on 03:27 - Dec 28 with 1692 views | PunteR |
Ferdinand isnt the problem. Its the owners. | |
| Occasional providers of half decent House music. |
| |
| Ferdinand Out on 04:17 - Dec 28 with 1676 views | ozexile |
| Ferdinand Out on 02:05 - Dec 28 by superhoopdownunder |
Below are the permanent signings made whilst Ferdinand has been our Director of Football since early in 2015.
Only a very few successes out of 88 permanent signings
Season Player Cost
2015-16 George Butler Trainee
2015-16 Nathan Corkery Trainee
2015-16 Jay Emmanuel-Thomas Free transfer
2015-16 Ben Gladwin Undisclosed
2015-16 Osman Kakay Trainee
2015-16 Massimo Luongo Undisclosed
2015-16 Jamie Mackie Free transfer
2015-16 Joseph N'Guessan Free transfer
2015-16 Axel Prohouly Free transfer
2015-16 Olamide Shodipo Trainee
2015-16 Sebastian Polter £1,000,000
2015-16 Tjaronn Chery £2,250,000
2015-16 James Perch Undisclosed
2015-16 Tyler Blackwood Free transfer
2015-16 Oscar Gobern Free transfer
2015-16 Grant Hall Undisclosed
2015-16 Alex Smithies Undisclosed
2015-16 Tom Rosenthal Undisclosed
2015-16 Dániel TÅ‘zsér Free transfer
2015-16 Joshua Wallen Free transfer
2015-16 Conor Washington $3,000,000
2015-16 Matt Ingram Undisclosed
2015-16 Abdenasser El Khayati £350,000
2016-17 Jake Bidwell Undisclosed
2016-17 Ariel Borysiuk £1,500,000
2016-17 Conor Hudnott Trainee
2016-17 Joel Lynch £1,200,000
2016-17 Chris Paul Free transfer
2016-17 Jordan Cousins £1,250,000
2016-17 Eberechi Eze Free transfer
2016-17 Yeni Ngbakoto Undisclosed
2016-17 Seny Dieng Free transfer
2016-17 Idrissa Sylla Undisclosed
2016-17 Alex Finney Free transfer
2016-17 Danny Rowe Free transfer
2016-17 Brandon Adams Trainee
2016-17 Sean Goss £500,000
2016-17 Luke Freeman £350,000
2016-17 Matt Smith £1,000,000
2016-17 Paweł Wszołek Undisclosed
2016-17 Ilias Chair Unknown
2016-17 Josh Bowler Trainee
2016-17 Marcin Brzozowski Trainee
2016-17 Dan Darbyshire Trainee
2016-17 Odysseus Alfa Trainee
2016-17 Aramide Oteh Free transfer
2017-18 Charlie Owens Free
2017-18 Giles Phillips Free
2017-18 Josh Scowen Free
2017-18 Chay Tilt Free
2017-18 Alex Baptiste Free
2017-18 Paul Smyth Undisclosed
2017-18 David Wheeler £500,000
2017-18 Bright Osayi-Samuel Undisclosed
2017-18 Zenon Stylianides Free
2017-18 Deshane Dalling Free
2018-19 Joe Felix Free transfer
2018-19 Charlie Fox Trainee
2018-19 Toni Leistner Free transfer
2018-19 Ben Wells Free transfer
2018-19 Ali Omar Free transfer
2018-19 Àngel Rangel Free transfer
2018-19 Charlie Rowan Free transfer
2018-19 Lewis Walker Free transfer
2018-19 Franklin Domi Free transfer
2019-20 Yoann Barbet Free
2019-20 Dylan Duncan Free
2019-20 Liam Kelly £50,000
2019-20 Lee Wallace Free
2019-20 Dominic Ball Free
2019-20 Conor Masterson Free
2019-20 Dillon Barnes Free
2019-20 Geoff Cameron Free
2019-20 Todd Kane Free
2019-20 Marc Pugh Free
2019-20 Stephen Duke-McKenna Free
2019-20 Marco Harboe Ramkilde Free
2020-21 George Thomas Free transfer
2020-21 Luke Amos £700,000
2020-21 Lyndon Dykes £2,000,000
2020-21 Rob Dickie £1,500,000
2020-21 Tom Carroll Free transfer
2020-21 Macauley Bonne £2,000,000
2020-21 Albert Adomah Free transfer
2020-21 Chris Willock £750,000
2020-21 Charlie Kelman £300,000
2020-21 Manasse Mampala Free transfer
2020-21 Sinclair Armstrong Undisclosed
Our League positions since he became DoF (he took over when we were 17th in EPL)
2014-15 20th in EPL
2015-16 12th in Championship
2016-17 18th
2017-18 16th
2018-19 19th
2019-20 13th
2020-21 Currently 19th in Championship
We are only going one way and that is not up.
