Please log in or register. Registered visitors get fewer ads.
Forum index | Previous Thread | Next thread
Yer top 5 all time westerns. 18:46 - Feb 10 with 8913 viewssainthelens

A discussion the lads had back on the plane last week.
I'll list mine. Be interested to know what else is out there I may have missed.

Good the bad the ugly.
Bone Tomahawk.
The Revenant.
The Alamo.
Magnificent 7. ( original).
3
Yer top 5 all time westerns. on 21:50 - Feb 10 with 1560 viewsTummer_from_Texas

OP - the Alamo?

The 1960 John Wayne version was awful. Historically way off, and John Wayne was badly miscast as Crockett. He should have played either Sam Houston (his choice) or James Bowie, but the studio forced him to play Crockett.

The 2004 version was a box office bomb, but was actually 100X better. Billy Bob Thorton was a great Crockett.

Anyways, that's me on my soapbox as a native San Antoinian (and probably with my better half, the only people in history who took a portrait of ourselves in front of the Alamo with Swans shirts on).

My top 5:

5. Tombstone (only because of Kilmer)
4. The Cowboys
3. 3:10 To Yuma (2007 remake with Crowe/Bale)
2. Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid
1. The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford

POTY 2015
Poll: Biggest signing so far in January? (just curious what Planet Swans thinks)

0
Yer top 5 all time westerns. on 21:58 - Feb 10 with 1542 viewsBanosswan

None, America has no history.

Ever since my son was... never conceived, because I've never had consensual sex without money involved... I've always kind of looked at you as... a thing, that I could live next to... in accordance with state laws.
Poll: How do you like your steak?

0
Yer top 5 all time westerns. on 22:02 - Feb 10 with 1538 viewslifelong

Jeremiah Johnson.
The Revenant.
Gunfight at the OK Corral.
Chato’s Land.
True Grit.
0
Yer top 5 all time westerns. on 22:22 - Feb 10 with 1524 viewsPegojack

The Outlaw Josey Wales
The Unforgiven
Dances with Wolves
High Plains Drifter
Pale Rider

(I likes Clinty, me)
2
Yer top 5 all time westerns. on 22:27 - Feb 10 with 1515 viewsjedijack

I've never been a fan of westerns but watched The Unforgiven for the first time the other night and thoroughly enjoyed.
I'll be taking some other recommendations from this thread so thanks all!
2
Yer top 5 all time westerns. on 22:35 - Feb 10 with 1507 viewsSwanjaxs

Penlan Cowboy.

Starring Dicky Mint back in the 80's

If you know you know...

Yeeeehaaa 🐎

You might think I've forgotten, but one day, when you least expect it, my time will come.
Poll: Celtic and Rangers should be fast tracked into the Championship ASAP

0
Yer top 5 all time westerns. on 23:06 - Feb 10 with 1484 viewsHighjack

Does Cannibal the musical count as a western?

The creatures outside looked from pig to man, and from man to pig, and from pig to man again; but already it was impossible to say which was which.
Poll: Should Dippy Drakeford do us all a massive favour and just bog off?

0
Yer top 5 all time westerns. on 23:25 - Feb 10 with 1471 viewsKilkennyjack

Yer top 5 all time westerns. on 21:58 - Feb 10 by Banosswan

None, America has no history.


Well it has some welsh history ...

‘Links between the USA and Wales are lengthier and far more considerable than many people know. For example, five of the first six Presidents of the USA were of Welsh descent and the country has had no fewer than ten Welsh-connected Presidents in all - plus, briefly, the President of the Confederate States of America.

The Welshmen at the helm of the most powerful country in the world were:- John Adams, John Quincy Adams, Thomas Jefferson, James Morrison Jnr, James Monroe, William Harrison, Abraham Lincoln, Benjamin Harrison, James A Garfield and Calvin Coolidge. The Confederate President was, of course, Jefferson Davis.’

