| Mirror publish story that "Monk wins permanent appointment" on 11:37 - Apr 26 with 1241 views | Gowerjack |
| Mirror publish story that "Monk wins permanent appointment" on 11:20 - Apr 26 by Darran |
So if Garry does get the gig what are you all going to do stop going in protest isi?
I appreciate what everyone is saying and he wouldn't be my choice either but if it is confirmed it's time to stop moaning and get behind him. |
True
But I still think he's the wrong man in the right place... |  |
|  |
| Mirror publish story that "Monk wins permanent appointment" on 11:39 - Apr 26 with 1233 views | Brynmill_Jack |
| Mirror publish story that "Monk wins permanent appointment" on 11:28 - Apr 26 by AngelRangelQS |
If he's the best man for the job then he should get it. I'm afraid that the board haven't even bothered to find out.
There's nobody I'd rather see make a good go of it as our manager but I'm hardly filled with confidence.
If they now decide to invest more heavily in the scouting side of things, I'd be a bit happier. |
Last 3 posts nail on head. Nobody wants to see Garry fail as he's a huge piece of our club's history. Let's hope the board haven't put him in a position where that does sadly happen |  |
| Each time I go to Bedd - au........................ |
| |
| Mirror publish story that on 11:44 - Apr 26 with 1219 views | Neath_Jack |
| Mirror publish story that "Monk wins permanent appointment" on 11:18 - Apr 26 by Dr_Winston |
You've just provided a cracking example of the point I'm making.
United could have had Jose Mourinho. It's common knowledge that he wanted the job and only turned back to Chelsea after it was made clear that United weren't interested. Instead they gambled on a man with no experience of dealing with the kind of challenges that managing Man Utd provides.
Look how that turned out. |
Do you think Sir Alex thought that Moyes was a gamble then, I very much doubt he did, afterall SAF isn't known for gambling with Man Utd. He genuinely thought that he was the best man for the job. Nothing to say Jose would have done much better with the squad that was left to him either. If Moyes appointment had worked, then everyone would be saying what a fantastic appointment by SAF, instead we're all experts who knew all along that he would be a massive failure. As i said, hindsight is a marvellous thing. [Post edited 26 Apr 2014 11:47]
|  |
| |
| Mirror publish story that "Monk wins permanent appointment" on 11:46 - Apr 26 with 1215 views | Neath_Jack |
| Mirror publish story that "Monk wins permanent appointment" on 11:06 - Apr 26 by Brynmill_Jack |
I'm sorry Neefie but I have to disagree with you. As long as we try to continue to grow we could definitely become a regular top twelve club. But we can't stand still and expansion is an absolute must. When you see the Redbirds expanding even in the face of probable relegation it makes it even more stupid not to have at least started the East stand extension. |
No need to apologise, football is all about opinions and we are all armchair managers/chairmen on here. | |
| |
| Mirror publish story that "Monk wins permanent appointment" on 11:51 - Apr 26 with 1197 views | Brynmill_Jack |
| Mirror publish story that "Monk wins permanent appointment" on 11:46 - Apr 26 by Neath_Jack |
No need to apologise, football is all about opinions and we are all armchair managers/chairmen on here. |
Agreed. There's one at the club now lol | |
| Each time I go to Bedd - au........................ |
| |
| Mirror publish story that "Monk wins permanent appointment" on 11:52 - Apr 26 with 1201 views | Neath_Jack |
| Mirror publish story that "Monk wins permanent appointment" on 11:13 - Apr 26 by WarwickHunt |
Yep - it's not rocket science.