We have changed managers quite a few times and still are performing the same so it can't be the manager.
The only other common denominators since 2015 are Les Ferdinand, Lee Hoos and the Owners.
I believe Lee Hoos has done a terrific job improving our financial position each season.
Whatever we think of the Owners they are still paying the bills and contributing each month to keep us in existence.
Unfortunately they don't seem too interested in the club anymore.
Ideally Amit would be more hands on and then we would not need a DoF.
The DoF role in my opinion is not required (could be covered by Amit and Lee Hoos) and not supported through the transfers above and our ongoing decline through a poor squad and results.
In my opinion Ferdinand has had 6 years to improve matters and he has not. He has bought poor players, many costing us a lot of money.
We still don't have good full backs, a quality central midfielder or a goalscorer.
He has recruited managers that have not met the mark or followed a clear direction. Each manager changes strategy - which should be set by the DoF.
Les Ferdinand is a far bigger problem than Warburton and needs to be sacked now. [Post edited 28 Dec 2020 2:10]
|
As my Dear old Dad use to say "There's a lot of Dead Wood there". | | | |
| Ferdinand Out on 07:11 - Dec 28 with 1611 views | corse |
| Ferdinand Out on 02:43 - Dec 28 by Sharpy36 |
That my friend is the post of the year, and sums up our club. |
Very true | | | |
| Ferdinand Out on 08:55 - Dec 28 with 1535 views | Wegerles_Stairs |
Les is a sacred cow. It's surprising how many Rangers fans fell for Fernandes' ploy in appointing him as DoF but good to see that the scales are starting to fall from some people's eyes now. Nothing will change until the entire structure of the club is challenged, including the puppet chairman and DoF. Sadly, I think it's just going to be a change of manager and another period of mediocrity and increasing apathy from the fans. The fact we couldn't even round up 2,000 fans for the Stoke game (despite the extenuating circumstances) should be a warning to the board.
Did we really pay more than a million for Joel 'Dubai' Lynch? Jesus wept. [Post edited 28 Dec 2020 8:58]
| | | |
| Ferdinand Out on 09:04 - Dec 28 with 1519 views | bakerloo8 |
| Ferdinand Out on 02:05 - Dec 28 by superhoopdownunder |
Below are the permanent signings made whilst Ferdinand has been our Director of Football since early in 2015.
Only a very few successes out of 88 permanent signings
Season Player Cost
2015-16 George Butler Trainee
2015-16 Nathan Corkery Trainee
2015-16 Jay Emmanuel-Thomas Free transfer
2015-16 Ben Gladwin Undisclosed
2015-16 Osman Kakay Trainee
2015-16 Massimo Luongo Undisclosed
2015-16 Jamie Mackie Free transfer
2015-16 Joseph N'Guessan Free transfer
2015-16 Axel Prohouly Free transfer
2015-16 Olamide Shodipo Trainee
2015-16 Sebastian Polter £1,000,000
2015-16 Tjaronn Chery £2,250,000
2015-16 James Perch Undisclosed
2015-16 Tyler Blackwood Free transfer
2015-16 Oscar Gobern Free transfer
2015-16 Grant Hall Undisclosed
2015-16 Alex Smithies Undisclosed
2015-16 Tom Rosenthal Undisclosed
2015-16 Dániel TÅ‘zsér Free transfer
2015-16 Joshua Wallen Free transfer
2015-16 Conor Washington $3,000,000
2015-16 Matt Ingram Undisclosed
2015-16 Abdenasser El Khayati £350,000
2016-17 Jake Bidwell Undisclosed
2016-17 Ariel Borysiuk £1,500,000
2016-17 Conor Hudnott Trainee
2016-17 Joel Lynch £1,200,000
2016-17 Chris Paul Free transfer
2016-17 Jordan Cousins £1,250,000
2016-17 Eberechi Eze Free transfer
