| Lillis 13:52 - Dec 6 with 3679 views | Ribbleblue |
Should he have started? |  | | |  |
| Lillis on 13:59 - Dec 6 with 3661 views | dean7321 |
Castro Pereira is not good enough.
* he doesn't know when to come out for balls.
*He doesn't talk to his defence.
Lillis should start from now as he did nothing wrong to be dropped anyway. |  |
| |
| Lillis on 14:15 - Dec 6 with 3588 views | rich_dale |
Think Hilly's obsessed with his distribution, and it is good at times, but even so there were a few odd kicks today that nearly put us in trouble. In any case, would rather have a really vocal, dominating keeper that commanded his box and cleared the ball emphatically than one that doesn't and occasionally sprays out a good pass. The outfield players are there to play the football. | | | |
| Lillis on 14:40 - Dec 6 with 3535 views | 1mark1 |
In answer to OP, YES. He has more big game experience.
I don't care about progressing a Manure player's career, any loan keeper should have been an improvement on what we have, and overall he is not in my view .
I have no doubt Castro will end up being a very good keeper, maybe even top class, but he has a lot to learn, and to me it's NOT our job to give him that education at the expense of our team.
Lillis has played ok this season, and didn't deserve to lose his place, to someone who at this moment is not better than him. |  |
| |
| Lillis on 14:49 - Dec 6 with 3459 views | DomDale |
Yes. We have to be the only club to name a "Player of the month" then drop him.
Feel sorry for Lillis he's a scapegoat far too often. |  |
| |
| Lillis on 14:53 - Dec 6 with 3459 views | Ribbleblue |
Have to agree on all points.Josh deserved to start today. | | | |
| Lillis on 14:54 - Dec 6 with 3453 views | MancDale |
Doesn't matter who started we would have lost today anyway. | | | |
| Lillis on 14:55 - Dec 6 with 3445 views | since58 |
| Lillis on 13:59 - Dec 6 by dean7321 |
Castro Pereira is not good enough.
* he doesn't know when to come out for balls.
*He doesn't talk to his defence.
Lillis should start from now as he did nothing wrong to be dropped anyway. |
rather than have a go at the keeper ,its the dross defence in front of him ,who were all over the place at set pieces you need to have a go at he had no chance with the goal. | | | |
| Lillis on 14:56 - Dec 6 with 3437 views | pedrodale |
I must admit I was surprised to see Castro today as he's cr@p |  | | |
Login to get fewer ads
| Lillis on 14:58 - Dec 6 with 3422 views | since58 |
| Lillis on 14:56 - Dec 6 by pedrodale |
I must admit I was surprised to see Castro today as he's cr@p |
so he lost us the game did he? right ok | | | |
| Lillis on 15:03 - Dec 6 with 3392 views | scooby |
| Lillis on 14:15 - Dec 6 by rich_dale |
Think Hilly's obsessed with his distribution, and it is good at times, but even so there were a few odd kicks today that nearly put us in trouble. In any case, would rather have a really vocal, dominating keeper that commanded his box and cleared the ball emphatically than one that doesn't and occasionally sprays out a good pass. The outfield players are there to play the football. |
That isn't Lillis! Two very different players, Castro is only lacking experience when compared to Josh. [Post edited 6 Dec 2015 15:04]
| | | |
| Lillis on 15:08 - Dec 6 with 3364 views | pedrodale |
| Lillis on 14:58 - Dec 6 by since58 |
so he lost us the game did he? right ok |
Chill out | | | |
| Lillis on 15:08 - Dec 6 with 3363 views | rich_dale |
| Lillis on 15:03 - Dec 6 by scooby |
That isn't Lillis! Two very different players, Castro is only lacking experience when compared to Josh. [Post edited 6 Dec 2015 15:04]
|
I know, wasn't suggesting Lillis has all those attributes, just thought that if we were going to bring in a loan keeper it should be someone who does, like Logan. Don't think Castro is any better than Lillis. | | | |
| Lillis on 15:13 - Dec 6 with 3334 views | since58 |
| Lillis on 15:08 - Dec 6 by pedrodale |
Chill out |
why is he crap please explain | | | |
| Lillis on 15:27 - Dec 6 with 3268 views | pedrodale |
From the Pearl st. His distribution is no better than Lillis, does'nt know when to come for the ball, lacks comunication, almost dropped ball in his own net today, he is certainly not comanding. you could say the same of Josh at times but what pi$$es me of more than anything is playing triangles in front of goal thats a no no.