As for "big names", I'm sure most of us would be thrilled with Paul Clement. |
Why? What makes you think that he would be any better than Garry? Genuine question. | |
| |
| Mirror publish story that "Monk wins permanent appointment" on 11:59 - Apr 26 with 1176 views | WarwickHunt |
| Mirror publish story that "Monk wins permanent appointment" on 11:52 - Apr 26 by Neath_Jack |
Why? What makes you think that he would be any better than Garry? Genuine question. |
You're really struggling with this "experienced coach" malarkey, aren't you? |  | | |
| Mirror publish story that "Monk wins permanent appointment" on 12:02 - Apr 26 with 1173 views | WarwickHunt |
| Mirror publish story that "Monk wins permanent appointment" on 11:51 - Apr 26 by Brynmill_Jack |
Agreed. There's one at the club now lol |
A tap in, but a cracker nonetheless... | | | |
Login to get fewer ads
| Mirror publish story that on 12:06 - Apr 26 with 1164 views | JackInLondon |
| Mirror publish story that on 22:29 - Apr 25 by DwightYorkeSuperstar |
Brendan was one of most tactically gifted managers I have ever seen. He knew when something wasn't working and he knew how to change it. Garry is no where near Brendan in terms of managerial ability. Absolutely no where near.
We are not playing the same football we did two seasons back under Monk. We are heading away from it. We no longer pass through teams like we did back then. We pass it around the defence and hoof it forward hoping something comes of a knockdown, like most other teams. |
He may have been a great manager for us but knew how to change something when it wasn't working? Time makes people forget but one of the biggest criticisms most of us had was that he had no plan B. We had one style of play and if it wasn't working (which it often did) that was that.
In the honeymoon period when everyone loved Laudrup that was one of the things everyone raved about, was how we now had a plan B, how he could make substitutions that could change a game. Fair play to him, in that period he'd make what seemed like baffling substitutions that by the end of a game seemed a masterstroke. Can't remember who, but the 2-0 win away to Arsenal was one example of that.
I agree we've moved away from our own style and become a lot more like other teams and that started before Monk too charge. |  | | |
| Mirror publish story that "Monk wins permanent appointment" on 12:07 - Apr 26 with 1157 views | Neath_Jack |
| Mirror publish story that "Monk wins permanent appointment" on 11:59 - Apr 26 by WarwickHunt |
You're really struggling with this "experienced coach" malarkey, aren't you? |
Instead of trying to be clever, just answer it. | |
| |
| Mirror publish story that "Monk wins permanent appointment" on 12:09 - Apr 26 with 1149 views | WarwickHunt |
| Mirror publish story that "Monk wins permanent appointment" on 12:07 - Apr 26 by Neath_Jack |
Instead of trying to be clever, just answer it. |
I just did. | | | |
| Mirror publish story that "Monk wins permanent appointment" on 12:12 - Apr 26 with 1142 views | Neath_Jack |
| Mirror publish story that "Monk wins permanent appointment" on 12:09 - Apr 26 by WarwickHunt |
I just did. |
No you didn't. You said something about an experienced coach. Which is not what we're looking for. Or are you subscribing to the notion that an experienced coach automatically equates to being a good manager?
I asked you, as a genuine question, why you thought Clement would be a better manager than Garry. | |
| |
| Mirror publish story that "Monk wins permanent appointment" on 12:13 - Apr 26 with 1135 views | Brynmill_Jack |
| Mirror publish story that "Monk wins permanent appointment" on 12:02 - Apr 26 by WarwickHunt |
A tap in, but a cracker nonetheless... |
 | |
| Each time I go to Bedd - au........................ |
| |
| Mirror publish story that "Monk wins permanent appointment" on 12:26 - Apr 26 with 1102 views | WarwickHunt |
| Mirror publish story that "Monk wins permanent appointment" on 12:12 - Apr 26 by Neath_Jack |
No you didn't. You said something about an experienced coach. Which is not what we're looking for. Or are you subscribing to the notion that an experienced coach automatically equates to being a good manager?
I asked you, as a genuine question, why you thought Clement would be a better manager than Garry. |
Exactly which bit of "considerably more experience than a complete rookie = less risk" are you having trouble with? Clement has almost 15 years coaching experience under his belt and Ancelotti thinks the sun shines out of his arse.