2016-17 Yeni Ngbakoto Undisclosed
2016-17 Seny Dieng Free transfer
2016-17 Idrissa Sylla Undisclosed
2016-17 Alex Finney Free transfer
2016-17 Danny Rowe Free transfer
2016-17 Brandon Adams Trainee
2016-17 Sean Goss £500,000
2016-17 Luke Freeman £350,000
2016-17 Matt Smith £1,000,000
2016-17 Paweł Wszołek Undisclosed
2016-17 Ilias Chair Unknown
2016-17 Josh Bowler Trainee
2016-17 Marcin Brzozowski Trainee
2016-17 Dan Darbyshire Trainee
2016-17 Odysseus Alfa Trainee
2016-17 Aramide Oteh Free transfer
2017-18 Charlie Owens Free
2017-18 Giles Phillips Free
2017-18 Josh Scowen Free
2017-18 Chay Tilt Free
2017-18 Alex Baptiste Free
2017-18 Paul Smyth Undisclosed
2017-18 David Wheeler £500,000
2017-18 Bright Osayi-Samuel Undisclosed
2017-18 Zenon Stylianides Free
2017-18 Deshane Dalling Free
2018-19 Joe Felix Free transfer
2018-19 Charlie Fox Trainee
2018-19 Toni Leistner Free transfer
2018-19 Ben Wells Free transfer
2018-19 Ali Omar Free transfer
2018-19 Àngel Rangel Free transfer
2018-19 Charlie Rowan Free transfer
2018-19 Lewis Walker Free transfer
2018-19 Franklin Domi Free transfer
2019-20 Yoann Barbet Free
2019-20 Dylan Duncan Free
2019-20 Liam Kelly £50,000
2019-20 Lee Wallace Free
2019-20 Dominic Ball Free
2019-20 Conor Masterson Free
2019-20 Dillon Barnes Free
2019-20 Geoff Cameron Free
2019-20 Todd Kane Free
2019-20 Marc Pugh Free
2019-20 Stephen Duke-McKenna Free
2019-20 Marco Harboe Ramkilde Free
2020-21 George Thomas Free transfer
2020-21 Luke Amos £700,000
2020-21 Lyndon Dykes £2,000,000
2020-21 Rob Dickie £1,500,000
2020-21 Tom Carroll Free transfer
2020-21 Macauley Bonne £2,000,000
2020-21 Albert Adomah Free transfer
2020-21 Chris Willock £750,000
2020-21 Charlie Kelman £300,000
2020-21 Manasse Mampala Free transfer
2020-21 Sinclair Armstrong Undisclosed
Our League positions since he became DoF (he took over when we were 17th in EPL)
2014-15 20th in EPL
2015-16 12th in Championship
2016-17 18th
2017-18 16th
2018-19 19th
2019-20 13th
2020-21 Currently 19th in Championship
We are only going one way and that is not up.
We have changed managers quite a few times and still are performing the same so it can't be the manager.
The only other common denominators since 2015 are Les Ferdinand, Lee Hoos and the Owners.
I believe Lee Hoos has done a terrific job improving our financial position each season.
Whatever we think of the Owners they are still paying the bills and contributing each month to keep us in existence.
Unfortunately they don't seem too interested in the club anymore.
Ideally Amit would be more hands on and then we would not need a DoF.
The DoF role in my opinion is not required (could be covered by Amit and Lee Hoos) and not supported through the transfers above and our ongoing decline through a poor squad and results.
In my opinion Ferdinand has had 6 years to improve matters and he has not. He has bought poor players, many costing us a lot of money.
We still don't have good full backs, a quality central midfielder or a goalscorer.
He has recruited managers that have not met the mark or followed a clear direction. Each manager changes strategy - which should be set by the DoF.
Les Ferdinand is a far bigger problem than Warburton and needs to be sacked now. [Post edited 28 Dec 2020 2:10]
|
Makes sober reading that.
Oscar Gobern 😱 | | | |
| Ferdinand Out on 09:32 - Dec 28 with 1479 views | Northolt_Rs |
| Ferdinand Out on 02:05 - Dec 28 by superhoopdownunder |
Below are the permanent signings made whilst Ferdinand has been our Director of Football since early in 2015.