Therefore I think he is cr@p. | | | |
| Lillis on 15:40 - Dec 6 with 3232 views | dean7321 |
| Lillis on 14:55 - Dec 6 by since58 |
rather than have a go at the keeper ,its the dross defence in front of him ,who were all over the place at set pieces you need to have a go at he had no chance with the goal. |
He went to come out and then come back alot of times | |
| |
| Lillis on 15:45 - Dec 6 with 3199 views | since58 |
| Lillis on 15:27 - Dec 6 by pedrodale |
From the Pearl st. His distribution is no better than Lillis, does'nt know when to come for the ball, lacks comunication, almost dropped ball in his own net today, he is certainly not comanding. you could say the same of Josh at times but what pi$$es me of more than anything is playing triangles in front of goal thats a no no.
Therefore I think he is cr@p. |
I seem to remember joe hart dropping the ball into his own net the other week and he s englands keeper hes a young lad learning his trade just give the kid a break slagging him off wont do his confidence any good at all. | | | |
| Lillis on 15:47 - Dec 6 with 3189 views | since58 |
| Lillis on 15:40 - Dec 6 by dean7321 |
He went to come out and then come back alot of times |
are you Portuguese. | | | |
| Lillis on 15:50 - Dec 6 with 3177 views | JimmyRustler |
Has anyone else heard that we're being paid a fairly substantial fee from United for every game that he plays? |  | | |
| Lillis on 15:50 - Dec 6 with 3170 views | pedrodale |
| Lillis on 15:45 - Dec 6 by since58 |
I seem to remember joe hart dropping the ball into his own net the other week and he s englands keeper hes a young lad learning his trade just give the kid a break slagging him off wont do his confidence any good at all. |
Joe Hearts cr@p as well | | | |
| Lillis on 15:52 - Dec 6 with 3156 views | since58 |
| Lillis on 15:50 - Dec 6 by pedrodale |
Joe Hearts cr@p as well |
I wont argue on that one. | | | |
| Lillis on 15:55 - Dec 6 with 3142 views | stuartcryer |
I agree Castro is no better than lillis send him back to Utd . If we are bringing in loan players they MUST be better than our players . It dents morale when team mates are dropped for an outsider that is no better. It is our defence we need to improve we are woeful at set pieces nobody seems to know what they are doing | |
| |
| Lillis on 15:57 - Dec 6 with 3132 views | scooby |
| Lillis on 15:50 - Dec 6 by JimmyRustler |
Has anyone else heard that we're being paid a fairly substantial fee from United for every game that he plays? |
If that is the case, then it is a no brainer. He is no worse than Josh. | | | |
| Lillis on 17:19 - Dec 6 with 2985 views | Dickydaler |
| Lillis on 15:50 - Dec 6 by JimmyRustler |
Has anyone else heard that we're being paid a fairly substantial fee from United for every game that he plays? |
That probably explains it if it is true. I find it a very strange affair whatever the arrangements with Utd. I don't think Castro P is a bad keeper, but he is certainly no better than Josh. If Josh had been playing badly I wouldn't have minded Joel Castro P playing. After saying that I don't think whoever was in the goal today would have stopped bury scoring. Neither of them seem brilliant at defending those sort of set pieces. | | | |
| Lillis on 17:41 - Dec 6 with 2927 views | since58 |
| Lillis on 17:19 - Dec 6 by Dickydaler |
That probably explains it if it is true. I find it a very strange affair whatever the arrangements with Utd. I don't think Castro P is a bad keeper, but he is certainly no better than Josh. If Josh had been playing badly I wouldn't have minded Joel Castro P playing. After saying that I don't think whoever was in the goal today would have stopped bury scoring. Neither of them seem brilliant at defending those sort of set pieces. |
youre right neither keeper would have stopped bury from scoring .the lad who scored left his marker for dead from a quality dead ball set piece something which we cant emulate .its the defenders who are not doing there job . | | | |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
