Please log in or register. Registered visitors get fewer ads.
Forum index | Previous Thread | Next thread
Who made the decision? 17:15 - Mar 2 with 6979 viewsborntogo

As supporters I think we've every right to ask this question and receive an answer from the club - who made the decision to give Keith Hill a five-year contract?

Almost all decisions emanate from a single person, whether accredited to 'the board' or 'the club' etc. So, who was it?

It is the single worst decision made in the last 20 years of Rochdale AFC. It has left us unable to afford to sack him while meaning we suffer a hemorrhage of fans and finances due to his shocking player acquisition, tactics and man-management.

Who knows the long-term damage.


0
Who made the decision? on 17:16 - Mar 2 with 5565 viewselectricblue

Obessed.......

My all time favourite Dale player Mr Lyndon Symmonds

0
Who made the decision? on 17:17 - Mar 2 with 5541 viewsSuddenLad

Irrelevant who made the decision.

“It is easier to fool people, than to convince them that they have been fooled”

1
Who made the decision? on 17:18 - Mar 2 with 5521 viewsforeverhopefulDale

Who made the decision? on 17:16 - Mar 2 by electricblue

Obessed.......


Yes about he Club he supports, and presumably the team he has watched lots of times. Got every right to ask the question he has asked.

Poll: Will you be signing up to Direct Debit for Goldbond?

2
Who made the decision? on 17:20 - Mar 2 with 5497 viewsborntogo

So it doesn't matter who is running the club and what they may or may not do in the future?

Everything to do with a football club or any business or organisation stems from above and filters down. It is essential they are accountable.
1
Who made the decision? on 17:21 - Mar 2 with 5482 viewsSuddenLad

Who made the decision? on 17:18 - Mar 2 by foreverhopefulDale

Yes about he Club he supports, and presumably the team he has watched lots of times. Got every right to ask the question he has asked.


For what purpose? Just to pick on someone else ?

“It is easier to fool people, than to convince them that they have been fooled”

-1
Who made the decision? on 17:23 - Mar 2 with 5456 viewsborntogo

Who made the decision? on 17:21 - Mar 2 by SuddenLad

For what purpose? Just to pick on someone else ?


No, to try and understand what has gone on and make sure it doesn't happen again.
2
Who made the decision? on 17:27 - Mar 2 with 5408 viewsSuddenLad

Who made the decision? on 17:20 - Mar 2 by borntogo

So it doesn't matter who is running the club and what they may or may not do in the future?

Everything to do with a football club or any business or organisation stems from above and filters down. It is essential they are accountable.


Did anyone ask the question at the time ? It's only 'become relevant' because of recent form. No interest in the question until the going gets tough.

No matter who it was, you can't do anything about it.

What if someone says 'It was me'. What happens then ? What action do you take ?

“It is easier to fool people, than to convince them that they have been fooled”

2
Who made the decision? on 17:31 - Mar 2 with 5372 viewsJames1980

Would this be the contract the majority of Dale supporters were behind?

'Only happy when you've got it often makes you miss the journey'
Poll: What does Jim need ?

3
Login to get fewer ads

Who made the decision? on 17:33 - Mar 2 with 5351 viewsdingdangblue

"And bringing him back was the single best decision made in the last 20 years of Rochdale AFC" ?

Ying and Yang

Its a BRILLIANT goal to cap a BRILLIANT start by Rochdale - Don Goodman 26/08/10
Poll: Are fans more annoyed losing or not playing Henderson centre forward?

0
Who made the decision? on 17:38 - Mar 2 with 5315 viewsmikehunt

At the time yes it is was.

The worm of time turns not for the cuckoo of circumstance.

0
Who made the decision? on 17:39 - Mar 2 with 5306 viewsrochdaleriddler

Genuine question to the Hill lovers, what is your man doing at the moment to maintain your manlove? His weird team selections continue and the slump deepens.

Poll: Will you download and use the contract tracing App being launched by the Govt

0
Who made the decision? on 18:00 - Mar 2 with 5195 viewsforeverhopefulDale

Who made the decision? on 17:31 - Mar 2 by James1980

Would this be the contract the majority of Dale supporters were behind?


How the hell do you know how many were behind it at the time, did you ask everybody?

Poll: Will you be signing up to Direct Debit for Goldbond?

0
Who made the decision? on 18:07 - Mar 2 with 5130 viewsShun

Who made the decision? on 18:00 - Mar 2 by foreverhopefulDale

How the hell do you know how many were behind it at the time, did you ask everybody?


The reaction on here/Twitter/around the ground at the time made it pretty clear what the general consensus was.
0
Who made the decision? on 18:08 - Mar 2 with 5116 views442Dale

Who made the decision? on 17:39 - Mar 2 by rochdaleriddler

Genuine question to the Hill lovers, what is your man doing at the moment to maintain your manlove? His weird team selections continue and the slump deepens.


Really don’t think creating issues amongst ourselves is going to help. I totally appreciate this works both ways.

The subject is valid but it could be asked in a different way. Just an opinion of course.

Poll: Greatest Ever Dale Game

4
Who made the decision? on 18:41 - Mar 2 with 4960 viewsforeverhopefulDale

Who made the decision? on 18:07 - Mar 2 by Shun

The reaction on here/Twitter/around the ground at the time made it pretty clear what the general consensus was.