🏴󠁧󠁢󠁷󠁬󠁳󠁿

Beware of the Risen People

0
Login to get fewer ads

Yer top 5 all time westerns. on 00:18 - Feb 11 with 1442 viewsJackSomething

Yer top 5 all time westerns. on 19:16 - Feb 10 by Dr_Winston

1. Blazing Saddles
2. Open Range
3. Maverick
4. Unforgiven
5. The Quick & The Dead

If they don't have to be movies, then Deadwood is #1 and that can bump The Quick & The Dead off the list.


Good call on Open Range. I can take or leave most westerns, but thought that was an excellent film. Recommended to anyone who likes westerns and hasn't seen it.

You know, Hobbes, some days even my lucky rocket ship underpants don't help.

0
Yer top 5 all time westerns. on 01:09 - Feb 11 with 1427 viewsWanderer

Throw John Wayne's "3 Godfathers" in there and " A Man named Horse" with Richard Harris.
0
Yer top 5 all time westerns. on 02:02 - Feb 11 with 1416 viewsossie_jacks

Yer top 5 all time westerns. on 19:32 - Feb 10 by dickythorpe

Stuart McAdam RIP



think you mean stuart adamson?

big country first band I ever saw live as a spotty 15 or 16 yo at the Brangwyn hall great gig it was to.
0
Yer top 5 all time westerns. on 03:16 - Feb 11 with 1402 viewsdameedna

Django Unchained
The Alamo
Blazing Saddles
Broke Back Mountain
The Three Amigos

Edit
Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid, completely forgot, that is my number one
Will have a watch of Bone Tomahawk laterz
[Post edited 11 Feb 2020 3:19]
0
Yer top 5 all time westerns. on 05:46 - Feb 11 with 1381 viewsSTID2017

Soldier Blue
Legends Of The Fall
Last of the Mohicans
[Post edited 11 Feb 2020 5:49]

"Sanity and happiness are an impossible combination" - Mark Twain
Poll: Who Would You Want As Captain For Swans ?

0
Yer top 5 all time westerns. on 05:50 - Feb 11 with 1380 viewsSTID2017

Yer top 5 all time westerns. on 19:26 - Feb 10 by perplex

Cant argue with most on the lists all great films, but for me the number one has to be The Big Country.


Brilliant film

"Sanity and happiness are an impossible combination" - Mark Twain
Poll: Who Would You Want As Captain For Swans ?

0
Yer top 5 all time westerns. on 05:58 - Feb 11 with 1379 viewsjackal

Shane

The Big Country

The Searchers

The Magnificent Seven

John Ford's cavalry trilogy (She Wore a Yellow Ribbon, Rio Grande and Fort Apache.
1
Yer top 5 all time westerns. on 09:17 - Feb 11 with 1325 viewsWarwickHunt

Yer top 5 all time westerns. on 05:58 - Feb 11 by jackal

Shane

The Big Country

The Searchers

The Magnificent Seven

John Ford's cavalry trilogy (She Wore a Yellow Ribbon, Rio Grande and Fort Apache.


Finally!

Most people on here will be surprised that one of our old players directed films...

No mentions for High Noon or Johnny Guitar either. Tsk tsk.
[Post edited 11 Feb 2020 9:25]
0
Yer top 5 all time westerns. on 11:05 - Feb 11 with 1281 viewsLohengrin

Yer top 5 all time westerns. on 21:58 - Feb 10 by Banosswan

None, America has no history.


What a bizarre statement.

An idea isn't responsible for those who believe in it.

0
Yer top 5 all time westerns. on 11:09 - Feb 11 with 1277 viewsLohengrin

Yer top 5 all time westerns. on 09:17 - Feb 11 by WarwickHunt

Finally!

Most people on here will be surprised that one of our old players directed films...

No mentions for High Noon or Johnny Guitar either. Tsk tsk.
[Post edited 11 Feb 2020 9:25]


The Duke doesn’t have to be listed. He’s a given.


An idea isn't responsible for those who believe in it.

0
Yer top 5 all time westerns. on 11:09 - Feb 11 with 1275 viewsCatullus

I couldn't pick a top 5, there's just too many that are so close together.

