 | Forum
Reply | The pïss stain coloured kit
at 10:37 24 Feb 2025
I accidentally upvoted this meant to just hit reply.
No one is fixating on kit over performance. It's a separate thread, separate discussion. We can comment or fixate on performance on several other threads.
We are passionate about our club and passionate about our kits. |
| Forum
Reply | Known knowns – Report
at 09:57 24 Feb 2025
You may think you know nothing Clive but a copy of your report should be sent to Marti (tactics and performance) and Noury (kit).
Btw Marti seemed to be having a right argument with their coach, in the presence of the 4th official, about their 'robust' tackling and probably the lack of control of the official in the middle.
Appalling refereeing. One think I do generally believe, in slight contrast to you Clive, is that referees let far too much go on, partly due to instructions on the interpretation of the laws of the game.
I totally get the letting the game flow desire but it has got totally out of hand.
I watch all our games home in the stand and usually away on a club stream (I'm overseas a lot) and I regularly watch MOTD etc.
I am amazed at some of the things that are considered 'not enough'. For me every shirt pull is a foul (cheating) and should be an instant yellow. Every push in the back is a foul and should be a free kick or penalty. Shoulder to shoulder is fine but not if the shoulder lands anywhere else. Blocking shouldn't be allowed, we are not playing American football.
I could go on with offside, handball etc but start with the above and we will ensure fairer play and help the skilful players and stamp out the cheating and thuggery. |
| Forum
Reply | The pïss stain coloured kit
at 17:59 23 Feb 2025
Not sure if you have seen it live, Brian but I saw it pre season on some of our fans and maybe the team wore it as well.
I think it looks worse live than on a stream. If it was a better shade of yellow or gold it would be preferable. I agree on the hoops, yellow and white?
Can't have yellow and black as we can't be wasps, bees or hornets😂 |
| Forum
Reply | OK own up
at 10:12 21 Feb 2025
I think Nobby would test the patience of refs in the modern game, just like our dear friend Samba Diakite did.
If Nobby was allowed to tackle in his usual style the likes of Zidane and Drogba would have retired much earlier and we would have been at war with France and a few other countries. |
| Forum
Reply | Development side .
at 09:32 18 Feb 2025
Thanks for the links, Nix. Very interesting, seems a hit as a player and comes over as a lovely young man. Hope he goes all the way in his career. |
| Forum
Reply | Rest of the Championship thread
at 09:58 16 Feb 2025
In 2018/19 Villa were 11th on 44 points after 33 games.
They drew the 34th game and then won ten on the spin, drew game 45 and lost game 46.
They finished 5th on 76 points, 3 points clear of 7th and went on to win the play offs.
It can happen and we can dream.😁 |
| Forum
Reply | Charlie Kelman’s Leyton Orient
at 09:32 16 Feb 2025
I think as of this moment he is worth considerably more than that.
I hope he carries on scoring till the end of the season. The value should be assessed then. Marti says that other clubs are enquiring about him. |
| Forum
Reply | Plymouth
at 09:02 10 Feb 2025
Well-done Plymouth, and as we have already played you twice, now replicate that form, survive in your relegation battle, whilst taking three points off all the teams you play, that are lying from 5th to14th in the Championship.😁 |
| Forum
Reply | Manure v Leicester
at 13:38 9 Feb 2025
That would be my preference, Brian but I think it's here to stay. With every match televised all incorrect decisions are highlighted. Opinions seem to be moving towards it with all these incidents occurring in the cups, when it isn't present.
I think we are going to have to live with some form of it, so let's make it better, more like it was 'sold' in the first place. |
| Forum
Reply | Manure v Leicester
at 11:40 9 Feb 2025
....and therin lies the problem.
The offside rule, that I played under and refed a bit with, would have given offside against all of them as soon as the ball is kicked. The current rule only gives a decision against a player when he becomes' active'. WTF are they doing on the pitch if they are not active?
No excuse for the error but I can see the confusion, trying to watch several players and determine if the one that plays the ball was one of those who were standing in an offside position.
As for VAR, it seems to be here to stay. So let's make it more sensible. Twenty seconds to make a decision, no stupid red and green lines, original decision stands unless it's clear and obvious. |
| Forum
Reply | Marriage. Tunes to waltz down the isle to..
at 11:21 9 Feb 2025
Congrats to you both and thanks for your entertaining and sometimes bewildering posts over the years.
Mrs FB and himself will be 32 years in July. 2nd time around for both of us. Guildford RO, no aisle, no tunes but our song is also Van the man, Have I told you lately...
We like the Rod the former Mod version too.
Best wishes for a long and happy future. |
| Forum
Reply | Charlie Kelman’s Leyton Orient
at 10:27 9 Feb 2025
I'm not sure either but do we ever offer a contract without an option? I can't see much logic in giving a player a year's deal only to then loan him to another club and, irrespective of how he performs, he can talk to other clubs in January and leave in July for free.
Unless, it was a belt and braces approach. We signed him before we knew what other strikers were available and knew we could recall him in January, if we had an injury crisis with the forwards.
I would imagine that there are some costs that are not being covered by Orient and that with our tight control on expense the above rational would be unlikely. Therefore I assume we have an option. |
| Forum
Reply | Charlie Kelman’s Leyton Orient
at 15:26 8 Feb 2025
Take up the option, that I presume we have, see how he goes in pre season and early season and make a decision to offer an extension or sell. |
| Forum
Reply | Live footie vs streams/TV
at 15:59 3 Feb 2025
It's pretty much the same for me, maybe one or two away games in a season.
I like to sit so going away is difficult as most tend to stand. I'm a similar size to most of our wide midfielders, so even if I stand, I can't see much.
Agree with your positives and negatives.
You can't see a lot of player movement off the ball on a stream and you don't have control of what you see. |
| Forum
Reply | Esquerdinha
at 15:52 3 Feb 2025
Wasn't much point putting long throws in for Cooper to head them away, especially without Jimmy. |
| Forum
Reply | Dunne off?
at 11:04 3 Feb 2025
It's a negotiation!
If we are asking for £3 million up front for him and he can walk for free in the summer, then I would expect it will be settled at £2 million and a bit. The rest, and more, could be made up with add ons for promotion. |
| Forum
Reply | Ref today
at 08:57 2 Feb 2025
I've seen worse but it was a fairly typical Busby performance.
As in the home game, what should be bookings early on are just given a 'stern' talking to and he makes a rod for his own back.
Open house from then on and he was lucky that it didn't blow up on him. |
| Forum
Reply | Yang Minh-Hyeok
at 11:08 30 Jan 2025
Wel I would imagine there is a negotiation but bearing in mind that Spurs have only signed him on the 1st January, he is a future asset that they want to toughen up and adjust to English football. We are a convenient location, with good facilities, an excellent manager and coach, with a rising reputation for improving young players. They will probably have instigated this. |
| Forum
Reply | Yang Minh-Hyeok
at 10:52 30 Jan 2025
I very much doubt we are paying anything for him. |
| | francisbowles
|
Site Scores| Forum Votes: | 2154 | | Comment Votes: | 44 | | Prediction League: | 0 | | TOTAL: | 2198 |
|
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.