Only a very few successes out of 88 permanent signings
Season Player Cost
2015-16 George Butler Trainee
2015-16 Nathan Corkery Trainee
2015-16 Jay Emmanuel-Thomas Free transfer
2015-16 Ben Gladwin Undisclosed
2015-16 Osman Kakay Trainee
2015-16 Massimo Luongo Undisclosed
2015-16 Jamie Mackie Free transfer
2015-16 Joseph N'Guessan Free transfer
2015-16 Axel Prohouly Free transfer
2015-16 Olamide Shodipo Trainee
2015-16 Sebastian Polter £1,000,000
2015-16 Tjaronn Chery £2,250,000
2015-16 James Perch Undisclosed
2015-16 Tyler Blackwood Free transfer
2015-16 Oscar Gobern Free transfer
2015-16 Grant Hall Undisclosed
2015-16 Alex Smithies Undisclosed
2015-16 Tom Rosenthal Undisclosed
2015-16 Dániel TÅ‘zsér Free transfer
2015-16 Joshua Wallen Free transfer
2015-16 Conor Washington $3,000,000
2015-16 Matt Ingram Undisclosed
2015-16 Abdenasser El Khayati £350,000
2016-17 Jake Bidwell Undisclosed
2016-17 Ariel Borysiuk £1,500,000
2016-17 Conor Hudnott Trainee
2016-17 Joel Lynch £1,200,000
2016-17 Chris Paul Free transfer
2016-17 Jordan Cousins £1,250,000
2016-17 Eberechi Eze Free transfer
2016-17 Yeni Ngbakoto Undisclosed
2016-17 Seny Dieng Free transfer
2016-17 Idrissa Sylla Undisclosed
2016-17 Alex Finney Free transfer
2016-17 Danny Rowe Free transfer
2016-17 Brandon Adams Trainee
2016-17 Sean Goss £500,000
2016-17 Luke Freeman £350,000
2016-17 Matt Smith £1,000,000
2016-17 Paweł Wszołek Undisclosed
2016-17 Ilias Chair Unknown
2016-17 Josh Bowler Trainee
2016-17 Marcin Brzozowski Trainee
2016-17 Dan Darbyshire Trainee
2016-17 Odysseus Alfa Trainee
2016-17 Aramide Oteh Free transfer
2017-18 Charlie Owens Free
2017-18 Giles Phillips Free
2017-18 Josh Scowen Free
2017-18 Chay Tilt Free
2017-18 Alex Baptiste Free
2017-18 Paul Smyth Undisclosed
2017-18 David Wheeler £500,000
2017-18 Bright Osayi-Samuel Undisclosed
2017-18 Zenon Stylianides Free
2017-18 Deshane Dalling Free
2018-19 Joe Felix Free transfer
2018-19 Charlie Fox Trainee
2018-19 Toni Leistner Free transfer
2018-19 Ben Wells Free transfer
2018-19 Ali Omar Free transfer
2018-19 Àngel Rangel Free transfer
2018-19 Charlie Rowan Free transfer
2018-19 Lewis Walker Free transfer
2018-19 Franklin Domi Free transfer
2019-20 Yoann Barbet Free
2019-20 Dylan Duncan Free
2019-20 Liam Kelly £50,000
2019-20 Lee Wallace Free
2019-20 Dominic Ball Free
2019-20 Conor Masterson Free
2019-20 Dillon Barnes Free
2019-20 Geoff Cameron Free
2019-20 Todd Kane Free
2019-20 Marc Pugh Free
2019-20 Stephen Duke-McKenna Free
2019-20 Marco Harboe Ramkilde Free
2020-21 George Thomas Free transfer
2020-21 Luke Amos £700,000
2020-21 Lyndon Dykes £2,000,000
2020-21 Rob Dickie £1,500,000
2020-21 Tom Carroll Free transfer
2020-21 Macauley Bonne £2,000,000
2020-21 Albert Adomah Free transfer
2020-21 Chris Willock £750,000
2020-21 Charlie Kelman £300,000
2020-21 Manasse Mampala Free transfer
2020-21 Sinclair Armstrong Undisclosed
Our League positions since he became DoF (he took over when we were 17th in EPL)
2014-15 20th in EPL
2015-16 12th in Championship
2016-17 18th
2017-18 16th
2018-19 19th
2019-20 13th
2020-21 Currently 19th in Championship
We are only going one way and that is not up.
We have changed managers quite a few times and still are performing the same so it can't be the manager.
The only other common denominators since 2015 are Les Ferdinand, Lee Hoos and the Owners.
I believe Lee Hoos has done a terrific job improving our financial position each season.