Very few post on Twitter, or really on here, and there were plenty around where I sit, and amongst others I know who questioned the decision, but most were happy to keep quiet and trust the Club.

Poll: Will you be signing up to Direct Debit for Goldbond?

0
Who made the decision? on 18:55 - Mar 2 with 4891 viewsrochdaleriddler

Who made the decision? on 17:33 - Mar 2 by dingdangblue

"And bringing him back was the single best decision made in the last 20 years of Rochdale AFC" ?

Ying and Yang


* yin and yang

Poll: Will you download and use the contract tracing App being launched by the Govt

1
Who made the decision? on 19:24 - Mar 2 with 4793 viewsNinco

Any man who walks out on a club should never be allowed back regardless of how successful he has been in the past as he has shown no loyalty. The fact that he is now prepared to put the club in to league 2 for the sake of money proves his lack of loyalty. To him, it's just a job. To us, it's our club where we were before Hill came and we will still be after he goes.
-4
Who made the decision? on 19:46 - Mar 2 with 4711 viewskel

Who made the decision? on 19:24 - Mar 2 by Ninco

Any man who walks out on a club should never be allowed back regardless of how successful he has been in the past as he has shown no loyalty. The fact that he is now prepared to put the club in to league 2 for the sake of money proves his lack of loyalty. To him, it's just a job. To us, it's our club where we were before Hill came and we will still be after he goes.


You said you weren’t renewing your season ticket (the one that gives you your exclusive seat) last week. Make your mind up.
3
Who made the decision? on 19:53 - Mar 2 with 4681 viewsroccydaleian

Who made the decision? on 19:24 - Mar 2 by Ninco

Any man who walks out on a club should never be allowed back regardless of how successful he has been in the past as he has shown no loyalty. The fact that he is now prepared to put the club in to league 2 for the sake of money proves his lack of loyalty. To him, it's just a job. To us, it's our club where we were before Hill came and we will still be after he goes.


Any man that wouldn’t take the opportunity to better himself and take a challenge would be an idiot. Like you say, it’s just a job to him, loyalty doesn’t come into it.
I remember at the time of the news of his five year contract was announced, there was a forum very soon after which Hill attended and was greeted with pretty much with unanimous applause, it seemed to me a decent deal for both parties at the time, but a lot of my mates and other people I know had deep reservations and reckoned it was a massive gamble that could easily go tits up.
As others have said, it’s pretty irrelevant who made the decision.
1
Who made the decision? on 20:00 - Mar 2 with 4635 viewsCleedale

Who made the decision? on 18:55 - Mar 2 by rochdaleriddler

* yin and yang


...no, it defniately Ting Tang...

Ting Tang from Macadangdang Mr.Dudley!
0
Who made the decision? on 20:11 - Mar 2 with 4566 viewsSuddenLad

Who made the decision? on 19:24 - Mar 2 by Ninco

Any man who walks out on a club should never be allowed back regardless of how successful he has been in the past as he has shown no loyalty. The fact that he is now prepared to put the club in to league 2 for the sake of money proves his lack of loyalty. To him, it's just a job. To us, it's our club where we were before Hill came and we will still be after he goes.


To be still banging that 'disloyal' drum after all these years is ridiculous. It was pathetic at the time, it's even worse to rake it all up, just to beat him with it again.

“It is easier to fool people, than to convince them that they have been fooled”

0
Who made the decision? on 20:39 - Mar 2 with 4484 viewsdingdangblue

Who made the decision? on 18:55 - Mar 2 by rochdaleriddler

* yin and yang


Thanks

Yours gratefully

dindangblue

Its a BRILLIANT goal to cap a BRILLIANT start by Rochdale - Don Goodman 26/08/10
Poll: Are fans more annoyed losing or not playing Henderson centre forward?

0
Who made the decision? on 20:41 - Mar 2 with 4471 viewselectricblue

Who made the decision? on 17:18 - Mar 2 by foreverhopefulDale

Yes about he Club he supports, and presumably the team he has watched lots of times. Got every right to ask the question he has asked.


Maybe he does have the right to ask the question..
But the answer as been repeated in various other topics numerous times...

My all time favourite Dale player Mr Lyndon Symmonds

0
Who made the decision? on 20:49 - Mar 2 with 4431 viewsdownunder

Who made the decision? on 18:55 - Mar 2 by rochdaleriddler

* yin and yang



Ying Tong.
This is correct. It's here in black and white.
0
Who made the decision? on 01:41 - Mar 3 with 4129 viewsJames1980

Other than the contract being 5 years and he may or not get a cut of transfer deals. Apart from the ITKers do any of us know the full ins and outs of the deal? Surely the contract negotiations were not all one sided. I wouldn't be surprised if the target is 20th or above in league 1 come the end of each season. As we have not reached the end of the season perhaps this is one of the reasons why the board are sticking with KH.

'Only happy when you've got it often makes you miss the journey'
Poll: What does Jim need ?

0
About Us Contact Us Terms & Conditions Privacy Cookies Advertising
© FansNetwork 2024