I can put some at the bottom of the list though, way down, any western with Audie Murphy. Real life wat hero that he was, he just wasn't a rough tough cowboy. Too clean cut and nicey nicey.
For rough and tough you can't beat Clint or the Wayne/McLaglen combo.

PS Lohengrin...the Young guns films, don't tell me you like them for the music. BJ fan are you?

It was considered by some the most accurate Billy the Kid film though I guess we'll never know the truth about Brushy Bill.

Just my opinion, but WTF do I know anyway?
Poll: Offended by what Brynmill J and Controversial J post on the Ukraine thread?
Blog: In, Out, in, out........

0
Yer top 5 all time westerns. on 11:15 - Feb 11 with 1271 viewsLohengrin

Yer top 5 all time westerns. on 11:09 - Feb 11 by Catullus

I couldn't pick a top 5, there's just too many that are so close together.

I can put some at the bottom of the list though, way down, any western with Audie Murphy. Real life wat hero that he was, he just wasn't a rough tough cowboy. Too clean cut and nicey nicey.
For rough and tough you can't beat Clint or the Wayne/McLaglen combo.

PS Lohengrin...the Young guns films, don't tell me you like them for the music. BJ fan are you?

It was considered by some the most accurate Billy the Kid film though I guess we'll never know the truth about Brushy Bill.


” PS Lohengrin...the Young guns films, don't tell me you like them for the music. BJ fan are you?

No, mate. It’s the Sons of the Pioneers for me every time.

An idea isn't responsible for those who believe in it.

0
Yer top 5 all time westerns. on 11:53 - Feb 11 with 1251 viewsWarwickHunt

Yer top 5 all time westerns. on 11:15 - Feb 11 by Lohengrin

” PS Lohengrin...the Young guns films, don't tell me you like them for the music. BJ fan are you?

No, mate. It’s the Sons of the Pioneers for me every time.


Don't faint...

0
Yer top 5 all time westerns. on 11:54 - Feb 11 with 1250 viewsHighjack

I’m disappointed with planetswans today. The comment “BJ fan are you?” has been up for nearly an hour now and nobody has jumped in two footed with a childish comment or a gif of Kenneth Williams.

The creatures outside looked from pig to man, and from man to pig, and from pig to man again; but already it was impossible to say which was which.
Poll: Should Dippy Drakeford do us all a massive favour and just bog off?

0
Yer top 5 all time westerns. on 12:10 - Feb 11 with 1243 viewsLohengrin

Yer top 5 all time westerns. on 11:53 - Feb 11 by WarwickHunt

Don't faint...



Ah! It’s a thing of beauty.

People with the wherewithal to indulge their hobbies to that degree inhabit an entirely different world to the rest of us. I’d give my right arm but I doubt that would even begin to cover it.

An idea isn't responsible for those who believe in it.

0
Yer top 5 all time westerns. on 12:13 - Feb 11 with 1241 viewsLohengrin

Yer top 5 all time westerns. on 11:54 - Feb 11 by Highjack

I’m disappointed with planetswans today. The comment “BJ fan are you?” has been up for nearly an hour now and nobody has jumped in two footed with a childish comment or a gif of Kenneth Williams.


This is serious week, they’re all snarling.

Not me though, here you go. Boosh!


An idea isn't responsible for those who believe in it.

0
Yer top 5 all time westerns. on 12:18 - Feb 11 with 1234 viewsCatullus

Yer top 5 all time westerns. on 11:54 - Feb 11 by Highjack

I’m disappointed with planetswans today. The comment “BJ fan are you?” has been up for nearly an hour now and nobody has jumped in two footed with a childish comment or a gif of Kenneth Williams.


I actually put BJ deliberately hoping to lead someone into it, I nearly replied myself but then went all sensible and said NO!

Besides I didn't want Lohengrin thinking it was an offer

Just my opinion, but WTF do I know anyway?
Poll: Offended by what Brynmill J and Controversial J post on the Ukraine thread?
Blog: In, Out, in, out........

0
About Us Contact Us Terms & Conditions Privacy Cookies Advertising
© FansNetwork 2024