Whatever we think of the Owners they are still paying the bills and contributing each month to keep us in existence.
Unfortunately they don't seem too interested in the club anymore.
Ideally Amit would be more hands on and then we would not need a DoF.
The DoF role in my opinion is not required (could be covered by Amit and Lee Hoos) and not supported through the transfers above and our ongoing decline through a poor squad and results.
In my opinion Ferdinand has had 6 years to improve matters and he has not. He has bought poor players, many costing us a lot of money.
We still don't have good full backs, a quality central midfielder or a goalscorer.
He has recruited managers that have not met the mark or followed a clear direction. Each manager changes strategy - which should be set by the DoF.
Les Ferdinand is a far bigger problem than Warburton and needs to be sacked now. [Post edited 28 Dec 2020 2:10]
|
Fair play for taking the time to put those stats together - they look horrible! I am constantly amazed how LF gets away with it starting with our abysmal surrender when we still had a chance to stay up in the Prem. it will be interesting to see how many clubs offer him a DOF role once he moves on from us - which I hope is now. He has been truly awful as our DOF for SIX years....and a big part of why we are where we are today. People need to open their eyes. |  |
| Scooters, Tunes, Trainers and QPR. |
| |
| Ferdinand Out on 09:36 - Dec 28 with 1465 views | paulparker |
| Ferdinand Out on 02:05 - Dec 28 by superhoopdownunder |
Below are the permanent signings made whilst Ferdinand has been our Director of Football since early in 2015.
Only a very few successes out of 88 permanent signings
Season Player Cost
2015-16 George Butler Trainee
2015-16 Nathan Corkery Trainee
2015-16 Jay Emmanuel-Thomas Free transfer
2015-16 Ben Gladwin Undisclosed
2015-16 Osman Kakay Trainee
2015-16 Massimo Luongo Undisclosed
2015-16 Jamie Mackie Free transfer
2015-16 Joseph N'Guessan Free transfer
2015-16 Axel Prohouly Free transfer
2015-16 Olamide Shodipo Trainee
2015-16 Sebastian Polter £1,000,000
2015-16 Tjaronn Chery £2,250,000
2015-16 James Perch Undisclosed
2015-16 Tyler Blackwood Free transfer
2015-16 Oscar Gobern Free transfer
2015-16 Grant Hall Undisclosed
2015-16 Alex Smithies Undisclosed
2015-16 Tom Rosenthal Undisclosed
2015-16 Dániel TÅ‘zsér Free transfer
2015-16 Joshua Wallen Free transfer
2015-16 Conor Washington $3,000,000
2015-16 Matt Ingram Undisclosed
2015-16 Abdenasser El Khayati £350,000
2016-17 Jake Bidwell Undisclosed
2016-17 Ariel Borysiuk £1,500,000
2016-17 Conor Hudnott Trainee
2016-17 Joel Lynch £1,200,000
2016-17 Chris Paul Free transfer
2016-17 Jordan Cousins £1,250,000
2016-17 Eberechi Eze Free transfer
2016-17 Yeni Ngbakoto Undisclosed
2016-17 Seny Dieng Free transfer
2016-17 Idrissa Sylla Undisclosed
2016-17 Alex Finney Free transfer
2016-17 Danny Rowe Free transfer
2016-17 Brandon Adams Trainee
2016-17 Sean Goss £500,000
2016-17 Luke Freeman £350,000
2016-17 Matt Smith £1,000,000
2016-17 Paweł Wszołek Undisclosed
2016-17 Ilias Chair Unknown
2016-17 Josh Bowler Trainee
2016-17 Marcin Brzozowski Trainee
2016-17 Dan Darbyshire Trainee
2016-17 Odysseus Alfa Trainee
2016-17 Aramide Oteh Free transfer
2017-18 Charlie Owens Free
2017-18 Giles Phillips Free
2017-18 Josh Scowen Free
2017-18 Chay Tilt Free
2017-18 Alex Baptiste Free
2017-18 Paul Smyth Undisclosed
2017-18 David Wheeler £500,000
2017-18 Bright Osayi-Samuel Undisclosed
2017-18 Zenon Stylianides Free
2017-18 Deshane Dalling Free
2018-19 Joe Felix Free transfer
2018-19 Charlie Fox Trainee
2018-19 Toni Leistner Free transfer
2018-19 Ben Wells Free transfer
2018-19 Ali Omar Free transfer
2018-19 Àngel Rangel Free transfer
2018-19 Charlie Rowan Free transfer
2018-19 Lewis Walker Free transfer
2018-19 Franklin Domi Free transfer
2019-20 Yoann Barbet Free
2019-20 Dylan Duncan Free
2019-20 Liam Kelly £50,000
2019-20 Lee Wallace Free
2019-20 Dominic Ball Free
2019-20 Conor Masterson Free
2019-20 Dillon Barnes Free
2019-20 Geoff Cameron Free
2019-20 Todd Kane Free
2019-20 Marc Pugh Free
2019-20 Stephen Duke-McKenna Free
2019-20 Marco Harboe Ramkilde Free
2020-21 George Thomas Free transfer