It's a risk whoever we appoint but we should be looking at minimising it, not increasing it.
ps We're not looking for an experienced coach? WTF? | | | |
| Mirror publish story that "Monk wins permanent appointment" on 12:33 - Apr 26 with 1076 views | VetchitBack |
| Mirror publish story that "Monk wins permanent appointment" on 01:45 - Apr 26 by DwightYorkeSuperstar |
Exactly. Unless you're Real Madrid, Barcelona, Manchester United etc then you will always be a stepping stone club. Even 'legendary' players of our recent past chose other teams / adventures before the Swans;
Trundle chose Bristol City, Britton chased the money to Sheffield United, Alan Tate chose Wind Street over a first team spot etc.
I'd quite frankly be delighted if a new manager came in, did well and left for a bigger club. It hasn't hurt us so far has it? |
"Alan Tate chose Wind Street over a first team spot..."
You know this for a fact do you or just being a nasty, pathetic c@nt as usual? |  |
| The orthodox are always orthodox, regardless of the orthodoxy.
|
| |
| Mirror publish story that "Monk wins permanent appointment" on 12:34 - Apr 26 with 1072 views | Neath_Jack |
| Mirror publish story that "Monk wins permanent appointment" on 12:26 - Apr 26 by WarwickHunt |
Exactly which bit of "considerably more experience than a complete rookie = less risk" are you having trouble with? Clement has almost 15 years coaching experience under his belt and Ancelotti thinks the sun shines out of his arse.
It's a risk whoever we appoint but we should be looking at minimising it, not increasing it.
ps We're not looking for an experienced coach? WTF? |
I'm not having trouble with anything my friend, Monk has more managerial experience than Mr Clement. Or are we saying that our next manager doesn't have to have that experience, as long as he's been coaching for x amount of years?
But Clement is at Real Madrid afterall so he must be ace. Similar to players that come from the continent as opposed to British players.
Sir Alex thought the sun shone out of Brian Kidd's ringpiece as well.
A Coach is not a manager, thought you had more about you than that. | |
| |
| Mirror publish story that "Monk wins permanent appointment" on 12:49 - Apr 26 with 1026 views | Darran |
Warwicks having a bit of a Regi. |  |
| |
| Mirror publish story that "Monk wins permanent appointment" on 12:55 - Apr 26 with 1008 views | QuakerJack |
Uwe Rossler please |  |
| |
| Mirror publish story that "Monk wins permanent appointment" on 12:57 - Apr 26 with 1001 views | Jackfath |
So to sum up, Monk maybe our manager, or he may not. It could be someone else and we don't know who. |  |
| |
| Mirror publish story that "Monk wins permanent appointment" on 13:00 - Apr 26 with 998 views | Gowerjack |
Neath
You are having a right shafting here son....
Time to give it up eh? | |
| |
| Mirror publish story that "Monk wins permanent appointment" on 13:19 - Apr 26 with 944 views | C_jack |
Well and truly bored to s**t of this topic now, roll on August, whoever is in charge.
It's simple rationale really, the club needs the best available candidate for the job. In my opinion, Garry Monk needs a severe population cull to be that candidate. |  |
| |
| Mirror publish story that "Monk wins permanent appointment" on 13:23 - Apr 26 with 926 views | Phil_S |
It's. Not. True. |  | | |
| Mirror publish story that "Monk wins permanent appointment" on 13:33 - Apr 26 with 907 views | DwightYorkeSuperstar |
| Mirror publish story that "Monk wins permanent appointment" on 12:33 - Apr 26 by VetchitBack |
"Alan Tate chose Wind Street over a first team spot..."
You know this for a fact do you or just being a nasty, pathetic c@nt as usual? |
Well seeing as it was widely reported he would come back overweight and out of shape most pre-seasons, I think it's a fact he wasn't 100% focussed on achieving the best he possibly could with us.
I'm sure there's 1 or 2 others on here who are aware of his favourite establishment and how often you would be able to find him there. |  |
| |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