2020-21 Luke Amos £700,000
2020-21 Lyndon Dykes £2,000,000
2020-21 Rob Dickie £1,500,000
2020-21 Tom Carroll Free transfer
2020-21 Macauley Bonne £2,000,000
2020-21 Albert Adomah Free transfer
2020-21 Chris Willock £750,000
2020-21 Charlie Kelman £300,000
2020-21 Manasse Mampala Free transfer
2020-21 Sinclair Armstrong Undisclosed
Our League positions since he became DoF (he took over when we were 17th in EPL)
2014-15 20th in EPL
2015-16 12th in Championship
2016-17 18th
2017-18 16th
2018-19 19th
2019-20 13th
2020-21 Currently 19th in Championship
We are only going one way and that is not up.
We have changed managers quite a few times and still are performing the same so it can't be the manager.
The only other common denominators since 2015 are Les Ferdinand, Lee Hoos and the Owners.
I believe Lee Hoos has done a terrific job improving our financial position each season.
Whatever we think of the Owners they are still paying the bills and contributing each month to keep us in existence.
Unfortunately they don't seem too interested in the club anymore.
Ideally Amit would be more hands on and then we would not need a DoF.
The DoF role in my opinion is not required (could be covered by Amit and Lee Hoos) and not supported through the transfers above and our ongoing decline through a poor squad and results.
In my opinion Ferdinand has had 6 years to improve matters and he has not. He has bought poor players, many costing us a lot of money.
We still don't have good full backs, a quality central midfielder or a goalscorer.
He has recruited managers that have not met the mark or followed a clear direction. Each manager changes strategy - which should be set by the DoF.
Les Ferdinand is a far bigger problem than Warburton and needs to be sacked now. [Post edited 28 Dec 2020 2:10]
|
Brilliant post
Some right crap signed there with no progression whatsoever in nearly 5 years |  |
| And Bowles is onside, Swinburne has come rushing out of his goal , what can Bowles do here , onto the left foot no, on to the right foot
That’s there that’s two, and that’s Bowles
Brian Moore
|
| |
| Ferdinand Out on 10:03 - Dec 28 with 1431 views | daveB |
| Ferdinand Out on 09:36 - Dec 28 by paulparker |
Brilliant post
Some right crap signed there with no progression whatsoever in nearly 5 years |
Disagree that there has been no progression. The club is very different now to 5 years ago, we are on the right track in terms of giving players a chance and developing young players, there has been some success stories over those years. 5 years ago we were having to pay players big money to leave, that's not happening anywhere near as much anymore. I'm not going to sit here and say everything Ferdinand has done has worked and he is wonderful because he has made mistakes and I look at that summer window under JFH and think that was the one we got badly wrong and proved to be very costly
The end of this summer window though did again seem good on paper, a lot of people were raving about how well we had done and were talking of the playoffs, it's amazing how quickly that has changed.
For me ferdinands biggest problem has been getting the balance right between developing and having a good first team hasn't been found.
Warburton last season was the closest we have come to the right formula but we were always one poor window away from that falling apart.
I do think the current issues are fixable and the situation at the club is not as bleak as it looks at the moment but they need to improve and do a lot better in the transfer market.
My biggest issue with the last window is not that the players aren't good enough but that so few are playing. 9 players signed in the summer only 3 of them regulars is not good enough. I get that Amos is injured but we've added Bonne, Adomah, Wilock, Kelman and Thomas and none of them look like being regulars this season.
Ultimately the question is will the club have a better chance of success without Les Ferdinand and if so what would the club structure be if he goes, do we continue with a DOF approach or start again.
I won't pretend to have the answer, I really don't know anymore. | | | |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
